North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Originally Posted by mhaze
Wouldn't a AGW Believer hold some position like...​
"For each of the next five years. sea ice summer minima will be progressively lower than the prior year?"
​
No, that would be a strawman...So, now you get to determine which output will be natural or artificial? In a sea/ice system? It must be good to be so powerful.
No strawman. $1000 USD at www.longbets.com.

I would like to bet against Hansen's point of view, which many on this forum say they agree with.
Anyone care to belly up to the bar with the
  • strength of his or her beliefs
  • clear understanding of how "the science is settled"
  • firm grounding in the "overwhelming consensus of scientists"
AGW True Believers, here is Hansen with your Actic sea ice "tipping points" - the subject of this very thread. Either Put Up or STFU.

Arctic Thaw May be at "Tipping Point"


OSLO- A record melt of Arctic summer sea ice this month may be a sign that global warming is reaching a critical trigger point that could accelerate the northern thaw, some scientists say.

"The reason so much (of the Arctic ice) went suddenly is that it is hitting a tipping point that we have been warning about for the past few years," James Hansen, director of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies, told Reuters.

The Arctic summer sea ice shrank by more than 20 percent below the previous 2005 record low in mid-September to 4.13 million sq km (1.6 million sq miles), according to a 30-year satellite record. It has now frozen out to 4.2 million sq km.

The idea of climate tipping points -- like a see-saw that suddenly flips over when enough weight gets onto one side -- is controversial because it is little understood and dismissed by some as scaremongering about runaway effects.

The polar thaw may herald a self-sustaining acceleration that could threaten indigenous peoples and creatures such as polar bears -- as Arctic sea ice shrinks, the darker ocean soaks up ever more heat than reflective snow and ice.​
 
http://discuss.longbets.org/discuss/postlist.php?Cat=&Board=180

Discuss a Long Bet » Bet180
"Science fiction author Michael Crichton has predicted the world will warm by 0.81 degrees Celsius by the year 2100. Thomas Wigley and Sarah Raper ("Interpretation of High Projections for Global-Mean Warming," Science Magazine, Volume 293, 20 July 2001) examined the projections of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in the IPCC's Third Assessment Report (TAR). Wigley and Raper concluded that the IPCC TAR projections were for a 50/50 chance of 3.06 degrees Celsius of warming from 1990 to 2100. I predict that the actual warming of the lower troposphere (the atmosphere from roughly zero to 20,000 feet), as measured by satellites, will be closer to Michael Crichton's predicted value of 0.81 degrees Celsius, than the IPCC's value (via Wigley and Raper) of 3.06 degrees Celsius. In other words, I predict that the actual warming of the lower troposphere from 1990 to 2100, as measured by satellites, will be less than 1.94 degrees Celsius. Measurements should be done as a 3-year average centered around the year in question (i.e. 1989, 1990 and 1991, compared to 2099, 2100 and 2101). My bet is only open to members of the IPCC."
 
No strawman. $1000 USD at www.longbets.com.


Whos going to make a long bet in US dollars? Gimme a break.

I would like to bet against Hansen's point of view ...

I'll take that as a fold on my Big Blind. Wuss.


... which many on this forum say they agree with.
Anyone care to belly up to the bar with the

  • strength of his or her beliefs
  • clear understanding of how "the science is settled"
  • firm grounding in the "overwhelming consensus of scientists"


What kind of frickin' bet is that? Bet on the strength of their convictions? WTF are you talking about?

I proposed a very clear bet. You bottled. Propose a clear bet and see if I bottle.

I'll call you on flailing around, which is all you're doing. Issuing challenges like the Black Knight - "Come back here and I'll bite your leg off!"

When it comes to strength of belief, you'll win every time. When it comes to predicting on an informed basis what's going to happen, you're screwed. Because what has happened, is happening, and will happen is not in the slightest bit affected by it. Nor vice versa.
 
The simple theory is wrong. Greenhouses don't warm using the greenhouse effect.

Like Capeldodgy, you use citations like flyswatters. You don't comprehend the serious questions at all.

Woops! Your comprehension is a little questionable too!:)
Greenhouses and the atmosphere get warmed by exactly the same physical processes. High frequency light (visible, ultra-violet) gets in (The atmosphere and the greenhouse glass are both somewhat transparent to it), but the lower-frequency light (infra-red) emitted from the ground can't escape as readily - both the 'greenhouse gasses' and the greenhouse glass are somewhat opaque to this, hence the warming.
 
Woops! Your comprehension is a little questionable too!:)
Greenhouses and the atmosphere get warmed by exactly the same physical processes. High frequency light (visible, ultra-violet) gets in (The atmosphere and the greenhouse glass are both somewhat transparent to it), but the lower-frequency light (infra-red) emitted from the ground can't escape as readily - both the 'greenhouse gasses' and the greenhouse glass are somewhat opaque to this, hence the warming.

An opportunity awaits. Instead of correcting the error you have made regarding the erroneous "standard AGW model" of greenhouse warming, you could simply skip that second erroneous theory and discuss what really is happening, to the extent that it is understood.
 
An opportunity awaits. Instead of correcting the error you have made regarding the erroneous "standard AGW model" of greenhouse warming, you could simply skip that second erroneous theory and discuss what really is happening, to the extent that it is understood.

Umm.. sorry mhaze, but what >are< you talking about?
 
An opportunity awaits. Instead of correcting the error you have made regarding the erroneous "standard AGW model" of greenhouse warming, you could simply skip that second erroneous theory and discuss what really is happening, to the extent that it is understood.

That's hard to parse but I'll have a try ...

It's certainly true that much of the warming effect inside greenhouses is due to the physical barrier-effect of the glass. Light comes in, is absorbed by surfaces, the surfaces warm the air it's in contact with, and the air can't get away very far. So it gets warm.

Note that, were glass as transparent to infra-red as it is to visible light, the greenhouse wouldn't warm up much. The loss through infra-red emission would be a strong negative feedback.

The term "greenhouse warming" is unfortunate. AGW is down to radiative forcings, not glasshouses.

To my mind, "blanket warming" would get us past this diversion. Blankets don't warm directly, and they don't contain warm air perfectly, what they do is shift the local (inside the blanket, just outside the skin) energy budget into the black for a while until a new equilibrium is established. Which is a more comfortable one for whoever lives under the skin.

A blanket can make you, say, 10C warmer, but that doesn't happen as soon as you wrap it around yourself. The warmth has to accumulate. Eventually it reaches a new equilibrium, where heat leaking out equals heat-input.

That's how blanket gases work. They alter the energy-budget inside the blanket. Add more, and the budget is positive until a new equilibrium is reached. We're in the warming-up phase because equilibrium has not yet been reached.
 
An opportunity awaits

It does indeed. The book's not closed on my bet. And there's Florida shoreline to be snapped-up at bargain prices. Once the alarmism fizzles out you can trouser some serious money, trust me on this. I used to work in the City, I know how these things work. Buy long when hysterical types are selling short.
 
beelzebub;3011065[INDENT said:
Instead of correcting the error you have made regarding the erroneous "standard AGW model" of greenhouse warming, you could simply skip that second erroneous theory and discuss what really is happening, to the extent that it is understood
[/indent]Umm.. sorry mhaze, but what >are< you talking about?

Now that CD has
correcting the error you have made
​
by providing us with
the erroneous "standard AGW model" of greenhouse warming
​
you could simply
skip that second erroneous theory and discuss what really is happening, to the extent that it is understood
​
Does it make sense now?
 
The simple theory is wrong. Greenhouses don't warm using the greenhouse effect.

Like Capeldodgy, you use citations like flyswatters. You don't comprehend the serious questions at all.

This has been explained before. Scientists often use a convenient, simple model to explain complex science to the masses. The greenhouse and the greenhouse are indeed different, the greenhouse works on trapping convection, the greehouse effect works on trapping radiation. Both have a similar end effect, so it is a convenient simple model to use. Much like science teachers in school told us atoms are like little coloured balls. They lied to us :eye-poppi, but I forgive them.
 
As somebody taking a passive interest in this thread, could I ask that "Capeldodgy" is dropped? It's not likely to endear you to any fence-sitters, and suggests that your argument is lacking in substance enough to require a bit of the ol' ad hom.
 
This has been explained before. Scientists often use a convenient, simple model to explain complex science to the masses. The greenhouse and the greenhouse are indeed different, the greenhouse works on trapping convection, the greehouse effect works on trapping radiation. Both have a similar end effect, so it is a convenient simple model to use. Much like science teachers in school told us atoms are like little coloured balls. They lied to us :eye-poppi, but I forgive them.


Originally Posted by beelzebub
Instead of correcting the error you have made regarding the erroneous "standard AGW model" of greenhouse warming, you could simply skip that second erroneous theory and discuss what really is happening, to the extent that it is understood

[/indent]Umm.. sorry mhaze, but what >are< you talking about?

Now that CD and AUP have
correcting the error you have made
​
by providing us with
the erroneous "standard AGW model" of greenhouse warming
​
you could simply
skip that second erroneous theory and discuss what really is happening, to the extent that it is understood
​

Again, does it make sense now?
 
Again, does it make sense now?

Not really. It could be a lot more coherent.

There's nothing erroneous about greenhouse theory (an unfortunate name, but there it is, too late to change it now. It was probably thought up by a journalist or "populiser of science"). The behaviour of the big bad analogue model is just further confirmation.

The theory predicts that the warming is most evident at night, in the winter, and at the North Pole. (If the South Pole didn't have a mountain range perched on top of it, it would be equally evident there.) That's three out of three for greenhouse theory.
 
Since I am not a scientist who is actively involved in research in this area, I am more than happy to defer to those who are. :o

Me too.

Of course, it doesn't take active involvement in climate research to realise that something remarkable happened in the Arctic this past summer. Or to notice that all seven of my rose-bushes are in bloom, for the second or third time, in late September. This is not normal. OK, I don't have figures and graphs to prove it, but it is still so. I'm sure you'll be happy to defer to my experience on that :). I don't expect the same from everybody else, though.
 
Great. That is, that you do not expect me to grant you that your seven rose bushes are in bloom for the second or third time in late September is obvious evidence of global warming. I do agree with you that you are seeing that phenomena and that it may be a bit unusual in your experience.

An observer outside the rose garden might indeed wonder whether the 60-80 year climate cycles that affect the ocean currents and temperatures might well have had something to do with this, as well as obviously having an influence on the Arctic.

Other observers might attribute it to the Flying Spagetti Monster.
 
Great. That is, that you do not expect me to grant you that your seven rose bushes are in bloom for the second or third time in late September is obvious evidence of global warming. I do agree with you that you are seeing that phenomena and that it may be a bit unusual in your experience.

I've had my current garden for nigh on twenty years and seen the changes that have occurred gradually over that time, but I'm a from a gardening family so my experience goes back further than that.

That said, the reason why climate change has become such a big issue is that there are so many people like me that have noticed the climate changing. All over the inhabited world.

An observer outside the rose garden might indeed wonder whether the 60-80 year climate cycles that affect the ocean currents and temperatures might well have had something to do with this, as well as obviously having an influence on the Arctic.

Would you classify youself as a 60-80 year cycle believer? You do seem to believe in it. You also seem to believe in the mechanism behind it - ocean currents - despite the lack of evidence from observation. Of which there's no lack in the North Atlantic, North Pacific, and Arctic, since that's where the second-strike subs used to skulk, and whence the Soviet first-strike subs would creep. There's nothing like strategic significance - aka "defence-related" - to get your research funded.

That's why the Southern Oceans are relatively speaking terra incognita :); of no strategic significance to anyone but the Australians and New Zealanders, who are, no offence intended, of no strategic significance to anybody else.



Other observers might attribute it to the Flying Spagetti Monster.

I can see you falling back on that belief. Without noticing that you're falling back on a disbelief. Which is what the FSM represents.

Of course, the Invisible Pink Unicorn represents something far more profound. The FSM is vulgar. There, I've said it.
 
Would you classify youself as a 60-80 year cycle believer? You do seem to believe in it. You also seem to believe in the mechanism behind it - ocean currents - despite the lack of evidence from observation. Of which there's no lack in the North Atlantic, North Pacific, and Arctic, since that's where the second-strike subs used to skulk, and whence the Soviet first-strike subs would creep. There's nothing like strategic significance - aka "defence-related" - to get your research funded.
​
References?
 
The behaviour of the big bad analogue model is just further confirmation.

​
CD, what exactly do you mean by this? I assume it has something to do with lots of unusual things going on - you read in the paper about hurricanes, floods, rain like a deluge, melting ice caps, shrinking sea ice, droughts, and from it reach a conclusion of sorts?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom