North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Is this what science has become? I hope not. But it is what it will become, unless there is a concerted effort by leading scientists to aggressively separate science from policy. The late Philip Handler, former president of the National Academy of Sciences, said that "Scientists best serve public policy by living within the ethics of science, not those of politics. If the scientific community will not unfrock the charlatans, the public will not discern the difference-science and the nation will suffer." Personally, I don't worry about the nation. But I do worry about science.



Yes, the IPCC soldiers on, despite the fact that the politics of what they are saying is not what people want to hear, that is, they should be modifying their lifestyle, and despite the amazing attacks made up people such as Hansen and Jones. They are attempting to unfrock the charlatans, but the charlatans are very good at making non-science appear to the uninformed to be science. They are worrying about the nation, and, in the process, holding back the relentless attacks on science.

 
That's a bit broad, I think. It's of interest to some because they can take comfort from it, and that's what these weasels intended it to provide. You're dead right on the likes of Diamond, though : dogmatic, uncritical, none too bright, and committed to pushing the message. They're no different from the sad types who push Socialist Worker on Saturday morning high-streets.

I would be right on CapelDodgy: paranoid, credulous, unthinking, antiscientific and a deeply unpleasant catastrophist crackpot. And I can quote lots of examples.

It's of interest to me because I like to keep up-to-date with the weaseling - for instance, the 1500-year cycle is fairly new to Singer, now that his "it won't happen" and "it's not happening" weaselings are no longer tenable. So on to the "it's nothing special" weaseling. Very similar to the "everybody wheezes when they get older, so it's nothing to do with your smoking" thing Singer cut his teeth on. (He still finds time to bat for the tobacco lobby, on secondary smoking. Praise be! he's discovered it's not a problem :) .)

Yes, the conflation of climate skepticism with tobacco science. You're a desperate man to keep reaching for strawy arguments like this.

In any case, Fred Singer has made a large scientific case that climate has a 1500 year cycle and you have no answer at all. In the eyes of creationists like yourself, climate should be stable unless 'perturbed', an idea easily debunked by mountains of paleoclimatological data.

The unchanging dogma, of course, is that AGW must not be to blame. You've obviously spotted the ideological under-pinning of contrarianism - AGW is the Daddy of all externalities; externalities imply the need for regulation by the wider society; all regulation is evil and damaging; ergo externalities don't exist. Especially not this one. If science says different, then science has to be trashed.

The unchanging dogma in your case is that man is to blame and that natural variation of climate is minor - a classic piece of creationist belief wrapped in secular clothing. The climate of the past was benign until man sinned by eating from the tree of knowledge (The Industrial Revolution) thus unleashing the dreadful punishment of climate change.

Of course in the 1970s, it was all about cooling, desertification and ice ages. Now its about warming. Until it turns colder again, and Capeldodgy will revert to the evils of cooling again.

In Capeldodgyworld, the only change in climate is a bad change and its all the fault of western industrialization, whatever these nasty scientists may say from vast experience. You're an antiscience catastrophist crackpot and have been for 30 years.

Sadly for the dogmatists, AGW and science just won't go away.

No-one on this board is more dogmatic and resistant to scientific insight than you. It's rather like being lectured on the evils of totalitarianism by Pol Pot.
 


Yes, the IPCC soldiers on, despite the fact that the politics of what they are saying is not what people want to hear, that is, they should be modifying their lifestyle, and despite the amazing attacks made up people such as Hansen and Jones. They are attempting to unfrock the charlatans, but the charlatans are very good at making non-science appear to the uninformed to be science. They are worrying about the nation, and, in the process, holding back the relentless attacks on science.


Oh dear these amazing attacks wouldn't include scientific fraud would they?

From Jennifer Marohasy's blog:

A claimed "first world conference on research integrity" opens in Lisbon, Portugal, today. The conference media release explains: "The controversies surrounding the recent assessment report of the United Nations' Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) demonstrates how research integrity is a critical issue not only for the science community, but for politicians and the society as a whole as well. In August 2007 the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) had to withdraw previous published historical climate data.

The incident came after a British mathematician discovered that the sources used by the Intergovernmental Panel for Climate Change (IPCC) have disregarded the positions of weather stations, plus intentionally using outdated data on China from 1991 and ignoring revised data on the country from 1997.

That British mathematician being Doug Keenan, and the scientific fraud being data used by Phil Jones to prove that the Urban Heat Island was a minor effect and nothing to worry about (and used by every IPCC report since 1990):

Link to scientific fraud in pdf format

Perhaps in another life, James Hansen wouldn't have been the author of a climate model that in the early 1970s claimed that we were going to enter a period of catastrophic cooling would he?

Or perhaps in this life as well.

NASA scientist James E. Hansen, who has publicly criticized the Bush administration for dragging its feet on climate change and labeled skeptics of man-made global warming as distracting "court jesters," appears in a 1971 Washington Post article that warns of an impending ice age within 50 years.

"U.S. Scientist Sees New Ice Age Coming," blares the headline of the July 9, 1971, article, which cautions readers that the world "could be as little as 50 or 60 years away from a disastrous new ice age, a leading atmospheric scientist predicts."

The scientist was S.I. Rasool, a colleague of Mr. Hansen's at the National Aeronautics and Space Administration. The article goes on to say that Mr. Rasool came to his chilling conclusions by resorting in part to a new computer program developed by Mr. Hansen that studied clouds above Venus.

The 1971 article, discovered this week by Washington resident John Lockwood while he was conducting related research at the Library of Congress, says that "in the next 50 years" or by 2021 fossil-fuel dust injected by man into the atmosphere "could screen out so much sunlight that the average temperature could drop by six degrees," resulting in a buildup of "new glaciers that could eventually cover huge areas."

You should ask Capeldodgy about this - he's probably still got the t-shirts.

Of course none of this will change in the slightest any of your beliefs about climate, past present or future because its not rooted in scientific evidence, but in a catastrophic belief system that you refuse to grow out of.
 
Oh dear these amazing attacks wouldn't include scientific fraud would they?

From Jennifer Marohasy's blog:



That British mathematician being Doug Keenan, and the scientific fraud being data used by Phil Jones to prove that the Urban Heat Island was a minor effect and nothing to worry about (and used by every IPCC report since 1990):

Link to scientific fraud in pdf format

Perhaps in another life, James Hansen wouldn't have been the author of a climate model that in the early 1970s claimed that we were going to enter a period of catastrophic cooling would he?

Or perhaps in this life as well.



You should ask Capeldodgy about this - he's probably still got the t-shirts.

Of course none of this will change in the slightest any of your beliefs about climate, past present or future because its not rooted in scientific evidence, but in a catastrophic belief system that you refuse to grow out of.

If you read the article, Hansen wasn't the author of it, he was asked to help out with calculations, which he did. The possibility of an ice age was investigate, since the cooling effect of aerosols was, in fact, demonstrated. It is the nature of science to do research, since, as we all know, the climate does change.
 


The models are continually validated against real data, and updated. It is a non stop task. We can't validate against 2100 data? What is the alternative, Mr Chrichton?

My guess is that Feynman, who is deeply involved in computer modelling, http://www.longnow.org/views/essays/articles/ArtFeynman.php, would regard Chrichton as an idiot.

Crichton quotes Feynman in the immediately following paragraph to the above quote regarding computer models, so let me just continue the quotation -

There can be no observational data about the year 2100. There are only model runs.

This fascination with computer models is something I understand very well. Richard Feynmann called it a disease. I fear he is right. Because only if you spend a lot of time looking at a computer screen can you arrive at the complex point where the global warming debate now stands.

Nobody believes a weather prediction twelve hours ahead. Now we're asked to believe a prediction that goes out 100 years into the future? And make financial investments based on that prediction? Has everybody lost their minds?
​
Crichton and Feynmann share similar views about the merits of computer modeling.
​
 


The models are continually validated against real data, and updated. It is a non stop task. We can't validate against 2100 data? What is the alternative, Mr Chrichton?

My guess is that Feynman, who is deeply involved in computer modelling, http://www.longnow.org/views/essays/articles/ArtFeynman.php, would regard Chrichton as an idiot.

You may have missed what the article actually said.
"Feynman considered a crazy idea something to prove right or wrong". (not something to discard)
​
And this -
During those first few months, Richard began studying the router circuit diagrams as if they were objects of nature. He was willing to listen to explanations of how and why things worked, but fundamentally he preferred to figure out everything himself by simulating the action of each of the circuits with pencil and paper.
​
That's what we may be doing a bit of on this forum in the coming months. Actually looking at raw data and asking -

"is there actually a connection between CO2 and temperature?"

If so, show me.
 
You may have missed what the article actually said.
"Feynman considered a crazy idea something to prove right or wrong". (not something to discard)
​
And this -
During those first few months, Richard began studying the router circuit diagrams as if they were objects of nature. He was willing to listen to explanations of how and why things worked, but fundamentally he preferred to figure out everything himself by simulating the action of each of the circuits with pencil and paper.
​
That's what we may be doing a bit of on this forum in the coming months. Actually looking at raw data and asking -

"is there actually a connection between CO2 and temperature?"

If so, show me.

There is

http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2007/04/learning-from-a-simple-model

A lot of what gets discussed here in relation to the greenhouse effect is relatively simple, and yet can be confusing to the lay reader. A useful way of demonstrating that simplicity is to use a stripped down mathematical model that is complex enough to include some interesting physics, but simple enough so that you can just write down the answer. This is the staple of most textbooks on the subject, but there are questions that arise in discussions here that don't ever get addressed in most textbooks. Yet simple models can be useful there too.
I'll try and cover a few 'greenhouse' issues that come up in multiple contexts in the climate debate. Why does 'radiative forcing' work as method for comparing different physical impacts on the climate, and why you can't calculate climate sensitivity just by looking at the surface energy budget. There will be mathematics, but hopefully it won't be too painful.

So how simple can you make a model that contains the basic greenhouse physics? Pretty simple actually. You need to account for the solar radiation coming in (including the impact of albedo), the longwave radiation coming from the surface (which depends on the temperature) and some absorption/radiation (the 'emissivity') of longwave radiation in the atmosphere (the basic greenhouse effect). Optionally, you can increase the realism by adding feedbacks (allowing the absorption or albedo to depend on temperature), and other processes - like convection - that link the surface and atmosphere more closely than radiation does. You can skip directly to the bottom-line points if you don't want to see the gory details.



Which is where it all started.
 
Crichton quotes Feynman in the immediately following paragraph to the above quote regarding computer models, so let me just continue the quotation -
There can be no observational data about the year 2100. There are only model runs.

This fascination with computer models is something I understand very well. Richard Feynmann called it a disease. I fear he is right. Because only if you spend a lot of time looking at a computer screen can you arrive at the complex point where the global warming debate now stands.

Nobody believes a weather prediction twelve hours ahead. Now we're asked to believe a prediction that goes out 100 years into the future? And make financial investments based on that prediction? Has everybody lost their minds?
​
Crichton and Feynmann share similar views about the merits of computer modeling.

Crichton has no idea if Feynmann would agree with him at all, it's only his opinion vs that of a dead man, and highly presumptuous of him to claim they think alike. As the article shows, Feynmann was deeply involved in modeling.

He was also quite happy to acknowledge when he did not know something, and to claim credit for it when he did. The quote was about the nuclear winter hypothesis, which was a question that was well worth asking then, and still is now. Modeling has advanced incredibly since those early days, as the power of computers has increased and the science of climate has also advanced. So he made an observation off the top of his head? He's entitled to do so, and it's no more than that.

As for this claim.

This fascination with computer models is something I understand very well.




Is Crichton going for an idiot of the year award? I bet he thinks he's a good novelist, too.
 
If you read the article, Hansen wasn't the author of it, he was asked to help out with calculations, which he did. The possibility of an ice age was investigate, since the cooling effect of aerosols was, in fact, demonstrated.

Hansen designed the computer model, which he communicated to Rasool as indicating that a fossil-fuel induced mini Ice Age was imminent. The cooling effect of aerosols is well known, as you say, but the cooling of the mid 20th Century wasn't put down to any old aerosols but to man-made aerosols. Which is what Hansen communicated.

It is the nature of science to do research, since, as we all know, the climate does change.

Who is this we? You know that climate does not change unless perturbed by man-made greenhouse gases. The Mann Hockey Stick fraud (which you refuse to let go of) tells you so.

A nice piece of freestyle denialism, but we know rather better about what you actually believe, don't we?

I note for the record that you're not bothering with the claims of scientific fraud concerning Jones or the conference specially convened to discuss it. Does this mean that you can't answer it?
 
Last edited:

Unfortunately scientific facts are not established by computer models but by theory. They may bamboozle the weak-minded on SurRealClimate but to atmospheric physicists they are tools to set out scenarios.

So where is the theory that says that increasing the partial pressure of a gas like carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere will increase the mean temperature?
 
Unfortunately scientific facts are not established by computer models but by theory. They may bamboozle the weak-minded on SurRealClimate but to atmospheric physicists they are tools to set out scenarios.

So where is the theory that says that increasing the partial pressure of a gas like carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere will increase the mean temperature?

A good way of posing the question.

Once located, it might then be subjected to scientific tests.
 
Who is this we? You know that climate does not change unless perturbed by man-made greenhouse gases.

I have never said that, nor has the IPCC. The claim is that at present, the other forcings are not making significant changes, it's the CO2 that is the strongest forcing. That claim is only being made for this time.
 
A good way of posing the question.

Once located, it might then be subjected to scientific tests.

The theory is very simple and well accepted.

http://www.pa.msu.edu/sciencet/ask_st/083194.html

Fossil fuels such as gasoline, methane and propane contain mostly carbon. When these fuels are burned, they react with oxygen and produce carbon dioxide. Because of our heavy use of fossil fuels, the amount of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere has been increasing since the industrial revolution. The destruction of forests which use carbon dioxide also contributes to the increase in carbon dioxide.
Most of the light energy from the sun is emitted in wavelengths shorter than 4,000 nanometers (.000004 meters). The heat energy released from the earth, however, is released in wavelengths longer than 4,000 nanometers. Carbon dioxide doesn't absorb the energy from the sun, but it does absorb some of the heat energy released from the earth. When a molecule of carbon dioxide absorbs heat energy, it goes into an excited unstable state. It can become stable again by releasing the energy it absorbed. Some of the released energy will go back to the earth and some will go out into space.
So in effect, carbon dioxide lets the light energy in, but doesn't let all of the heat energy out, similar to a greenhouse.
 
Unfortunately scientific facts are not established by computer models but by theory. They may bamboozle the weak-minded on SurRealClimate but to atmospheric physicists they are tools to set out scenarios.

So where is the theory that says that increasing the partial pressure of a gas like carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere will increase the mean temperature?

As he says, Millwood and Idso, and more recently Schwartz, all use similar calculations to debunk AGW, but get the calculations wrong. These calculations are all accepted by the deniers, AFAIK.
 
Unfortunately scientific facts are not established by computer models but by theory.

Facts are established by observation. Theories survive as long as they are not discredited by observation. The theory behind AGW has not been so discredited. Nor, by the way, have decades-old models.

They may bamboozle the weak-minded on SurRealClimate but to atmospheric physicists they are tools to set out scenarios.

More precisely, a theory is a tentative explanation of observed phaenomena which can provide predictions of as-yet unobserved phaenomena. Greenhouse theory was originally an explanation for the observed phaenomenon that the world is a lot warmer than thermodynamics would have us believe. Thermodynamics was the science of the Industrial Revolution, and so was very well-established early on. And still survives. Thanks to greenhouse theory, which explains this apparent anomaly.

So where is the theory that says that increasing the partial pressure of a gas like carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere will increase the mean temperature?

Arrhenius is credited with a good treatment of the subject. That was a century ago, but these days we can actually train infra-red cameras on the night sky and confirm one prediction of the theory - the atmosphere glows in the infra-red.
 
As he says, Millwood and Idso, and more recently Schwartz, all use similar calculations to debunk AGW, but get the calculations wrong. These calculations are all accepted by the deniers, AFAIK.

To be scrupulously fair, Schwartz is downplaying AGW rather than trying to debunk it - he knows that game is lost. Offcourse, this doesn't mean he intervenes to put matter straight in the not-so-secret clubhouses where it's "understood" differently. On that circuit, he makes the same old stump-speech. Without that audience he's nobody.

I doubt Schwartz ever expected his "model" to be anything other than a cross to be nailed to by the "scientific establishment". Martyrdom goes down well with his audience. Actual science, well, not so much. Actual events, again, not so much.
 
A good way of posing the question.

If the question is "where is the theory?", I suggest you check out Arrhenius's treatment of a existing greenhouse theory in the late 19thCE. The theory behind AGW is not secret or hard to find.

Once located, it might then be subjected to scientific tests.

It has been and is being. On the biggest baddest analogue model there is. The current experiment is unplanned, but it's a continuing experiment nonetheless. Observations conform to the theory. They do not conform to any of the alternatives so far offered up.
 
If the question is "where is the theory?", I suggest you check out Arrhenius's treatment of a existing greenhouse theory in the late 19thCE. The theory behind AGW is not secret or hard to find.

Repeating assertions does not make them true.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom