Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Okay, let's go through the criteria:

(1)" . . .accurately re-directed missing person police investigations . . " Did the individual in Switzerland do that? The article doesn't say.

Rodney. He/she found the body. It's hard to get more re-directed than that. It's the very definition of "re-directed".

(2)" . . . with, as far as can be determined, no inside (non-paranormal) information that was not available to the police . . . " Did the individual in Switzerland have no inside information? The article doesn't say.

Since having inside information would be noteworthy (i.e. they were considered a suspect, they were a witness, they were a family member, etc.), the lack of any mention of this suggests they did not.

(3)" . . . police officers . . . stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing persons would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of the psychic [or non-psychic]. . ." Did the Swiss police say that they doubted that the girl's body would have been found when it was found? I'll grant you that seems to be the implication, but the article doesn't say that. Further, we don't even know who the person is who found the body. For all we know, it was an avowed psychic!

But if it was an avowed psychic, that tidbit would likely be included in the article: it's noteworthy. Again, the lack of any mention suggests they weren't.

Again, that's what the police seem to believe, but that's not the issue here. You, Linda, and Garrette seem to think that what Pratt and Martin did was nothing special. If you're right, you should be able to find at least one example where a non-psychic assisted the police in the way that Pratt and Martin did.

As I said before, it is of no use whatsoever, in deciding this issue, for us to give you evidence. You are the one claiming an exception, so it's really up to you to provide the evidence. And even if it's not obvious to you already that people can do these things through normal means, that you don't know whether or not they can means that you cannot know whether or not Pratt and Martin are exceptions. Unless normal people have actually been tested and failed, you have no support for your claim. So in this case, your hope that there is no evidence for us to present to you, actually works against you. If your hope is right, then your assertion is wrong. The only kind of evidence that is needed in this case is evidence that normal people try to help the police but don't succeed. Now we've gone one step further and actually given you examples where normal people try to help the police and do succeed, but we didn't have to do that, since you didn't actually present any evidence to support your claim in the first place.

The other reason that it's of no use is that no matter how good the evidence, you will be unreasonable rather than concede anything.

Linda
 
<snip>

The other reason that it's of no use is that no matter how good the evidence, you will be unreasonable rather than concede anything.

Linda

Perhaps there should be an award, like The Language Award, for people who have actually conceded their assertion after being presented with good evidence or logic that refutes it or makes it so unlikely to be true as to be absurd?
 
By the way, here are five more:

http://www.knoxstudio.com/shns/story.cfm?pk=MISSING-CASES-10-04-05&cat=AN

And here's another:

http://www.courttv.com/news/hiddentraces/boyinthebox/tent_girl.html

And here's a whole site where amateurs help to solve crimes:

http://www.doenetwork.org/

Here's one example from that site:

http://www.doenetwork.org/media/news76.html:



Of course, I'm sure none of these will be acceptable either.

-Bri
Bri, now really. All of these examples are "John Does"; i.e., cases where bodies had been found, but the police could not identify the remains. They are not cases where the police were looking for a particular person, but could not find the body.
 
Rodney. He/she found the body. It's hard to get more re-directed than that. It's the very definition of "re-directed".

Since having inside information would be noteworthy (i.e. they were considered a suspect, they were a witness, they were a family member, etc.), the lack of any mention of this suggests they did not.

But if it was an avowed psychic, that tidbit would likely be included in the article: it's noteworthy. Again, the lack of any mention suggests they weren't.
You're just speculating, Linda. The article is too brief to decide any of these issues.

The other reason that it's of no use is that no matter how good the evidence, you will be unreasonable rather than concede anything.
How do you know that? Give me a link that proves that a non-psychic has done what Pratt and Martin have done and I'll concede the point.
 
Rodney,

Linda is speculating that the person found the body? It's written in the article -- it's not speculation.

What sort of inside information are you talking about here? I thought that was just to disallow the case when the person who found the body actually committed the crime or something. The article certainly doesn't say that the person who found the body committed the crime, and it certainly would have! If you require that the article specifically say "the person who found the body had no inside information" then we certainly don't know that about Pratt, do we? None of the articles about Pratt said that he had no inside information.

And are you suggesting that we have to prove that the person didn't use psychic abilities to solve the crime? As in, the police have to say "We would never have found the body without his help and he didn't use any psychic abilities whatsoever!"

That's why this shifting of the burden of proof never works. Rodney, how about you provide some evidence that Pratt fits your own criteria and used psychic abilities to do whatever it is that you think he did?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
You're just speculating, Linda. The article is too brief to decide any of these issues.

I agree. I'm just saying that exceptions tend to be noteworthy. When there are no exceptions mentioned, it would be unreasonable to assume that those exceptions are present.

How do you know that?

This is based on our numerous conversations where I have given you, in exact detail, the information that you have requested and you either move the goalposts, or, when you can no longer move because all avenues of escape have been cut off, you drop the conversation until you can pick it up later and pretend that nothing happened.

Give me a link that proves that a non-psychic has done what Pratt and Martin have done and I'll concede the point.

You have not yet specified how Pratt is different from what others have done in a way that is not normal. That is, this continues to be an example of you withholding consent against all reason. Give me a reason to think otherwise - concede the point or come up with a valid difference. All you have come up with so far are differences that are normal or are false.

I don't care whether you concede anything on Martin, since you have provided nothing that can possibly serve as evidence in the first place. As I mentioned earlier, the only thing that can serve as evidence that what she does is not normal is to provide research or articles that show normal people trying to do the same thing and failing, without exception. It is not up to us to falsify your premise for you. Premises are not "true until proven false", they are provisionally true if reasonably complete and thorough efforts to prove them false have failed. You have provided no good reason to consider your premises true in the first place. That you continually provide only evidence of what she can do (rather than of what others can't do), and then ask us to falsify your premise for you, means that you have entirely missed the point of concepts like proof and reason.

Linda
 
You're just speculating, Linda. The article is too brief to decide any of these issues.


How do you know that? Give me a link that proves that a non-psychic has done what Pratt and Martin have done and I'll concede the point.

Rodney, Have you read Joe Nickell's book Psychic Sleuths?

Are you aware that the FBI claim that no psychic has ever added anything usefull to any of their investigations?

Missing persons, and police cases are solved everyday by non psyhic people... police, and FBI agents.

Just because once out of thousands of tries a claimed psychic happens to get a guess right, does not offer conclusive proof for psychic ability, as there are just so many factors and other explanations.

If Norm were to repeatedly and conclusively solve cases one after the other, this would defineatly offer some pretty good proof. But until this happens, there is no good reason to chalk this up to anything other than chance, or retrofitting by the police officer who wants to beleive and validate the fact he got a "psychic" involved.
 
Rodney, Have you read Joe Nickell's book Psychic Sleuths?
No, but I found his critique of Lincoln's dreams wanting. See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1473574&postcount=5

Are you aware that the FBI claim that no psychic has ever added anything usefull to any of their investigations?
Depends on who you believe. According to -- http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/sept11/features/5615/ -- "The FBI does not use psychics as official sources, the lawyer says; it happens 'under the table.'"

Missing persons, and police cases are solved everyday by non psyhic people... police, and FBI agents.
Some are and some aren't.

Just because once out of thousands of tries a claimed psychic happens to get a guess right, does not offer conclusive proof for psychic ability, as there are just so many factors and other explanations.

If Norm were to repeatedly and conclusively solve cases one after the other, this would defineatly offer some pretty good proof. But until this happens, there is no good reason to chalk this up to anything other than chance, or retrofitting by the police officer who wants to beleive and validate the fact he got a "psychic" involved.
Perhaps, but your argument would be more persuasive if you could come up with an example of a non-psychic doing the same thing as Pratt did on at least one occasion.
 
No, but I found his critique of Lincoln's dreams wanting. See http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1473574&postcount=5


Depends on who you believe. According to -- http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/sept11/features/5615/ -- "The FBI does not use psychics as official sources, the lawyer says; it happens 'under the table.'"


Some are and some aren't.


Perhaps, but your argument would be more persuasive if you could come up with an example of a non-psychic doing the same thing as Pratt did on at least one occasion.


Oh come on... you think some lawyer saying "It happens under the table" is a credible source? - there is absolutely no evidence. And even if some FBI agent did consult with a psychic out of his own descision, there is no evidence to show that a psychic has ever solved a crime for the FBI, and given that they deny any psychic has helped... i think the conclusion to draw if fairly obvious.

Your request for a normal person to have done what a claimed psychic has done is unreasonable. Here is why...

Normal people that dont claim to be psychic would have NO reason whatsoever to approach police and claim to know details of a case they couldnt know.
People who think they are psychic DO approach police and offer guesses... sometimes they are right, and the majority of times they are completely wrong.
Im sure if i was to poke my nose in on some police cases i would end up making some guesses that were eventually correct... as would you.
If Norm pratt is truly psychic, why doesnt he prove it under test conditions, and change the world forever... Why? Because he cant. He is just a person who thinks he is psychic, who made a lucky guess.

Here is a very brief article for you, since you have not read Joe Nickell's book.
http://www.csicop.org/specialarticles/police-psychics.html
 
Last edited:
Oh come on... you think some lawyer saying "It happens under the table" is a credible source? - there is absolutely no evidence. And even if some FBI agent did consult with a psychic out of his own descision, there is no evidence to show that a psychic has ever solved a crime for the FBI, and given that they deny any psychic has helped... i think the conclusion to draw if fairly obvious.
You posted: "Are you aware that the FBI claim that no psychic has ever added anything usefull to any of their investigations?" When did the FBI make that claim?

Your request for a normal person to have done what a claimed psychic has done is unreasonable. Here is why...

Normal people that dont claim to be psychic would have NO reason whatsoever to approach police and claim to know details of a case they couldnt know.
People who think they are psychic DO approach police and offer guesses... sometimes they are right, and the majority of times they are completely wrong.
Im sure if i was to poke my nose in on some police cases i would end up making some guesses that were eventually correct... as would you.
"Normal" people are contacting the police all the time with tips, hypotheses, and speculation. I'm just looking for evidence that at least one of them accomplished the same feat as Pratt and Martin.

If Norm pratt is truly psychic, why doesnt he prove it under test conditions, and change the world forever... Why? Because he cant. He is just a person who thinks he is psychic, who made a lucky guess.
See post #179 on this thread.
 
You posted: "Are you aware that the FBI claim that no psychic has ever added anything usefull to any of their investigations?" When did the FBI make that claim?

From Wikipedia (you can go to the article for the sources):
No psychic detective has ever been praised or given official recognition by the F.B.I. or US national news for solving a crime, preventing a crime, or finding a kidnap victim or corpse.[8][9]

The Australian Institute of Criminology, Australia's official crime research agency, advises parents of missing children not resort to psychics who approach them.[10] Former FBI analyst and profiler Clint Van Zandt has criticized the notion of psychic detectives and has stated that "What happens many times is that professed psychics allow themselves the benefit of 20/20 hindsight. After the case is solved, they make their previously vague predictions somehow fit the crime and the criminal." [11]​

"Normal" people are contacting the police all the time with tips, hypotheses, and speculation. I'm just looking for evidence that at least one of them accomplished the same feat as Pratt and Martin.

Tips, yes. Speculations no. Are you saying that you'll accept evidence of a tip that led police to find a missing person? Didn't think so.

-Bri
 
You posted: "Are you aware that the FBI claim that no psychic has ever added anything usefull to any of their investigations?" When did the FBI make that claim?


"Normal" people are contacting the police all the time with tips, hypotheses, and speculation. I'm just looking for evidence that at least one of them accomplished the same feat as Pratt and Martin.


See post #179 on this thread.

Well given that they officially state "we do not concuslt with psychics" it is pretty clear that a psychic has not solved an FBI case.
Read psychic sleuths if you want proper quotes and references.

Have you never watched a television crime show where they ask the public to call a hotline if they have information.. every episode they tell of people they have caught through tips from witnesses.

Answer me this;

1.) Why do you not accept the possiblity this was just a lucky guess?
2.) Why does Norm not constantly solve cases?
3.) Why are you focussing on one correct guess, when it is well documented that the majority of the time psychics are wrong. (again, read Joe Nickell's book if you want documented cases)

You refer to the ganzfeld experiments as if they are a credible source, these experiments have received a huge amount of criticism and can in no way be considered conclusive. So they are irrelevant to this discussion, that is another discussion in itself.

consider this analogy;
Someone claims to be the best three point shooter in basketball history.
They then demonstrate this by shooting 100 shots.
They miss 99, and get 1.
It would not be resonable to say "Look! they got one shot in! They must be the best in history!"
Yet it seems this is what you are doing with this case.
Yes yes i know it is a poor anology, but im sure you know what i mean :)
 
Last edited:
"Normal" people are contacting the police all the time with tips, hypotheses, and speculation. I'm just looking for evidence that at least one of them accomplished the same feat as Pratt and Martin.

Every cop that solved a cold case is an example. Every private detective that was hired to solve a case and was successful is an example. Every self-proclaimed investigator that has contributed to the solving of a case is an example. Norm Pratt and Annette Martin are an example of people using normal means to help solve a case. To say otherwise, you must present evidence that excludes the possibility that these cases could be solved through normal means. You must present evidence that individuals carrying on a search long after others have given up never find clues. You must present evidence that people given case reports to review never make novel connections. You must present evidence that tips, hypotheses, and speculation from normal people have never been right. You are the one claiming the exception.

Linda
 
Well given that they officially state "we do not concuslt with psychics" it is pretty clear that a psychic has not solved an FBI case.
Read psychic sleuths if you want proper quotes and references.
Where did you obtain your quote? According to -- http://noreenrenier.com/testimonials.htm -- "the Bureau has used Renier strictly in an academic setting, to expand the thinking of police officers. We have, however, given her name to law enforcement people who want to try a psychic. And some of them have said she's solved cases."
— F.B.I. Special Agent Robert Ressler, New York Post, June 4, 1988

FBI Agent Ressler is also quoted as saying: "She helped to locate a plane containing the body of a relative of an FBI agent."

Have you never watched a television crime show where they ask the public to call a hotline if they have information.. every episode they tell of people they have caught through tips from witnesses.

Answer me this;

1.) Why do you not accept the possiblity this was just a lucky guess?
2.) Why does Norm not constantly solve cases?
3.) Why are you focussing on one correct guess, when it is well documented that the majority of the time psychics are wrong. (again, read Joe Nickell's book if you want documented cases)

You refer to the ganzfeld experiments as if they are a credible source, these experiments have received a huge amount of criticism and can in no way be considered conclusive. So they are irrelevant to this discussion, that is another discussion in itself.
No, the point is that psychics may be wrong the majority of the time -- just as participants in ganzfeld experiments may be wrong the majority of time -- but their performance still exceeds what would be expected if they were just guessing.

consider this analogy;
Someone claims to be the best three point shooter in basketball history.
They then demonstrate this by shooting 100 shots.
They miss 99, and get 1.
It would not be resonable to say "Look! they got one shot in! They must be the best in history!"
Yet it seems this is what you are doing with this case.
Yes yes i know it is a poor anology, but im sure you know what i mean :)
There are many cases where the police say that psychics have assisted them in solving cases. Sure, Pratt may have gotten lucky, but I doubt if all of these cases were just a matter of luck.
 
Where did you obtain your quote? According to -- http://noreenrenier.com/testimonials.htm -- "the Bureau has used Renier strictly in an academic setting, to expand the thinking of police officers. We have, however, given her name to law enforcement people who want to try a psychic. And some of them have said she's solved cases."
— F.B.I. Special Agent Robert Ressler, New York Post, June 4, 1988
Ressler still promotes Renier, though he embellishes her accomplishments quite a bit.

See this site.


FBI Agent Ressler is also quoted as saying: "She helped to locate a plane containing the body of a relative of an FBI agent."
And Ressler is wrong.

See this site.


No, the point is that psychics may be wrong the majority of the time -- just as participants in ganzfeld experiments may be wrong the majority of time -- but their performance still exceeds what would be expected if they were just guessing.
No, they do not. The ganzfeld experiments with tight controls do not unless a selective and erroneous metanalysis is performed. You are well aware of Ersby's work on this.

And please show me your statistics on "guessing" regarding solving criminal cases. How many psychic guesses are there? How many are accurate?

You're pulling things out of the air now.


There are many cases where the police say that psychics have assisted them in solving cases.
Many? I doubt it. Doesn't matter, though, since you've chosen the best. Not our fault they're collapsing.


Sure, Pratt may have gotten lucky, but I doubt if all of these cases were just a matter of luck.
Ah. So now it's a matter of "I-must-be-right-because-heck-I-really-don't-know-the-actual-numbers-and-I-haven't-done-any-real-study-but-it's-a-lot-of-claims-even-if-there-is-no-evidence-to-back-up-the-claims"?

I actually kind of like you, Rodney, but you are really embarassing yourself here.
 
Where did you obtain your quote? According to -- http://noreenrenier.com/testimonials.htm -- "the Bureau has used Renier strictly in an academic setting, to expand the thinking of police officers. We have, however, given her name to law enforcement people who want to try a psychic. And some of them have said she's solved cases."
— F.B.I. Special Agent Robert Ressler, New York Post, June 4, 1988

FBI Agent Ressler is also quoted as saying: "She helped to locate a plane containing the body of a relative of an FBI agent."

And for an opposing viewpoint: http://www.amindformurder.com/


-Bri
 
No, the point is that psychics may be wrong the majority of the time -- just as participants in ganzfeld experiments may be wrong the majority of time -- but their performance still exceeds what would be expected if they were just guessing.

And what evidence do you have for this?

I am aware of a controlled experiment done which showed psychics to be LESS accurate than a group of univeristy students. (again in in Joe Nickell's excellent book, which you should read if you are really interested in getting both sides of the story, and not just trying to confirm your desire for this to be true)

The simple facts are:
-There is no way to prove Norm did not just make a lucky guess.
-If Norm were truly psychic, he could test it under controlled conditions, and change the world foverever for the better... He has not done so.

Until Norm either, consistently solves cases at a better than chance level, or demonstrates he has psychic ability in a evident and repeatable way, there is no reason to chalk this up to anything other than chance.
 
Until Norm either, consistently solves cases at a better than chance level, or demonstrates he has psychic ability in a evident and repeatable way, there is no reason to chalk this up to anything other than chance.
Yes, except it's too soon even for that. There isn't anything yet to chalk up. The only thing we can discern Pratt did was to tell the police to stop looking where they were looking. He didn't tell them where to find the body.
 
Psychics failed miserably in Atlanta GA when the little black kids went missing and later were found murdered in the early 80's. The psychics descriptions didn't fit the murderer Wayne Williams a bit. The descriptions were of dark possibly hispanic men. Williams is African American.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom