North Pole is melting faster than predicted

If it is primarily an economic one - and the resistor / denier crowd definitely wishes to make this a money issue - then we are screwed. There's no sense in having banks full of cash - with a croaked human species. Future space archaeologists would howl over that one.

"Geez I wonder why this species went extinct?"

"My guess is it cost too much bucks for them to save themselves. Thrifty fossils. Gotta admire 'em for that, though. Least they didn't exceed their credit limits."

There's this extremely simple rule, and that is: As long as there is enough good air, water, food, good health and safe shelter for every human on the planet - then everything else is purely made-up crap. That's all it is. The stock market? We made it up, it's a game. Money? Credit? Deficits and surpluses? Games, games, games.

For example, I live in Los Angeles. We are suffering through our driest season on record. Now let's say that in order to get freshwater, we have to build solar-powered desalinization plants along the ocean coastlines. And we can't move out - we have to make it right here. We've got the materials and the skills - but no money to pay workers to do it. If it came to that, people would simply work for nothing to build those plants. We'd all do our little work shifts, get watered and fed - but no paychecks. Just because it appears we are joined at the hip to monetary compensation - does not make it so. It's really just a temporary and tenuous agreement.

An independent observer might note that California's governor, a Republican, is rather progressive when it comes to the environment. Could it be that he can't move either, and he sees the way the tides are turning?

Certainly, the anti-AGW movement is a political and economic one, as anyone with a brain and the ability to look at the facts can attest to.
 
So how much sea level change does it require to have major impact on humanity, do you think?

As Conspir noted, desalination plants would be needed with a 1 meter sea rise in certain places. Unlike what Conspir noted, no, people don't go build them for free, they are build by companies that do that sort of stuff. Actually, in CA, the unions would really laugh at the idea of letting people who wanted to work for free on the job site.

Desalination plants need power to run them, of course. Lots of it. Sounds like more new coal fired power plants. Carbon sequesteration from power plants does not exist, but has been estimated if built to use about 1/2 to 2/3 of the total power output of the plant. So forget that - it was just science fiction, anyway.

So you are looking at higher water prices, and some effect on farming which might become uneconomic under those conditions.

It's been noted before that Bangladesh was pretty low. Isn't that a mistake in it's own right. Didn't Holland take care of it's own problems with sea level pretty nicely?
 
But here is perhaps the flaw with that thinking: IF the freshwater ice is alREADY floating in the saltwater, that means that the displacement has already worked out the weight disparity!

That makes no sense. Just consider an extreme case. Drop a chunk of ice into a pool of mercury. It will float high and barely displace any of the mercury. The volume of water added to the mercury-plus-water level when it melts will be much greater than that displacement.

Also, the relation between water salinity and density is nearly linear in the range of interest to us, so there is no funny business there.
 
And ....

the polar bears are after him.:eek:
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1890842/posts

Sep 04, 2007
British Yachtsman Who Counted On Global Warming to Cross Arctic Now Trapped by Ice P.J. Gladnick’s blog

In one of the most hilarious cases of being tripped up by dubious scientific hype, British yachtsman Adrian Flanagan attempted to be the first to sail across the arctic north of Russia. He based his hope on the fact that he believed in the Global Warming propaganda that the arctic is rapidly losing its ice thus making his trip possible.

One little problem. Cold cruel reality has crushed the Global Warming hype and now Flanagan’s boat is trapped by ice in the arctic. To add to the irony, Flanagan who seems to be destined to go down in history as Wrong Way Flanagan, is now pleading with Russian authorities to provide him with the services of a nuclear powered icebreaker to get him out of his embarrassing situation.
​


http://www.icecap.us/

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1890842/posts

I don't know about the merits of his getting the services of the nuclear powered icebreaker but I'd contribute to dropping him some high powered rifles by parachute. Sort of a "funny and not funny" thing here.
 
Of course if the a 2 mile thick slab of ice somehow leaves the land, the land rises by about 5000 feet.

To look at sea level, you have to use the entire planet ice mass balance, since it will go up in one place and down in another. Then add thermal expansions.

Greenland has about 6% of the total ice.

Which leaves 94% elsewhere. In the Andes, the Alps, the Arctic Ocean, Canada, the Himalayas, Scandinavia, Siberia, Africa, and of course the Antarctic. Much of that is far more susceptible to melting than the two-mile thick part of the Greenland icecap (or Central Antarctica, for that matter). Remember, the ice on Greenland is up to two miles thick. It's not all two-miles thick. And a lot of it is sliding towards the sea at a relatively good lick.

If all of Greenland's ice melting is an alarming prospect, a much smaller proportion of the other 94% is equally alarming.

Sea-level rise up to now has been mostly from thermal expansion, but the proportions are changing fast. That's why a metre-and-more sea-level rise over the next century is a perfectly rational projection.
 
And ....

the polar bears are after him.:eek:


Sep 04, 2007
British Yachtsman Who Counted On Global Warming to Cross Arctic Now Trapped by Ice P.J. Gladnick’s blog



In one of the most hilarious cases of being tripped up by dubious scientific hype, British yachtsman Adrian Flanagan attempted to be the first to sail across the arctic north of Russia. He based his hope on the fact that he believed in the Global Warming propaganda that the arctic is rapidly losing its ice thus making his trip possible. ​

One little problem. Cold cruel reality has crushed the Global Warming hype and now Flanagan’s boat is trapped by ice in the arctic. To add to the irony, Flanagan who seems to be destined to go down in history as Wrong Way Flanagan, is now pleading with Russian authorities to provide him with the services of a nuclear powered icebreaker to get him out of his embarrassing situation. ​

http://www.icecap.us/

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1890842/posts

I don't know about the merits of his getting the services of the nuclear powered icebreaker but I'd contribute to dropping him some high powered rifles by parachute. Sort of a "funny and not funny" thing here.

So an idiot's interpretation of what's actually meant by Arctic sea-ice retreat can get you into trouble. What does this tell us?
 
Last edited:
Now with even more melting:

The Greenland ice cap is melting so quickly that it is triggering earthquakes as pieces of ice several cubic kilometres in size break off.

Scientists monitoring events this summer say the acceleration could be catastrophic in terms of sea-level rise and make predictions this February by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change far too low.

The glacier at Ilulissat, which supposedly spawned the iceberg that sank the Titantic, is now flowing three times faster into the sea than it was 10 years ago.

Robert Correll, chairman of the Arctic Climate Impact Assessment, said in Ilulissat today: "We have seen a massive acceleration of the speed with which these glaciers are moving into the sea. The ice is moving at two metres an hour on a front 5km [3 miles] long and 1,500 metres deep. That means that this one glacier puts enough fresh water into the sea in one year to provide drinking water for a city the size of London for a year."

http://www.guardian.co.uk/international/story/0,,2164776,00.html

Sure sounds like something significant is happening.

The glacier is now moving at 15km a year into the sea although in surges it moves even faster. He measured one surge at 5km in 90 minutes - an extraordinary event.
 
Minor point: in the OP, the article said that the Arctic could be ice free in as little as a couple of decades. I've heard a similar thing on a radio show--though they did clarify that'd it'd only be ice-free in the summer.

Are they saying the Arctic Ocean will be ice free or "the Arctic" (which I certainly take to include Greenland, or least that part of it that lies within the Arctic Circle)?

The reference is to sea-ice, not land-ice. There'll still be icebergs from glaciers until they run out.

Back to more current discussion: at the very least we need to address the unprecedented development of shorelines. A higher proportion of the population lives close to the shore than ever before.

Something else, which we've been made very aware of in Europe over the last decade, is the development on floodplains. And it's still going on. Sea-level rise is one thing, the more frequent occurrence of torrential downpours is another.

Like coastal development, floodplain development is one of its own worst enemies. But it's how things have always been done ...
 
Why isn't it reasonable to think it would go back towards increased ice? That's what has happened in the past.

Polar history shows melting ice-cap may be a natural cycle


The recent past has not been like the present. The present has 385ppmCO2. The visible - and predicted - effects of that are all around us (the Arctic Ocean is just the harbinger, since that's where the warming is predictably most rapid). It isn't reasonable to think that it'll all just stop for no reason. A "natural cycle" evident in the past is not a reason. This is the present, and the present is a very different country.

Hope what you like, but it isn't gonna happen.
 
The reference is to sea-ice, not land-ice. There'll still be icebergs from glaciers until they run out.

That's what I thought (see my first post in this thread). Also, the report I'm reading now doesn't even say the Arctic Ocean will be "ice free" in 15-20 years, but
An analysis of 20 years' worth of real-life observations supports recent U.N. computer predictions that by 2050, summer sea ice off Alaska's north coast will probably shrink to nearly half the area it covered in the 1980s, federal scientists say.
Source.

Granted, the news is alarming, and supports the GW models, but it's not the same as saying "if this unexpectedly faster trend continues, the Artic could be ice-free in as little as 15-20 years", which, as I said before, would mean a major catastrophe is immanent.

Like coastal development, floodplain development is one of its own worst enemies. But it's how things have always been done ...
Don't get me started! One of my pet peeves is the ridiculous unplanned development/suburban sprawl we've got going here around St. Louis. The more soil you cover with pavement, the more water goes in storm sewers to swell the streams and rivers.

I used to consider a highway to be like a ribbon--long and narrow, but these interstates nowadays are wide enough to accommodate a basketball court acrosswise (and naturally hundreds of miles long). We're talking huge areas that are bone dry under the concrete and asphalt.

Oh yeah--and commuting 20 plus miles each way to work has become routine for lots of people.
 
That's what I thought (see my first post in this thread). Also, the report I'm reading now doesn't even say the Arctic Ocean will be "ice free" in 15-20 years, but
Source.

Granted, the news is alarming, and supports the GW models, but it's not the same as saying "if this unexpectedly faster trend continues, the Artic could be ice-free in as little as 15-20 years", which, as I said before, would mean a major catastrophe is immanent.

To my mind, a twenty-year analysis is too long to pick up a strong signal from the last five years or so. I think we've entered a new regime. The next few years should give us a definitive answer on that.


Don't get me started! One of my pet peeves is the ridiculous unplanned development/suburban sprawl we've got going here around St. Louis. The more soil you cover with pavement, the more water goes in storm sewers to swell the streams and rivers.

Doing things the same old way never requires justification; changing behaviour always does, and the inertia of the vested interests it struggles against is enormous. The first reaction is usually to try engineering around problems as they emerge. Bigger storm-drains, higher levees, whatever.

Change is almost always forced.
 
Hi Guys,
I just started following this thread - the situation looks even more alarming than even the most pessimistic among you might think. The AGW deny-ers should see this - (aitch tee tee pee)//nsidc.org/news/press/2007_seaiceminimum/20070810_index.html (Sorry, not allowed to link sites yet).
Basically, the actic sea ice coverage for the month of August is 240,000km less than the lowest ever coverage previously seen - that was in September 2005!! One month early, and already dramatically down. As if that was not bad enough, the rate of decrease has just suddenly increased, instead of (as has historically been the case for August) levelling off!!
I, personally, find this very alarming!:eek:
 
One pretty good way to look at what's going on with possible sea level change is .... look at sea level change. Actual sea level is the sum of all glacier, polar and sea ice changes, plus various other things.

So here is sea level "change".



Whoops. No change.

Data series from the TOPEX satellites through 2006. Sea level change is a couple mm per year. What has it been historically?

Wikipedia has what seems to be a pretty good page on this.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise
More or less the same - no increase, or a decrease.

Let's go back to the chart for a second. If things were getting worse, there would be an increasing rise? Is there one? No. Just a straight line.

So where is the evidence of this alarming catastrophe? Something better than the Guardian, please. Looks like they do bend a bit toward sensationalism. Must sell newspapers.

CP, you conjecture that 385 ppm CO2 is responsible for something happening that doesn't even seem to be happening. That must mean that 385 ppm CO2 does not have an effect different from historical levels.

Or did CO2 suddenly, right now in the year 2007, start to have this effect, and thence is your prediction that the above chart, when updated for 2007, will show a sudden jump?
 
So how much sea level change does it require to have major impact on humanity, do you think?

So here is the conundrum we face: Do we want palm trees growing in Milwaukee, with no Miami? Hmmmmmm.
 
Hmm.. mhaze presents data purportedly showing absolutely Zero sea level rise, then points to the Wikipedia Sea Level Rise page which directly contradicts this assertion - See the "Recent Sea Level Rise" graph right at the top-right of the page. Sea-levels have been rising since around the beginning of the last century.
 
Hi Guys,
I just started following this thread - the situation looks even more alarming than even the most pessimistic among you might think. The AGW deny-ers should see this - (aitch tee tee pee)//nsidc.org/news/press/2007_seaiceminimum/20070810_index.html (Sorry, not allowed to link sites yet).
Basically, the actic sea ice coverage for the month of August is 240,000km less than the lowest ever coverage previously seen - that was in September 2005!! One month early, and already dramatically down. As if that was not bad enough, the rate of decrease has just suddenly increased, instead of (as has historically been the case for August) levelling off!!
I, personally, find this very alarming!:eek:

Reading on down, these scientists note the major cause is what I already said it was (my quip was 49 of 53 days of clear sky).
Contributing to the loss: sea-level pressure and clear skies
Why have we seen such a rapid loss of sea ice in the summer of 2007? A major cause is unusually clear-sky conditions in the months of June and July. Figure 3 is a contour map of sea-level pressure averaged for June and July. High pressure dominated the central Arctic Ocean during this period, promoting very sunny conditions just at the time the sun is highest in the sky over the far north. This led to an unusually high amount of solar energy being pumped onto the Arctic ice surface, accelerating the melting process. Satellite data show that skies over the Beaufort Sea were clear or mostly clear for 43 of the 55 days between June 1 and July 23, 2007.
​
The Great Melting Sea Ice Disaster Alarm is now a wrap.

No huge sea level increase obvious from the recent record of the last 10 years or the last 1000 years.

No alarming effect from all that CO2 we evil humans put out.

Natural cycles of 60-80 years are definitely in effect, as previously noted.
 
Hmm.. mhaze presents data purportedly showing absolutely Zero sea level rise, then points to the Wikipedia Sea Level Rise page which directly contradicts this assertion - See the "Recent Sea Level Rise" graph right at the top-right of the page. Sea-levels have been rising since around the beginning of the last century.

Umm, I was a bit unclear. "More or less the same" I was intending to mean more or less the same as the last ten years shown in the satellite data, about 2-3 mm per year - not more or less the same meaning zero sea level rise.

Also, welcome, Beelz.
 
Reading on down, these scientists note the major cause is what I already said it was (my quip was 49 of 53 days of clear sky).
Contributing to the loss: sea-level pressure and clear skies
Why have we seen such a rapid loss of sea ice in the summer of 2007? A major cause is unusually clear-sky conditions in the months of June and July. Figure 3 is a contour map of sea-level pressure averaged for June and July. High pressure dominated the central Arctic Ocean during this period, promoting very sunny conditions just at the time the sun is highest in the sky over the far north. This led to an unusually high amount of solar energy being pumped onto the Arctic ice surface, accelerating the melting process. Satellite data show that skies over the Beaufort Sea were clear or mostly clear for 43 of the 55 days between June 1 and July 23, 2007.
​
The Great Melting Sea Ice Disaster Alarm is now a wrap.

No huge sea level increase obvious from the recent record of the last 10 years or the last 1000 years.

No alarming effect from all that CO2 we evil humans put out.

Natural cycles of 60-80 years are definitely in effect, as previously noted.

I don't think you can say, from this, that "The Great Melting Sea Ice Disaster Alarm is now a wrap". The clear skies will have contributed to the melting, no doubt, but the sheer amount of sea-ice cover reduction is unprecedented. (BTW, I was in Greenland this summer, and it was cold, cloudy and wet:( )
As for "No alarming effect from all that CO2 we evil humans put out", that is plain silly - The scientists have got their models of sea-ice cover wrong, not because they were exagerating, but because they were overly optimistic! The models tried to factor in this "evil human CO2", but reality is showing us that this factor wasn't nearly enough - Anthropic contributions are having an even greater effect than even the most dyed-in-the-wool AWG supporters thought. Note that models with anthropic effects removed (i.e. just natural variations, solar output etc) predict nothing like what we have been observing in the real world. Sooner or later we have to face it - the warming trends over the last few years/decades can only really be explained if we factor-in human (anthropogenic) contributions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom