North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Ad hominem arguments do not work.

We are talking about science here. Science is just as much about the journey, as the destination. That is, the scientific method. If you don't follow that, you aren't contributing much to science. AGW is all about science, not numerous opinions of individuals of indeterminant expertise. It has to be, it's a complex area of knowledge, without some formal process like the scientific method, you just end up with the denier position, numerous points of view, many of which are contradictory, but all of which appear to be a valid contradiction of the accumulated research. The end result is confusion. For some deniers, that is all they want to achieve, it means any action to prevent AGW is effectively sabotaged.
 
We are talking about science here.

Except when you digress into rubbish, loons and nutters, which you do have a very large closet full.

For some deniers, that is all they want to achieve, it means any action to prevent AGW is effectively sabotaged.

​
Sounds like something that would get "attaboys" at Realclimate but negatives here.
 
Except when you digress into rubbish, loons and nutters, which you do have a very large closet full.
For some deniers, that is all they want to achieve, it means any action to prevent AGW is effectively sabotaged.

​
Sounds like something that would get "attaboys" at Realclimate but negatives here.

I'm not the one who produces them.

There is a scientific method for a reason, the results of it are everywhere in our everyday lives. All of a sudden, that proven process is tossed out. Read the conservative blogs, every second seems to be about beating the commies, or socialists, or liberals.

http://littlegreenfootballs.com/weblog/?entry=24691_The_Great_Global_Warming_Swindle#comments
 
Kill off all cattle. Terminal for the cattle. Side-effects on cattle-dependent parasites and dung-beetles. And some people, obviously.
Nice hypothetical .. How about a ' realistic ' extinction that will occur from AGW, and severely impact life as we know it..

It's only with the emergence of HomSap that distinction between "artificial" and "natural" has become necessary.
It's ridiculous to suggest HomSap'sactivities are any less natural than any other animal's ..

We have as much right to destroy the planet as any other natural force.

The Earth will be gone someday .. If humans survive , it will be because we leave .. ( .. and maybe leave a bit of necessary garbage behind )

Chances are, we will be destroyed before that happens, and it's highly unlikely AGW will have anything to do with it.


I find it hilarious to think that anyone really thinks that HomSap can really ' Save The Planet ' , anything now living on it; or that natural forces will have any less trouble destroying this planet and all life on it, because of any puny effort of anyone alive today...
 
But how do you know for sure? I mean, really, really for sure?

That one extra run down to the store in the SUV yesterday might have been the final straw for the Big Tipping Point. And now we're all doomed. Doomed, I say. Doooommmmmeddddd...
 
Nice hypothetical .. How about a ' realistic ' extinction that will occur from AGW, and severely impact life as we know it..

What's likely to happen is a lot of extinctions adding up to a significant regional impact. These will be extinctions at the "little people" end of things, but in the end the show does depend on all those little people'

It's ridiculous to suggest HomSap'sactivities are any less natural than any other animal's ..

So what does "artificial" mean to you? The word exists for a reason. Hunger is natural, social-climbing is natural, plastic bags are artificial. The Mid-West grain belt is artificial. The British traditional landscape is artificial. Great swathes of Holland are artificial. Belgium's artificial in a different sense. Gender imbalance in India is artificial in yet another.

Coal-mines and oil-wells are artificial. They're not just some HomSap equivalent of poking a twig into a termite nest.

We are not like other species. There was a step-change in evolution when we turned up. It's time we got over getting-over ourselves; that was a liberating in the 18th and 19thCE, but no longer.

We have as much right to destroy the planet as any other natural force.

Which is to say, none at all. Rights are an artificial concept.

The Earth will be gone someday ..

So it will, but it's natural for people with children to hope that it won't be very soon.

If humans survive , it will be because we leave .. ( .. and maybe leave a bit of necessary garbage behind )

When the Sun's about to consume this rock we call home, nobody's going to clean house for the next tenants. A more pressing question, for people with dynastic ambitions, concerns the necessity of leaving garbage around for their grandchildren and their grandchildren. It's more natural for people to want to provide for their offspring, not dump on them.

Chances are, we will be destroyed before that happens, and it's highly unlikely AGW will have anything to do with it.

Human society, with it's technology and science, will survive what's coming. Not in the form it takes today, but every today is fleeting. Progress continues because we learn from experience, and there's a rich seam of experience coming up over the next few decades. And AGW will have a lot to do with it.

There'll be other stuff, mostly related to depletion. The big lesson that will be learned is that sustainability is not optional. The zeitgeist will shift from Now! to Deep Time.


I find it hilarious to think that anyone really thinks that HomSap can really ' Save The Planet ' , anything now living on it; or that natural forces will have any less trouble destroying this planet and all life on it, because of any puny effort of anyone alive today...

That's a difficult sentence to work with. You start with HomSap, and end with anyone. HomSap is, you know, everyone, and it is not puny. Not in its neck of the woods, anyway, which is this thin fluid skim on a rock that we call Home. Atmospheric CO2-load up by a third, and acidification of the oceans at the same time! Boo-Yah! Match that, Nature!

The planet and the life that lives on it have survived for a very long time, and will survive these coming Tribulations. When it comes to individuals and blood-lines, of course, it's a very different matter.

We're not talking about the end of the world here. We're talking about a world without SUV's.
 
The point is we have a scientific process to follow, to achieve results of some sort of scientific validity. It is entirely possible Corbyn ...

Piers Corbyn, what a loon, up on his back legs positively baying about his predictions of the July storms over here, loud enough to get Diamond's juices flowing. August and September : completely and utterly wrong. Not within a whisker. Nil points. And not a squeak out of him. No surprises there then.

... or Crichton are actually correct, and I could win the lottery this week.

Just an informed guess here, but you don't buy lottery tickets, do you? Sorry if I tripped a trap, but I don't think anyone else even noticed the bait.

Chrichton. Summoned by Senator Inhofe. It came to that. On the way down.

The Arctic Ice has stopped melting, from what I hear. That's the end of that scare :).
 
Stay consistent, continue to worry and fret about the melting polar ice. Go on to being worried about next summer. The thicker the ice grows and the wider the extent of it becomes, that much the more, state that it will completely melt. The faster variability, the increasing extremes.
 
But how do you know for sure? I mean, really, really for sure?

That one extra run down to the store in the SUV yesterday might have been the final straw for the Big Tipping Point. And now we're all doomed. Doomed, I say. Doooommmmmeddddd...

Calm yourself. We're not doomed. If we were there'd be a comet to tell us so, wouldn't there? There's no comet. It's OK.

Some of us won't come out of this well, obviously, and some won't come out at all, but some will do adequately well. Some will do splendidly. One may even be you. Life's a lottery, after all. Informed decisions are no more useful than astrology. Go with your gut. Alarmism is distorting the market, but that can't last. Bet against it over the medium term.

Buy land in Florida, that's my advice. When this AGW alarmism runs into the sand, in three to eight years time by my estimation, you'll coin it big-time.

For maximum benefit, buy on margin. That's what the real players do.
 
Stay consistent, continue to worry and fret about the melting polar ice.

Not sure this is directed to me, but do I appear worried? Or fretful? (Rhetorical)

Go on to being worried about next summer.

I'm more concerned with the coming winter. I had my chimney swept and first delivery of coal - Mr. Farmer is most reliable for both, never any mess, always punctual, I thoroughly recommend him - just this morning.

The thicker the ice grows and the wider the extent of it becomes, that much the more, state that it will completely melt. The faster variability, the increasing extremes.

Shouldn't we be settling down at the end of a 60-80 year cycle? Last-minute extreme events don't really fit that profile.

Something that does fit this last Arctic summer is a longer-term thinning of the ice, which obviously doesn't show up in ice-extent figures. For so much retreat this summer - several times the average annual retreat over the last decade - there had to be a lot of thin ice out there in March 2007.

The ice that survived will be heavy on the thick stuff, so I doubt we'll see a similar surge for a few years. But then - say, three to eight years time - there will be. The thin ice was thinner than expected, so the thick stuff is probably not as thick as expected.

In three to eight year time, we'll know. The ice comes back - your 60-80 year cycle - or it makes another major retreat - my informed prediction.

A thousand euros and three shares in Gazprom is my bet. Care to take it?
 
.....
We're not talking about the end of the world here. We're talking about a world without SUV's.

Well, I was talking about the end of the world, and our complete inability to do anything about it, except leave as soon as possible...

blue_marble.jpg


Don't see any SUV's here ..

If you are concerned about SUV's, it's because you choose to live in a tiny piece of the globe where they happen to exist ..
 
Well, I was talking about the end of the world, and our complete inability to do anything about it, except leave as soon as possible...

http://science.hq.nasa.gov/kids/images/blue_marble.jpg

Don't see any SUV's here ..

If you are concerned about SUV's, it's because you choose to live in a tiny piece of the globe where they happen to exist ..

Something like a big bad CO2 spewing Hummer is actually just a microbe sized, totally insignificant grain of dust?

You don't think that maybe - just maybe - the warming of the planet
might come from ...



 
In three to eight year time, we'll know. The ice comes back - your 60-80 year cycle - or it makes another major retreat - my informed prediction.

A thousand euros and three shares in Gazprom is my bet. Care to take it
?
​
Wouldn't a AGW Believer hold some position like
"For each of the next five years. sea ice summer minima will be progressively lower than the prior year?"
​
That would seem to imply other than natural causes. Good writup on actual causes of arctic ice decline here.
 
Wouldn't a AGW Believer hold some position like
"For each of the next five years. sea ice summer minima will be progressively lower than the prior year?"​

No, that would be a strawman...

That would seem to imply other than natural causes.

So, now you get to determine which output will be natural or artificial? In a sea/ice system? It must be good to be so powerful.

Good writup on actual causes of arctic ice decline here.

Why didn't you link directly to the NSIDC site? Why that strange pdf? Maybe you have problems with the fact that the scientists at NSIDC actually link both the decrease in artic ice and the melting of the permafrost to... wait for it... greenhouse gases emmited by human activities.

Oh well. Par for the course, I guess.
 
No, that would be a strawman...
So, now you get to determine which output will be natural or artificial? In a sea/ice system? It must be good to be so powerful.

Why didn't you link directly to the NSIDC site? Why that strange pdf? Maybe you have problems with the fact that the scientists at NSIDC actually link both the decrease in artic ice and the melting of the permafrost to... wait for it... greenhouse gases emmited by human activities.

Oh well. Par for the course, I guess.

You might have missed the comment by CP, being in your usual drive by mode, so I'll repeat it. It had to do with betting on climate change.
Shouldn't we be settling down at the end of a 60-80 year cycle? Last-minute extreme events don't really fit that profile.

Something that does fit this last Arctic summer is a longer-term thinning of the ice, which obviously doesn't show up in ice-extent figures. For so much retreat this summer - several times the average annual retreat over the last decade - there had to be a lot of thin ice out there in March 2007.

The ice that survived will be heavy on the thick stuff, so I doubt we'll see a similar surge for a few years. But then - say, three to eight years time - there will be. The thin ice was thinner than expected, so the thick stuff is probably not as thick as expected.

In three to eight year time, we'll know. The ice comes back - your 60-80 year cycle - or it makes another major retreat - my informed prediction.

A thousand euros and three shares in Gazprom is my bet. Care to take it?
​
 
I didn't miss it. It was a good post, with a valid chalenge. Your reply was a strawman at best.

You still didn't explain why you prefered the babble of a blogger over the site of the persons who actually did the work.
 
Well, I was talking about the end of the world, and our complete inability to do anything about it, except leave as soon as possible...

But the party's just got started :confused: .

AGW, which is kinda what the rest of us are talking about, doesn't mean the end of the world. End of the world as we know it, perhaps, but that's using "world" as a metaphor for human society. "His world collapsed around him", that sort of thing.
 
Wouldn't a AGW Believer hold some position like
"For each of the next five years. sea ice summer minima will be progressively lower than the prior year?"​

If that's the expected position of an "AGW Believer" then I'm not one. You can strike my name from that list.

I gave my general reasoning for not expecting another sudden retreat for a few years at least. The easy stuff has been harvested first, so what's left is the hardier stuff. To expand a little, weather conditions probably won't be as conducive to melting for some years. During that time the thicker ice will get thinner without vanishing, so when the next summer similar to this one occurs there's another large area of ice thin enough to disappear.

If next summer's ice is as much as or greater than this summer's, I do expect contrarians will leap upon it.

Anyhoo, enough chat about what my hand is. Are you going to call my bet? Obviously it doesn't have to include three actual shares in Gazprom, just their market value. It's like a futures deal.
 
Something like a big bad CO2 spewing Hummer is actually just a microbe sized, totally insignificant grain of dust?/quote]

Yes. Quite. One molecule of sarin is even more insignificant. The thing is, when you come across one there are usually lots more around it. And then you have a problem. Not for long, of course, but a problem all the same.

You choose to mention the Hummer, a particulary egregious compensation-mechanism, but there are millions of smaller Chelsea Tractors and wannabes. It's the cumulative effect that's a problem.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom