North Pole is melting faster than predicted

One more peer reviewed article saying Greenland isn't melting down.

That's not stated in the conclusions. Here's one such :

"22] To summarize, we find no direct evidence to support the claims that the Greenland ice sheet is melting due to increased temperature caused by increased atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide. The rate of warming from 1995 to 2005 was in fact lower than the warming that occurred from 1920 to 1930. The temperature trend during the next ten years may be a decisive factor in a possible detection of an anthropogenic part of climate signal over area of the Greenland ice sheet."

It seems they're open to the possibility that Greenland is melting down, and the next ten years may tell us for certain.

(Not my highlighting, of course.)

“Greenland Warming of 1920-1930 and 1995-2005”, from Petr Chylek and M.K. Dubey (Los Alamos National Laboratory) and G. Lesins (Dalhousie University, Halifax), published on Geophysical Research Letters,

http://meteo.lcd.lu/globalwarming/Chylek/greenland_warming.html
Abstract

We provide an analysis of Greenland temperature records to compare the current (1995–2005) warming period with the previous (1920–1930) Greenland warming. We find that the current Greenland warming is not unprecedented in recent Greenland history. Temperature increases in the two warming periods are of a similar magnitude, however, the rate of warming in 1920–1930 was about 50% higher than that in 1995–2005.


Here's another conclusion :

"[19] v) There are significant differences between the global temperature and the Greenland temperature records within the 1881-2005 period. While all the decadal averages of the post-1955 global temperature are higher (warmer climate) than the pre-1955 average, almost all post-1955 temperature averages at Greenland stations are lower (colder climate) than the pre-1955 temperature average."

None of that was highlighted, so perhaps you missed it. Something strange is going on here. Greenland temperatures don't seem to reflect global temperatures, and it appears to be systematic. (Let's assume there's no systemic problem with the weather-stations and their distribution.)

It's not really surprising; Greenland is a unique and complicated place. For instance, on its western side it has a narrow sea which will gather melt-water from a warming Canada, thus freshening it and affecting the Gulf Stream flow. And so prehaps cooling Greenland, even though global warming is going on all around. A tricky place.

It's interesting that there was faster warming in the 20's. I assume there's no direct ice-mass or glacial-rate measurements, from this

"[21] The glacier acceleration observed during the 1996-2005 period [Rignot and Kanagaratnam, 2006] has probably occurred previously. There should have been the same or more extensive acceleration during the 1920-1930 warming ..."

Not observed, then. Should have been. I find this a bit of a reach. We don't know that the recent acceleration doesn't result from events in 1986-1995. Is that period directly comparable to 1910-20 in Greenland? It's all a bit circular for me.

I took note of this :

"... as well as during the Medieval Warm period in Greenland [Dahl-Jensen et al., 1998; DeMenocal et al., 2000] when Greenland temperatures were generally higher than today. "

(That wasn't highlighted either.) The Medieval Warm Period in Greenland. Not "The Medieval Warm Period". I like these guys :) .
 
If it couldn't be accurately worked out beforehand, how can it be more quickly than expected ?

Because it was inaccurately estimated. Everybody had their own estimate, and didn't claim them to be anything else. There was very little to go on, after all. Estimates have come down as observations have rolled in over the years, but it still can't be accurately worked out.
 
I took note of this :

(That wasn't highlighted either.) The Medieval Warm Period in Greenland. Not "The Medieval Warm Period". I like these guys :) .

CP I'm not going to play grammer games. They don't impress me, and the meaning of the paragraphs is quite obvious. You could try a sixth grade classroom, perhaps, on that type of thing.

Actual scientists tend to be pretty conservative in their statements, and quite limited in the scope of application of their experimental results. If they do a good job, they should self criticize a bit and list all the things they might have not fully explored, or not understood (We can leave Mann, Jones, and Hansen, Lovelock, and Gore in the basement, out of this definition of scientist).

What about the MWP in Greenland? Should they have started talking about something other than the object of their study, Greenland?

I'm still waiting for Gurdor to produce those IPCC refs that he alleges support the Greenland meltdown.:D Of course, you and I have already had that conversation and you most likely recall what the IPCC says on this matter. Or have you revised your opinions?

So we are headed where, exactly on this subject? (Aside from the obvious, that Greenland would take a thousand years to melt down if it decided to). Quite frankly, I agree with your comment that Greenland is very complex - not related to North Pole in any direct fashion.

Regional factors overwhelm global factors, of course.
 
CP I'm not going to play grammer games. ...
What about the MWP in Greenland? Should they have started talking about something other than the object of their study, Greenland?


Lessee, you get it pointed out to you that the difference between Greenland and the rest of Europe in response to climate change is significant, and you evade the point, calling it "grammar games". Uh huh. Another indicator to your lack of sincerity here, but really, no more indicators were needed to anyone knowing your posting history.
I'm still waiting for Gurdor to produce those IPCC refs that he alleges support the Greenland meltdown


You can keep on waiting as far as I am concerned. I prefer discussing things with honest debators, to the point where I no longer waste any time at all on the dishonest ones. Cheers.
 
Thanks for the insight.

IPCC Scenario A2, discussion of Greenland melting/not melting, not provided by Gurdor.

And I thought we were going to have some definitative, Authoritative Conclusionary evidenciary stuff coming in!
 
CP I'm not going to play grammer games. They don't impress me, and the meaning of the paragraphs is quite obvious. You could try a sixth grade classroom, perhaps, on that type of thing.

Don't talk down to me. It's not big and it's not clever.

There's nothing grammatical about these guys attaching in Greenland to "Medieval Warm Period". It's recognition of something they're aware of - that the term "Medieval Warm Period" needs to be qualified. When you consider how much Greenland figures in the argument for a global MWP, perhaps you'll start to see my point.

Actual scientists tend to be pretty conservative in their statements, and quite limited in the scope of application of their experimental results. If they do a good job, they should self criticize a bit and list all the things they might have not fully explored, or not understood (We can leave Mann, Jones, and Hansen, Lovelock, and Gore in the basement, out of this definition of scientist).

Back to that crap. Sad, really.

What about the MWP in Greenland? Should they have started talking about something other than the object of their study, Greenland?

They were referring entirely to Greenland. There was no need to qualify "Medieval Warm Period" with "in Greenland" unless they were distancing themselves from the commony-held misconcpetion of a global MWP.

I'm still waiting for Gurdor to produce those IPCC refs that he alleges support the Greenland meltdown.:D Of course, you and I have already had that conversation and you most likely recall what the IPCC says on this matter. Or have you revised your opinions?

If we've discussed them before you must have the links you're so coy about. I doubt I've revised my opinions, but in this case you seem less keen to bring them out.

So we are headed where, exactly on this subject? (Aside from the obvious, that Greenland would take a thousand years to melt down if it decided to).

Have you got a date yet for that NASA projection you popped up earlier? i mean the one that indicates a fairly linear melting.

Quite frankly, I agree with your comment that Greenland is very complex - not related to North Pole in any direct fashion.

It's directly related to the Arctic because a big chunk of it lives there.

Regional factors overwhelm global factors, of course.

In certain special places they do, but in the main - the lower latitudes where most people live - they don't.
 
You can keep on waiting as far as I am concerned. I prefer discussing things with honest debators, to the point where I no longer waste any time at all on the dishonest ones. Cheers.

Forgive mhaze, for he knows not what he does. He's not terribly bright.

Apparently mhaze has already discussed the subject with me, and I'm generally reactive, so I can't help thinking mhaze has the links already. And a "devastating" response. Like I say, not terribly bright. But quite possibly sincere.

Oh, there it is :

"IPCC Scenario A2, discussion of Greenland melting/not melting, not provided by Gurdor."

That's the money-shot for mhaze. Like I say, not terribly bright.
 
Date for what chart? The one that indicate 4cm contribution if 10% of Greenland melted by 2100?

What's the date you are looking for? Or just use your money shot, you can look it up.
 
Follow up, as promised:

I went home and plopped a sizeable chunk of freshwater ice in a bowl of HEAVILY salted water. I plopped it into the ice to where the water level then came to 1/8 inch of the top. After it melted, from what I could tell, the level was still about 1/8 inch from the top.

A thought occured to me: In theory, saltwater is less dense than freshwater and one would presume then that placing freshwater ice in the saltwater would make the water level raise, once melted.

But here is perhaps the flaw with that thinking: IF the freshwater ice is alREADY floating in the saltwater, that means that the displacement has already worked out the weight disparity!

If freshwater icebergs are already in saltwater (which they are), that means the bottom of the freshwater icebergs will be deeper in the water, due to displacement laws, as stated earlier. Therefore, perhaps the melted ice will NOT make the saltwater rise higher, if melted.

If you dispute this with me, then I will have to perform my test all over again only using graduation marks to more accurately tell the actual before and after levels.

Glaciers on land: What I've said would not apply. These melting WOULD raise the sea level.
 
Last edited:
Follow up, as promised:

I went home and plopped a sizeable chunk of freshwater ice in a bowl of HEAVILY salted water. I plopped it into the ice to where the water level then came to 1/8 inch of the top. After it melted, from what I could tell, the level was still about 1/8 inch from the top.

A thought occured to me: In theory, saltwater is less dense than freshwater and one would presume then that placing freshwater ice in the saltwater would make the water level raise, once melted.

But here is perhaps the flaw with that thinking: IF the freshwater ice is alREADY floating in the saltwater, that means that the displacement has already worked out the weight disparity!

If freshwater icebergs are already in saltwater (which they are), that means the bottom of the freshwater icebergs will be deeper in the water, due to displacement laws, as stated earlier. Therefore, perhaps the melted ice will NOT make the saltwater rise higher, if melted.

If you dispute this with me, then I will have to perform my test all over again only using graduation marks to more accurately tell the actual before and after levels.

Glaciers on land: What I've said would not apply. These melting WOULD raise the sea level.
An enormous amount of ice is on land, much of it on Greenland (which is why you keep hearing about it so much). Combine that with all the continental ice in Canada, Russia, Antarctica and other places, and there is a whole bunch of ice that is supported by land, not by buoyancy. More than a bowlful. Enough to affect sea level. A lot.
 
An enormous amount of ice is on land, much of it on Greenland (which is why you keep hearing about it so much). Combine that with all the continental ice in Canada, Russia, Antarctica and other places, and there is a whole bunch of ice that is supported by land, not by buoyancy. More than a bowlful. Enough to affect sea level. A lot.

Of course if the a 2 mile thick slab of ice somehow leaves the land, the land rises by about 5000 feet.

To look at sea level, you have to use the entire planet ice mass balance, since it will go up in one place and down in another. Then add thermal expansions.

Greenland has about 6% of the total ice.
 
Of course if the a 2 mile thick slab of ice somehow leaves the land, the land rises by about 5000 feet.

To look at sea level, you have to use the entire planet ice mass balance, since it will go up in one place and down in another. Then add thermal expansions.
You're speaking of isostatic rebound. The problem with that is that it takes hundreds or thousands of years for the crust to rebound. Ice melting raises the sea level immediately. Of course, you could just go into cryogenic_suspension until the isostatic rebound is complete... if you can find enough ice. And oh yes. The rebound only happens where the ice was, which is normally in godforsaken frozen wastelands. Everywhere else stays the same, so the effect of isostatic rebound is to raise the average land elevation, making the seas even shallower and sea level (in non-godforsaken-frozen-wasteland areas) even higher.

You really need to get your science from places other than selected websites.

Greenland has about 6% of the total ice.
You don't think that's enough? Want to add in Canada, Russia and Antarctica?
 
Last edited:
You don't think that's enough? Want to add in Canada, Russia and Antarctica?

Enough? For What?

Complete melt of Greenland would raise sea level 7 meters if everything else stayed exactly the same, what is impossible.
 
Enough? For What?

Complete melt of Greenland would raise sea level 7 meters if everything else stayed exactly the same, what is impossible.
So how much sea level change does it require to have major impact on humanity, do you think?
 
So how much sea level change does it require to have major impact on humanity, do you think?

You should ask how much before it is worth paying for. This is, after all, not a scientific debate but an economic one.
 
You should ask how much before it is worth paying for. This is, after all, not a scientific debate but an economic one.
If it is primarily an economic one - and the resistor / denier crowd definitely wishes to make this a money issue - then we are screwed. There's no sense in having banks full of cash - with a croaked human species. Future space archaeologists would howl over that one.

"Geez I wonder why this species went extinct?"

"My guess is it cost too much bucks for them to save themselves. Thrifty fossils. Gotta admire 'em for that, though. Least they didn't exceed their credit limits."

There's this extremely simple rule, and that is: As long as there is enough good air, water, food, good health and safe shelter for every human on the planet - then everything else is purely made-up crap. That's all it is. The stock market? We made it up, it's a game. Money? Credit? Deficits and surpluses? Games, games, games.

For example, I live in Los Angeles. We are suffering through our driest season on record. Now let's say that in order to get freshwater, we have to build solar-powered desalinization plants along the ocean coastlines. And we can't move out - we have to make it right here. We've got the materials and the skills - but no money to pay workers to do it. If it came to that, people would simply work for nothing to build those plants. We'd all do our little work shifts, get watered and fed - but no paychecks. Just because it appears we are joined at the hip to monetary compensation - does not make it so. It's really just a temporary and tenuous agreement.
 
Minor point: in the OP, the article said that the Arctic could be ice free in as little as a couple of decades. I've heard a similar thing on a radio show--though they did clarify that'd it'd only be ice-free in the summer.

Are they saying the Arctic Ocean will be ice free or "the Arctic" (which I certainly take to include Greenland, or least that part of it that lies within the Arctic Circle)?

Back to more current discussion: at the very least we need to address the unprecedented development of shorelines. A higher proportion of the population lives close to the shore than ever before.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom