North Pole is melting faster than predicted

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2826449&postcount=162

Also, the article "Greenland all but doomed to melt" which is based on computer modeling, is very misleading. Last sentence says the worst case scenario was a 1000 year melt with an 8 degree C global temp rise, if I recall correctly.

That Greenland - that thing is frigging 2 miles thick. That ice sort of oozes down and breaks off, right? Melt isn't even the right word.

And that 1000 year timeframe you don't need to worry about either, because over that timeframe, the longer climate cycles of the planet kick in.
 
Also, the article "Greenland all but doomed to melt" which is based on computer modeling, is very misleading. Last sentence says the worst case scenario was a 1000 year melt with an 8 degree C global temp rise, if I recall correctly.

And what are you basing your assertions on?

That Greenland - that thing is frigging 2 miles thick. That ice sort of oozes down and breaks off, right? Melt isn't even the right word.

No? what is the right word, then?

And that 1000 year timeframe you don't need to worry about either, because over that timeframe, the longer climate cycles of the planet kick in.

You're wrong...

And it's funny that you don't think that GW is caused by CO2, for which evidence abunds, but put faith in milenar climate cycles, for which the evidence is much weaker.

But since you're mentality seems to be stuck on "It's not my fault, so I don't have to do anything about it" mode, just carry on...
 
And what are you basing your assertions on?
No? what is the right word, then?
You're wrong...

And it's funny that you don't think that GW is caused by CO2, for which evidence abunds, but put faith in milenar climate cycles, for which the evidence is much weaker.

But since you're mentality seems to be stuck on "It's not my fault, so I don't have to do anything about it" mode, just carry on...

Ad hominems are always welcome, but...

You don't seriously think Greenland is melting in the near term, do you?

That was the question...
 
.....You don't seriously think Greenland is melting in the near term, do you? ..


Hmmm. I went and checked with the IPCC and other scientific literature on possible Greenland melting; their data seems to indicate a risk of significant melting.

You, mhaze, OTOH, appear to be claiming no such melting is happening at all, and you seem to claim no significant melting would occur, though you do make it unclear by your deliberate usage of strawmen, such as your referring to the total melting of the entire Greenland icecap, though of course that was not the actual issue under discussion.

Hmmm. Who to believe. Scientists actually involved in the area and very qualified; or a poster whom I know to be politically motivated in his denial of global warming.

Hmmm hmmm. Decisions, decisions.
 
Hmmm. I went and checked with the IPCC and other scientific literature on possible Greenland melting; their data seems to indicate a risk of significant melting.

You, mhaze, OTOH, appear to be claiming no such melting is happening at all, and you seem to claim no significant melting would occur, though you do make it unclear by your deliberate usage of strawmen, such as your referring to the total melting of the entire Greenland icecap, though of course that was not the actual issue under discussion.

Dynamics of North Pole and Greenland are different, right?

Here is a link to Rigor's Polar Science Page, with a fascinating animation of arctic sea ice, and his published articles.

http://seaice.apl.washington.edu/

GW by theory should increase snow and thickness of the central Greenland.
 
According to http://www.physorg.com/news5619.html --

In a paper titled "The Melting of Floating Ice will Raise the Ocean Level" submitted to Geophysical Journal International, [Dr. Peter] Noerdlinger [a professor at St. Mary’s University in Nova Scotia, Canada] demonstrates that melt water from sea ice and floating ice shelves could add 2.6% more water to the ocean than the water displaced by the ice, or the equivalent of approximately 4 centimeters (1.57 inches) of sea-level rise.

The common misconception that floating ice won’t increase sea level when it melts occurs because the difference in density between fresh water and salt water is not taken into consideration. Archimedes’ Principle states that an object immersed in a fluid is buoyed up by a force equal to the weight of the fluid it displaces. However, Noerdlinger notes that because freshwater is not as dense as saltwater, freshwater actually has greater volume than an equivalent weight of saltwater. Thus, when freshwater ice melts in the ocean, it contributes a greater volume of melt water than it originally displaced.

Well now. Interesting. Easy for me to test in my kitchen lab. :) Ice cube in salt water, here we come.
 
Actually it WASN'T really Katrina. It was our stupidity to build a city well below sea level. Katrina only hit as a cat3 storm.

But New Orleans was well fortified.

Well, well fortified with ample liquor and great food...
 
Actually it WASN'T really Katrina. It was our stupidity to build a city well below sea level. Katrina only hit as a cat3 storm.

The stupidity was in lowering a coastal city (established back when the French owned Luisiana) and then building canals to channel the sea towards it.

Building a significant proportion of US refining capacity in hurricane territory wasn't too clever either. No doubt it worked fine for the accountants, but it's not always just about the numbers.
 
... why the hell not increase comfort for us all and have a designer EARTH!?!?

I'm firmly of the opinion that this will indeed happen. It's just further along the path that humanity's always been following. We eliminated predators for our own security, we cleared/are clearing forests and wetlands for our food-supply. Now we've learnt that we can influence the climate. There's no plan behind it as yet, but we're going to gain a great deal more knowledge about how the whole thing works as we watch AGW play out.

When the climate stablises we'll want it to stay that way because we'll have adjusted to it. It'll be public policy to at least maintain the prevailing CO2 levels, and maybe tweak them a bit.

(I'm always prepared to predict the distant future, defined as "after I'm dead". If I'm right I'm a prophet, if I'm wrong who'll remember me anyway? :) )
 
I'm firmly of the opinion that this will indeed happen. It's just further along the path that humanity's always been following. We eliminated predators for our own security, we cleared/are clearing forests and wetlands for our food-supply. Now we've learnt that we can influence the climate. There's no plan behind it as yet, but we're going to gain a great deal more knowledge about how the whole thing works as we watch AGW play out.

When the climate stablises we'll want it to stay that way because we'll have adjusted to it. It'll be public policy to at least maintain the prevailing CO2 levels, and maybe tweak them a bit.

(I'm always prepared to predict the distant future, defined as "after I'm dead". If I'm right I'm a prophet, if I'm wrong who'll remember me anyway? :) )

Good thought! All we need to do first is convince the people who control the CO2 (us) that people who aren't able to afford a more-suitable place to live will be just become the unfittest part of "survival of the fittest", then we can go ahead and do it.
 
Sea level rise is also caused by warming of the ocean. Warmer water - expanded volume. Bye-bye Manhattan Island.

That'll sound like a good plan to some.

The danger of the cap melting in summer is the loss of sunlight reflection, and therefore increased heat absorption.

What about the permafrost? Will nobody think of the permafrost :) ?

There's got to be a positive and mutual feedback between permafrost and Arctic ice-extent. Since permafrost has been melting in the far north the two may already be interacting. I'm pretty sure GCM predictions don't take account of permafrost. The effects are too uncertain, apart from anything else. What is certain is that melting permafrost is a positive feedback to climate warming. And since a fair bit of that feedback comes from methane, it'll pack some regional punch right from the start.

This story is definitely one to watch. Frankly, I find hurricanes a bit of a yawn.
 
I'm firmly of the opinion that this will indeed happen. ...

Now we've learnt that we can influence the climate. There's no plan behind it as yet, but we're going to gain a great deal more knowledge about how the whole thing works as we watch AGW play out.

When the climate stablises we'll want it to stay that way because we'll have adjusted to it. It'll be public policy to at least maintain the prevailing CO2 levels, and maybe tweak them a bit.

When the climate stabilizes???

That is a rather absurd statement, isn't it?
 
Good thought! All we need to do first is convince the people who control the CO2 (us) that people who aren't able to afford a more-suitable place to live will be just become the unfittest part of "survival of the fittest", then we can go ahead and do it.

By the times I'm thinking of the Great Dying will be long over. The ones that survive will be the ones that control the CO2, descendents of those who do now. Or rather who don't control it now because they see no sufficient reason to. A few generations up the line they'll see things differently.

It's the Little Guys who are going to the wall. It was ever thus.
 
When the climate stabilizes???

That is a rather absurd statement, isn't it?

No. CO2 will level off at some point, and probably reduce. Feedbacks such as permafrost and albedo-change will have been exhausted. Climate will at some point catch up with the CO2 forcing and a new equilibrium will be established.

The current instability isn't normal, it reflects a shift between one equilibrium and another. Climate change is characterised by such shifts, the most obvious being the glacial/inter-glacial shift. Between the shifts are much longer periods of stability. Once CO2 and climate have reached an equilibrium, stability will follow.

Of course, CO2 will have to have reached an equilibrium with the rest of the world, so we may have to maintain it by burning a measured amount of coal - it's as easy as that.

By this point the climate will be a much simpler system to model and so manipulate. Without permafrost there's no need to factor it in. Without ice there's no need to factor in albedo-change. We know the orbital influences and can adjust CO2 to compensate. I foresee a smooth ride.
 
That Greenland - that thing is frigging 2 miles thick.

Not all of it. Just the deepest bit, in the mountains of the north and centre. That's the bit that will last longest. Most of Greenland's ice will go in the coming century.

That ice sort of oozes down and breaks off, right?

Into the sea. Where it melts. At the same time melt-water flows from land to see, under the ice.

Melt isn't even the right word.

When ice becomes water, "melt" is the common usage.

And that 1000 year timeframe you don't need to worry about either, because over that timeframe, the longer climate cycles of the planet kick in.

You're well convinced of those, it seems. Cycles that just happen. Well, it's time we put a stop to that. Given a thousand years, I rather think we will. The so-far hidden culprits of these cycles will have revealed themselves, and we can adjust the coal-burning well in advance to compensate. And we won't have to worry about feedbacks much because we'll have offed most, if not all, of them by then.

I bet the cameras will be there when the last remnant of the Greenland ice-cap sinks into the gravel. I doubt they'll make much of its influence on sea-levels. Much might well be made of how stupid people were a thousand years ago. It was ever thus.

The thousand-year melting of Greenland will not be by one-thousandth per annum. It will be quick to start with and very slow at the end.
 
Last edited:
The meek shall inherit the earth.










Six feet of it.

Which they share with more meeks. Until the developers move in ...

There'll be no justice, any more than there's ever been. The victims will be powerless and innocent, the survivors will be powerful and guilty. In a general sense, of course.

I hope I live to see the day that Danes invade Wisonsin just for the sake of plunder and up-yours destruction. That would be one glorious Unintended Consequence :) .
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom