Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

Jackpot! Answers to all the 'questions' being asked in the last 2 pages or so.

Access to The Sunday Times article, not paywalled for me so hopefully that's true for everyone. A lot of things are explained. Quotes may not be in the order they are in the article; and it's a long thorough account of the situation well worth reading if one is interested. These are few excerpts and there was so much material I'll need several posts and tomorrow to address the issues.

https://archive.is/OP7rh#top

First, there is mutual agreement the virus was NOT a bioengineered weapon. However, that doesn't mean the military wasn't involved.



Second, where did The Sunday Times get their information?
So you have a reliable investigative news organization who took months and months to go over a vast amount of information from multiple sources. And we don't even have what the US is hopefully going to release.

This is not something that is going to be easily dismissed.

Was it Professor Taibbi with an anonymous source in the parking garage. Nope. ;)

No Taibbi, no Shellenberger, but Quay does come up in a minor role if you want to read ahead.

It is not thorough. It only presents one side of the case. It fails to report recent research such as identifying SARS like viruses with Furin cleavage sites and more closely related viruses to SARS-CoV-2. They make fundamental errors of science, like extracting RNA from the spike protein.

There is nothing published that hasn't been out there for a long time. They could have got all this apart from some quotes by browsing the web.

Investigators who scrutinised top-secret intercepted communications and scientific research believe Chinese scientists were running a covert project of dangerous experiments, which caused a leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology and started the Covid-19 outbreak.

Really? They caused a leak?

SARS-CoV-2 is so far from being a bioweapon, you wonder at the idea. The vast majority of people infected are asymptomatic, if affects the elderly and frail, it is a virus where developing a vaccine would be expected to be difficult. The virus has no features of being manipulated.

At least it suggests that this was not research in Shi's laboratory, so she is not to blame.

I wonder how much US research is in collaboration with the military or funded?
 
Jackpot! Answers to all the 'questions' being asked in the last 2 pages or so.

Access to The Sunday Times article, not paywalled for me so hopefully that's true for everyone. A lot of things are explained. Quotes may not be in the order they are in the article; and it's a long thorough account of the situation well worth reading if one is interested. These are few excerpts and there was so much material I'll need several posts and tomorrow to address the issues.

https://archive.is/OP7rh#top

First, there is mutual agreement the virus was NOT a bioengineered weapon. However, that doesn't mean the military wasn't involved.



Second, where did The Sunday Times get their information?
So you have a reliable investigative news organization who took months and months to go over a vast amount of information from multiple sources. And we don't even have what the US is hopefully going to release.

This is not something that is going to be easily dismissed.

Was it Professor Taibbi with an anonymous source in the parking garage. Nope. ;)

No Taibbi, no Shellenberger, but Quay does come up in a minor role if you want to read ahead.

In terms of reliability they were one of the main drivers of HIV denialism.

https://www.nytimes.com/1993/12/10/world/british-paper-and-science-journal-clash-on-aids.html

So they don't have a great track record on pandemic viruses.
 
It was sarcasm about the Daily Mail, @angrysoba. I've cited them as well when that's where the information happened to be. The difference is I don't believe I hand-waved away spillover sources because the evidence was found in a newspaper instead of a virologist's research paper.


All quotes here are from The Sunday Times unless otherwise noted.
Rather than warning the world, the Chinese authorities did not report the fatalities. The viruses found there are now recognised as the only members of Covid-19’s immediate family known to have been in existence pre-pandemic.
What I said turns out to be true, it's the world that wasn't notified. How many posts were wasted in this thread trying to discredit the entire article and all that investigative work because supposedly claiming "not reported" seemed like such an important flaw?

The reference in the report was concerning China not alerting the world that there might be a dangerous new SARS-like coronavirus that had entered the human population.


Then there was a fixation which began pages back because the 3 ill WIV workers were brought up as evidence and it had not been corroborated. I thought that was resolved when Biden (or was it the GOP controlled House) made public the intelligence reports from Trump's time in office.

They found evidence that researchers working on these experiments were taken to hospital with Covid-like symptoms in November 2019 — a month before the West became aware of the pandemic — and one of their relatives died.

An investigator said: “We were rock-solid confident that this was likely Covid-19 because they were working on advanced coronavirus research in the laboratory. They’re trained biologists in their thirties and forties. Thirty-five-year-old scientists don’t get very sick with influenza.”

If you weren't incessantly harping about the cables because you keep trying to discredit everything I post you might have noticed I corrected the source. It was not my job to point out to you something that was on the same bloody thread page.

angrysoba said:
You could have just said “oh sorry. I said “cable” but I meant “intelligence report”.”

The way you worded this made it look like you were berating ME for not remembering the earlier discussions.

So, this appeared in an intelligence report, but we have no idea how it got in there:
It wasn't about remembering earlier discussions, it was about not reading the posts right in front of you.

And now here you are again refusing to let go of this by questioning the source the intelligence report used. It's hardly a game changer except it suggests Shi was dishonest about testing all her staff for coronavirus antibodies, that plus she refused to let the WHO inspection team see the actual test data.

Now that a different source has named the ill WIV workers I'm sure we'll be hearing more about it.
 
In terms of reliability they were one of the main drivers of HIV denialism.

https://www.nytimes.com/1993/12/10/world/british-paper-and-science-journal-clash-on-aids.html

So they don't have a great track record on pandemic viruses.
:rolleyes: This from the person who posts that Daszak and Shi wouldn't lie.

It was in 1993 and you didn't even quote a relevant paragraph or two knowing the NYT is behind a paywall.

But don't bother if that's all you have to go on that The Sunday Times is not a reliable source.
 
Last edited:
It was sarcasm about the Daily Mail, @angrysoba. I've cited them as well when that's where the information happened to be. The difference is I don't believe I hand-waved away spillover sources because the evidence was found in a newspaper instead of a virologist's research paper.


All quotes here are from The Sunday Times unless otherwise noted.
What I said turns out to be true, it's the world that wasn't notified. How many posts were wasted in this thread trying to discredit the entire article and all that investigative work because supposedly claiming "not reported" seemed like such an important flaw?

The reference in the report was concerning China not alerting the world that there might be a dangerous new SARS-like coronavirus that had entered the human population.


Then there was a fixation which began pages back because the 3 ill WIV workers were brought up as evidence and it had not been corroborated. I thought that was resolved when Biden (or was it the GOP controlled House) made public the intelligence reports from Trump's time in office.



If you weren't incessantly harping about the cables because you keep trying to discredit everything I post you might have noticed I corrected the source. It was not my job to point out to you something that was on the same bloody thread page.

It wasn't about remembering earlier discussions, it was about not reading the posts right in front of you.

And now here you are again refusing to let go of this by questioning the source the intelligence report used. It's hardly a game changer except it suggests Shi was dishonest about testing all her staff for coronavirus antibodies, that plus she refused to let the WHO inspection team see the actual test data.

Now that a different source has named the ill WIV workers I'm sure we'll be hearing more about it.



Thirty-five-year-old scientists don’t get very sick with influenza.

Evidence for this? What is the evidence that a 35 year old would be more likely unwell with SARS-CoV-2 than influenza? Given that most 35 year olds with SARS-CoV-2 would have a mild illness or be asymptomatic, for three to need to go to hospital makes it unlikely this was SARS-CoV-2. Without meaning to be sexist but I think the named persons are male, and 'man-flu' is a well recognised phenomeneon.

There was a flu outbreak in Wuhan mid November 2019.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41564-020-0713-1/tables/1

Overall the rates of flu in Wuhan and the clinical pattern of illness more favours influenza than SARS-CoV-2. In any case there is no evidence that WIV had a potential precursorvirus to SARS-CoV-2, so even if they had SARS-CoV-2 this might imply a common source, but perhaps they all bought meat at the meat market!
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes: This from the person who posts that Daszak and Shi wouldn't lie.

It was in 1993 and you didn't even quote a relevant paragraph or two knowing the NYT is behind a paywall.

But don't bother if that's all you have to go on that The Sunday Times is not a reliable source.

The Sunday Times is notorious for its HIV denialism.

THE Sunday Times will continue its controversial campaign questioning whether HIV causes Aids and whether there is an epidemic of the disease in Africa, John Witherow, its acting editor, said yesterday, writes Steve Connor.

Mr Witherow said there would be no change in policy despite the resignation of the Sunday Times journalist Neville Hodgkinson, the driving force behind the newspaper's reports denying the link between HIV and Aids. 'We're not abandoning this by any means at all. We're not suddenly going to accept the orthodox line (on Aids),' Mr Witherow said. He hopes that Mr Hodgkinson will continue to come up with 'new news stories'.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...e-to-question-hiv-link-with-aids-1424871.html

During Neil's time as editor, The Sunday Times backed a campaign to prove that HIV was not a cause of AIDS.[19][20][21][22] In 1990, The Sunday Times serialized a book by an American conservative who rejected the scientific consensus on the causes of AIDS and argued that AIDS could not spread to heterosexuals.[21] Articles and editorials in The Sunday Times cast doubt on the scientific consensus, described HIV as a "politically correct virus" about which there was a "conspiracy of silence", disputed that AIDS was spreading in Africa, claimed that tests for HIV were invalid, described the HIV/AIDS treatment drug AZT as harmful, and characterized the WHO as an "Empire-building AIDS [organisation]".[21] The pseudoscientific coverage of HIV/AIDS in The Sunday Times led the scientific journal Nature to monitor the newspaper's coverage and to publish letters rebutting Sunday Times articles which The Sunday Times refused to publish.[21] In response to this, The Sunday Times published an article headlined "AIDS – why we won't be silenced", which claimed that Nature engaged in censorship and "sinister intent".[21] In his 1996 book, Full Disclosure, Neil wrote that the HIV/AIDS denialism "deserved publication to encourage debate".[21] That same year, he wrote that The Sunday Times had been vindicated in its coverage, "The Sunday Times was one of a handful of newspapers, perhaps the most prominent, which argued that heterosexual Aids was a myth. The figures are now in and this newspaper stands totally vindicated ... The history of Aids is one of the great scandals of our time. I do not blame doctors and the Aids lobby for warning that everybody might be at risk in the early days, when ignorance was rife and reliable evidence scant." He criticized the "AIDS establishment" and said "Aids had become an industry, a job-creation scheme for the caring classes."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Sunday_Times
 
Last edited:
Not only do I know a LOT of people who have been very sick with flu around that age, but I know plenty of people who swore that they had been very sick in 2019 with an illness that they took a lot of drugs for. When Covid became the big even of 2020, a LOT of people began saying that they were sure that they had had something like Covid long before the official outbreak.

This is on top of the fact that China's healthcare system, perhaps in a way that's similar to Japan, makes different use of hospitals, with people going to them for all sorts of ailments in a way that might be done in a clinic.

I once went to hospital here in Japan because I wanted to have my teeth looked at, and then another time because I had a swollen ankle and pain in my lower back that turned out later to be sarcoidosis.

We are not necessarily talking about someone who had pneumonia and had to be hospitalized. If it was that serious, would Daszak and Shi have been so sanguine at the Nipah Virus conference the following month? Would some of the people named have been looking so full of health when their photographs were taken a couple of months later after their hospitalizations?
 
Continuing with the issue about who the authors got their opinion from that persons in their thirties do not get 'unwell' with influenza, it is worth remebering that unlike covid the H1N1 flu pandemic mainly killed young adults it remains that flu jugely affects children and young adults.

It is interestying how a non-evidenced claim about influenza that is clearly wrong is used to justify a claim that they were infected by SARS-CoV-2. Whereas the truth is the opposite of what is written. Young adults are more likely to become ill with influenza, especially children, and mortality was lowest in the last h1N1 pandemic in those over 65. Just the opposite pattern of disease we see with SARS-CoV-2. Given (retrospective) tests showed circulating flu but no circulating SARS-CoV-2 and flu would be more likely to affect young adults than SARS-CoV-2 we see how facts can be distorted and innuendo used.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2729409/

https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/h1n1-200...s-global-2009-pandemic-h1n1-infection-rate-24
 
Look, squirrel ....

Hospital traffic in fall of 2019 in Wuhan and the odds of 3 workers from the WIV visiting a hospital in Nov 2019 are both speculative evidence and nothing more.

And Shi could have put the worker infection claim to bed had she been forthcoming with the raw data from testing all her staff for COVID antibodies.
But she didn't.


We went over this evidence early in the thread. Yes, going to the hospital was common for outpatient evaluation in China.

Until the 2009v H1N1HPAI and a couple other epidemic years much earlier, in general flu has been more serious in the very young and very old. It would have been unusual for 3 serious cases clustered in one worksite near the same time in 2019. It wouldn't have been impossible, other viruses could account for the cluster, and it would not have been unusual for a cluster of ill workers in the fall of 2019 from one worksite if it were only people seeing a doctor.


China tracks 'flu and pneumonia' cases across the country the same way we do here and I believe the UK does the same. There were no increases country-wide in flu and pneumonia cases in the fall of 2019. And according to the BBC, neither were there any increases in fall of 2019.

BBC Coronavirus: Fact-checking claims it might have started in August 2019

We wouldn't expect to see such an increase that early in the pandemic. Not sure why that wasn't thought about when the satellite and other data was evaluated. I didn't think about that either when I looked at the hospital parking lot data early in this thread. But then we didn't know at the time just how widespread the virus was.

The BBC also questions the search engine data showing an increase in searches for diarrhea before that gets brought up again. Don't bother.


The actual evidence here was the WHO investigative team being denied access to the raw data of tested workers by Shi. There was a lot of spaghetti being thrown at the wall when the pandemic started. Obviously not all of it stuck.

And early 2020 there were no increases in pneumonia elsewhere in China which one should have seen if one were looking for COVID outbreaks outside of Wuhan. There wasn't. It clearly started in Wuhan coincidentally close to the WIV.
 
Continuing with the issue about who the authors got their opinion from that persons in their thirties do not get 'unwell' with influenza, [snipped waste of time]

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2729409/

https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/h1n1-200...s-global-2009-pandemic-h1n1-infection-rate-24
In 2009 the flu variant followed a different pattern.

And neither of your sources looked at hospital admissions for flu. They looked at culture data, the majority of which in the US are from sentinel physician submissions. IOW outpatient specimens.

This is the kind of misleading information you get when you are not familiar with influenza and only look to confirm your bias. Plus if you had waited for my reply above (below your post) you could have saved yourself some time.


To repeat re the ill workers at the WIV in Nov 2019, the important evidence here was the WHO investigative team being denied access to the raw data of tested workers by Shi.
 
Last edited:
The Sunday Times is notorious for its HIV denialism. ...
Notorious for? Good grief!

In case you didn't know the HIV denialism you speak of was still widespread in 1994. It doesn't mean The Sunday Times is an unreliable source.

ETA after reviewing the whole Wiki entry: Turns out it was a single editor responsible for the HIV denialism. He left in 1994.

The Sunday Times has a few other misses but the majority of the exposés are right on, like this one:
Between 2004 and 2010, the newspaper ran an award-winning investigation by Brian Deer which revealed that research by Andrew Wakefield into the MMR vaccine was fraudulent. The investigation led to Wakefield being banned from medicine, and the retraction of his research from The Lancet.
 
Last edited:
In 2009 the flu variant followed a different pattern.

And neither of your sources looked at hospital admissions for flu. They looked at culture data, the majority of which in the US are from sentinel physician submissions. IOW outpatient specimens.

This is the kind of misleading information you get when you are not familiar with influenza and only look to confirm your bias. Plus if you had waited for my reply above (below your post) you could have saved yourself some time.


To repeat re the ill workers at the WIV in Nov 2019, the important evidence here was the WHO investigative team being denied access to the raw data of tested workers by Shi.

What is the evidence that WHO asked for the serology tests on laboratory staff at WIV?
 
What is the evidence that WHO asked for the serology tests on laboratory staff at WIV?

IIRC WIV did serology testing on their own and subsequently reported that blood samples from early 2020 showed no cases of SARS-CoV-2 in any WIV staff. In typical CT fashion this was interpreted by some as evidence for a cover-up rather then evidence against a lab leak.

I'm not sure what "raw data" even means in this context, perhaps this is an extension of calls to turn over private medical records so lab leak proponents can data mine them for "evidence".
 
Yeah, my memory is that Shi either showed the test results or that she reported that no one had got sick with Covid to the visiting Origins team, and that they had been satisfied with it.

The idea that she “denied” or refused or stonewalled or other verbs that you could use to imply a cover-up seem to be inserted to make things seem more sinister.

My recollection of this is that some people were incredulous that after all this time none of the WIV had got Covid even if the origin had been natural. That might be a more reasonable raise of the eyebrow. The other thing that I remember people complaining about is that Daszak didn’t insist that the team personally test the WIV staff and it was thus considered the Daszak was too accommodating and eager not to press the WIV staff in general and Shi in particular.

I don’t think it does lab leakers any favours to over-egg the pudding and it just comes across as another fish story that gets bigger on each retelling.
 
Oh for pity's sake! Read the thread, look it up, there are multiple sources for it and I'm not your spoon feeder.
There are lots of claims that Shi did not handover data. But no authoritative source that WHO asked for the data and it was refused. Even if WHO asked for the data almost certainly it would not be Shi who would have the authority to agree or disagree, this would be at a political level. Do you not recognise how Shi is being demonised. She is being held responsible for decisions that the Chinese government would make. Decisions that the head of WIV would make. Many of the things Shi is 'blamed' for she would have had no control over.
 
IIRC WIV did serology testing on their own and subsequently reported that blood samples from early 2020 showed no cases of SARS-CoV-2 in any WIV staff. In typical CT fashion this was interpreted by some as evidence for a cover-up rather then evidence against a lab leak.

I'm not sure what "raw data" even means in this context, perhaps this is an extension of calls to turn over private medical records so lab leak proponents can data mine them for "evidence".

There are direct quotes from Shi reporting this. But of course SG views everything Shi says as a lie therefore untrue therefore evidence of the opposite. If Shi says that staff tested negative for Covid-19 that means they were positive, that means they were infected at work from an unknown (concealed) coronavirus, that means they caused the covid-19 pandemic. Case proven by Shi saying they tested negative.

This is what the WHO says
The three laboratories in Wuhan working with either CoVs diagnostics and/or CoVs isolation and vaccine development all had high quality biosafety level (BSL3 or 4) facilities that were well-managed, with a staff health monitoring programme with no reporting of COVID-19 compatible respiratory illness during the weeks/months prior to December 2019, and no serological evidence of infection in workers through SARS-CoV-2-specific serology-screening.
So no evidence they were denied access to this data, let alone by Shi.
 
IIRC WIV did serology testing on their own and subsequently reported that blood samples from early 2020 showed no cases of SARS-CoV-2 in any WIV staff. In typical CT fashion this was interpreted by some as evidence for a cover-up rather then evidence against a lab leak.

I'm not sure what "raw data" even means in this context, perhaps this is an extension of calls to turn over private medical records so lab leak proponents can data mine them for "evidence".

Yes, i am uncomfortable with the demand that individual patient data is revealed to the world. There are complaints that only conglomerate data was given. In most cases this is entirely reasonable. Individual patient data is not required. If we do not believe a report saying that no WIV scientists tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies in early 2020, would we believe a piece of paper saying names and test results, or a print out from an ELISA plate reader, or even a data output. All could be fabricated. We either believe or we disbelieve, at this point there is no way to prove that people had positive or negative antibodies in January 2020.
 
Notorious for? Good grief!

In case you didn't know the HIV denialism you speak of was still widespread in 1994. It doesn't mean The Sunday Times is an unreliable source.

ETA after reviewing the whole Wiki entry: Turns out it was a single editor responsible for the HIV denialism. He left in 1994.

The Sunday Times has a few other misses but the majority of the exposés are right on, like this one:

It had a massive impact in the UK. A 'reputable' newspaper publishing article after article challenging that HIV was the cause of AIDS. Arguing against anti-viral therapy. HIV denialism moved from the fringe to the mainstream. The Sunday Times has never apologised. It was not just an editor it was their science editor supported by their senior editor. Neville Hodgkinson was the science editor and author of many of the articles and Andre Neil was the Chief Editor and key supporter. Both had to be sacked before this nonsense ceased. Neville Hodgkinsn is also active in SARS-CoV-2 denialism. To give him his due Andrew Neil hasn't replicated his errors.

The MMR issue is different, it is not as if the medics or scientists believed Wakefield until the Sunday Times broke the truth. In this case they pursued an individual, but not challenged the consensus.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom