Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Bri, now really. All of these examples are "John Does"; i.e., cases where bodies had been found, but the police could not identify the remains. They are not cases where the police were looking for a particular person, but could not find the body.

Exactly. They weren't missing person's cases.

So you want us to provide an example of a person who has accurately re-directed missing person police investigations with, as far as can be determined, no inside information that was not available to the police?

And you require that a police officer involved in the investigation has stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing person would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of said person?

Is that what you're asking for?

-Bri

For a missing person case, yes. Similar criteria would apply to other cases, such as unsolved murders.

Like you said, these are not missing person's cases. These are clearly "other cases," and clearly meet "similar criteria."

The person clearly re-directed police investigations with, as far as can be determined, no inside information that was not available to the police. Furthermore, in many of these cases, a police officer involved in the investigation has stated that they doubt that the body would have been identified, if not for the involvement of said person.

Of course, that's not going to stop you from changing the criteria as you already have when other examples have been presented. And none of this matters much since you have yet to show that Pratt met your criteria by using psychic abilities.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Silly Bri. You can't counter Rodney's arguments with a description of events involving court cases and evidence.

Rodney has testimonials from a real psychic's site to back up his claim.
And, speaking of evidence, on his website John Merrell attempts to discredit Noreen Renier's claim of having located in February 1984 the wreckage of a January 1984 fatal plane crash in a wooded Massachusetts area by noting that he conducted an in-depth investigation of that plane crash -- a mere 22 years after the fact! Unfortunately for Merrell, his 1985 claim that Renier was a charlatan resulted in Renier suing him, whereupon Renier won $25,000 in a lawsuit. Merrell has since evened the score by winning a lawsuit that alleged Renier had breached the terms of their confidentiality agreement regarding her legal victory, but Merrell's recent victory did not hinge at all on whether Renier is a charlatan.
 
Last edited:
Neither did the original lawsuit, Rodney. It was a case of libel, not a proof of psychic ability.
It was adjudicated to be libel because Merrell could not prove in court his claim that Renier is a charlatan. If he could have proven that, he would have prevailed.
 
Proving that she is a charlatan has little to do with whether or not she located an airplane crash. Without having read the court transcript, the decision by the judge doesn't necessarily mean she isn't a charlatan -- it might just mean that he didn't have proof at the time he wrote that she was a charlatan.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Proving that she is a charlatan has little to do with whether or not she located an airplane crash. Without having read the court transcript, the decision by the judge doesn't necessarily mean she isn't a charlatan -- it might just mean that he didn't have proof at the time he wrote that she was a charlatan.

-Bri
Yeah, well that's the thing about being a real skeptic, Bri: Before making an accusation, you should have proof.
 
Yeah, well that's the thing about being a real skeptic, Bri: Before making an accusation, you should have proof.

That's not being a skeptic, that's being prudent. :)

Being a skeptic isn't about proving things wrong. I think the bulk of our conversation wouldn't exist if you understood that.

Linda
 
That's not being a skeptic, that's being prudent. :)

Being a skeptic isn't about proving things wrong. I think the bulk of our conversation wouldn't exist if you understood that.

Linda
I do understand that, but Mr. Merrell and many folks here are convinced that there is no such thing as the paranormal and call anyone who claims to be a psychic a charlatan. Is that being a skeptic?
 
Merrell responds

I figured something was up as my website viewership climbed upward an additional 250 or so today. Maybe this is part of it. I hope at some point everyone spends a few hours reading my complete website at www.amindformurder.com , or at least the four segments coverng Renier's claims about the crash and the involvement of retired FBI agent Robert Ressler --- the man who coined the phrase 'serial killer'. A complete reading will showcase why the investigation came after 22 years. The beauty of it is that the actual witnesses who found the plane were located after 22 years. The claims were so corrupted by a psychic charade it's amazing the story all came together at all. Noreen Renier is now attempting bankruptcy in a Virginia court (she filed August 28, 2007) in an attempt to discharge her debt to me (awarded in April 2007 by a Washington federal court) of approximately $40,000 though the amount is climbing due to collection costs. She will have an October 12th hearing in the Virginia Bankruptcy court --- this would be her second bankruptcy in 8 years --- but I have extensive filings to provide to the court to show her bankruptcy filings are incomplete. So the battle continues... yet I believe this latest uncovering and its upcoming twist may unveil some very remarkable clients and funding behind key psychics. People that will likely become discussions of their own in coming months. Stay tuned.
 
I figured something was up as my website viewership climbed upward an additional 250 or so today. Maybe this is part of it. I hope at some point everyone spends a few hours reading my complete website at www.amindformurder.com , or at least the four segments coverng Renier's claims about the crash and the involvement of retired FBI agent Robert Ressler --- the man who coined the phrase 'serial killer'. A complete reading will showcase why the investigation came after 22 years. The beauty of it is that the actual witnesses who found the plane were located after 22 years. The claims were so corrupted by a psychic charade it's amazing the story all came together at all. Noreen Renier is now attempting bankruptcy in a Virginia court (she filed August 28, 2007) in an attempt to discharge her debt to me (awarded in April 2007 by a Washington federal court) of approximately $40,000 though the amount is climbing due to collection costs. She will have an October 12th hearing in the Virginia Bankruptcy court --- this would be her second bankruptcy in 8 years --- but I have extensive filings to provide to the court to show her bankruptcy filings are incomplete. So the battle continues... yet I believe this latest uncovering and its upcoming twist may unveil some very remarkable clients and funding behind key psychics. People that will likely become discussions of their own in coming months. Stay tuned.


Just read your website now.
Congratulations on an excellent site.
 
I do understand that, but Mr. Merrell and many folks here are convinced that there is no such thing as the paranormal and call anyone who claims to be a psychic a charlatan. Is that being a skeptic?

Why wouldn't it be? (With the caveat that there are explanations other than "charlatan".)

Linda
 
So the battle continues... yet I believe this latest uncovering and its upcoming twist may unveil some very remarkable clients and funding behind key psychics. People that will likely become discussions of their own in coming months. Stay tuned.

This part sounds quite interesting.

Linda
 
Why wouldn't it be? (With the caveat that there are explanations other than "charlatan".)

Linda
A skeptic should keep an open mind, not assume that something is impossible because (s)he doesn't understand it.
 
A skeptic should keep an open mind, not assume that something is impossible because (s)he doesn't understand it.

Believing everything somebody tells you is not the same as not assuming that something is impossible. And how is understanding how we are tricked by ourselves and by others translate to "doesn't understand it"?

Linda
 
I figured something was up as my website viewership climbed upward an additional 250 or so today. Maybe this is part of it.

It couldn't be because of our little thread could it?

John, perhaps you can explain the libel case. I assume you were sued for writing that Renier is a charlatan? So did the court case hinge on your proving that she didn't really locate the crashed airplane, and if so why weren't you able to present the same evidence in court that is presented on the website?

-Bri
 
Yeah, well that's the thing about being a real skeptic, Bri: Before making an accusation, you should have proof.

I agree that before making an accusation, you should have proof. But as Linda pointed out, that has nothing to do with being a skeptic.

The key difference is that when someone makes a claim, it is up to them to provide evidence of that claim. The burden of proof is on the person making the claim.

However, if one is going to accuse someone of something, that is a claim itself, and so the burden of proof is on the person making the accusation. I suspect that's why Merrell lost the case.

I am puzzled as to why Merrell wasn't able to meet the burden of proof during the trial given the evidence he has now. Perhaps he didn't have the evidence at the time. I hope he can shed some light on that.

-Bri
 
The basis of the original lawsuit by Noreen Renier was libel in a letter I wrote to a small Oregon newspaper, which was never published. She claimed that because I made Xerox copies of my letter ---approximately 14--- and sent copies of my letter to others that this was "publishing" even though none of the receivers of my letter further notified the public. My use of phrases such as "Like herding sheep for the slaughter, a good charlatan prefers to keep the public ignorant of the facts" and my own testimony in court that she was a fraud allowed (in my opinion) the six member jury over 3-days of testimony to consider this a simple case of whether or not Renier was real. The testimony by Renier and Jessica Herbert convinced them --- two of the female jury members to tears --- that Renier had located a lost plane crash and had seen psychic visions that Jessica's brother aboard the plane had carried a young injured woman out of the plane and left the scene in search of help across snow and ice before he collapsed and died. Though the case should never have hinged on proving that she didn't really locate the crashed airplane --- in reality it did, and Renier and Jessica Herbert provided the testimony that (again in my opinion) offered me as a man unwilling to accept the fantastic ability of Renier able to see this heroic scene and provide it to the sister of the dead hero. I didn't stand a chance. The reason I was never able to provide the truth is because Renier (in pretending to be an uninvolved "Nancy Uzdavinis" prior to the trial in her conversations and letters to me)literally "set up" some of the very information which later she was able to showcase as errors or confusion on my part. I never knew what hit me. And it was many years later by complete accident that I discovered that the "Nancy Uzdavinis" who had written myself and another skeptic was in fact Noreen Renier. The full story is on my web site along with an actual example of a letter and a handwriting expert's testimony that Renier was the actual writer of multiple letters BEFORE she even filed against me for libel. In fact her first letter written as "Nancy Uzdavinis" was actually written BEFORE she even knew I existed!
 
Thanks, John. That clarifies some things. If there is now new evidence that Renier set you up by writing you as someone else and that Renier didn't find the crash, can you now provide additional evidence to have the original verdict overturned, or file a new suit to reclaim your losses? Or do you feel that the handwriting expert and other evidence won't hold up in court? Is there any additional evidence that Renier wrote those letters? I skimmed your website, but didn't read it over carefully yet. Isn't Nancy Uzdavinis a real person? Can't she confirm that she didn't write those letters?

-Bri
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom