North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Maybe I'm being a little silly...maybe... on what I just said. But suppose we allow SOME global warming to occur just to make it where life is more hosPITable in some of the more northerly and southerly lattitudes...and THEN try to halt it. Wouldn't that be a good compromise?
No. Northern latitudes and the effects of global warming... don't go well together. Ask anyone in Russia whose house has been destroyed when its permafrost foundation suddenly melted. Or the kids in South Norwegian cities whose snow largely went away. Not to mention sudden climate change causes more severe weather, which is never good.

So thanks for the kind idea, but no thanks.
 
You guys....

You guys are going to want some of these Air Conditioners.

We got lots. They werk real good.

They are Certified Good.

Made by that Houston branch of Exxon, Global Cooling Inc.
 
Not all of it. Just the deepest bit, in the mountains of the north and centre. That's the bit that will last longest. Most of Greenland's ice will go in the coming century.

I bet the cameras will be there when the last remnant of the Greenland ice-cap sinks into the gravel. I doubt they'll make much of its influence on sea-levels. Much might well be made of how stupid people were a thousand years ago. It was ever thus.

The thousand-year melting of Greenland will not be by one-thousandth per annum. It will be quick to start with and very slow at the end.

Those are fascinating speculations you have there, I particularly like the one about the "Great Dying" and the (obvious) need for jack booted troopers from the CO2 overlord to control the humanity threatening death rays of CO2 gas emissions.
By the times I'm thinking of the Great Dying will be long over. The ones that survive will be the ones that control the CO2, descendents of those who do now. Or rather who don't control it now because they see no sufficient reason to. A few generations up the line they'll see things differently.

​
But they are not going to be dying off because Greenland isn't going into melt down.





The Y axis label didn't come through on this for some reason, but it is full scale 4 cm at year 2100 and represents approximately a 10% contribution of Greenland to sea level rise.

From NASA.

I won't ask what your source is...
 
Danes live by the sea. It comes with the territory. Which is famously flat and low. Temperature is not everybody's first priority.

At any time, you can not be further than ca. 70 km from the ocean.

The average height is 31 metres above sea level and the highest point is 170.86 metres. Yes, we measure Møllehøj, our highest point, in centimeters. You take a crap on Møllehøj, and the maps have to be changed.

Denmark: Geography
 
The following paper indicates that arctic sea ice was less between 1130 and 1300 than during the 1990s. Published in 2006.
Continentality was greatest during the Little Ice Age but decreased around 1870, 20–30 years before the rise in temperatures indicated by the δ18O profile. The degree of summer melt was significantly larger during the period 1130–1300 than in the 1990s.

​
Svalbard summer melting, continentality, and sea ice extent from the Lomonosovfonna ice core (2006) by Grinsted, Moor and Pohjola


http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2006/2005JD006494.shtml

Discussed here, and here to some extent.
 
A bit of a broader perspective can't hurt.


Nor would some commentary on the links you provide. Save people guessing why you posted them.

Anyway, so by broader you mean historical, and by 'can't hurt' you mean.... what?
 
The Arctic ice cap has collapsed at an unprecedented rate this summer and levels of sea ice in the region now stand at record lows, scientists have announced.

Experts say they are "stunned" by the loss of ice, with an area almost twice as big as the UK disappearing in the last week alone.

So much ice has melted this summer that the Northwest passage across the top of Canada is fully navigable, and observers say the Northeast passage along Russia's Arctic coast could open later this month.

If the increased rate of melting continues, the summertime Arctic could be totally free of ice by 2030.

Mark Serreze, an Arctic specialist at the US National Snow and Ice Data Centre at Colorado University in Denver, said: "It's amazing. It's simply fallen off a cliff and we're still losing ice."

The Arctic has now lost about a third of its ice since satellite measurements began thirty years ago, and the rate of loss has accelerated sharply since 2002.

Dr Serreze said: "If you asked me a couple of years ago when the Arctic could lose all of its ice then I would have said 2100, or 2070 maybe. But now I think that 2030 is a reasonable estimate. It seems that the Arctic is going to be a very different place within our lifetimes, and certainly within our childrens' lifetimes."

The new figures show that sea ice extent is currently down to 4.4m square kilometres (1.7m square miles) and still falling.

The previous record low was 5.3m square kilometres in September 2005. From 1979 to 2000 the average sea ice extent was 7.7m square kilometres.

The sea ice usually melts in the Arctic summer and freezes again in the winter. But Dr Serreze said that would be difficult this year.

"This summer we've got all this open water and added heat going into the ocean. That is going to make it much harder for the ice to grow back."

Changes in wind and ocean circulation patterns can help reduce sea ice extent, but Dr Serreze said the main culprit was man-made global warming.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2007/sep/04/climatechange
 
Those are fascinating speculations you have there, I particularly like the one about the "Great Dying" and the (obvious) need for jack booted troopers from the CO2 overlord to control the humanity threatening death rays of CO2 gas emissions.

I certainly mentioned the Great Dying, but where did you get the rest of it from? Do you think people will have to be forced to act in their obvious own best interest? To keep the the stabilised climate stable? They'll have very recent experience of what climate change means - see Great Dying above - and no good reason to revisit it. Politicans will be vying with each other over their climate-stabilisation policies.

If you get properly into History you can see it as if it's already happened.
But they are not going to be dying off because Greenland isn't going into melt down.

That's hardly the only problem, is it? We are about to encounter what's vulgarly referred to as a cluster-<Rule 8> .

So this is your comfort-zone? Greenland? Even Eric the Red only went there because he was on the run.

[URL]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_1422446dd6106457e5.gif[/URL]

The Y axis label didn't come through on this for some reason, but it is full scale 4 cm at year 2100 and represents approximately a 10% contribution of Greenland to sea level rise.

From NASA.

I could do with a bit more than that. What date is that graph from? What model does it use? Has the code been released? It should be checked, because ice-mass modelling has not performed well over the last couple of decades.

I won't ask what your source is...

It's widely reported that Greenland's glaciers have accelerated unexpectedly over the last ten years, and glaciers are the main outflow of Greenland's ice. Or any continental ice; glaciers are analogous to rivers in a drainage system. The high mountain ice is analogous to lakes.

Common sense tells us that the quicker the drainage, the quicker the ice-loss. None of this is properly reflected in the ice-dynamics models, as these new observations are yet to be fully explained. I go with the observations on general principle. They show that the models are significantly under-estimating the rate of loss. Which is hardly surprising; modelling ice-dynamics is a seriously hard problem. Climate's a breeze in comparison.

I doubt this will make much difference to the "lakes" of ice left up there in the Greenland mountains. They have no outflow available so they'll melt from the top. A very slow affair.
 
Indeed. How bad was Katrina, afterall?
Red herring, since AGW has not been demonstrated to cause an increase in the frequency or severity of tropical storms; and there is some evidence that it may, in fact, decrease both, as ocean/atmosphere temperatures converge.

http://www.gfdl.noaa.gov/~tk/glob_warm_hurr.html

The problem with Katrina is not that it was more severe than previous hurricanes, it demonstrably wasn't; but that unlike many previous hurricanes of similar severity 1) it landed in an area of high population density; 2) it landed in a region that was substantially below sea level; 3) the delta/estuary buffer zone had been greatly reduced, thus removing a feature which had previously mitigated and reduced the severity of Gulf-coast hurricanes prior to landfall in that region; and 4) existing artificial hurricane protections had not been designed to deal with a hurricane of that severity.
 
The following paper indicates that arctic sea ice was less between 1130 and 1300 than during the 1990s. Published in 2006.

Published in 2006 but about the 90's. It's 2007 now, and a lot's been going since the late nineties. A comparison against the last ten years would be more apposite.



Continentality was greatest during the Little Ice Age but decreased around 1870, 20–30 years before the rise in temperatures indicated by the δ18O profile. The degree of summer melt was significantly larger during the period 1130–1300 than in the 1990s.​

What exactly is continentality? It's new to me, but I'm no expert in the field.

Discussed here, and here to some extent.

I looked at the first one and it didn't tell me what continentality is. The second does,

"The seasonality in the amplitude of the oxygen isotope within the ice core could therefore be used to create a continentality index that could represent distance to open water through time, or relative size of an ice field that advances/retreats toward/away from the island."

Are you happy with all the "coulds" in there? And it does all seem to be about one specific island in the Arctic. Reading total sea-ice extent from that is frankly silly. All these guys were doing - and I don't think they claim anything else - was that the local summer ice-loss was at a minimum back in the day when Danes were fearsome.

The climate was quite warm around that period - you can see this on Mann et al and many other reconstructions, and it also makes historical sense. This would have affected wind-patterns around Svalrsbad ( and lots of other places) and sea-ice does respond to winds. There's really nothing to go on in this claim.

That won't stop McIntyre trumpeting it, of course (the first link). And I don't suppose you'll ever stop falling for him.


eta : when I say wind affects sea-ice, I'm not referring to its extent but to its location.
 
Last edited:
Although no particular hurricane can in itself be tied to climate change, AGW is bringing the expected increase in volatile weather including hurricanes. Hurricane Felix is at a 5 right now... we can't say it is definitely due to AGW either, but worsening hurricanes and weather extremes have been predicted due to AGW and we are experiencing such all over the world.

All we can do is say that we have an increase... we can't say which one's are part of the increase... you are dishonest luchog and mhaze (but what else is new).
 
Nor would some commentary on the links you provide. Save people guessing why you posted them.

Anyway, so by broader you mean historical, and by 'can't hurt' you mean.... what?

There is huge variability in the artic ice, so it would seem. Here's one guy who describes the (accurate) animation of the ice as being the pulsing heart of a chaotic lunatic.

The evidence is that the current variation is not outside natural variation historically, and there is no reason whatsoever to presume that events in the Artic today are somehow related to man made global warming. The current decades are a subset of those in which Arctic sea ice decreases.

Alarmism is utterly ridiculous. Like hysterical women all jumping up on tables and chairs because there is a wild raccoon in the parlor. I'm using the analogy of a wild raccoon because that Mother Nature is not exactly a little docile sheep that placidly is led where Man wants.
 
...Alarmism is utterly ridiculous. ....


No, what IS ridiculous is your politically-motivated denial of global warming, and the various dishonest tactics you use to obsfucate the discussion. For you very obviously the politics comes WAAAY before the science, and instead of it.

Here is the latest news on the Arctic. Please don't bore us with your latest apologias.

from The Guardian

The Arctic ice cap has collapsed at an unprecedented rate this summer and levels of sea ice in the region now stand at record lows, scientists have announced. Experts say they are "stunned" by the loss of ice, with an area almost twice as big as the UK disappearing in the last week alone.

So much ice has melted this summer that the Northwest passage across the top of Canada is fully navigable, and observers say the Northeast passage along Russia's Arctic coast could open later this month.
......
The Arctic has now lost about a third of its ice since satellite measurements began thirty years ago, and the rate of loss has accelerated sharply since 2002. ....
 
{snip}The evidence is that the current variation is not outside natural variation historically, and there is no reason whatsoever to presume that events in the Artic today are somehow related to man made global warming. The current decades are a subset of those in which Arctic sea ice decreases.

Emphatic statements like the above set off alarm bells with me. Not because I'm looking for reasons to disagree with you, but because you write with such certainty. I find your lack of doubt... disturbing.

The issues are rather less settled than you present them. Can the loss of ice be attributed to AGW? To what extent? What are the uncertainties? There is an interesting discussion to be had here.

Alarmism is utterly ridiculous. Like hysterical women all jumping up on tables and chairs because there is a wild raccoon in the parlor. I'm using the analogy of a wild raccoon because that Mother Nature is not exactly a little docile sheep that placidly is led where Man wants.


Non sequitur? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Suddenly ?

I think Safe-Keeper misplaced his "suddenly". The collapse is sudden, the melting is not.

I lived in North London in the 80's when relatively low rainfall and a clay-soil led to a lot of sudden subsidence. The shrinkage in the clay was gradual, but the effects generally weren't. Overnight one edge of an Edwardian semi-detached could drop by a few centimetres, which may not sound like much but these properties weren't designed to bend. Unsurprisnlgy, they tended to fracture instead. Not collapse, fortunately, but those fissures were pretty disconcerting. And did the property-value no favours at all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom