North Pole is melting faster than predicted

I'm using the analogy of a wild raccoon because that Mother Nature is not exactly a little docile sheep that placidly is led where Man wants.

Nobody's suggesting that we haven't had to beat Mother Nature into doing our will. Nobody's suggesting that she's yet domesticated, and nobody's suggesting that she's going somewhere anybody wants right now. AGW is an unintended consequence of human activity. It's no less a consequence because it's unplanned.
 
No, what IS ridiculous is your politically-motivated denial of global warming ...

Sorry to keep picking at people, it's the pedant in me, but I think ideologically-motivated is more accurate. "Political" carries too much extra baggage, stuff about party and power and pragmatism. "Ideology" is about belief.

... and the various dishonest tactics you use to obsfucate the discussion.

To be fair, I think mhaze is channeling dishonesty he doesn't recognise. It's not deliberate. And there's a modicum of panic, which can lead us all astray.
 
Last edited:
Emphatic statements like the above set off alarm bells with me. Not because I'm looking for reasons to disagree with you, but because you write with such certainty. I find your lack of doubt... disturbing.

The issues are rather less settled than you present them. Can the loss of ice be attributed to AGW? To what extent? What are the uncertainties? There is an interesting discussion to be had here. :rolleyes:

You raise some good points, but I think I'm on firm ice here.;)

How could one say precisely, that the current issue with the ice was related to AGW?

Soot deposition and the Asian "brown clouds" obviously would affect the ice. Sort of AGW (really traditional pollution).

Connect the dots from man made CO2 increases to ice loss? That's one bunch of dots there......
 
Soot deposition and the Asian "brown clouds" obviously would affect the ice. Sort of AGW (really traditional pollution).

When in doubt, change the subject. Doubt is uncomfortable, and Mother Nature has brought us up to seek comfort.

Connect the dots from man made CO2 increases to ice loss? That's one bunch of dots there......

And yet there they are.
 
Emphatic statements like the above set off alarm bells with me. Not because I'm looking for reasons to disagree with you, but because you write with such certainty. I find your lack of doubt... disturbing.

The issues are rather less settled than you present them. Can the loss of ice be attributed to AGW? To what extent? What are the uncertainties? There is an interesting discussion to be had here.

Quite obviously, it is not possible to answer a question such as "To what extent" unless one first determines the natural cycles, then subtracts them out from the data.

Gurder, you assert that the IPCC reports the support the concept of Greenland melting. I presume that you are referring to the A2 scenario modeling. What exactly did you find with reference to that?

As for the North Pole, here is another scientist - one of the Certified, Degreed Brain guys - discussing natural cycles. In the article he does note that if the ice does not begin to increase within a 5 to 10 year time span, then that would be possibly evidence of AGW in terms of the disruption of the established cycle.

Polar history shows melting ice-cap may be a natural cycle

IAN JOHNSTON

THE melting of sea ice at the North Pole may be the result of a centuries-old natural cycle and not an indicator of man-made global warming, Scottish scientists have found.

After researching the log-books of Arctic explorers spanning the past 300 years, scientists believe that the outer edge of sea ice may expand and contract over regular periods of 60 to 80 years. This change corresponds roughly with known cyclical changes in atmospheric temperature.

The finding opens the possibility that the recent worrying changes in Arctic sea ice are simply the result of standard cyclical movements, and not a harbinger of major climate change.

The amount of sea ice is currently near its lowest point in the cycle and should begin to increase within about five years.
 
British Prime Minister Tony Blair wrote in a letter to European heads of state "We have only a window of 10 -15 years to take the steps we need to avoid crossing a catastrophic climate tipping point".

Dr. William Gray, of the University of Colorado, said "Observations and theory do not support these ideas of dangerous human caused warming".

Obviously, both statements are generalizations across a broad group of phenomena and data. These are recent (2007) statements, so we may presume that both knew of the shrinking of North Pole ice.

But the statements are contradictory.

Who is right and why?
 
British Prime Minister Tony Blair wrote in a letter to European heads of state "We have only a window of 10 -15 years to take the steps we need to avoid crossing a catastrophic climate tipping point".

Dr. William Gray, of the University of Colorado, said "Observations and theory do not support these ideas of dangerous human caused warming".

Obviously, both statements are generalizations across a broad group of phenomena and data. These are recent (2007) statements, so we may presume that both knew of the shrinking of North Pole ice.

But the statements are contradictory.

Who is right and why?


Dr. William Gray's view is not supported by the massed weight of scientific consensus. But, since you already "know" he's right, you also don't really need to ask do you?

Gray acknowledges that we've had some warming the past 30 years. "I don't question that," he explains. "And humans might have caused a very slight amount of this warming. Very slight. But this warming trend is not going to keep on going. My belief is that three, four years from now, the globe will start to cool again, as it did from the middle '40s to the middle '70s."

unless you can find something more substancial than a "belief" to support his opinion then it's hardly worth trumpeting is it?
 
Last edited:
Dr. William Gray's view is not supported by the massed weight of scientific consensus. But, since you already "know" he's right, you also don't really need to ask do you?

unless you can find something more substancial than a "belief" to support his opinion then it's hardly worth trumpeting is it?

Since Gray was the IPCC reviewer who had the largest number of comments rejected, one may presume that his views were not shared by those few who defined consensus at that time.

Thanks for the ad hominems, they do come in handy.
 
Since Gray was the IPCC reviewer who had the largest number of comments rejected, one may presume that his views were not shared by those few who defined consensus at that time.

Thanks for the ad hominems, they do come in handy.

lol
 
British Prime Minister Tony Blair wrote in a letter to European heads of state "We have only a window of 10 -15 years to take the steps we need to avoid crossing a catastrophic climate tipping point".

Dr. William Gray, of the University of Colorado, said "Observations and theory do not support these ideas of dangerous human caused warming".

Obviously, both statements are generalizations across a broad group of phenomena and data. These are recent (2007) statements, so we may presume that both knew of the shrinking of North Pole ice.

But the statements are contradictory.

Who is right and why?


That is the question.

The ice loss is a convenient fit for AGW. So how does Gray account for it? It's an observation that certainly begs an explanation.
 
Since Gray was the IPCC reviewer who had the largest number of comments rejected, one may presume that his views were not shared by those few who defined consensus at that time.

Thanks for the ad hominems, they do come in handy.

ad hominem

1. appealing to one's prejudices, emotions, or special interests rather than to one's intellect or reason.
2. attacking an opponent's character rather than answering his argument.

I addressed your question - your question was not an argument. That i also think you are disingenuous in your treatment of this topic can certainly be included within my reply as a subsidiary point. So if you agree that Gray's view is not in the scientific consensus, why do you apparently wish to give his view the same weight than that of the scientific consensus? What evidence does he have beyond an unspecified "belief"? Faith based logic?
 
As for the North Pole, here is another scientist - one of the Certified, Degreed Brain guys - discussing natural cycles. In the article he does note that if the ice does not begin to increase within a 5 to 10 year time span, then that would be possibly evidence of AGW in terms of the disruption of the established cycle.

Dr Dick actually says :
"I’ve this gut feeling that within ten years from now we’ll know for certain whether we’re losing sea ice long term or whether it’s coming back.

"If it doesn’t come back it shows we are in serious trouble. Sea ice has a whole lot of effects on climate and it is pretty important."

Which is quite alarming. "Would be possibly evidence" doesn't really get that across, to my mind.

The "five to ten years" was from from 2005, so it's "three to eight years" now, given that no such return has yet occurred. Quite the opposite, in fact. The rate of retreat over the last few years has increased markedly.

There may well be a 60-80 year cycle and we may well be near the ice-mininum of that cycle. Were that the major - or even a major - influence then the cycle is oddly shaped, given that as we approach the minimum a reduction in the rate would normally be expected.

Much more likely is that it's a minor influence, if any at all. The obvious candidate for the major influence is AGW. Unless you've another broken reed to lean on?
 
British Prime Minister Tony Blair wrote in a letter to European heads of state "We have only a window of 10 -15 years to take the steps we need to avoid crossing a catastrophic climate tipping point".

That's a commonly-held opinion. In ten years we'll be over 400ppmCO2 with "business as usual", quite possibly as much as 410 if there's no serious depression (economic, not atmospheric).

Dr. William Gray, of the University of Colorado, said "Observations and theory do not support these ideas of dangerous human caused warming".

Dr William Gray has been playing the same record for decades. No observations will ever make him change the tune. His opinions on this matter are worthless. He's not even a climate scientist, and he's far too old to learn. He's got at least 15 reasons for the giant conspiracy theory that is directed at him through the "invention" of AGW. He's a nutter. One who dwells in shiny-hat land.

Obviously, both statements are generalizations across a broad group of phenomena and data.

Do what now?

Who is right and why?

Tony Blair. He's a vapid self-baster, but he's not a nutter. Nor is he senile. And on this one he's right.

History might conclude that it's already too late, but ten years on with no action or even policy in place is definitely too late. Which is when denialists can relax. After all, what can you do if it's too late already? Bloody scientists! If their warnings hadn't been so alarming (and fraudulent) something would have been done about it! :mad:
 
How about the South Pole?

Sea ice extent is rapidly climbing to the 16 million km2 mark:

http://arctic.atmos.uiuc.edu/cryosphere/IMAGES/current.365.south.jpg

We may be heading for a record high Antarctic sea-ice extent.
Observations over the last decade reveal an overall increase in the rate of glacial flow off the continent; once that ice is off the continent it's on the sea. So increasing seai-ce is not simply a measure of sea-water freezing, and thus is not a direct indicator of temperature.

Things are a lot different at the North Pole, of course, since that's covered with ocean, not a continent. A significant difference by any measure.
 
Since Gray was the IPCC reviewer who had the largest number of comments rejected, one may presume that his views were not shared by those few who defined consensus at that time.


Those few? How many do you think were involved? If they were so few, how come Gray was included in the first place?

Gray was included because the process was very inclusive; his comments were rejected because they were numptie comments. If he ever had it, he's lost it. Those few, those happy few, that still stick with him are mostly of his generation; they re-fight old battles together a lot.
 
Gurder, you asserted that the IPCC reports the support the concept of Greenland melting. I presume that you are referring to the A2 scenario modeling. What exactly did you find with reference to that? While waiting for your data, though, here is some immediate, non Alarmist information.

One more peer reviewed article saying Greenland isn't melting down.

“Greenland Warming of 1920-1930 and 1995-2005”, from Petr Chylek and M.K. Dubey (Los Alamos National Laboratory) and G. Lesins (Dalhousie University, Halifax), published on Geophysical Research Letters,

http://meteo.lcd.lu/globalwarming/Chylek/greenland_warming.html
Abstract

We provide an analysis of Greenland temperature records to compare the current (1995–2005) warming period with the previous (1920–1930) Greenland warming. We find that the current Greenland warming is not unprecedented in recent Greenland history. Temperature increases in the two warming periods are of a similar magnitude, however, the rate of warming in 1920–1930 was about 50% higher than that in 1995–2005.
 
Dr Dick actually says :
"I’ve this gut feeling that within ten years from now we’ll know for certain whether we’re losing sea ice long term or whether it’s coming back.
​
"If it doesn’t come back it shows we are in serious trouble. Sea ice has a whole lot of effects on climate and it is pretty important."
​
Which is quite alarming. "Would be possibly evidence" doesn't really get that across, to my mind.

The "five to ten years" was from from 2005, so it's "three to eight years" now, given that no such return has yet occurred. Quite the opposite, in fact. The rate of retreat over the last few years has increased markedly.

There may well be a 60-80 year cycle and we may well be near the ice-mininum of that cycle. Were that the major - or even a major - influence then the cycle is oddly shaped, given that as we approach the minimum a reduction in the rate would normally be expected.

Much more likely is that it's a minor influence, if any at all. The obvious candidate for the major influence is AGW. Unless you've another broken reed to lean on?

Bravo, CDodger!

I wondered if anyone would actually read that article to find the few gems that could prop up Alarmism!!!!

All in all, a balanced article. It is as he says, utterly ridiculous to ignore the climate cycles and historical record of them.

I've got no problem, either, with reassessing my view in 3 to 8 years based on the facts and physical evidence. I am not sure that would even be call ed Alarmism. Alarmism is worry before the fact.
the cycle is oddly shaped, given that as we approach the minimum a reduction in the rate would normally be expected.
​
The last 49 of 53 days up there were completely clear, cloudless sky.

Regular weather could easily have been the cause of higher ice melt rates. Probably a better conjecture than alarmist mode AGW, right?
 
Bravo, CDodger!

I wondered if anyone would actually read that article to find the few gems that could prop up Alarmism!!!!

I was simply pointing out how you'd misrepresented Dr Dick.

All in all, a balanced article. It is as he says, utterly ridiculous to ignore the climate cycles and historical record of them.

I missed that bit.

Here's a bit I didn't miss :
"You couldn’t say, ‘The sea ice is coming back so therefore there’s no global warming’. It’s never going to be that simple," he said. "But the question now is the extent of global warming, how fast it will happen and whether there are any surprises on the way.

"We know there is warming and that it’s caused by humans, but it will be a great relief to many people if the ice comes back as opposed to going away."

I'm sure it would be a relief to you. And I'm sure we'll hear about it if it happens.

I've got no problem, either, with reassessing my view in 3 to 8 years based on the facts and physical evidence. I am not sure that would even be call ed Alarmism.

Why would anyone consider re-assessment on the basis of new observations alarming? After all, you do have the full eight-year option. That's far enough away for comfort, surely.

Alarmism is worry before the fact.

Anything except the "it might not happen" option, then. Prediction can only lead to worry and alarm so predictions are inherently alarmist. I think I'm homing in on this word now.
The last 49 of 53 days up there were completely clear, cloudless sky.

Your point being? This started with a 60-80 year cycle, as I recall, and now you summon up a month-and-a-half's recent weather. There's a problem of scale there.

Given that we are putatively at the low end of said cycle, where we'd expect ice-extent to be stabilising prior to an increasing trend, said cycle does have an odd shape, I'm sure you'll agree. With accelerating decrease just before a shuddering reversal in direction. Most natural cycles don't work like that. They swoop, rather than jerk. Which is good, since jerks can be alarming.

Regular weather could easily have been the cause of higher ice melt rates.

No, it couldn't. Ocean-temperature does not react to weather quickly, and they play an important role in Arctic sea-ice extent.

Probably a better conjecture than alarmist mode AGW, right?

Everday predictive (aka alarmist) AGW has Arctic sea-ice receding. Now we're seeing how quickly it does - something which couldn't be accurately worked out beforehand. It turns out to be more quickly than expected.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom