North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Umm, I was a bit unclear. "More or less the same" I was intending to mean more or less the same as the last ten years shown in the satellite data, about 2-3 mm per year - not more or less the same meaning zero sea level rise.

Also, welcome, Beelz.

Thanks for the welcome!:)
I was commenting on your "More or less the same - no increase, or a decrease." bit, and the apparent zero increase showing on the graph at the top of your post. The tide-hight figures show a different story. Also note that the Holocene sea-level rise following on from the end of the ice-age, show a distinct levelling-off for at least the last thousand years. Until now, that is. Since the beginning of the last century, sea-levels have started rising again, and we have to ask why.
 
British Yachtsman Who Counted On Global Warming to Cross Arctic Now Trapped by Ice
So misinformation and poor research are wrong undesirable. Thank you.

No alarming effect from all that CO2 we evil humans put out.
What about the 480 landslides in Hordaland county, Norway, from spring '06 to today alone, caused by the increase in precipitation? We've still got ten families living in temporary homes after the worst of them, back in September 2005.

Oh, and these slides were predicted, after the aforementioned slide in 2005. Scientists figured out that our county and a surrounding one would see increased precipitation and as a result more landslides. The worst thing is that while the municipalities try to map and secure all landslide risk locations, slides are not only far more numerous than anticipated, they're also occurring in places no one would dream to see them. It's like trying to lock down day care centers in a district against a flamboyant pedophile rapist, only to catch him breaking into a clothes workshop to sexually molest a mannequin.

We've got only sheer dumb luck on a near-divine scale to thank for that only four lives have been lost to slides so far - there have been some uncomfortably close calls when roads have suddenly been hit by cascades of rock and mud. As a resident of this very mountainous region, I am alarmed by this turn of events, and hope that the last two years have been a 'hiccup' and that the predictions are wrong. Which I know they aren't.
 
So misinformation and poor research are wrong undesirable. Thank you.

What about the 480 landslides in Hordaland county, Norway, from spring '06 to today alone, caused by the increase in precipitation? We've still got ten families living in temporary homes after the worst of them, back in September 2005.

The link in #883 does indicate that an increase in temperature will cause an increase in atmospheric moisture, right? Three times what was previously believed?

So how do you connect the dots from this, to global warming, and thence, to CO2 as the culprit? Therein are the logical errors.

Misinformation and poor research are wrong undesirable. I agree with you.
 
The link in #883 does indicate that an increase in temperature will cause an increase in atmospheric moisture, right? Three times what was previously believed?

So how do you connect the dots from this, to global warming, and thence, to CO2 as the culprit? Therein are the logical errors.

Misinformation and poor research are wrong undesirable. I agree with you.

Australia is having similar problem. A land that has just experienced sustained drought, is still experiencing drought, plus largely useless regional flooding. Many farmers are just about to experience yet another year of crop failure. CO2 -> Global Warming -> Extreme Weather Events.
 
Australia is having similar problem. A land that has just experienced sustained drought, is still experiencing drought, plus largely useless regional flooding. Many farmers are just about to experience yet another year of crop failure. CO2 -> Global Warming -> Extreme Weather Events.

CO2 -> Global Warming -> Extreme Weather Events.

A -> B -> C

Hmm....

Then you can show a curve of increasing "global warming" with increasing CO2, and decreasing "global warming" with decreasing CO2 atmospheric concentrations?

And a statistical chart of extreme weather events that correlates with increasing temperature, and which decreases with decreasing temperature?
 
One pretty good way to look at what's going on with possible sea level change is .... look at sea level change. Actual sea level is the sum of all glacier, polar and sea ice changes, plus various other things.

Well there's a thing.


No change in what? What do you think this chart signifies?

Data series from the TOPEX satellites through 2006. Sea level change is a couple mm per year. What has it been historically?

The chart shows about 4mm change in "anomaly" over 12 years. The current decadal rate is 3.5-4mm pa.

In the 19thCE sea-level rise was zero, as I recall. I've not much on the few centuries previous to that, but there's no obvious signal of inexorable sea-level rise. beelzebub reckons there was little or no change over the last thousand years. I trust in beelzebub (so to speak :) ).

Wikipedia has what seems to be a pretty good page on this.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise
More or less the same - no increase, or a decrease.

No habla Wikipedia.

Let's go back to the chart for a second. If things were getting worse, there would be an increasing rise? Is there one? No. Just a straight line.

Glacial melt is only just kicking in. The 1998-2010 chart is where it'll become evident.

So where is the evidence of this alarming catastrophe? Something better than the Guardian, please. Looks like they do bend a bit toward sensationalism. Must sell newspapers.

Try to stick to the science. In future, such digressions will merely merit a :rolleyes: from me. Ideological prejudices have no place in science.

CP, you conjecture that 385 ppm CO2 is responsible for something happening that doesn't even seem to be happening.

Of course it's happening. Have you not looked outside recently? Nor felt the tremors emanating from Greenland? (Rhetorical)



That must mean that 385 ppm CO2 does not have an effect different from historical levels.

It would if the effects of AGW were not so abundantly clear. Most dramatically in the Arctic, which is where warming was predicted to be most rapid and, lo, it is. Ask anyone in Norway, they'll tell you.

Or did CO2 suddenly, right now in the year 2007, start to have this effect, and thence is your prediction that the above chart, when updated for 2007, will show a sudden jump?

Given that your premise is bollocks, the "or" option is as redundant as your conclusion.

No amount of chart-diving and suckling from ClimateAudit's teats is going to bring back any ice, break any droughts, or prevent any floods. Nor is it going to persuade people that the evidence of their own senses is not to be trusted. Even if they don't have the exact figures, or know how they should interpret them. You can fool all the people some of the time, and some all of the time, but you can't fool most people for long. AGW has decades of backing from popular observation. Even Bush Minor has gone hands-up to that.

I've come to a tentative conclusion that most people who contest the reality and significance of AGW spend a lot of their time in controlled environments. Bush Minor does get out quite a bit. (As an alternative to getting out of it quite a bit ...)
 
The link in #883 does indicate that an increase in temperature will cause an increase in atmospheric moisture, right?

#883? Aren't you getting a bit ahead of yourself?

Of course an increase in oceanic and atmospheric temperature will lead to an increased evaporation rate, and so more water vapour in the atmosphere. Consider it a very tiny transfer of water from the oceans to the atmosphere.

Three times what was previously believed?

Previous to what, and by whom?

The water-vapour response to increased temperatures is just what would be expected from basic science. Evaporation is a well-studied subject from way back. Refrigeration's based on it, and that's hardly a new technology.

So how do you connect the dots from this, to global warming, and thence, to CO2 as the culprit? Therein are the logical errors.

From this? What is this "this" you speak of?

I'll come up with some dots of my own. CO2 is a greenhouse gas. More CO2 means more greenhouse effect, and so a higher equilibrium temperature in that thin skin of fluids on the surface of the planet. Any increase in temperature leads to a transfer of H2O from ocean to atmosphere. H2O is itself a greenhouse gas, and so acts as a positive feedback to any warming influence. In the current case, this initial influence is the first dot - more CO2 in the atmosphere.

The increased CO2-load is the result of a non-climate-related influence, aka the first ever industrialised species on the planet doing its inevitable thing. In that very thin skin of fluids.

Misinformation and poor research are wrong undesirable. I agree with you.

And yet you take suck from such weasels as Singer and McIntyre, while damning honest scientists on their say-so. Maybe we have a language problem here.
 
I just find everyone's apparent panic to be funny. This has happened before, IIRC, and life has continued apace. Well, there's been some disruption, of course - entire species dying off, for example. And humans might not make it through total global warming. But life will still carry on, and repopulate the earth until the next ice age, and it's back to square one again.

Considering mankind's ingenuity, science, and technology, there's a pretty good possibility that some humans will still survive total global warming and be able to rebuild toward the next ice age. It's just part of nature. Accept it, and prepare for survival.
 
CO2 -> Global Warming -> Extreme Weather Events.

A -> B -> C

Hmm....

Then you can show a curve of increasing "global warming" with increasing CO2, and decreasing "global warming" with decreasing CO2 atmospheric concentrations?

We've been watching the actual CO2-increase global warming and its effects for some time now. That experience is no less real for not being reduced to a curve. We haven't had the option of directly observing a CO2-decrease.

And a statistical chart of extreme weather events that correlates with increasing temperature, and which decreases with decreasing temperature?

Such demands do not make reality go away. Extreme weather events have been becoming more frequent for at least a decade. Just watch the news. Coverage tends to be hurricane-heavy, since that affects 'Murricans, but there's a lot more been going on out there. In the big world.

And it's not as if there's been a shortage of other stories - war, scandal, financial jiggery-pokery, the rise of China and India (and partial eclipse of Japan). Yet there it is, extreme weather news.

The thing about extreme is that it's subjectively evaluated. No amount of argument by statistics and appeals to history is going to make headway against that.
 
I just find everyone's apparent panic to be funny. This has happened before, IIRC, and life has continued apace. Well, there's been some disruption, of course - entire species dying off, for example. And humans might not make it through total global warming. But life will still carry on, and repopulate the earth until the next ice age, and it's back to square one again.

Considering mankind's ingenuity, science, and technology, there's a pretty good possibility that some humans will still survive total global warming and be able to rebuild toward the next ice age. It's just part of nature. Accept it, and prepare for survival.

I don't doubt that human society, with all its science and technology and humanism, will survive this time of tribulation and learn from it. It's happened before. Science and what works always wins out over prayer and wishful-thinking.

That's an objective view. The power of monarchs couldn't have been broken without a time of tribulations. My ancestors have survived every such time, at least long enough to breed, and I raise my glass to them. As a boomer, I've had it easy.

The matter becomes subjective when you're emotionally invested in the youngsters who'll experience this time of tribulation. That's where panic lurks. The next ice-age really doesn't feature in such concerns.

Besides which, HomSap has no good reason for allowing another glaciation to occur. So it won't.
 
Not that It matters but I wonder if the insurance industry is insuring people whos property may be under water permanently.
 
Last edited:
Not that It matters but I wonder if the insurance industry is insuring people whos property may be under water permanently.

The quality end of the industry is well out of that market, leaving it - or selling it on - to the scalpers.

The quality end of insurance is a bellwether. It has actuaries, and accords them the respect they deserve. And it has deep roots.
 
OK, I've read up on everyone's favorite 2005 hurricane.

Hurricane Katrina hit as a Category 3, yes, but with one of the biggest storm surges in American history, giving it a total strength equal to that of a Category 5 hurricane. In fact, it was not the hurricane, but the storm surge that breached New Orleans' levees.

As for statistics, Katrina was the sixth most powerful hurricane ever recorded in the Atlantic. It pushed ahead of it one of the biggest storm surges in recorded American history. More here.

In conclusion, saying that Katrina was just another Category 3 and that it was the levees which were at fault is... wrong. As a matter of fact, it's like saying that the high number of lives lost on 9/11 is not the fault of Usama, but of the Americans for not strengthening the towers sufficiently to withstand impacts from hijacked 767s, or stopping the hijackers before they boarded their planes. Which is technically true, of course, but like every rational person out there, I'm still considering ole ibn Ladin the main culprit. Guess that makes me an alarmist.
 
OK, I've read up on everyone's favorite 2005 hurricane.

Hurricane Katrina hit as a Category 3, yes, but with one of the biggest storm surges in American history, giving it a total strength equal to that of a Category 5 hurricane. In fact, it was not the hurricane, but the storm surge that breached New Orleans' levees.

As for statistics, Katrina was the sixth most powerful hurricane ever recorded in the Atlantic. It pushed ahead of it one of the biggest storm surges in recorded American history. More here.

In conclusion, saying that Katrina was just another Category 3 and that it was the levees which were at fault is... wrong. As a matter of fact, it's like saying that the high number of lives lost on 9/11 is not the fault of Usama, but of the Americans for not strengthening the towers sufficiently to withstand impacts from hijacked 767s, or stopping the hijackers before they boarded their planes. Which is technically true, of course, but like every rational person out there, I'm still considering ole ibn Ladin the main culprit. Guess that makes me an alarmist.

New Orleans was 'fortunate' Katrina was undergoing an Eyewall Replacement Cycle at around the same time. That sapped a lot of the strength out of it for a short time.
 
AUP, Safekeeper -

You aware that the actual construction of the levees had a large amount of peat used, instead of the proper engineering specification of (expensive) base material? You aware that the Corp. of Engineers drawings showed 17 foot deep iron support, but visual inspection showed the supports were only 10 feet deep?

Let me translate this issue of peat. The contractor with the winning bid is required by the job specification to use base material for the levees that must be trucked in from a quarry. Instead he dredges up muck from nearby because that's free. He builds these things that look like they will hold water back. But they won't, because the peat has no shear strength - under pressure it just oozes sideways and collapses. Contractor pockets large amounts of money....

Would you like your house built on a foundation of peat? How about a road? US taxpayers paid for those jobs, through the Corp. of Engineers. Although this is ancient history now, we got cheated.

That's in a nutshell what happened. There was some question about whether the levees would have worked even if they had been properly constructed, also.
 
The essence of this thread is that "North Pole is melting fasted than predicted". Can anyone explain the following apparent revisions to the historical data? No conspiracy theories please.

First is
----- Images Snipped as I cannot yet include urls in posts (Grrr...:rolleyes:

Hi mhaze,
It only took me 2 mins to find reference to the effect this years melt has on previous predictions. From the 'Seattle Times' 6th Sept:

"About 40 percent of the ice that usually blankets the top of the world during the summer will be gone by 2050, according to a new analysis. Earlier studies had predicted it would be nearly a century before that much ice vanished.

"This is a major change," said James Overland, an oceanographer at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory. "This is actually moving the threshold up."

Scientists blame the rapid melt on a combination of natural weather fluctuations and global warming. But over the next few decades, the effects of global warming will dominate in the region, Overland said. And because greenhouse gases linger in the atmosphere for up to five decades, the melting will intensify even if emissions from cars, power plants and industries are slashed dramatically."

There is no suggestion that AGW is >solely< responsible for these effects, but it is a significant, and growing, contribution. Cloud cover, El Nino and other natural variables will always be present, but these are essentially random - hence it is overall trends that are important in discerning any long-term climactic changes. The graphs you supplied show just such a trend towards polar ice thinning, and the experts really are taken aback with the speed and extent of this change.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom