Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Trying to goad me into providing a source for something discussed many times in the thread?


How about adding something new to the thread: search for the raw data on Shi's testing of the staff and students at the WIV for COVID antibodies. Even a report that the investigative team looked that data over would be good.


Maybe you can find the demographic data on the earliest cases that is still missing. You could update the thread. I think it's about 175 cases, half of which did not have a connection to the seafood market.
 
It had a massive impact in the UK. A 'reputable' newspaper publishing article after article challenging that HIV was the cause of AIDS. Arguing against anti-viral therapy. HIV denialism moved from the fringe to the mainstream. The Sunday Times has never apologised. It was not just an editor it was their science editor supported by their senior editor. Neville Hodgkinson was the science editor and author of many of the articles and Andre Neil was the Chief Editor and key supporter. Both had to be sacked before this nonsense ceased. Neville Hodgkinsn is also active in SARS-CoV-2 denialism. To give him his due Andrew Neil hasn't replicated his errors.

The MMR issue is different, it is not as if the medics or scientists believed Wakefield until the Sunday Times broke the truth. In this case they pursued an individual, but not challenged the consensus.

It's time to either get back on topic or provide something else that discredits The Sunday Times reporting other than their articles on HIV back in the early '90s. The editor responsible for HIV denial hasn't worked at The Times for DECADES! And you said yourself the other editor was fired.

It's a reliable source and you've not shown otherwise.
 
Trying to goad me into providing a source for something discussed many times in the thread?


How about adding something new to the thread: search for the raw data on Shi's testing of the staff and students at the WIV for COVID antibodies. Even a report that the investigative team looked that data over would be good.


Maybe you can find the demographic data on the earliest cases that is still missing. You could update the thread. I think it's about 175 cases, half of which did not have a connection to the seafood market.

i seem to provide links to primary sources. You make a claim (unreferenced) about the 'DRASTIC database' contains 22K genomes, I reference what DRASTIC actually said about the database that it contained 22K samples. You say Shi refused to provide data on testing of laboratory staff (unreferenced), I provide a reference to the WHO report saying they had data on testing of laboratory staff.

Your reliable source is a newspaper article, one in which there are errors of science. Where some of the facts are from talking to someone who knows someone who heard from someone who worked at WIV.

You accept the claim that young people are more likely to visit hospital with SARS-coV-2 rather than flu. I at least provide some references that young people are affected by flu. You disagree but fail to provide any evidence to support your view that young people are more likely to be ill with Covid-19 than flu.
 
Last edited:
Until you go back to the beginning of the thread and catch up, don't accuse me of not posting sources.
 
I don't know if this has already been posted in this thread, but it is being reported that according to multiple US government sources, the first case of Covid-19 was the scientist overseeing gain-of-function research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

https://public.substack.com/p/first-people-sickened-by-covid-19

https://www.racket.news/p/on-todays...ource=multiple-personal-recommendations-email

Yeah, we have discussed it. My thoughts on this is that relying on unnamed sources is unwise. I would prefer to see the declassified intel that this was based on.

Shellenberger, who wrote one of those pieces, literally published an article just before that arguing that insiders he had spoken to were just as adamant that the US has hidden UFOs and that multiple sources have told him the same thing that David Gursh has been saying to the press recently. In short, I’m skeptical.
 
Yeah, we have discussed it. My thoughts on this is that relying on unnamed sources is unwise. I would prefer to see the declassified intel that this was based on. ...
They are not relying on unnamed sources. They just aren't revealing the names of the sources to the public. It's an important distinction.

From the first link:
According to multiple U.S. government officials interviewed as part of a lengthy investigation by Public and Racket, the first people infected by the virus, “patients zero,” included Ben Hu, a researcher who led the WIV’s “gain-of-function” research on SARS-like coronaviruses, which increases the infectiousness of viruses.
Ben Hu is a public figure who some say is in line to follow Shi. So that part is verifiable.

Here you are again dismissing evidence based on what the reporter's other article [singular] was about. Is that the only whacko piece Shellenberger wrote? And the UFO articles got a boost this year when some official US gov videos of UFO footage showing speed and manipulability were released.

I don't know **** about Shellenberger and I have dismissed the 'UFOs are at Area 51 or wherever" articles. But those 3 investigative journalists aren't exactly on the CT or bust band wagon that I've seen. Not that I spend any time on click-bait titles about UFOs in the garage,

But none of that matters. Those 3 reporters are not the only source naming those 3 WIV workers. And the existence of 3 workers at the WIV who became ill in Nov 2019 is not new. It was in state dept reports from early in 2020.

You've been asking for verification every time it comes up. And that's fine, at first we didn't even have verification it was in a state dept official report. Then when Biden came into office the report was verified as coming from US intelligence as opposed to some crap a Trump propagandist spewed.

And take it or leave it, the fact the WIV was working on GoF with coronaviruses, and the fact they had live cultures at the WIV, and the fact the bulk of the research was being done in level 2BSL conditions have all been corroborated. The evidence has been posted in this thread, and I'm not going to be intimidated by the insistence sources be cited again. It's a long thread but tough tiddly-winks it's not a revived necro-thread.
 
Last edited:
They are not relying on unnamed sources. They just aren't revealing the names of the sources to the public. It's an important distinction.

I don't see any reason why sources cannot be named. If the public aren't told, then why should they conclude there is any there there?

My stance is this:

I remain skeptical of the claims about the sick WIV workers. It looks to me like an internal rumour that has gained a life of its own and is being bandied about by people who may well believe it just as they believe in UFOs.

However...

I will change my mind if and when the intel is released.

If it turns out that previous intel (circa 2020) specifically names these scientists being hospitalized in November 2019 or a month or two earlier, with ground glass opacity pneumonia (not just went to hosptial with flu-like sypmtoms), then I will almost certainly accept it was a lab leak. If it turns out that Ben Hu's wife died of Covid or one of the others died of Covid then absolutely, I will accept it was a lab leak.

Now, on the other hand, if the intel comes out and there is nothing particularly interesting, will it shift your view in any way?
 
I don't see any reason why sources cannot be named. If the public aren't told, then why should they conclude there is any there there?
News reporters rely on getting information from sources by promising not to reveal the sources' names. How is this a new concept to you?:confused:

My stance is this:

I remain skeptical of the claims about the sick WIV workers. It looks to me like an internal rumour that has gained a life of its own and is being bandied about by people who may well believe it just as they believe in UFOs.

However...

I will change my mind if and when the intel is released.

If it turns out that previous intel (circa 2020) specifically names these scientists being hospitalized in November 2019 or a month or two earlier, with ground glass opacity pneumonia (not just went to hosptial with flu-like sypmtoms), then I will almost certainly accept it was a lab leak. If it turns out that Ben Hu's wife died of Covid or one of the others died of Covid then absolutely, I will accept it was a lab leak.

Now, on the other hand, if the intel comes out and there is nothing particularly interesting, will it shift your view in any way?
Yes, corroborating evidence the 3 had COVID and not something else would be important. So would evidence Shi actually did test the staff and students at the WIV also be important.

Reuters, Feb 2021: China refused to give raw COVID data to WHO, team member says.
Dominic Dwyer, an Australian infectious disease expert, told the Reuters news agency on Saturday that the WHO mission had requested raw patient data on 174 cases that China had identified from the early phase of the outbreak in the city of Wuhan in December 2019, as well as other cases, but was only provided with a summary.

Such raw data is known as “line listings”, Dwyer said, and would typically be anonymised but contain details such as what questions were asked of individual patients, their responses and how their responses were analysed.

“That’s standard practice for an outbreak investigation,” he told Reuters via video call from Sydney, where he is currently undergoing quarantine.

He said that gaining access to the raw data was especially important since only half of the 174 cases had exposure to the Huanan market, the now-shuttered wholesale seafood centre in Wuhan where the virus was initially detected.
Daszak denied China withheld any data, more evidence he's lied given said data isn't available.

If the only evidence we had supporting the lab origin hypothesis was these 3 workers then discrediting that evidence would carry a lot of weight. As it is that's only one piece of many supporting the lab-leak.

I could ask you a similar question: if the crossover animal species is never found, if COVID is never found to have been circulating anywhere outside of Wuhan before Nov 2019, at what point are you going to accept they aren't going to find such evidence?
 
Reuters, Feb 2021: China refused to give raw COVID data to WHO, team member says.

Daszak denied China withheld any data, more evidence he's lied given said data isn't available.

If the only evidence we had supporting the lab origin hypothesis was these 3 workers then discrediting that evidence would carry a lot of weight. As it is that's only one piece of many supporting the lab-leak.

I could ask you a similar question: if the crossover animal species is never found, if COVID is never found to have been circulating anywhere outside of Wuhan before Nov 2019, at what point are you going to accept they aren't going to find such evidence?

This is different to the earlier claim you made about refusing raw data on WIV workers.

The data on patients was refused on the grounds of privacy for private individuals from what I remember, but this was not on the WIV workers.
 
This is different to the earlier claim you made about refusing raw data on WIV workers.individuals from what I remember, but this was not on the WIV workers.
Of course it's different! It's a separate issue. :rolleyes:

I have been posting repeatedly about this specific information. What that link adds is the total number of patients Worobey doesn't have in his data analysis and half of 174 having no link to the market is a larger number than I realized.


Honestly, if you spent as much time looking for evidence as you spend trying to discredit me you might be able to move your spillover argument further along. Or you might find out it isn't just me, a lot of people are recognizing the lab origin has more evidence than the spillover origin.


As for this:
as said:
The data on patients was refused on the grounds of privacy for private
One need not release anyone's name when doing an epidemiological investigation.

Again from Reuters:
Such raw data is known as “line listings”, Dwyer said, and would typically be anonymised but contain details such as what questions were asked of individual patients, their responses and how their responses were analysed.

“That’s standard practice for an outbreak investigation,” he told Reuters via video call from Sydney, where he is currently undergoing quarantine.
So it is a bogus excuse for not releasing the data.
 
News reporters rely on getting information from sources by promising not to reveal the sources' names. How is this a new concept to you?:confused:

Yes, corroborating evidence the 3 had COVID and not something else would be important. So would evidence Shi actually did test the staff and students at the WIV also be important.

Reuters, Feb 2021: China refused to give raw COVID data to WHO, team member says.

Daszak denied China withheld any data, more evidence he's lied given said data isn't available.

If the only evidence we had supporting the lab origin hypothesis was these 3 workers then discrediting that evidence would carry a lot of weight. As it is that's only one piece of many supporting the lab-leak.

I could ask you a similar question: if the crossover animal species is never found, if COVID is never found to have been circulating anywhere outside of Wuhan before Nov 2019, at what point are you going to accept they aren't going to find such evidence?

It is worth remembering SARS not been found in the wild. What has been found are closely related viruses. Given millions of bats we are never likely to have an exhaustive survey of bat viruses. The animal source of Ebola and Mpox outbreaks is unknown. The sort of perfect data you ask for is not available.

Nor are we likely to have proof that what infected the WIV workers if they were unwell and went to hospital in November was Covid, because there was no test for covid then. They may have been tested for flu, given there was an outbreak of flu at that time, but there is no guarantee any samples were kept. Hospital laboratories tend to keep samples for a short time unless asked to keep them and then only do so reluctantly.
 
Of course it's different! It's a separate issue. :rolleyes:

I have been posting repeatedly about this specific information. What that link adds is the total number of patients Worobey doesn't have in his data analysis and half of 174 having no link to the market is a larger number than I realized.


Honestly, if you spent as much time looking for evidence as you spend trying to discredit me you might be able to move your spillover argument further along. Or you might find out it isn't just me, a lot of people are recognizing the lab origin has more evidence than the spillover origin.


As for this:One need not release anyone's name when doing an epidemiological investigation.

Again from Reuters:So it is a bogus excuse for not releasing the data.

Such raw data is known as “line listings”, Dwyer said, and would typically be anonymised but contain details such as what questions were asked of individual patients, their responses and how their responses were analysed.

“That’s standard practice for an outbreak investigation,” he told Reuters via video call from Sydney, where he is currently undergoing quarantine.

I am not sure that Dwyer is correct, but terminology may vary. Line listings usually refer to the laboratory output. A line listing would be the tests for covid-19, result (reactive / non-reactive) and basic patient data; name, id, DoB, age, sex, location of test and requesting clinician, possibly home address. The clinicians looking after the patient may have entered more detail into the clinical record, but that would have to be extracted from the clinical record, and access to that would not normally be given without consent. There may be an outbreak database with the data from the line listing and additional data from a questionnaire, including occupation, travel, contacts, co-morbidities, etc. This would contain patient identifiable data and access to the raw data would not usually be given. Suitably anonymised data might be shared but summary data would be usually shared. Generally if you want to interrogate a database like this you construct a question / search that you enter e.g. proportion of people reporting travel through place X; but you never see the raw data.
 
I could ask you a similar question: if the crossover animal species is never found, if COVID is never found to have been circulating anywhere outside of Wuhan before Nov 2019, at what point are you going to accept they aren't going to find such evidence?

No, I think it depend on what other viruses are found in the wild. If, for example, a virus closer to SARS-CoV2 is found in the wild with a furin cleavage site o would probably assume it was spillover.

Maybe I would give a ten-year time frame.
 
As it happens, I am listening to the BBC series Fever, which is quite interesting.

I *think* he’s foreshadowing an interview with Ian Lipkin (from Proximal Origins fame) and suggesting that he may have changed his mind on the origin. That said , I haven’t listened to all the ones available yet.
 
No, I think it depend on what other viruses are found in the wild. If, for example, a virus closer to SARS-CoV2 is found in the wild with a furin cleavage site o would probably assume it was spillover.

Maybe I would give a ten-year time frame.
That would be important evidence but you would still need the missing piece, how did it get from X to Wuhan? Without that it would not be a smoking gun.
 
As it happens, I am listening to the BBC series Fever, which is quite interesting.

I *think* he’s foreshadowing an interview with Ian Lipkin (from Proximal Origins fame) and suggesting that he may have changed his mind on the origin. That said , I haven’t listened to all the ones available yet.

Are we at slack tide* yet?

*Slack tide for those unfamiliar is the time between the tide going in and out.

Top WHO virologist admits it should never have dismissed lab leak theory as being more implausible than China's own 'frozen food' origin story
Professor Marion Koopmans is head of viroscience at Erasmus Medical Centre ...
In March 2021 the WHO confirmed the lab leak theory was 'extremely unlikely'
But she said ranking theories 'was not smart' and the lab leak cannot be ruled out.
Moving on to Lipkin:
.... However, while most lab leak scenarios for Covid's origins have centred on the WIV, he [Lipkin] pointed to another lab, the Wuhan Centre for Disease Control, located just a few hundred metres from Huanan market, where the first cases of the virus were tracked, as one possible source.

This lab was known to be involved in the collection of thousands of blood and faecal samples from wild bats with staff who worked there not always wearing the recommended level of PPE while doing so.
I agree but I doubt this went on without Shi's knowledge given they were both working on SARS-like coronaviruses.
 
It is worth remembering SARS not been found in the wild. What has been found are closely related viruses. Given millions of bats we are never likely to have an exhaustive survey of bat viruses. The animal source of Ebola and Mpox outbreaks is unknown. The sort of perfect data you ask for is not available.

Nor are we likely to have proof that what infected the WIV workers if they were unwell and went to hospital in November was Covid, because there was no test for covid then. They may have been tested for flu, given there was an outbreak of flu at that time, but there is no guarantee any samples were kept. Hospital laboratories tend to keep samples for a short time unless asked to keep them and then only do so reluctantly.
:rolleyes:

Shi's teams retrieved specimens for a decade from bats and other sources in Yunnan. They didn't toss them in a week. We're not talking about specimens kept in a diagnostic lab be it commercial or in the hospital.



I am not sure that Dwyer is correct, but terminology may vary. Line listings usually refer to the laboratory output. A line listing would be the tests for covid-19, result (reactive / non-reactive) and basic patient data; name, id, DoB, age, sex, location of test and requesting clinician, possibly home address. The clinicians looking after the patient may have entered more detail into the clinical record, but that would have to be extracted from the clinical record, and access to that would not normally be given without consent. There may be an outbreak database with the data from the line listing and additional data from a questionnaire, including occupation, travel, contacts, co-morbidities, etc. This would contain patient identifiable data and access to the raw data would not usually be given. Suitably anonymised data might be shared but summary data would be usually shared. Generally if you want to interrogate a database like this you construct a question / search that you enter e.g. proportion of people reporting travel through place X; but you never see the raw data.
You need to review epidemiological investigations. This post suggests you don't know what you are talking about but you are trying to discredit a source anyway. Line listing on a spread sheet can be any number of variables, not just lab output. Every investigation is not done in a hospital.


ETA Here's a good resource for anyone interested:
CDC: Describing Epidemiologic Data
 
Last edited:
Are we at slack tide* yet?

*Slack tide for those unfamiliar is the time between the tide going in and out.

Top WHO virologist admits it should never have dismissed lab leak theory as being more implausible than China's own 'frozen food' origin story
Moving on to Lipkin:
I agree but I doubt this went on without Shi's knowledge given they were both working on SARS-like coronaviruses.

Yeah I saw the click-baity headlines from NYPost and now the Fail. Koopmans says in the interview that she now thinks lab leak is about as likely as the cold-chain hypothesis. That is to say they are both unlikely, but not impossible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom