Cont: Origins of Covid (2)

When you get around to actually reading my post, let me know. :(

I read it. I asked where the information came from.

You said "a cable"

The information on those sick workers from the WIV was in a cable sent from embassy staff in China to the US gov. I don't recall if some of the cable was redacted or the original not shown at all, only reported on.

Where is this cable?

Are you now moving away from your claim it was in a cable, but not admitting it?

Where is this cable that you said the information about the sick workers came from?
 
No idea what you are talking about here. Though I think it was you and Plainigale who had a disagreement when you were both referencing different databases, not Debarre.

Once again I find I am having a discussion with the wind.:rolleyes:

Debarre and @Planigale were referencing the data Bloom found on the cloud. Debarre was sarcastically dissing DRASTIC because she saw the database Bloom found and Debarre took that as evidence DRASTIC was a bunch of idiots.

Debarre didn't then and probably doesn't now recognize DRASTIC had exposed a different missing database. That's why I'm calling her Ms confirmation-bias Debarre. It appears she doesn't want to know there is a different database DRASIC was talking about despite the fact one database has 22K genomes and was taken offline in Sept 2019 and the other was I believe ~4 genomes in a paper Shi wrote sometime in 2019.


Can we get back to an honest discussion at some point here?
 
Why? The report was inaccurate. I don't have to "give up" on stating this just because you want to massage it from what it said to maybe, possibly what they meant if you add a bunch of qualifiers.

The article was dog ****.
Hello. Is there anybody out there?

The issue is NOT whether the news article got a fact wrong.

The issue is you trying to claim the entire reporting by The Times UK is dog **** to use your words because you found a single flaw in one report.


Let's not forget just how many flaws were in Worobey's paper.:rolleyes:
 
I read it. I asked where the information came from.

You said "a cable"

Where is this cable?

Are you now moving away from your claim it was in a cable, but not admitting it?

Where is this cable that you said the information about the sick workers came from?
SG: Wind, are you there?

Wind: Yes, SG.

SG: Can you get back to me tomorrow after you rest or sober up or whatever it is you do when you are in one of these states? Your posts fluctuate between being rational and being bonkers, a definite pattern. I prefer a discussion with the rational you.
 
SG: Wind, are you there?

Wind: Yes, SG.

SG: Can you get back to me tomorrow after you rest or sober up or whatever it is you do when you are in one of these states? Your posts fluctuate between being rational and being bonkers, a definite pattern. I prefer a discussion with the rational you.

I still don't understand where the claim of sick WIV workers came from.

You said a cable.

Okay, where is the cable?

Then you talked about a 2018 cable.

Do you not think this is confusing?
 
I still don't understand where the claim of sick WIV workers came from.

You said a cable.

Okay, where is the cable?

Then you talked about a 2018 cable.

Do you not think this is confusing?
I'll try again tomorrow if you can't figure it out from actually reading my posts. :rolleyes:
 
Once again I find I am having a discussion with the wind.:rolleyes:

Debarre and @Planigale were referencing the data Bloom found on the cloud. Debarre was sarcastically dissing DRASTIC because she saw the database Bloom found and Debarre took that as evidence DRASTIC was a bunch of idiots.

Debarre didn't then and probably doesn't now recognize DRASTIC had exposed a different missing database. That's why I'm calling her Ms confirmation-bias Debarre. It appears she doesn't want to know there is a different database DRASIC was talking about despite the fact one database has 22K genomes and was taken offline in Sept 2019 and the other was I believe ~4 genomes in a paper Shi wrote sometime in 2019.


Can we get back to an honest discussion at some point here?

Even Drastic don't claim this. They do not say there is a database with 22K genomes.

This is how drastic describes the database.

More specifically: The WIV had collected over 15,000 samples from bats (amongst the 22,000 records of samples in theDB). The DB contained over 1,400 strains of viruses across all species (animal, insect), including around1,000 coronaviruses, with at least 500 recently discovered bat coronaviruses, and at least 50 of these close to SARS. At least 19 of these coronaviruses were isolated (meaning grown in cell culture).

There are according to DRASTIC 22,000 samples recorded. Many of those samples will have failed to yield evidence of viruses. According to DRASTIC (and I have no independent verification) only 500 were bat coronaviruses. These will have been identified by testing for coronavirus RNA, most will be partial sequences and not sufficient to obtain a WGS. I think DRASTIC are wrong when they say 19 were viable - grown in culture. I think the 19 refers to genetic isolation where a whole genome was extractable. I think only six viable viruses were isolated by cell culture.

I think both DRASTIC and DeBarre refer to the same database. You have invented a fantasy database with 22K genomes.

Edit tissue culture corrected to cell culture.
 
Last edited:
I still don't understand where the claim of sick WIV workers came from.

You said a cable.

Okay, where is the cable?

Then you talked about a 2018 cable.

Do you not think this is confusing?

Diplomatic cables often contain gossip. So long as one remembers that being in a diplomatic cable is no evidence for veracity, then I can imagine that some one said over a glass of wine that they had heard that 3 WIV scientists became unwell with ? in October or was it November. This then gets reported back up the line.

I do feel sorry for these named individuals who will now be harassed for years. If you think how CT about school shooting have harassed the Sany Hook parents imagine what will now descend on these people.
 
Diplomatic cables often contain gossip. So long as one remembers that being in a diplomatic cable is no evidence for veracity, then I can imagine that some one said over a glass of wine that they had heard that 3 WIV scientists became unwell with ? in October or was it November. This then gets reported back up the line.

I do feel sorry for these named individuals who will now be harassed for years. If you think how CT about school shooting have harassed the Sany Hook parents imagine what will now descend on these people.

It is not even the question of whether diplomatic cables are good sources of evidence.

For me, the issue is to with an actual example of that popular, but often misused term, "gaslighting".

I asked where the information about sick WIV workers came from and was told it came from a cable.

When pressed, SG started talking about a cable from 2018. This cannot be the cable that the info about sick WIV workers came from.

When pointed out, SG then says I don't seem to be rational or sober. So apparently my very mental health is being questioned because I cannot make any sense of SG's claims.

This is absolutely gaslighing.
 
It is not even the question of whether diplomatic cables are good sources of evidence.

For me, the issue is to with an actual example of that popular, but often misused term, "gaslighting".

I asked where the information about sick WIV workers came from and was told it came from a cable.

When pressed, SG started talking about a cable from 2018. This cannot be the cable that the info about sick WIV workers came from.

When pointed out, SG then says I don't seem to be rational or sober. So apparently my very mental health is being questioned because I cannot make any sense of SG's claims.

This is absolutely gaslighing.
You don't read what I post and now you resort to insulting me? Was my post #235 really that difficult to understand? :rolleyes:
The "cables" initially were in 2018 warning the US government of the lax safety controls and dangerous research at the WIV. I HAVE A MIXED MEMORY but every bit of this was discussed earlier in the thread. ...

LATER an intelligence report said there was evidence of the ill workers in Nov 2019 at the WIV.


Well insult away, I'm going to move on from this and your other post obsession that The Times UK got one fact wrong* therefore the whole paper is discredited.

*It's possible it wasn't even wrong depending on who the reporter was talking about that wasn't informed.

And BTW, I am not going to read or reply to your giant sized font. It messes up the page width. Maybe you could ask the mods to resize the images because I know I'm not the only one bothered by members who post images which make the post boxes so large one has to scroll right and left to read the page.
 
I'm not sure why you made a point of naming David Asher as a source of information so I looked him up. In doing so I found this:

ABC News US: Nature-based or lab leak? Unraveling the debate over the origins of COVID-19 - Accomplished scientists and public health officials stand on both sides.

It has a long summary for anyone interested. I wanted to point this out (about 2/3 down the page) which is relevant to what we were discussing here. It's also something that was discussed in the beginning of this thread,

Then, in January 2021, a State Department report revealed that several Wuhan Institute of Virology researchers fell ill in the fall of 2019 with "symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses" -- though it's not clear if they had COVID-19, the flu, or possibly another illness. ABC News confirmed from a separate U.S. intelligence report that three researchers sought hospital treatment in November of 2019.

Shi Zhengli insists that she tested all her workers for COVID-19 antibodies, and all tests came back negative.
That was the testing Shi claimed was done but then refused to show any members of the WHO inspection team the actual raw data.

ABC News also reported in June 2020 that satellite images showed dramatic spikes in auto traffic around major hospitals in Wuhan in the fall of 2019, suggesting the novel coronavirus may have been present before the outbreak was first reported to the world.
Again, discussed upthread.

Meanwhile, ABC News reached out to all 27 of the scientists who penned the February 2020 letter "denouncing conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin." Of the 12 who replied, one now believes a lab leak is more likely and five more said a lab leak should not be ignored as a possibility. Four others stood by their stance in the letter, and another called for a complete and thorough investigation.
I have brought up time and time again that Daszak didn't disclose he wrote the letter when he asked those scientists to sign on.

Dr. Charles Calisher, a Colorado State University virologist and the lone signatory to completely change his position, told ABC News that he now believes that "there is too much coincidence" to ignore the lab-leak theory and that "it is more likely that it came out of that lab."
 
You don't read what I post and now you resort to insulting me? Was my post #235 really that difficult to understand? :rolleyes:



Well insult away, I'm going to move on from this and your other post obsession that The Times UK got one fact wrong* therefore the whole paper is discredited.

*It's possible it wasn't even wrong depending on who the reporter was talking about that wasn't informed.

And BTW, I am not going to read or reply to your giant sized font. It messes up the page width. Maybe you could ask the mods to resize the images because I know I'm not the only one bothered by members who post images which make the post boxes so large one has to scroll right and left to read the page.

You could have just said “oh sorry. I said “cable” but I meant “intelligence report”.”

The way you worded this made it look like you were berating ME for not remembering the earlier discussions.

So, this appeared in an intelligence report, but we have no idea how it got in there:

The U.S. government has reason to believe that several researchers inside the WIV became sick in autumn 2019, before the first identified case of the outbreak, with symptoms consistent with both COVID-19 and common seasonal illnesses. This raises questions about the credibility of WIV senior researcher Shi Zhengli’s public claim that there was “zero infection” among the WIV’s staff and students of SARS-CoV-2 or SARS-related viruses.

https://2017-2021.state.gov/fact-sheet-activity-at-the-wuhan-institute-of-virology/

What? Consistent with seasonal illnesses as well as Covid? Unsurprisingly, The Intelligence Community report referred to this and said it was not very interesting.

Later on, the story of the sick workers seems to have grown into a “fish story”. New details about ground glass pneumonia and a claim that one of the researchers’ wife died from Covid.

This should be easy to check. If the three, now, named scientists were present at the WIV or had a wife die of Covid then it might firm up the story (corroborate). But if it is just people repeating the story with murky origins then it is no different from how lots of experts keep repeating the UFO stories. Skeptics should be interested in where this story comes from instead of blithely repeating the most extreme versions and claiming “corroboration”.

Oh and before you say “oh now you are comparing lab leak to UFOs!” remember that the article mentioning the scientists was partly written by Shellenberger relying on anonymous US government sources and that is literally the exact same methodology that he used in his recent article about UFOs acting as stenographer for inside sources that we have to trust his judgment on the reliability or. I do not accept the reliability of Shellenberger one bit and if you listen to his recent talk with Shermer on UFOs you should understand why.
 
I'm not sure why you made a point of naming David Asher as a source of information so I looked him up. In doing so I found this:

ABC News US: Nature-based or lab leak? Unraveling the debate over the origins of COVID-19 - Accomplished scientists and public health officials stand on both sides.

It has a long summary for anyone interested. I wanted to point this out (about 2/3 down the page) which is relevant to what we were discussing here. It's also something that was discussed in the beginning of this thread,

That was the testing Shi claimed was done but then refused to show any members of the WHO inspection team the actual raw data.

Again, discussed upthread.

I have brought up time and time again that Daszak didn't disclose he wrote the letter when he asked those scientists to sign on.

Why did I bring up David Asher?

Because it was his job to “investigate” Covid origins on behalf of the Trump administration.

Most recently in 2020 he served at the State Department, advising and supporting investigations into nuclear biological and chemical weapons proliferation and development issues. At State, he spearheaded a task force for the Office of the Secretary looking into the origins of COVID-19 and the role of the Chinese government.


https://www.hudson.org/experts/1299-david-asher

Why did I link to the Daily Fail? Because he gave an interview to them about origins and sick workers.

So here is a question, did he compile the fact sheet? If so why did he tell the Daily Fail that a researcher’s wife died of Covid? Why was that not in the fact sheet? Why didn’t they name the scientists? Why were the more lurid symptoms not in the fact sheet?

David Asher has also been talking with Sherri Markson and Fox News. It is pretty clear that these memes are being spread by the person who was responsible for making the claim in the first place.

And yet when you read many many articles all sourced from David Asher’s initial “fact sheet” you claim “oh it is being corroborated”. No, it is a story in which the fish keeps getting bigger on every retelling!
 
Jackpot! Answers to all the 'questions' being asked in the last 2 pages or so.

Access to The Sunday Times article, not paywalled for me so hopefully that's true for everyone. A lot of things are explained. Quotes may not be in the order they are in the article; and it's a long thorough account of the situation well worth reading if one is interested. These are few excerpts and there was so much material I'll need several posts and tomorrow to address the issues.

https://archive.is/OP7rh#top

First, there is mutual agreement the virus was NOT a bioengineered weapon. However, that doesn't mean the military wasn't involved.
Investigators who scrutinised top-secret intercepted communications and scientific research believe Chinese scientists were running a covert project of dangerous experiments, which caused a leak from the Wuhan Institute of Virology and started the Covid-19 outbreak.

The US investigators say one of the reasons there is no published information on the work is because it was done in collaboration with researchers from the Chinese military, which was funding it and which, they say, was pursuing bioweapons.


Second, where did The Sunday Times get their information?
The Sunday Times has reviewed hundreds of documents, including previously confidential reports, internal memos, scientific papers and email correspondence that has been obtained through sources or by freedom of information campaigners in the three years since the pandemic started. We also interviewed the US State Department investigators — including experts on China, emerging pandemic threats, and biowarfare — who conducted the first significant US inquiry into the origins of the Covid-19 outbreak.
So you have a reliable investigative news organization who took months and months to go over a vast amount of information from multiple sources. And we don't even have what the US is hopefully going to release.

This is not something that is going to be easily dismissed.

Was it Professor Taibbi with an anonymous source in the parking garage. Nope. ;)

No Taibbi, no Shellenberger, but Quay does come up in a minor role if you want to read ahead.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom