North Pole is melting faster than predicted

Is The Earth in Imminent Peril?

Of course some scientists cater to public fears and cater to the Alarmist cult of True AGW Believers. Hansen, for example. They don't believe the IPCC report. Hmmm.....

A group of six U.S. scientists have warned that our planet is in imminent peril due to global warming. In the article from Rawstory.com they state that global warming may run out of control and become a great danger to humans and creatures. The scientists say that the recent UN Panel report on climate change from this past February underestimates the scale of sea-level rise this century. The UN report said that sea-levels could rise as much as 18-59 cm (7 inches-2 feet) by 2100, while the findings from this group of scientists stated that it could rise by several meters! Several meters is not very specific, but it looks like they are saying that ocean levels would rise at least 4 feet or more by 2100.
 
Of course some scientists cater to public fears and cater to the Alarmist cult of True AGW Believers. Hansen, for example. They don't believe the IPCC report. Hmmm.....

A group of six U.S. scientists have warned that our planet is in imminent peril due to global warming. In the article from Rawstory.com they state that global warming may run out of control and become a great danger to humans and creatures. The scientists say that the recent UN Panel report on climate change from this past February underestimates the scale of sea-level rise this century. The UN report said that sea-levels could rise as much as 18-59 cm (7 inches-2 feet) by 2100, while the findings from this group of scientists stated that it could rise by several meters! Several meters is not very specific, but it looks like they are saying that ocean levels would rise at least 4 feet or more by 2100.

Several meters would be more like 15 or 20 feet. Have you considered that scientists, in their quest to be correct, would understate the problem? They hate to be wrong, so understating is the safe option.
 
Several meters would be more like 15 or 20 feet. Have you considered that scientists, in their quest to be correct, would understate the problem? They hate to be wrong, so understating is the safe option.

I've considered that going Alarmist is the way for a scientist to get out of the lab, out of proposal writing, out of teaching a dull class, and to get into the media spotlight.
 
And that passes for evidence? I can consider anything, and I just did, but it has no more validity than what you are claiming.

You are the one that is always saying "Read the IPCC".

But now it seems that if scientists go way beyond the IPCC, and add "tipping points" and alarmist scenarios that require "urgent action now" because the earth is in "imminent peril"

... you accept their statements unquestionably.

Which is Authority? The IPCC, or the most Alarmist scientists on the planet?
 
You are the one that is always saying "Read the IPCC".

But now it seems that if scientists go way beyond the IPCC, and add "tipping points" and alarmist scenarios that require "urgent action now" because the earth is in "imminent peril"

... you accept their statements unquestionably.

Which is Authority? The IPCC, or the most Alarmist scientists on the planet?

There are two issues. What is highly likely, in the sense that scientists are pretty damn sure it will happen, and what should we consider from a risk management strategy.

The IPCC is telling us the first case, because they hate to be wrong, but the smaller group of scientists are saying things could quite possibly get a lot worse than that, and we should consider those possibilities too.

"Tipping points" are important, they mean we have reached a point of no return.
 
Slight OT:
I've considered that going Alarmist is the way for a scientist to get out of the lab, out of proposal writing, out of teaching a dull class, and to get into the media spotlight.
A hypothetical scenario for you: A group of scientists discover that there is a significant threat to humanity. Say, that there's an alien race out there that appears to be plotting to invade Earth. What do you want them to do?

...what? Tell people about it? But wouldn't that be... alarmist?

Could it be that these researchers are saying AGW is real and dangerous because [...drumroll...] it's real and dangerous? Isn't it a bit naïve of you to go 'OK, this is alarming, so I'm going to hide under my Rock of Personal Incredulity (+3) and say they're doing it just to get famous'?

Fair enough that it's wrong of the media to scare people. But the implied statement that this somehow invalidates the AGW theories is pure nonsense.
 
Something as important and world changing as man made climate change should be subjected to the most rigorous and skeptical inquiry. From all sides. Especially if it is used to make policy changes and economic restrictions on the entire population of the planet.

I like the idea of reducing pollution and alternative energy, but that doesn't mean I am going to ignore the science.
 
I assume from your ad hominem attacks that you do not want to address the scientific facts addressed by the studies that Singer references, some hundreds of them. In trying to sort through the ad hominem attacks to find something worth replying to, I do see an issue with the concept of "1500 year plus or minus 500 year" cycle.

What part of that do you have a problem with? If a scientist looks at other work other scientists have done, and notes that many of them have seen these cycles, and then reports the range of the cycle, what is wrong with that?

Do those other scientists provide evidence of a cycle with uncertain periodicity somewhere between one and two thousand years? I strongly doubt it, and would even if I didn't know that Singer is a weasel.

It is wrong if it is actually "plus or minus 500" and it is incorrectly stated "plus or minus 250".

Do what now :confused:?


Which leads me right square back to my prior question to you.

What it actually does is avoid my question : who introduced the "plus or minus 500 years", Singer or the scientists he references?

Singer is a weasel. He'll happily cite papers that make even the most tangential reference to his product - the 1500-year cycle being the best he can find - and then introduce his own "plus or minus 500 years" as if that's what's expressed in the papers. He has no problems with doing that. He's a weasel. What he does is nothing to do with science, everything about it is to do with an audience. Of which you are a classic pew-filler.

You're the one pushing Singer, so check his citations. Don't just tell me you're impressed by the numbers he conjures up. Does the "plus or minus 500 years" come from them, or from Singer?

Singer's problem with the 1500-year cycle that's supposedly reaching a peak is that so much has previously been made of the Medieval Warm Period. For him, that "plus or minus 500 years" could be a godsend, but is far more likely to be an invention.
 
Something as important and world changing as man made climate change should be subjected to the most rigorous and skeptical inquiry. From all sides. Especially if it is used to make policy changes and economic restrictions on the entire population of the planet.

I like the idea of reducing pollution and alternative energy, but that doesn't mean I am going to ignore the science.

I'm sure you'd agree that it sensible for policy to respond to events, even if the precise science behind them is not yet pinned down. The uncertainties of AGW are very much at the fringes, not in the basic science. When a theory-set pans out as well as AGW has over the last fifty years - and most obviously over the last twenty - it's perverse to keep questioning it.

Whatever the ultimate effect, the observed evidence is that it won't be good. It certainly hasn't been so far. Human society was way behind adjusting to globalisation without climate change being thrown into the mix. Check it out. It's already way out of equilibrium.
 
It very well may be that we have caused Global Climate change, and that we are warming up, or keeping warm, the entire climate. What isn't clear, is that this is a global catastrophe. Or will become one. We may have staved off the next Ice Age. We may have actually saved our current civilization from the opposite effect, Global Cooling.

How can we know? And what will happen if we have multiple Volcanic eruptions, which in the past have caused immediate cooling, and vast hardship and starvation, not in decades, but right away.

Assuming we know everything about climate, CO2, weather, ice and such, is dumb. We don't know that much. If somebody wants to question the science and research, so what? It isn't like we are, or even can, do anything about CO2 in a timely manner. Even if we stop burning fossil fuels, right now, everywhere, the current science says we are still in deep trouble.

Right?
 
Have you considered that scientists, in their quest to be correct, would understate the problem? They hate to be wrong, so understating is the safe option.

Something that's very wrong is the idea that scientists are, as a class, self-promoting media-hounds that like to jump out and shout "Boo!" at passers-by.

That may well be the impression that some people get if they only notice scientists when there's a "Boo!" issue in the media. At which point they appear (to the aforementioned proles) no different from any other celebrity or politician.

Those of us who understand science and mix socially with scientists know better. As a class, and on their subject, they're generally very reluctant to go out on a limb that they haven't checked out carefully. That's even how they/we talk :).

Being wrong doesn't screw up a scientist's career. Being wrong for ideological reasons does. Even being right for ideological reasons does them no favours.
 
Of course some scientists cater to public fears ...

Singer certainly caters for a demand. The demand that AGW not be so because it's frightening.



... and cater to the Alarmist cult of True AGW Believers.

By which, presumably, you mean confirm how real and alarming AGW is.


Hansen, for example. They don't believe the IPCC report. Hmmm.....

Many people feel that IPCC reports are understated. It's only to be expected. Science is a very conservative and risk-averse field, and IPCC reports are a risk-averse and politically-influenced interpretation of the science.

The IPCC is your fixation, a graven image that is worshipped or not.

Hansen doesn't speak for the IPCC, or NASA, or me for that matter. He says what is obvious to anybody who isn't desperate to believe that it might not be so.

Al Gore. IPCC. Hansen.

Al Gore. IPCC. Hansen.

Al Gore. IPCC. Hansen.

Al Gore. IPCC. Hansen.

Ommmmmm ...


A group of six U.S. scientists have warned that our planet is in imminent peril due to global warming.

Plaent Earth is in no peril. Shame on them for saying so.

In the article from Rawstory.com they state that global warming may run out of control and become a great danger to humans and creatures.

That's a serious back-pedal from "our planet", don't you think? Even life can survive the loss of creatures.

When they state that global warming may run out of control ... what kind of control is climate under now? And why haven't we been told about it?

The scientists ...

The scientists :confused:?

... say that the recent UN Panel report on climate change from this past February underestimates the scale of sea-level rise this century.

I would wonder why "UN Panel " instead of IPCC if I wasn't well aware how much of a bogey-man the UN is in some circles.

The UN report ...

There it is again. "IPCC" doesn't get across that essential UN sponsorship, and its continuity from Woodrow Wilson (simply coincident with Bolshevism's triumph in Russia? We report, you decide) and FDR.

... said that sea-levels could rise as much as 18-59 cm (7 inches-2 feet) by 2100, while the findings from this group of scientists stated that it could rise by several meters! Several meters is not very specific, but it looks like they are saying that ocean levels would rise at least 4 feet or more by 2100.

Yes, it does look like that. More than a metre, so four feet in Imperial measure. From what we can see by looking about at what's actually going on, that's a conservative prediction.
 
Singer certainly caters for a demand. The demand that AGW not be so because it's frightening.

By which, presumably, you mean confirm how real and alarming AGW is.
Many people feel that IPCC reports are understated. It's only to be expected. Science is a very conservative and risk-averse field, and IPCC reports are a risk-averse and politically-influenced interpretation of the science.

Yes, it does look like that. More than a metre, so four feet in Imperial measure. From what we can see by looking about at what's actually going on, that's a conservative prediction.

Science does not agree with you, and you agree with Hansen. Science agrees with Singer. Hmm... Science does not agree with Hansen... hmm...

The "rise" in sea levels just keeps shrinking...

http://www.worldclimatereport.com/in...down/#more-266

World Climate Reports a new study on sea level rise being lowered, Woppelmann et al 2007.

By using a network of distributed GPS stations, they measured vertical motion of the earth. Two thirds of these stations were less than 15 km from a tide gauge. Factoring measurements of land motion into the estimate of sea-level rise, they determined a global value of 1.31 ±0.30 mm per year compared to the 1.8±0.5 mm per year value given by the IPCC for the recent half century.

Reference:
Wöppelmann, G., B. Martin Miguez, M.-N. Bouin, and Z. Altamimi. 2007. Geocentric sea-level trend estimates from GPS analyses at relevant tide gauges world-wide. Global and Planetary Change, 57, 396–406.
 
Do those other scientists provide evidence of a cycle with uncertain periodicity somewhere between one and two thousand years? I strongly doubt it, and would even if I didn't know that Singer is a weasel

Singer's problem with the 1500-year cycle that's supposedly reaching a peak is that so much has previously been made of the Medieval Warm Period. For him, that "plus or minus 500 years" could be a godsend, but is far more likely to be an invention.

You can easily answer your own question with the references. If after reading Singer something is not clear, why not email him and ask?

Check my reference Tsonis 2007 on synchronized chaos for a general answer to why events in climate don't precisely line up with your calendar. If it is actually "plus or minus 500" that's what a scientist should say it is.

Which leads me right square back to my prior question to you.
Originally Posted by CapelDodger
It was the siren-song of 80% uncertainty that led you so far from shore. As is so often the case.
​
I replied
Siren song...Suppose
2005 ice is 1,000,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.
2006 ice is 900,000 sq. km plus or minus 10%.
How much did ice change?
​
One more time. How much did the ice change?
 
Slight OT:A hypothetical scenario for you: A group of scientists discover that there is a significant threat to humanity. Say, that there's an alien race out there that appears to be plotting to invade Earth. What do you want them to do?

...what? Tell people about it? But wouldn't that be... alarmist?

Could it be that these researchers are saying AGW is real and dangerous because [...drumroll...] it's real and dangerous? Isn't it a bit naïve of you to go 'OK, this is alarming, so I'm going to hide under my Rock of Personal Incredulity (+3) and say they're doing it just to get famous'?

Fair enough that it's wrong of the media to scare people. But the implied statement that this somehow invalidates the AGW theories is pure nonsense.

I Invoke Michael Crichton's essay "Aliens cause global warming".

An Argument from Authority.:)

http://www.michaelcrichton.com/speech-alienscauseglobalwarming.html

In 1960, Drake organizes the first SETI conference, and came up with the now-famous Drake equation:

N=N*fp ne fl fi fc fL

Where N is the number of stars in the Milky Way galaxy; fp is the fraction with planets; ne is the number of planets per star capable of supporting life; fl is the fraction of planets where life evolves; fi is the fraction where intelligent life evolves; and fc is the fraction that communicates; and fL is the fraction of the planet's life during which the communicating civilizations live.

This serious-looking equation gave SETI an serious footing as a legitimate intellectual inquiry. The problem, of course, is that none of the terms can be known, and most cannot even be estimated. The only way to work the equation is to fill in with guesses. And guesses-just so we're clear-are merely expressions of prejudice. Nor can there be "informed guesses." If you need to state how many planets with life choose to communicate, there is simply no way to make an informed guess. It's simply prejudice.

As a result, the Drake equation can have any value from "billions and billions" to zero. An expression that can mean anything means nothing. Speaking precisely, the Drake equation is literally meaningless, and has nothing to do with science. I take the hard view that science involves the creation of testable hypotheses. The Drake equation cannot be tested and therefore SETI is not science. SETI is unquestionably a religion.

Global warming has numerous untestable hypotheses.
Is it science or religion?
 
I Invoke Michael Crichton's essay "Aliens cause global warming".

An Argument from Authority.:)

http://www.michaelcrichton.com/speech-alienscauseglobalwarming.html

In 1960, Drake organizes the first SETI conference, and came up with the now-famous Drake equation:

N=N*fp ne fl fi fc fL

Where N is the number of stars in the Milky Way galaxy; fp is the fraction with planets; ne is the number of planets per star capable of supporting life; fl is the fraction of planets where life evolves; fi is the fraction where intelligent life evolves; and fc is the fraction that communicates; and fL is the fraction of the planet's life during which the communicating civilizations live.

This serious-looking equation gave SETI an serious footing as a legitimate intellectual inquiry. The problem, of course, is that none of the terms can be known, and most cannot even be estimated. The only way to work the equation is to fill in with guesses. And guesses-just so we're clear-are merely expressions of prejudice. Nor can there be "informed guesses." If you need to state how many planets with life choose to communicate, there is simply no way to make an informed guess. It's simply prejudice.

As a result, the Drake equation can have any value from "billions and billions" to zero. An expression that can mean anything means nothing. Speaking precisely, the Drake equation is literally meaningless, and has nothing to do with science. I take the hard view that science involves the creation of testable hypotheses. The Drake equation cannot be tested and therefore SETI is not science. SETI is unquestionably a religion.

Global warming has numerous untestable hypotheses.
Is it science or religion?

Chrichton is a novelist who has not actually referred to any of the IPCC reports, just taken some ideas he has heard and said that what he heard disproves global warming. It's his usual pattern, as typified in "state of fear", make a nice strawman, beat it up, then turn around and bow to the applause.
 
No longer are models judged by how well they reproduce data from the real world-increasingly, models provide the data. As if they were themselves a reality. And indeed they are, when we are projecting forward. There can be no observational data about the year 2100. There are only model runs.



The models are continually validated against real data, and updated. It is a non stop task. We can't validate against 2100 data? What is the alternative, Mr Chrichton?

My guess is that Feynman, who is deeply involved in computer modelling, http://www.longnow.org/views/essays/articles/ArtFeynman.php, would regard Chrichton as an idiot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom