Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

I hadn't known about the Nancy Uzdavinis bit. On the assumption that you are correct that Renier wrote the NU letters, then my opinion of psychics has dropped even further, though I hadn't thought that possible.

I wish I had been more into my skeptical ways in the late 80s and early 90s. I lived in Leominster, Massachusetts, only a short distance east of Gardner (where the plane crash was) and could have done some checking firsthand.

Keep up the good fight, John.
 
I hadn't known about the Nancy Uzdavinis bit. On the assumption that you are correct that Renier wrote the NU letters, then my opinion of psychics has dropped even further, though I hadn't thought that possible.
According to -- http://members.aol.com/garypos/Renier_chap_pt3.html --

"Though he had been unable to do so prior to the judge's verdict, Merrell later obtained the services of a forensic handwriting expert, Dorothy Lehman of Portland. After examining the 'Uzdavinis' letters, as well as other relevant documents, Lehman 'arrived at a firm conclusion. It is my opinion that the two questioned letters purportedly written by Nancy Uzdavinis . . . were actually executed by Noreen Renier.' Merrell had by then also discovered that there really is a 'Nancy Uzdavinis' - Renier's sister-in-law, who lives in Ashland.

"Armed with these startling new allegations, Merrell's attorney filed another motion for dismissal of the $25,000 debt, arguing that the original Oregon judgement 'was based in part on fraud, misrepresentation and other misconduct of Noreen Renier. . . . Renier used a false name and tricked the Defendant into investigating her claims of psychic ability. . . . Assuming that the handwriting expert is correct, Ms. Renier has perjured herself.' In response, Renier filed a sworn affidavit with the court attesting that, 'Because I had...become aware that...Merrell and certain of his associates were making. . . . inquiries and representations concerning me...to impair and undermine my pursuit of my profession . . . I requested my sister- in-law, Nancy Uzdavinis, to make an inquiry to determine the nature and content of the representations....[She] told me that since I knew precisely what I wished to find out, I could make the inquiry myself in her name. . . . I have never denied or concealed this inquiry. . . . I did not 'trick' or 'entrap' the Defendant . . . '

"Regarding Merrell's letter to Uzdavinis, Renier's affidavit states, 'I have never seen or received the purported . . . letter. . . . Nor has my sister-in-law ever seen or received the letter. . . . Nor has the purported letter even been produced in the extensive discovery and document production activity engaged in during the course of this litigation . . . " During a later deposition, Renier went further: 'John Merrell wrote a bogus letter and backdated it, pretending he was writing to Nancy Uzdavinis. It was filled with fraudulent statements and quotes.' The real Uzdavinis also filed an affidavit in which she attests that although Merrell's letter was correctly addressed, 'I have never received that letter or any other letter from Mr. Merrell. In the letter I have been shown...I purportedly made a phone call to Mr. Merrell on the Monday preceeding the date of the letter. I never made any such telephone call and have no knowledge whatsoever regarding any such phone call. . . . [M]y sister-in-law, Noreen Renier, at about that time had sent to Mr. Merrell a letter under my name. She did so with my knowledge and consent. . . . I have no knowledge of [her] ever having made any phone calls to Mr. Merrell using my name.'"

So, the bottom line here is that the judge knew that Renier signed letters to Merrell with Uzdavinis' name. However, since Renier had Uzdavinis' permission to do so, the judge didn't think that was a big deal and denied Merrell's motion for dismissal of the $25,000 libel judgement against him.
 
According to -- http://members.aol.com/garypos/Renier_chap_pt3.html --

"Though he had been unable to do so prior to the judge's verdict, Merrell later obtained the services of a forensic handwriting expert, Dorothy Lehman of Portland. After examining the 'Uzdavinis' letters, as well as other relevant documents, Lehman 'arrived at a firm conclusion. It is my opinion that the two questioned letters purportedly written by Nancy Uzdavinis . . . were actually executed by Noreen Renier.' Merrell had by then also discovered that there really is a 'Nancy Uzdavinis' - Renier's sister-in-law, who lives in Ashland.

"Armed with these startling new allegations, Merrell's attorney filed another motion for dismissal of the $25,000 debt, arguing that the original Oregon judgement 'was based in part on fraud, misrepresentation and other misconduct of Noreen Renier. . . . Renier used a false name and tricked the Defendant into investigating her claims of psychic ability. . . . Assuming that the handwriting expert is correct, Ms. Renier has perjured herself.' In response, Renier filed a sworn affidavit with the court attesting that, 'Because I had...become aware that...Merrell and certain of his associates were making. . . . inquiries and representations concerning me...to impair and undermine my pursuit of my profession . . . I requested my sister- in-law, Nancy Uzdavinis, to make an inquiry to determine the nature and content of the representations....[She] told me that since I knew precisely what I wished to find out, I could make the inquiry myself in her name. . . . I have never denied or concealed this inquiry. . . . I did not 'trick' or 'entrap' the Defendant . . . '

"Regarding Merrell's letter to Uzdavinis, Renier's affidavit states, 'I have never seen or received the purported . . . letter. . . . Nor has my sister-in-law ever seen or received the letter. . . . Nor has the purported letter even been produced in the extensive discovery and document production activity engaged in during the course of this litigation . . . " During a later deposition, Renier went further: 'John Merrell wrote a bogus letter and backdated it, pretending he was writing to Nancy Uzdavinis. It was filled with fraudulent statements and quotes.' The real Uzdavinis also filed an affidavit in which she attests that although Merrell's letter was correctly addressed, 'I have never received that letter or any other letter from Mr. Merrell. In the letter I have been shown...I purportedly made a phone call to Mr. Merrell on the Monday preceeding the date of the letter. I never made any such telephone call and have no knowledge whatsoever regarding any such phone call. . . . [M]y sister-in-law, Noreen Renier, at about that time had sent to Mr. Merrell a letter under my name. She did so with my knowledge and consent. . . . I have no knowledge of [her] ever having made any phone calls to Mr. Merrell using my name.'"

1. Uzdavinis gives permission for Renier to "make an inquiry in [Uzdavini's] name." This is entirely different from giving permission to send a letter as if Renier were actually Uzdavinis. I have made inquiries in other people's names numerous times. I always make it clear, i.e., "Dear Mr. X, I am Mr. Y. I am writing on behalf of Mr. Z to ask you if..."

2. This fact did not come out in discovery. It came out when evidence was gathered by Merrell to the effect. Renier admitted it when she was forced to admit it.

3. Renier accused Merrell of fraud in regard to his own letter, yet Renier provided no evidence in that regard.

If you will read the portions of the link you have conveniently left out, you will discover that Renier's admission of writing those letters amounted to an admission of perjury because she testified she knew nothing about Merrell's prior investigation.

Yup. I can see the difference and the type of characters involved.


So, the bottom line here is that the judge knew that Renier signed letters to Merrell with Uzdavinis' name.
He was informed of it when the evidence forced Renier to admit it.


However, since Renier had Uzdavinis' permission to do so,
. Not according to your citation. Renier had Uzdavinis' permission to make an inquiry in Uzdavinis' name. Big difference.


the judge didn't think that was a big deal and denied Merrell's motion for dismissal of the $25,000 libel judgement against him.
Yes he did. Which gets back to my point: The original lawsuit was about libel, not about Renier's psychic ability. But it's interesting that you leave out this relevant portion from your link:

from Rodney's link said:
Merrell's motion for dismissal of the $25,000 libel judgement was denied, but in a curiously ambiguous manner. Although the motion had requested relief due to alleged misconduct tainting the original Oregon trial, the Federal bankruptcy judge's ruling, without elaboration, states that "Upon consideration of the defendant's Motion and accompanying exhibits . . . the court concludes that its Judgement [i.e. the bankruptcy judgement] was not based in any part on perjury, fraud, misrepresentation or any other misconduct" by Renier (emphasis added). (39) The integrity of the original libel trial was thus not commented upon.

You could definitively demonstrate that Merrell perjured himself repeatedly if you like. It will not add one iota of evidence to you claim about Renier's psychic ability.
 
Which gets back to my point: The original lawsuit was about libel, not about Renier's psychic ability.
Garrette, please. If Merrell's attorney had convinced the jury that Renier had no psychic ability, Merrell would have prevailed.
 
Rodney, please. Once again you shift the burden of proof. A civil case regarding libel in which an empaneled jury need only perceive a preponderance of evidence regarding the law, has no bearing on the fact that Renier has not demonstrated she has psychic abilities.

Nor does it obviate the fact that, regardless of the civil suit result, Merrell showed the holes in Renier's claims. Actually, the Wilbers (I think it's the Wilbers; I'm going from memory) showed the holes in Renier's claims. The Wilbers found the plane. Without psychic help.
 
Rodney, please. Once again you shift the burden of proof. A civil case regarding libel in which an empaneled jury need only perceive a preponderance of evidence regarding the law, has no bearing on the fact that Renier has not demonstrated she has psychic abilities.
According to no less an authority than John Merrell, in post #359 on this thread:

"The testimony by Renier and Jessica Herbert convinced them --- two of the female jury members to tears --- that Renier had located a lost plane crash and had seen psychic visions that Jessica's brother aboard the plane had carried a young injured woman out of the plane and left the scene in search of help across snow and ice before he collapsed and died. Though the case should never have hinged on proving that she didn't really locate the crashed airplane --- in reality it did, and Renier and Jessica Herbert provided the testimony that (again in my opinion) offered me as a man unwilling to accept the fantastic ability of Renier able to see this heroic scene and provide it to the sister of the dead hero."

So, while you and Merrell don't think that Renier has psychic ability, the jury found otherwise.

Nor does it obviate the fact that, regardless of the civil suit result, Merrell showed the holes in Renier's claims. Actually, the Wilbers (I think it's the Wilbers; I'm going from memory) showed the holes in Renier's claims. The Wilbers found the plane. Without psychic help.
Renier never said she personally found the plane, but Jessica Herbert stated in her deposition that Renier pinpointed the location where it was found.
 
According to no less an authority than John Merrell, in post #359 on this thread:

"The testimony by Renier and Jessica Herbert convinced them --- two of the female jury members to tears --- that Renier had located a lost plane crash and had seen psychic visions that Jessica's brother aboard the plane had carried a young injured woman out of the plane and left the scene in search of help across snow and ice before he collapsed and died.
Yup. They went off the (legal) reservation and cast their vote based on emotion and not the law.


Though the case should never have hinged on proving that she didn't really locate the crashed airplane --- in reality it did, and Renier and Jessica Herbert provided the testimony that (again in my opinion) offered me as a man unwilling to accept the fantastic ability of Renier able to see this heroic scene and provide it to the sister of the dead hero."
Just as John Edward convinces his crying audience members of his ability even though he's an obnoxious lying fraud.


So, while you and Merrell don't think that Renier has psychic ability, the jury found otherwise.
Let's assume for the moment that you are correct. So what? I do not rely upon juries to determine the efficacy of proposed pharmacological treatments nor to determine the whether or not homeopathy produces an effect beyond placebo. I will certainly not rely upon a jury to determine--in a trial specifically about libel--that a psychic is actually psychic.

But, hey, if you want to use a jury verdict to jump to conclusions, let's go back to the later jury award that Ressler won and Renier lost. Surely Renier wouldn't have lost if she were truly psychic?


Renier never said she personally found the plane, but Jessica Herbert stated in her deposition that Renier pinpointed the location where it was found.
Yes, she did. As an investigator/interviewer earlier in my life, I have taken depositions from people who pinpointed a tall black man when the security video distinctly showed a white man of average height.

Herbert believed Renier because she had to; she was desperate. But the facts do not match the claim.

Renier said Herbert's brother carried another survivor out of the plane before dying. The investigation revealed everyone died on impact.

Renier claims to have provided latitude and longitude but never provided evidence that she actually did, not even in the trial.

Renier claimed she saw the plane and gave the latitude in longitude but also said it was in either Massachusetts or New Hampshire.

Renier gave the letters DHA. The D and the H do not apply to the crash in question at all. The A might only by a stretch.

The searchers who actually found the plane (the Wilbers) did so simply by going out and looking, along with hundreds of other volunteers. Neither the Wilbers nor anyone else involved in actually finding the plane used any of Renier's information.

Renier didn't find the plane.

The jury finding don't demonstrate that she did.
 
Garrette, please. If Merrell's attorney had convinced the jury that Renier had no psychic ability, Merrell would have prevailed.

It sounds more like Merrell was unprepared for the level of deceit and manipulation that could be expected in a case like this.

Linda
 
It sounds more like Merrell was unprepared for the level of deceit and manipulation that could be expected in a case like this.

Linda
You and Garrette might try reading the links on Merrell's own website. For example:

"Following a three-day trial in Oregon, the jury awarded Renier $25,000 in general damages (9% of the $275,000 requested by her). Merrell's subsequent appeal was unsuccessful.

"In a further effort to nullify the award to Renier, Merrell, after first guaranteeing payment to all of his other creditors, elected to declare bankruptcy. The law specifies that a debt may not be discharged through bankruptcy if it resulted from an act of 'malice,' i.e. an injurious charge that not only is false, but is knowingly (rather than inadvertently) so. Renier contended that ten allegations within Merrell's letter were indeed malicious. Following three days of testimony, the Federal bankruptcy court judge agreed that four of the ten fulfilled the criteria for 'malice' (one would have sufficed), and the $25,000 debt was reaffirmed. As one cited example, regarding Merrell's claim of 'current ongoing investigations by representatives of the National Council Against Health Fraud,' the judge ruled that Merrell, though himself an NCAHF member, 'knew there was no such investigation [by NCAHF as an organization] at the time he made this statement.'"

See http://members.aol.com/garypos/Renier_chap_pt3.html
 
Just curious...what does any of this have to do with whether or not Renier has any psychic powers? For some reason, Renier -- like every other psychic in history -- apparently failed to document her predictions beforehand. Imagine that.

-Bri
 
You and Garrette might try reading the links on Merrell's own website. For example:

"Following a three-day trial in Oregon, the jury awarded Renier $25,000 in general damages (9% of the $275,000 requested by her). Merrell's subsequent appeal was unsuccessful.

"In a further effort to nullify the award to Renier, Merrell, after first guaranteeing payment to all of his other creditors, elected to declare bankruptcy. The law specifies that a debt may not be discharged through bankruptcy if it resulted from an act of 'malice,' i.e. an injurious charge that not only is false, but is knowingly (rather than inadvertently) so. Renier contended that ten allegations within Merrell's letter were indeed malicious. Following three days of testimony, the Federal bankruptcy court judge agreed that four of the ten fulfilled the criteria for 'malice' (one would have sufficed), and the $25,000 debt was reaffirmed. As one cited example, regarding Merrell's claim of 'current ongoing investigations by representatives of the National Council Against Health Fraud,' the judge ruled that Merrell, though himself an NCAHF member, 'knew there was no such investigation [by NCAHF as an organization] at the time he made this statement.'"

See http://members.aol.com/garypos/Renier_chap_pt3.html

Huh? It's already been established that she won a libel suit. This is all irrelevant.

Linda
 
Huh? It's already been established that she won a libel suit. This is all irrelevant.

Linda
She won the suit, as Merrell has acknowledged, because the jury concluded she is psychic. And your notion that Merrell was the guileless victim in that case is contradicted by the evidence.
 
She won the suit, as Merrell has acknowledged, because the jury concluded she is psychic.

So what. It's not like a bunch ordinary people who couldn't get out of jury duty are even remotely capable of figuring this stuff out.

And your notion that Merrell was the guileless victim in that case is contradicted by the evidence.

Huh? Where did I say that, and what evidence are you talking about that shows otherwise? That he exaggerated the NCAHF involvement?

I don't care what he did. He could have called her all the names that'll get you censored on the JREF and it still doesn't change that the details of her amazing story demonstrating her psychic abilities are wrong or unsupported by any evidence.

Linda
 
So what. It's not like a bunch ordinary people who couldn't get out of jury duty are even remotely capable of figuring this stuff out.
Do you have evidence to support this stereotype?

Huh? Where did I say that, and what evidence are you talking about that shows otherwise? That he exaggerated the NCAHF involvement?
You didn't say that per se, but you asserted that "Merrell was unprepared for the level of deceit and manipulation", as if he were the unwitting victim of an unethical psychic. But, according to Renier, he was the one who started the whole case by calling her late at night and then making unfounded accusations against her in a letter. Then, when he lost the case, he tried to avoid paying her by filing for bankruptcy. So perhaps Renier is just imitating his behavior. :)

I don't care what he did. He could have called her all the names that'll get you censored on the JREF and it still doesn't change that the details of her amazing story demonstrating her psychic abilities are wrong or unsupported by any evidence.

Linda
Except that he and his lawyer had the opportunity to convince a jury of the rightness of his charges, and the jury didn't buy into it.
 
Do you have evidence to support this stereotype?


You didn't say that per se, but you asserted that "Merrell was unprepared for the level of deceit and manipulation", as if he were the unwitting victim of an unethical psychic. But, according to Renier, he was the one who started the whole case by calling her late at night and then making unfounded accusations against her in a letter. Then, when he lost the case, he tried to avoid paying her by filing for bankruptcy. So perhaps Renier is just imitating his behavior. :)


Except that he and his lawyer had the opportunity to convince a jury of the rightness of his charges, and the jury didn't buy into it.

O.J Simpson.
 
Do you have evidence to support this stereotype?

What stereotype are you talking about? That people without expertise in a subject that requires expertise come to conclusions that are wrong? Spend five minutes in the Conspiracy Theory forum if you want evidence.

You didn't say that per se, but you asserted that "Merrell was unprepared for the level of deceit and manipulation", as if he were the unwitting victim of an unethical psychic. But, according to Renier, he was the one who started the whole case by calling her late at night and then making unfounded accusations against her in a letter. Then, when he lost the case, he tried to avoid paying her by filing for bankruptcy. So perhaps Renier is just imitating his behavior. :)

All that is irrelevant to the issue.

Except that he and his lawyer had the opportunity to convince a jury of the rightness of his charges, and the jury didn't buy into it.

As he said, "I never knew what hit me." The jury was not presented with the relevant information they would need to make any sort of reasonable evaluation, their response to the testimony was emotional, and as a group of lay-people would not have had the specialized knowledge and experience necessary to evaluate the claim. When it comes to advancing scientific knowledge, their finding is absolutely meaningless.

That you choose to insist on the acknowledgement of crap like this only serves to make your case look bad.

Linda
 
The time limit is long gone to respond or overturn my original libel decision by six members in the small southern Oregon county courtroom where Renier originally filed. At the time the city she was living in had a population of just under 2000 people. Even when discovered in about 1991 it was too late to overturn the decision. Renier admitted to the Court slightly later that "Nancy Uzdavinis" is her real sister-in-law but she claimed that Nancy had given her permission to use her name. Whether or not this is true --- and I don't personally believe it to be --- it doesn't explain a series of connected issues under the facade presented that I was talking with and corresponding to "Nancy Uzdavinis" rather than Noreen Renier. When you get a chance read at least the four segments on my website covering the plane crash. Much will be revealed including the FBI's involvement. And on that note --- Noreen Renier claimed in testimony that she was paid cash by the FBI and named the FBI officer who paid her for working on the Atlanta Child Murder investigation. The FBI, including Special Agent Robert Ressler (who was not the one named who paid her) never disputed that claim, though he also testified. So it seems that "under the table" paid of use psychics (at least prior to 1995) actually occurred. And Noreen Renier did lecture directly at the FBI, including before new trainees. That I verified several times for previous court actions.
 
Renier admitted to the Court slightly later that "Nancy Uzdavinis" is her real sister-in-law but she claimed that Nancy had given her permission to use her name. Whether or not this is true --- and I don't personally believe it to be --- it doesn't explain a series of connected issues under the facade presented that I was talking with and corresponding to "Nancy Uzdavinis" rather than Noreen Renier. When you get a chance read at least the four segments on my website covering the plane crash.
Despite these things--the fact of Renier's lying about knowing of your investigation, the fact that the Wilbers found the plane without any information at all from Renier, the fact that Renier never produced any latitude/longitude though she claims to have divined it, the fact that your letter was never even published--the jury found in her favor. And Rodney wonders why we put little trust in the ability of a non-expert panel to decide such issues.


Noreen Renier claimed in testimony that she was paid cash by the FBI and named the FBI officer who paid her for working on the Atlanta Child Murder investigation.
Which she notably failed to solve.


The FBI, including Special Agent Robert Ressler (who was not the one named who paid her) never disputed that claim, though he also testified. So it seems that "under the table" paid of use psychics (at least prior to 1995) actually occurred. And Noreen Renier did lecture directly at the FBI, including before new trainees. That I verified several times for previous court actions.
A very sad state of affairs.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom