North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Believer?
Now that isn't the right term or right approach. I just look at data and draw conclusions from it, those being subject to change as new data is acquired, found or discovered.

When others do that you call them believers, but when you do it "believer" isn't the right term?

Such as those references I am waiting for from you on the the lack of evidence from ocean currents being related to 60-80 year climate cycles.

You're asking me to prove a negative.

Speaking of which ...

Here is John M. commenting on www.climateaudit.org about the "big bad analogue model".




John M. says: October 2nd, 2007 at 9:57 pm
... As a child in the 1970s back when an imminent new ice age was sometimes being mentioned as a possibility on the television, I could see skating ponds built during the LIA in the countryside around the village where I grew up that could hardly ever be used as it seldom ever got cold enough for the water to freeze sufficiently to safely use them. ... I could also see field patterns for cropland dating back to the MWP and Roman times at altitudes where there was only sheep pasture in the modern era. Dramatic historical natural climate changes were obvious in other words and everybody knew about it.​
Scientists were already seriously concerned about global warming by the late 80s and early 90s before Mann published his paper and Hansen started playing around with the historical temperature record.​
Showing they are possibly up to mischief in terms of the scientific method doesn’t change much in the big scheme of things in other words.​

Up to mischief, eh? And playing around with the historical temperature record. Presumably as represented by John M's down-home meanderings.

I don't know where John M's village is, but I'd want something more solid than what he heard as a boy to be convinced they weren't created as fish-ponds rather than skating-ponds. Those were a common Medieval feature in Europe, a useful source of protein. Giving over potentially productive land to skating-ponds was not a common feature.

It certainly was colder in Europe in the 16thCE than in the 20thCE, particularly in the Lowlands (where skating is traditionally popular) and Germany. It was also colder in the 19thCE, which is probably when the "skating-pond" tradition originated.

The sheep-pasture point suggests that this is an English village. There's a fallacy at play here which probably has a fancy name. Essentially, it involves attributing land-use change solely to climate because that suits the argument being made. In fact, economics is far more important, and sheep are often more profitable than peasants. Hence the enclosures and clearances that turned arable land into pasture and peasants into paupers. Wool earned money to buy cheap grain from Poland with a lot left over.


The Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice Age are built on such tenuous sands as these. This is the "historical temperature record" John M refers to - stuff he heard as a child about the European experience. When it turns out the global experience doesn't match it, he thinks that has to be wrong and somebody's "playing around with the historical temperature record". In fact, the warm 10th-12thCE and cool 16thCE are there in the reconstructions, but they're not as pronounced as the European tradition has it. (Which is, by the way, rather exaggerated. There was a lot of other stuff going on in 16thCE Europe.)

The multiplicity of such reconstructions, independently produced, argues that they're pretty much on the button.
 
So in other words, many other people do not share your opinion about the evidence produced by the "big bad analogue model" for global warming.

As for your issues with the Medieval Warming Period and the Little Ice Age, unfortunately, their existence is not really debatable.

Well, with one exception, and that is if someone wanted to play grammer games. Like first define MWP as being more than 5C hotter, and define LIA as being more than 5C cooler. Then voila! They just went away!

Alternately, of course, one could argue that they were regional. And that would cause either myself or someone else to reply with a world map with hundreds of locations where studies show evidence of the phenomena. So that avenue (LIA and MWP) does not seem a productive one for discussion at all. Of course, you are always welcome to your opinion.

Then yet again, Singer's 1,500 year cycles are built on the concept of repeating cycles of events such as the MWP and LIA, and he provides hundreds of studies to support his theory.

But that just leads back to my challenge, can anyone refute his theory.;)
 
A good description of what has happened.

http://tamino.wordpress.com/2007/10/01/explain-this/

Just a cycle?
As usual, the comments trump the blogger. Some are pretty funny. Tamino was on Climateaudit, got kicked off for using 4 letter words and essentially, trolling. I think he is back and behaving now. I like this comment on the graphs (same old Arctic sea ice graphs)
Wellll… OK then. Try this: We can happily attribute the overall trend to GW - its what we expect, and its what the models show. This years anomaly is *not* what we expect and its *not* what the models show. Why should we attribute it to GW? What do you expect to see next year?

​
See...it's not what the models show.... you believe in models...you don't get to attribute it to being caused by GW.

Climate is not a linear equation or group of them.



`





​
 
As usual, the comments trump the blogger. Some are pretty funny. Tamino was on Climateaudit, got kicked off for using 4 letter words and essentially, trolling. I think he is back and behaving now. I like this comment on the graphs (same old Arctic sea ice graphs)
Wellll… OK then. Try this: We can happily attribute the overall trend to GW - its what we expect, and its what the models show. This years anomaly is *not* what we expect and its *not* what the models show. Why should we attribute it to GW? What do you expect to see next year?

​
See...it's not what the models show.... you believe in models...you don't get to attribute it to being caused by GW.

Climate is not a linear equation or group of them.



`





​

OK, ignore the evidence, go with the bloggers.
 
Tamino was on Climateaudit, got kicked off for using 4 letter words and essentially, trolling. I think he is back and behaving now.

Libel does not help your argument at all, mhaze. You are lying and you know it.
 
Tamino was on Climateaudit, got kicked off for using 4 letter words and essentially, trolling. I think he is back and behaving now.

Libel does not help your argument at all, mhaze. You are lying and you know it.

Yawn.

Anyone here can go use the search function at climate audit. It is a nice google search. Prove me wrong, dude. I'll be happy to be corrected.

Otherwise, be polite.
 
This was relayed to me to post here.

(begin message)

Re: comments #444 and #447 by mhaze

I am tamino, author of the blog tamino.wordpress.com.
Mistletoesquest has kindly agreed to post this for me.

I have never, ever, posted or commented anything at all on the
climateaudit site. Anyone here can go use the search function at
climateaudit and confirm this. I have often been referred to
in comments on that site, but I have never commented or posted
anything there.

Your statement that I "got kicked off for using 4 letter words and
essentially, trolling" is not only false, it's libelous. When you are
criticized for this, you challenge the critic to prove you wrong and
to "be polite." I challenge you to admit you are wrong and apologize.

(end message)

The burden of proof, "dude", is yours; you're the one to make this outlandish claim in the first place. You have a lot of nerve telling me to be polite, when you're the one trying to pass off a falsehood as fact. I'd expect better of a member of this forum.
 
This was relayed to me to post here.

(begin message)

Re: comments #444 and #447 by mhaze

I am tamino, author of the blog tamino.wordpress.com.
Mistletoesquest has kindly agreed to post this for me.

I have never, ever, posted or commented anything at all on the
climateaudit site. Anyone here can go use the search function at
climateaudit and confirm this. I have often been referred to
in comments on that site, but I have never commented or posted
anything there.

Your statement that I "got kicked off for using 4 letter words and
essentially, trolling" is not only false, it's libelous. When you are
criticized for this, you challenge the critic to prove you wrong and
to "be polite." I challenge you to admit you are wrong and apologize.

(end message)

The burden of proof, "dude", is yours; you're the one to make this outlandish claim in the first place. You have a lot of nerve telling me to be polite, when you're the one trying to pass off a falsehood as fact. I'd expect better of a member of this forum.

RE Tamino, Mistletoesquest

You are correct. I apologize. I was confusing "Tamino" with another frequent poster at climateaudit whose name also begins with a capital T. On examination find that although your name comes up frequently, it is in reference to your work and never in a derogatory sense.

Mhaze
 
See...it's not what the models show.... you believe in models...you don't get to attribute it to being caused by GW.
Climate is not a linear equation or group of them.

Models are based on differential equations, but that's as maybe.

Climate models predict warming in the Arctic and ice-loss as a result. The extent and rate of the ice-loss are determined by ide-dynamics models, and it's these that have turned out to underestimate the effect of the accurately predicted climate change.

I'm sure we've been over this ground before.

Climate models incorporate ice-loss according to the predictions of ice-dynamics models. A single model incorporating both would be ridiculous. Ice-dynamics models have consistently turned out to underestimate the rate of melting. That means climate models similarly underestimate the reduction in albedo, and thus underestimate the rate of warming.

Modelling ice-dynamics is far more difficult than modelling climate, which is a doddle in comparison. With Arctic ice you have water in all three phases interacting in a variety of combinations. Surface melt-water and ice, water-vapour and ice, water-vapour and ocean, ocean and ice. It's a nightmare. I wouldn't be surprised if it's still in catch-up mode when the only ice that's left is in Central Antarctica.

The upshot is that the Arctic has warmed, as was predicted, and sea-ice has retreated, as was predicted. The rate of warming is within the predicted range, but the rate of sea-ice retreat is not. It's above the predicted range. Climate models will have to be adjusted to take account of that. Given the albedo feedback, that can only mean an upward movement in the predicted rate of Arctic warming (and warming in general).

We should start to see the effect on the big bad analogue model in the next three-to-eight years, I'd say.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your consideration.

Thinking of which, where did you get that idea from in the first place? I don't suspect you of making it up yourself, so your retraction in this particular backwater doesn't come close to lancing the boil. I'm sure you're as eager as we all are that this egregious calumny be nailed at source.

If I searched ClimateAudit for the esteemed tamino, would I find the answer there, do you think, amongst the comments? Obviously McIntyre wouldn't be personally involved.
 
Not at all surprised to see someone who isn't present to defend themselves being libeled in this fashion, nor to see the same sort of rhetorical tricks used in defense of it. I am surprised to see an apology; that's unusual, from that source.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom