North Pole is melting faster than predicted

A complete list of events caused by global warming:

Here is your list of fears.

Agricultural land increase, Africa devastated, African aid threatened, air pressure changes, Alaska reshaped, allergies increase, Alps melting, Amazon a desert, American dream end, amphibians breeding earlier (or not), ancient forests dramatically changed, Antarctic grass flourishes, anxiety, algal blooms, Arctic bogs melt, Asthma, atmospheric defiance, atmospheric circulation modified, avalanches reduced, avalanches increased, bananas destroyed, bananas grow, bet for $10,000, better beer, big melt faster, billion dollar research projects, billions of deaths, bird distributions change, birds return early, blackbirds stop singing, blizzards, blue mussels return, boredom, Britain Siberian, British gardens change, bubonic plague, budget increases, building season extension, bushfires, business opportunities, business risks, butterflies move north, cardiac arrest, caterpillar biomass shift, challenges and opportunities, Cholera, civil unrest, cloud increase, cloud stripping, cod go south, cold climate creatures survive, cold spells (Australia), computer models, conferences, coral bleaching, coral reefs dying, coral reefs grow, coral reefs shrink , cold spells, cost of trillions, crumbling roads, buildings and sewage systems, cyclones (Australia), damages equivalent to $200 billion, Dengue hemorrhagic fever, dermatitis, desert advance, desert life threatened, desert retreat, destruction of the environment, diarrhoea, disappearance of coastal cities, diseases move north, Dolomites collapse, drought, drowning people, ducks and geese decline, dust bowl in the corn belt, early spring, earlier pollen season, Earth biodiversity crisis, Earth dying, Earth even hotter, Earth light dimming, Earth lopsided, Earth melting, Earth morbid fever, Earth on fast track, Earth past point of no return, Earth slowing down, Earth spinning out of control, Earth to explode, earth upside down, Earth wobbling, earthquakes, El Niño intensification, erosion, emerging infections, encephalitis, Europe simultaneously baking and freezing, evolution accelerating, expansion of university climate groups, extinctions (human, civilisation, logic, Inuit, smallest butterfly, cod, ladybirds, bats, pandas, pikas, polar bears, pigmy possums, gorillas, koalas, walrus, whales, frogs, toads, turtles, orang-utan, elephants, tigers, plants, salmon, trout, wild flowers, woodlice, penguins, a million species, half of all animal and plant species, less, not polar bears), experts muzzled, extreme changes to California, famine, farmers go under, figurehead sacked, fish catches drop, fish catches rise, fish stocks decline, five million illnesses, floods, Florida economic decline, food poisoning, food prices rise, food security threat (SA), footpath erosion, forest decline, forest expansion, frosts, fungi invasion, Garden of Eden wilts, genetic diversity decline, gene pools slashed, glacial retreat, glacial growth, glacier wrapped, global cooling, global dimming, glowing clouds, Gore omnipresence, grandstanding, grasslands wetter, Great Barrier Reef 95% dead, Great Lakes drop, greening of the North, Gulf Stream failure, habitat loss, Hantavirus pulmonary syndrome, harvest increase, harvest shrinkage, hay fever epidemic, hazardous waste sites breached, heat waves, hibernation ends too soon, hibernation ends too late, high court debates, human fertility reduced, human health improvement, human health risk, hurricanes, hydropower problems, hyperthermia deaths, ice sheet growth, ice sheet shrinkage, inclement weather, infrastructure failure (Canada), Inuit displacement, Inuit poisoned, Inuit suing, industry threatened, infectious diseases, insurance premium rises, invasion of midges, island disappears, islands sinking, itchier poison ivy, jellyfish explosion, Kew Gardens taxed, krill decline, lake and stream productivity decline, landslides, landslides of ice at 140 mph, lawsuits increase, lawsuit successful, lawyers’ income increased (surprise, surprise!), lightning related insurance claims, little response in the atmosphere, Lyme disease, Malaria, malnutrition, Maple syrup shortage, marine diseases, marine food chain decimated, marine dead zone, Meaching (end of the world), megacryometeors, Melanoma, methane emissions from plants, methane burps, melting permafrost, Middle Kingdom convulses, migration, migration difficult (birds), microbes to decompose soil carbon more rapidly, more bad air days, more research needed, mountain (Everest) shrinking, mountains break up, mountains taller, mudslides, next ice age, Nile delta damaged, no effect in India, nuclear plants bloom, oaks move north, ocean acidification, outdoor hockey threatened, oyster diseases, ozone loss, ozone repair slowed, ozone rise, Pacific dead zone, personal carbon rationing, pest outbreaks, pests increase, phenology shifts, plankton blooms, plankton destabilised, plankton loss, plant viruses, plants march north, polar bears aggressive, polar bears cannibalistic, polar bears drowning, polar bears starve, polar tours scrapped, psychosocial disturbances, railroad tracks deformed, rainfall increase, rainfall reduction, refugees, reindeer larger, release of ancient frozen viruses, resorts disappear, rice yields crash, rift on Capitol Hill, rioting and nuclear war, rivers raised, rivers dry up, rockfalls, rocky peaks crack apart, roof of the world a desert, Ross river disease, salinity reduction, salinity increase, Salmonella, salmon stronger, sea level rise, sea level rise faster, sex change, sharks booming, shrinking ponds, ski resorts threatened, slow death, smog, snowfall increase, snowfall reduction, societal collapse, songbirds change eating habits, sour grapes, spiders invade Scotland, squid population explosion, squirrels reproduce earlier, spectacular orchids, stormwater drains stressed, taxes, tectonic plate movement, terrorism, ticks move northward (Sweden), tides rise, tourism increase, trade winds weakened, tree beetle attacks, tree foliage increase (UK), tree growth slowed, trees could return to Antarctic, trees less colourful, trees more colourful, tropics expansion, tropopause raised, tsunamis, turtles lay earlier, UK Katrina, Venice flooded, volcanic eruptions, walrus pups orphaned, war, wars over water, water bills double, water supply unreliability, water scarcity (20% of increase), water stress, weather out of its mind, weather patterns awry, weeds, Western aid cancelled out, West Nile fever, whales move north, wheat yields crushed in Australia, white Christmas dream ends, wildfires, wind shift, wind reduced, wine - harm to Australian industry, wine industry damage (California), wine industry disaster (US), wine - more English, wine -German boon, wine - no more French , winters in Britain colder, wolves eat more moose, wolves eat less, workers laid off, World bankruptcy, World in crisis, Yellow fever
 
Alright, to save mhaze from a possible breach of rule 4, here is what looks like the primary source for his post:

Thanks. But now that you mention it, I recall having seen this list floating around the internet and at one time, there was an "original source" list in which each item linked to that subject matter. Have to locate that....

But it changes so fast, it is hard to keep up with it.
We need to add "frostbite" -

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/03/12/AR2007031200997.html
A North Pole expedition meant to bring attention to global warming was called off after one of the explorers got frostbite. The explorers, Ann Bancroft and Liv Arnesen, on Saturday called off what was intended to be a 530-mile trek across the Arctic Ocean after Arnesen suffered frostbite in three of her toes, and extreme cold temperatures drained the batteries in some of their electronic equipment…


…Atwood said there was some irony that a trip to call attention to global warming was scuttled in part by extreme cold temperatures.


“They were experiencing temperatures that weren’t expected with global warming,” Atwood said. “But one of the things we see with global warming is unpredictability.”
​
 
Yes, Global Warming really is man - made

The original list, with links to each item.

It is from John Brinell's Website, Numbers watch, and is indeed directly linked to by the news column Pipirr reference.

Here is the summary on Brinell's home page.
This site is devoted to the monitoring of the misleading numbers that rain down on us via the media. Whether they are generated by Single Issue Fanatics (SIFs), politicians, bureaucrats, quasi-scientists (junk, pseudo- or just bad), such numbers swamp the media, generating unnecessary alarm and panic. They are seized upon by media, hungry for eye-catching stories. There is a growing band of people whose livelihoods depend on creating and maintaining panic. There are also some who are trying to keep numbers away from your notice and others who hope that you will not make comparisons.

Their stock in trade is the gratuitous lie.

The aim here is to nail just a few of them.

​
Here is his analysis of just one small part of the whole AGW mess.

http://www.numberwatch.co.uk/manmade.htm
 
What is wrong with Arrenhius?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svante_August_Arrhenius#Greenhouse_effect_as_cause_for_ice_ages

Over a hundred years ago, and science was already on the scent.

His initial work has been refined and errors corrected, but the basic idea is still sound.

Nothing is wrong with Arrenhius. He produced a formula which represented the "greenhouse effect". Into that you plug some coefficient values, right?
What is wrong is wrong coefficient values, or in your case, no numerical values at all, just arm waving that the Authorities (IPCC, etc) must have the right coefficients for the equations because, after all they are the Authorities.

You are most welcome to believe whatever you like, but just saying it does not convince others.

Isn't this forum, JREF?

It is a skeptical forum, correct?

You might expect to be asked to substantiate your position with facts?

And nothing is wrong with
Ipso,
Carter,
Singer,
Avery,
Daly,
Schwartz,
Tsonis,
Wentz,
Nordhaus,
Lomborg,
Durbin,
Crichton,
Steve McIntyre,
Corbyn,
Christy,
Lindzen,
Mockton,
Shulte,
Armstrong,
Spencer,
Legales,
Inhofe,
McKitrick,
Keenan,
Calder,
Svensmark,
Friis-Christensen,
Tim Ball,
Shaviv,
Ian Clark,
Paul Reiter,
Phillip Stott,
Patrick Moore,
Patrick Michaels,
Shikwati

and many others who you have dismissed as "loons" and "nutters".

Of course, anyone is most welcome to refute the scientific arguments made by these individuals. As is anyone welcome to refute the scientific arguments made by the IPCC, Hansen, Mann, and Gore.

Right?
 
Nothing is wrong with Arrenhius. He produced a formula which represented the "greenhouse effect". Into that you plug some coefficient values, right?
What is wrong is wrong coefficient values, or in your case, no numerical values at all, just arm waving that the Authorities (IPCC, etc) must have the right coefficients for the equations because, after all they are the Authorities.

You are most welcome to believe whatever you like, but just saying it does not convince others.

Isn't this forum, JREF?

It is a skeptical forum, correct?

You might expect to be asked to substantiate your position with facts?

And nothing is wrong with
Ipso,
Carter,
Singer,
Avery,
Daly,
Schwartz,
Tsonis,
Wentz,
Nordhaus,
Lomborg,
Durbin,
Crichton,
Steve McIntyre,
Corbyn,
Christy,
Lindzen,
Mockton,
Shulte,
Armstrong,
Spencer,
Legales,
Inhofe,
McKitrick,
Keenan,
Calder,
Svensmark,
Friis-Christensen,
Tim Ball,
Shaviv,
Ian Clark,
Paul Reiter,
Phillip Stott,
Patrick Moore,
Patrick Michaels,
Shikwati

and many others who you have dismissed as "loons" and "nutters".

Of course, anyone is most welcome to refute the scientific arguments made by these individuals. As is anyone welcome to refute the scientific arguments made by the IPCC, Hansen, Mann, and Gore.

Right?

Lomborg? he has no credentials in the area, but agrees that global warming is happening, and the science behind it. I don't know why he is in there.
Monckton and those like him? He does not even understand the basic science.
Some on that list, nothing wrong with their science, but somehow the deniers have completely misrepresented what their findings are.
A novelist? What has he got to do with science?
Corbyn, Daly and their friends, just a bunch of nutters.
Inhofe? A politician, ditto novelists and documentary makers.

Gore is just presenting the science of the IPCC, mostly correctly.
Mann has been validated by the 4AR, see my post, hockey stick not broken.
IPCC, read the number of scientific papers it is based on.
 
Thanks. But now that you mention it, I recall having seen this list floating around the internet and at one time, there was an "original source" list in which each item linked to that subject matter. Have to locate that....

But it changes so fast, it is hard to keep up with it.
We need to add "frostbite" -

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/03/12/AR2007031200997.html
A North Pole expedition meant to bring attention to global warming was called off after one of the explorers got frostbite. The explorers, Ann Bancroft and Liv Arnesen, on Saturday called off what was intended to be a 530-mile trek across the Arctic Ocean after Arnesen suffered frostbite in three of her toes, and extreme cold temperatures drained the batteries in some of their electronic equipment…


…Atwood said there was some irony that a trip to call attention to global warming was scuttled in part by extreme cold temperatures.


“They were experiencing temperatures that weren’t expected with global warming,” Atwood said. “But one of the things we see with global warming is unpredictability.”
​

You are confusing press reports with science. Stick to the 4AR, and you'll get a more reliable source of information.

As to the breadth of problems that it will cause, that is the whole point. The human race has coped with all kinds of problems. This will be a whole lot of problems, affecting people simultaneously, around the globe. It will affect trade, agriculture, the environment, infrastructure, all at once. The effects on much of the natural world will be terminal, with us experiencing the side effects.
 
Nothing is wrong with Arrenhius. He produced a formula which represented the "greenhouse effect". Into that you plug some coefficient values, right?

Wrong. Using the formula and observations the parameters are derived.

What is wrong is wrong coefficient values, or in your case, no numerical values at all ...

Are we supposed to mention a list of coefficients in every post :confused:?

... just arm waving ...

Unintentional irony yet again.

... that the Authorities (IPCC, etc) must have the right coefficients for the equations because, after all they are the Authorities.

The IPCC reports to governments on the current science, it does no science itself nor does it derive coefficients. Scientists in many institutions worldwide do that. They publish their work, which is examined, compared, discussed, and replicated in the wider scientific world.

You are most welcome to believe whatever you like, but just saying it does not convince others.

Your dismissal of any science you don't like as "alarmism" produced for ideological or careerist reasons is deeply unconvincing.

aup and I (amongst many others) look to the science and to events when forming our opinions. When it comes to AGW, the case is convincing.

Isn't this forum, JREF?

It is a skeptical forum, correct?

You might expect to be asked to substantiate your position with facts?

I'd ask you to substantiate your position, but it appears to be that nothing can be substantiated on the subject of AGW. Since, in your opinion, it can't be proven, it doesn't need to be disproven. Whatever happens.

And nothing is wrong with ...

The usual coven, with some unwilling conscripts added.

If you actually think there was nothing wrong with a mendacious paranoid like Daly your recommendation is not worth a lot.

... and many others who you have dismissed as "loons" and "nutters".

Not that many other scientists. Weathermen galore, and you missed Rush Limbaugh from your list - he'll be hurt. You'll find, if you look, that it mostly comes down to that introverted - not to say incestuous - cabal in your list.

Of course, anyone is most welcome to refute the scientific arguments made by these individuals.

Been there, done that, had no effect. No need to refute their research, since they don't do any.

As is anyone welcome to refute the scientific arguments made by the IPCC, Hansen, Mann, and Gore.

The IPCC and Gore report, they do not do science. How often does that have to be said before it gets through? Whatever, I can keep it up as long as you like.

The science of Hansen, Mann, and all those teams of researchers in institutions across the world has survived all attempts at refutation by your favoured cabal. That's why they fall back so often on alternative hypotheses, such as Singer's Cycle - you know, the one with oval wheels. iI's an uncomfortable ride; I'm surprised it's sells so well. Data-mining, nit-picking, and weaseling - apart from the abject lunacy (check out Gray) that's all they've got.
 
Lomborg? he has no credentials in the area, but agrees that global warming is happening, and the science behind it. I don't know why he is in there.
Monckton and those like him? He does not even understand the basic science.
Some on that list, nothing wrong with their science, but somehow the deniers have completely misrepresented what their findings are.
A novelist? What has he got to do with science?
Corbyn, Daly and their friends, just a bunch of nutters.
Inhofe? A politician, ditto novelists and documentary makers.

Gore is just presenting the science of the IPCC, mostly correctly.
Mann has been validated by the 4AR, see my post, hockey stick not broken.
IPCC, read the number of scientific papers it is based on.

Okay, so you want to just discredit the messengers, and not discuss the messages. Fine. But you might want to consider this discussion as similar to one in a college study of comparative religions. You come into the class with a very strict point of view, let's say a fundamentalist of type XYZ. Nonetheless, the class is defined as a study of comparative religions. They will have differing points of view and they will be discussed. Shouting that they are all nutters and loons will not stop the discussion, will it?

Alternately, suppose it is a class in science. Various theories are proposed and discussed as causative. The opinion of one person in that class, or several, that some of the scientists are nutters or loons has nothing to do with the theories.

It looks like an attempt to prevent discussion of the theories, all this side stepping into ad hominems.

Frankly, I couldn't care less who you think is a nutter or a loon.
 
As to the breadth of problems that it will cause, that is the whole point.

As I read it, mhaze's point is that the more alarming it is the less it can be true. The correlation is linear, so "less true" soon becomes "untrue" and moves on down to "culpably untrue". After that is "heinous", then it's Al Gore all the way down :).

The human race has coped with all kinds of problems. This will be a whole lot of problems, affecting people simultaneously, around the globe.

Think globally, watch stuff happen locally. I was saying thirty years ago that ticks would have a bigger impact than sea-level rise if AGW really kicked in. Ticks are emblematic of the general expansion of pests and disease-vectors into new regions, and they're generally not given the recognition they deserve.

It will affect trade, agriculture, the environment, infrastructure, all at once. The effects on much of the natural world will be terminal, with us experiencing the side effects.

This period may not go down as one of the Major Extinctions (though I wouldn't write off its chances) but it's certainly one of the Minor Extinctions. Definitely the first Artificial Extinction.

In human terms, it's just the latest Time of Tribulation. The biggest yet, of course, but they're always the biggest yet. That's progress. Walk, run, run faster, trip ... get up, limp, walk, run ... and so it goes. It may not be the best way of getting on, but it gets us on.

That's the Big Picture, of course. If I had children, I would not wish such a time on them. I'd wish my sort of time, as a boomer (born '54). I would also have a more visceral reaction to airy "it might not" attitudes. As it is, my visceral response is to the contrarian assault on Science, and to weasels in general. Human weasels, that is.
 
Okay, so you want to just discredit the messengers, and not discuss the messages.

You brought up a list of messengers. Not one message. What's there to discredit apart from the messengers? Who are not credible.

Give us messages, and their discrediting can begin.

You've given us Singer and his 1500-year cycle plus or minus 500 years message. I've asked you who introduced the plus-or-minus - Singer or the scientsts he references? My money's on Singer. He and his minion conjure up what they claim is support for a 1500-year cycle, then slap a plus-or-minus on it to make it fit the Medieval Warm Period that they're already deeply invested in. It's called weaseling. You clearly wouldn't notice it if I didn't point it out. For all I know, you still won't when I have.

Fine. But you might want to consider this discussion as similar to one in a college study of comparative religions.

You might want to, since it gets you away from all that science stuff, but for most folk it's a pointless diversion.

You come into the class with a very strict point of view, let's say a fundamentalist of type XYZ.

You might want to consider this discussion as similar to a college study of science. You come into the class with no understanding of science but a very strict world-view - in which AGW is too disturbing to be allowable.

Nonetheless, the class is defined as a study of comparative religions. They will have differing points of view and they will be discussed.

In my scenario, you'll have brought a cardboard knife to a gun-fight. Science is not about belief or points of view.

Shouting that they are all nutters and loons will not stop the discussion, will it?

Who's shouting? We're mostly just laughing and pointing.

Alternately, suppose it is a class in science.

A seminar would be a better analogy, but yeah, why not.

Various theories are proposed and discussed as causative.

So they are.

The opinion of one person in that class, or several, that some of the scientists are nutters or loons has nothing to do with the theories.

Who are "the scientists"? Weren't we talking about "various theories" a moment ago?

It looks like an attempt to prevent discussion of the theories, all this side stepping into ad hominems.


And "the scientists" side-steps back into "theories" just like that.

Frankly, I couldn't care less who you think is a nutter or a loon.

Frankly, nobody really cares what you personally think. You're of interest as an archetype of the contrarians' audience. Their messages are easily dismissed, but they're not aimed at the likes of me. They're aimed at the likes of you. A contrarian message is an experiment; your response to it is an observation.

None of that has anything to with AGW. I just felt I ought to share it.
 
Oh my ! No alarmism there ..
What exactly is a side effect of a terminal effect ?

Kill off all cattle. Terminal for the cattle. Side-effects on cattle-dependent parasites and dung-beetles. And some people, obviously.

Could you be more specific about what you mean by this ?

The first mass extinction caused by artifice. Not deliberately, but there it is. It's only with the emergence of HomSap that distinction between "artificial" and "natural" has become necessary. We are the first species on Earth to engineer its environment by design, and we've done it in a spectacular fashion over the last ten thousand years. The merest blink of an eye. An evolutionary phase-change.

Of course, this has always been subject to the Law of Unintended Consequences, a physical law that lies dormant until a species like ours emerges.
 
Okay, so you want to just discredit the messengers, and not discuss the messages. Fine. But you might want to consider this discussion as similar to one in a college study of comparative religions. You come into the class with a very strict point of view, let's say a fundamentalist of type XYZ. Nonetheless, the class is defined as a study of comparative religions. They will have differing points of view and they will be discussed. Shouting that they are all nutters and loons will not stop the discussion, will it?

Alternately, suppose it is a class in science. Various theories are proposed and discussed as causative. The opinion of one person in that class, or several, that some of the scientists are nutters or loons has nothing to do with the theories.

It looks like an attempt to prevent discussion of the theories, all this side stepping into ad hominems.

Frankly, I couldn't care less who you think is a nutter or a loon.

The point is we have a scientific process to follow, to achieve results of some sort of scientific validity. It is entirely possible Corbyn or Crichton are actually correct, and I could win the lottery this week. How about we pare off the people with no actual expertise, or for that matter, people like Corbyn who have a 'secret' method they won't reveal (so much for peer review), and list the actual scientists performing actual research, then start from there. Your list is going to be a lot shorter.
 
The point is we have a scientific process to follow, to achieve results of some sort of scientific validity. It is entirely possible Corbyn or Crichton are actually correct, and I could win the lottery this week. How about we pare off the people with no actual expertise, or for that matter, people like Corbyn who have a 'secret' method they won't reveal (so much for peer review), and list the actual scientists performing actual research, then start from there. Your list is going to be a lot shorter.

Actually, no, it would just get longer.

I could not can less who you think is a loon or nutter.

Don't bother me with the constant attacks on the messengers. It will not prevent discussion of the subjects you would like to suppress.
 
Actually, no, it would just get longer.

I could not can less who you think is a loon or nutter.

Don't bother me with the constant attacks on the messengers. It will not prevent discussion of the subjects you would like to suppress.

You still don't get the point. If you want to provide evidence of any level of scientific credibility, you need to go through the recognised scientific process.

Corbyn doesn't. He hides his whole methodology and theory.

Novelists don't count, it's just opinion, ditto politicians, ditto 16 year olds, or other punters on the internet. Their opinions carry no more weight than mine do.

Lomborg actually believes the theory is correct, he just doesn't believe it's worth doing anything about it.

I'm not suppressing anything, you are free to put these opinions forward, that's what I like about the JREF forum. I'm just going to point out my opinion, which is that worthless evidence is just that, and give my reasons why.

Monckton is just a nutter. He has no expertise, and his work is purely the output of a naive amateur, for example. He honestly believes all you have to do is read up a bit, say what the deniers want to hear, and you are an authority.

I don't see Gore as an authority on the topic, I see him as someone who presents the arguments based on the authority of others. He does a reasonable job of it, but his opinion is based on the results of scientific research.

There are a few scientists on your list. I would try sticking to them, for a start.
 
You still don't get the point. If you want to provide evidence of any level of scientific credibility, you need to go through the recognised scientific process.

I'm not suppressing anything, you are free to put these opinions forward, that's what I like about the JREF forum. I'm just going to point out my opinion, which is that worthless evidence is just that, and give my reasons why.

Ad hominem arguments do not work.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom