North Pole is melting faster than predicted

The behaviour of the big bad analogue model is just further confirmation.

​
CD, what exactly do you mean by this? I assume it has something to do with lots of unusual things going on - you read in the paper about hurricanes, floods, rain like a deluge, melting ice caps, shrinking sea ice, droughts, and from it reach a conclusion of sorts?

Observations: Surface and Atmospheric Climate Change
Observations: Changes in Snow, Ice and Frozen Ground
Observations: Oceanic Climate Change and Sea Level

http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html
 
There is no complaint that there is too much information, neither is there credibility on your part that facts exist as you have stated they do.

Nobody is going off on a wild goose chase at your bequest.

You prove your assertions. That is done with page and chapter references.
 
CD, what exactly do you mean by this? I assume it has something to do with lots of unusual things going on - you read in the paper about hurricanes, floods, rain like a deluge, melting ice caps, shrinking sea ice, droughts, and from it reach a conclusion of sorts?

Yes I do - although I don't just get information from the papers, there's also SciAm, NASA, NSIDC and the evidence of my own eyes. I don't read much into current hurricanes and cyclones, and floods have a variety of causes, but deluges, droughts and loss of ice-mass are significant. From this and the science of AGW - which predicted them - I reach a conclusion.

Further behaviour of the big bad analogue model includes more warming at night than in daytime and in the winter than in summer, and the more rapid warming at the North Pole. Again, these are all predicted by the science of AGW.

At the same time, there's nothing going on that's evidence against AGW.

I find all this, in sum, conclusive.
 
There is no complaint that there is too much information, neither is there credibility on your part that facts exist as you have stated they do.

Nobody is going off on a wild goose chase at your bequest.

You prove your assertions. That is done with page and chapter references.

Three whole chapters of IPCC work that directly address you question, and you won't read them on the basis that it's a 'wild goose chase' :confused:.
 
Three whole chapters of IPCC work that directly address you question, and you won't read them on the basis that it's a 'wild goose chase' :confused:.

CD said:
The behaviour of the big bad analogue model is just further confirmation.
​
My question:
CD, what exactly do you mean by this?
​
You said -
Observations: Surface and Atmospheric Climate Change
Observations: Changes in Snow, Ice and Frozen Ground
Observations: Oceanic Climate Change and Sea Level
http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html
​
If you seriously expect me to go plowing through your chapters looking for references to "Exactly what CD meant by this" that is definitely a wild goose chase.

Maybe you could help?

Look up "Capeldodger" in the index and tell us what you find.
 
CD said:
The behaviour of the big bad analogue model is just further confirmation.
​
My question:
CD, what exactly do you mean by this?
​
You said -
Observations: Surface and Atmospheric Climate Change
Observations: Changes in Snow, Ice and Frozen Ground
Observations: Oceanic Climate Change and Sea Level
http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/wg1-report.html
​
If you seriously expect me to go plowing through your chapters looking for references to "Exactly what CD meant by this" that is definitely a wild goose chase.

Maybe you could help?

Look up "Capeldodger" in the index and tell us what you find.

CD is talking about observations in the real world. There are three chapters dedicated to evaluating those observations.
 
You answered a question other than the one asked?

you said

CD, what exactly do you mean by this? I assume it has something to do with lots of unusual things going on - you read in the paper about hurricanes, floods, rain like a deluge, melting ice caps, shrinking sea ice, droughts, and from it reach a conclusion of sorts?

You understood what he meant.
 
CD answered the question I posed in #420 with his response in #426.

Really, you are just trolling.
 
There is no complaint that there is too much information, neither is there credibility on your part that facts exist as you have stated they do.

Is it your default position that nobody is to be trusted? Has aup given you cause to think that he isn't?

I can't see aup being mendacious in a manner that's so easily detectable. He can be secure in the knowledge that you won't go and look, but there are others around who will. This is, to all intents, a public arena.

Given that nobody's pounced on aup it's a better than fair bet that he's not making this up.

Nobody is going off on a wild goose chase at your bequest.

Any more than I'm ploughing through some pdf of Singer's weaseling because you won't report the gist. You seem to be applying more than one standard, don't you think?
 

Thanks for that, I hadn't come across it. What the implications are is anybody's guess, but it's a good example of unpredicted stuff happening because other stuff has happened.

These ice-islands are obviously thick ice, and if they tend to move south when the thin ice isn't there that does have significant implications. We'll have to wait and see, though. One summer and one ice-island is simply happenstance.
 

I think it's important because it indicates the break up of large bodies of ice is going to happen in an unpredictable way. The Greenland ice shelf, if it was to just melt away, could take over a thousand years. If chunks break off this, or other ice bodies, more often, then sea level rise could be quicker than predicted.
 
Nobody is going off on a wild goose chase at your bequest.
Any more than I'm ploughing through some pdf of Singer's weaseling because you won't report the gist. You seem to be applying more than one standard, don't you think?
​
Unfortunately, in that case....my stated challenge was for AGW True Believers to disprove Singer's 1,500 year climate cycle hypothesis. So I can't really do your work for you. Neither am I going to let on whether I think a valid disproval exists (although I might let out a hint or two just for fun).

Incidentally, you asked
Would you classify youself as a 60-80 year cycle believer? You do seem to believe in it. You also seem to believe in the mechanism behind it - ocean currents - despite the lack of evidence from observation.
​
That did get me curious, and I asked -
References?
​
I'm still waiting.
 
Unfortunately, in that case....my stated challenge was for AGW True Believers to disprove Singer's 1,500 year climate cycle hypothesis.

Singer's 1500-year cycle (plus or minus 500) is based on D-O events, which occur during glaciations not inter-glacials and which do not resemble current the current warming.

So I can't really do your work for you.

I did it myself already.

Neither am I going to let on whether I think a valid disproval exists (although I might let out a hint or two just for fun).

I'd expect no better of you.



Incidentally, you asked
Would you classify youself as a 60-80 year cycle believer? You do seem to believe in it. You also seem to believe in the mechanism behind it - ocean currents - despite the lack of evidence from observation.​

That did get me curious, and I asked -
References?​
I'm still waiting.

Was I wrong? Do you not believe in it? To me, it seems as if you do, so I asked the question.
 
:
Incidentally, you asked
Would you classify youself as a 60-80 year cycle believer? You do seem to believe in it. You also seem to believe in the mechanism behind it - ocean currents - despite the lack of evidence from observation.​
That did get me curious, and I asked -
References?​
I'm still waiting.

Was I wrong? Do you not believe in it? To me, it seems as if you do, so I asked the question.
Believer?
Now that isn't the right term or right approach. I just look at data and draw conclusions from it, those being subject to change as new data is acquired, found or discovered. Such as those references I am waiting for from you on the the lack of evidence from ocean currents being related to 60-80 year climate cycles.

Speaking of which ...

Here is John M. commenting on www.climateaudit.org about the "big bad analogue model".

John M. says: October 2nd, 2007 at 9:57 pm
... As a child in the 1970s back when an imminent new ice age was sometimes being mentioned as a possibility on the television, I could see skating ponds built during the LIA in the countryside around the village where I grew up that could hardly ever be used as it seldom ever got cold enough for the water to freeze sufficiently to safely use them. ... I could also see field patterns for cropland dating back to the MWP and Roman times at altitudes where there was only sheep pasture in the modern era. Dramatic historical natural climate changes were obvious in other words and everybody knew about it.

Scientists were already seriously concerned about global warming by the late 80s and early 90s before Mann published his paper and Hansen started playing around with the historical temperature record.

Showing they are possibly up to mischief in terms of the scientific method doesn’t change much in the big scheme of things in other words.​
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom