Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Update on Information Request reference Nancy Orlen Weber

Here's the text of the email I received yesterday from the Mount Olive Police Department:

I am receipt the several information requests you forwarded to the police department. Please allow me some time to process you requests as these records are old and I’m not sure where they are if we still have all of them. Some retention periods may have elapsed and records may have been destroyed as per NJ Attorney General guidelines. If you have immediate needs please email me, otherwise I will get back to you next week. Thanks for your anticipated cooperation.
 
And on that note --- Noreen Renier claimed in testimony that she was paid cash by the FBI and named the FBI officer who paid her for working on the Atlanta Child Murder investigation.

I find it interesting that Renier admits to having worked on the Atlanta Child Murder investigation. I lived in Atlanta at the time, and it was fairly well-publicized that psychics had been hired to find the killer. It was also well-publicized that the psychics didn't help one bit in the case, but instead wasted police time and resources tracking down useless "leads" provided by the psychics. The real killer was eventually caught by conventional police work.

-Bri
 
There are dozens if not hundreds out there. Rodney has given us the names of the ones he considers the best examples (though we've wandered a bit with Renier).

Is Coronado the example you consider the best? If not, I'd rather not waste time on it. Psychic-whack-a-mole ceases to be fun rather quickly.
 
In regard to: "But, according to Renier, he was the one who started the whole case by calling her late at night and then making unfounded accusations against her in a letter. Then, when he lost the case, he tried to avoid paying her by filing for bankruptcy. So perhaps Renier is just imitating his behavior." Everyone should remember that the phone call records were shown in testimony so that my first call to Noreen Renier (with the intent of reaching Noreen Renier, not placing a call to Nancy Uzdavinis that may have actually been answered by Noreen Renier) was approximately 5 MONTHS later than her letters that she wrote and signed as Nancy Uzdavinis. My earliest phone call to a phone which was at the home she was sharing (as a sister-in-law) with Nancy Uzdavinis, was about 45 days earlier after several months of letters. Thus there is absolutely NO TRUTH that I started this long history. As I noted her first letters asking another skeptic how to locate me (and my address) went out, then after his reply she wrote to me as Nancy Uzdavinis, and then I phoned and wrote her back --- responding to her only as "Nancy Uzdavinis." About five months after that (still under the impression there were two people) I called Noreen Renier for the first time. Shortly after she filed her lawsuit --- obviously fully prepared as she had information from me that I had been giving to "Nancy Uzdavinis" in letters and calls. The comment that I had no clue how clever the deception was is a major understatement! Pam Coronado by-the-way has a statement saying she takes overflow from Renier when Renier cannot handle her calls --- surprising since the level of income from Renier in her bankruptcy filing for this same period indicates otherwise.
 
In regard to: "But, according to Renier, he was the one who started the whole case by calling her late at night and then making unfounded accusations against her in a letter. Then, when he lost the case, he tried to avoid paying her by filing for bankruptcy. So perhaps Renier is just imitating his behavior." Everyone should remember that the phone call records were shown in testimony so that my first call to Noreen Renier (with the intent of reaching Noreen Renier, not placing a call to Nancy Uzdavinis that may have actually been answered by Noreen Renier) was approximately 5 MONTHS later than her letters that she wrote and signed as Nancy Uzdavinis. My earliest phone call to a phone which was at the home she was sharing (as a sister-in-law) with Nancy Uzdavinis, was about 45 days earlier after several months of letters. Thus there is absolutely NO TRUTH that I started this long history. As I noted her first letters asking another skeptic how to locate me (and my address) went out, then after his reply she wrote to me as Nancy Uzdavinis, and then I phoned and wrote her back --- responding to her only as "Nancy Uzdavinis." About five months after that (still under the impression there were two people) I called Noreen Renier for the first time. Shortly after she filed her lawsuit --- obviously fully prepared as she had information from me that I had been giving to "Nancy Uzdavinis" in letters and calls. The comment that I had no clue how clever the deception was is a major understatement!
According to the excerpts from Renier's book that are published on her website: "Then one night, very late, Merrell called me. At the time, I didn't know he was connected to the skeptics. I was very tired, but I answered the phone anyway, and he started asking me questions about what cases I had solved and what I had worked on. Back then, I was even more trusting -- some would say naive -- than I am now, and I hate to disappoint people. So I tried my best to answer his questions."
 
As her own statements acknowledge my phone call came in late fall 1985 and her first letter signed as Nancy Uzdavinis was written the previous spring it showcases the kind of creative fantasies she spins. But it's quite clear that it because I asked her during that fall phone call about her claims of finding a crashed airplane --- claims that had been published just hours before in the Ashland Daily Tidings --- she must have worried that I was already close to uncovering the truth about the plane crash charade. Perhaps in panic and having fed me enough jumbled fabricated nonsense as "Nancy Uzdavinis" she proceeded to sue. But now 22 years later the truth is posted on this masquerade at www.amindformurder.com
 
As her own statements acknowledge my phone call came in late fall 1985 and her first letter signed as Nancy Uzdavinis was written the previous spring it showcases the kind of creative fantasies she spins. But it's quite clear that it because I asked her during that fall phone call about her claims of finding a crashed airplane --- claims that had been published just hours before in the Ashland Daily Tidings --- she must have worried that I was already close to uncovering the truth about the plane crash charade. Perhaps in panic and having fed me enough jumbled fabricated nonsense as "Nancy Uzdavinis" she proceeded to sue. But now 22 years later the truth is posted on this masquerade at www.amindformurder.com
Okay, so what is the complete chronology of events? You say that Noreen Renier's "first letter signed as Nancy Uzdavinis was written the previous spring." What happened prior to that to cause Renier to send you that letter?
 
The first one that I am aware of she wrote in response to a published 'Letter to the Editor' by a skeptic named Leroy Coppedge who lived in southern Oregon. He had written a critical letter about an article that had run about Renier, including her references to locating a crashed plane. He responded to "Nancy Uzdavinis" that she might contact me about the psychic she was inquiring about --- psychic Noreen Renier. Coppedge knew me as he was a member of the Northwest Skeptics group which I co-founded in 1984 while living in the Portland area, about 5 hours from the Ashland area. He also let me know that a "Nancy Uzdavinis" would be contacting me. Soon afterward I received a letter from "Nancy Uzdavinis" which asked for my help in investigating Noreen Renier. She began that contact in the early summer of 1985, and always as Nancy Uzdavinis. But the handwriting expert concluded these letters were written and signed by Noreen Renier using the name Nancy Uzdavinis.
 
One other note. Renier claimed (and still apparently does) that I caused her the loss of working with police or sheriff personnel in Oregon in late 1984 or early 1985. She also has alleged that I wrote various letters in 1984 that mentioned her by name and instructed Oregon law officers not to use her. And she has even used language that I had caused her the loss of a "teaching job" in southern Oregon. As she has no accredited four year degree, no accredited teaching certificate, and has never to my knowledge actually taught an accredited course at any accredited college or university, this is all fabricated nonsense. Even today her website (www.noreenrenier.com) lists "teaching appointments" and herself as a "adjunct faculty member" at a slew of academic institutions. See my website for the background on these claims at www.amindformurder.com under the Noreen Renier background section. I certainly never caused her the loss of any teaching job in Oregon. In fact at the times she has indicated (late 2004 and early 2005) I had never even heard of her. This is the problem in dealing with her fantastic claims. So many on close scrutiny are simply creative visions which sounded great before a jury --- THE LOSS OF A TEACHING JOB! --- but in reality have no basis in truth. But media spin and quick takes are perfect for television or radio and this woman has always been 25 years ahead of everyone in dealing with the media and promoting herself.
 
Last edited:
The first one that I am aware of she wrote in response to a published 'Letter to the Editor' by a skeptic named Leroy Coppedge who lived in southern Oregon. He had written a critical letter about an article that had run about Renier, including her references to locating a crashed plane. He responded to "Nancy Uzdavinis" that she might contact me about the psychic she was inquiring about --- psychic Noreen Renier. Coppedge knew me as he was a member of the Northwest Skeptics group which I co-founded in 1984 while living in the Portland area, about 5 hours from the Ashland area. He also let me know that a "Nancy Uzdavinis" would be contacting me. Soon afterward I received a letter from "Nancy Uzdavinis" which asked for my help in investigating Noreen Renier. She began that contact in the early summer of 1985, and always as Nancy Uzdavinis. But the handwriting expert concluded these letters were written and signed by Noreen Renier using the name Nancy Uzdavinis.
Renier admits sending those letters, but she claims with the full knowledge and consent of her sister-in-law Nancy Uzdavinis and only after receiving a late night call from you in the spring of 1985.
 
Can you give consent for someone to write a letter as if they're you? Isn't that deceitful regardless? In this case, why would she do that other than to deceive Mr. Merrell? If she has psychic powers, why couldn't she just divine the answers instead of lying to get them?

-Bri
 
Anyone reviewing the testimony will find that her letters came months before my phone call intended to reach Noreen Renier. Where did you get the information that she indicates my call came in the spring of 1985? In one sense she is strangely right as I've often suspected my earlier call to "Nancy Uzdavinis" (at the same residence) was actually answered by Noreen Renier. I suspect she is so confused at this point on how she answered what and when and as whom that things have gotten somewhat complex. Why would things become that way to you think?
 
Anyone reviewing the testimony will find that her letters came months before my phone call intended to reach Noreen Renier. Where did you get the information that she indicates my call came in the spring of 1985? In one sense she is strangely right as I've often suspected my earlier call to "Nancy Uzdavinis" (at the same residence) was actually answered by Noreen Renier. I suspect she is so confused at this point on how she answered what and when and as whom that things have gotten somewhat complex. Why would things become that way to you think?
Perhaps because, according to an excerpt from her book -- http://www.noreenrenier.com/bookexcerpt.htm -- your October 1985 letter to the Ashland Daily Tidings stated: "During a forty-minute telephone conversation in May of 1985 with Northwest Skeptics personnel, Ms. Renier made several innuendoes linking the FBI Bureau with requests for her participation in a case where a lost plane was allegedly found by her "psychic ability."

Do you deny that you had a 40-minute telephone conversation in May of 1985 with Noreen Renier?
 
Sorry, my error. My memory is out of sequence after 23 years. So I went back to the court transcripts and some related materials tonight, and here is a broader sequence, including some never previously noted items. This gets a bit long winded, but here it is:

May 4, 1985: First of two newspaper articles covering Noreen Renier appear in Ashland Daily Tidings, Ashland, Oregon. Skeptic Leroy Coppedge who lived in Ashland reads the news article and writes a “Letter to the Editor” of the paper. Coppedge also sends a copy of the article and his letter to me. He has never met me but is aware of as I co-founded the Northwest Skeptics group in Portland.
In referring to what he sent to me in his testimony in Court he described the material as “the letter asking him if he knew her.”

After receiving this letter from Coppedge in the mail, which he sent May 6th, according to my own testimony in court (page 335 of Transcript of Proceedings) “The first thing I did was go through the files of information that is sent to Northwest Skeptics through the CSICOP organization to see if we had any background material on her. We did not, and at that point I contacted a number of other people involved in Northwest Skeptics and we began to go through our various files. . . By June I had certainly received the media packet from Leroy Coppedge, which was given to him by hand by Ms. Renier which included statements of effectively associating herself directly with the FBI.”

Early May 1985: According to a letter written by an instructor at the Southern Oregon State campus in Ashland (Harry Kloor) Noreen Renier “showed up on campus and proclaimed she was ‘gifted.’”

On May 7th or 8th Coppedge meets Renier on the Southern Oregon State campus in Ashland briefly.

On May 13th Coppedge obtains a copy of Renier’s media package indirectly and also learns about an upcoming experiment where Renier has agreed to be tested by Harry Kloor and participants in his classroom on the Southern Oregon State campus.

On May 14th I receive my first call from a student in Ashland asking if I had information about Noreen Renier who is going to be tested at Southern Oregon State. I provide them with information on controlled testing, double-blind studies, etc.

May 17th: A person who is aware of Northwest Skeptics and is also a student involved with the upcoming test at Southern Oregon State calls Noreen Renier and in asking questions about the preparations for the test over approximately 40 minutes also references CSICOP and the group I co-founded, Northwest Skeptics. They also question her about some of her statements in the newspaper article. They let me know of some responses made by Renier by phone a few days later. I let them know that I will await the testing and be interested in hearing about the results.

Early June: Coppedge’s ‘Letter to the Editor’ is finally published and shortly after Noreen Renier experiment takes place in the classroom with instructor Harry Kloor. Harry Kloor’s class was titled “On the Edge of Science.” The object of the course was to teach students to carefully examine pseudoscience claims. According to a letter written to me by Harry Kloor, Noreen Renier agreed to participate in a double-blind test on whether she could obtain “readings” that would match with students in the classroom through “reading” blood samples. She agreed to participate in the test as long as the samples were not handled by multiple people.

Each blood slide was prepared according to Kloor “by first being handled by the subject and then a blood smear was carefully taken and the numbered plate placed in a box.” There were 7 plates of blood prepared with one plate not the blood of one of the student’s to act as a blank. On the day of the test according to Kloor, Renier agreed to the blood reading experiment and after picking up a blood slide at random and “in a somewhat theatrical manner she described the sex, age range, personal traits, etc. of the subject. After her detailed description she demanded to know how well she had done. When it became quite clear she would not continue, Dr. Greg Fowler revealed the identity of the subject to be the blood of a rat. To say the least she was not very pleased.” After additional testing on Renier including readings off objects previously selected from students it was found that Noreen actually performed worst than average.

I heard about these results from one of the students and made the decision Renier was not worth the trouble to investigate.

By mid June: Renier was under critical scrutiny by several students in the Ashland area, and I was living 229 miles away in Beaverton, Oregon and began receiving calls about her involvement with attempting to set up lectures on the use of police psychics with Oregon law enforcement agencies. And this same time Leroy Coppedge receives a letter from “Nancy Uzdavinis” (identified by a handwriting expert as actually written by Noreen Renier) which states “I read your letter to the Editor about that psychic Noreen Renier and I’m confused. I need your help. I attended her lecture and thought she sounded sincere. She’s having another workshop but before I decide I need to know more. You sounded like you know a lot about her. Is she a phoney? Could I learn anything? I thanking you in advance for your help. Sincerely, Nancy Uzdavinis.”

June 19: Coppedge writes back a 350+ word response to “Nancy Uzdavinis” in which he states “I believe your forty dollars would be better spent in some other way. A library card costs nothing. I’m sure you can get all the information that Noreen Renier can give you from books. . . It is very important to be skeptical about claims of the type made by Noreen.” Coppedge also includes a copy of the latest Northwest Skeptic newsletter with my address and name, and a reference to the CSICOP (now CSI) organization.

June 26: “Nancy Uzdavinis” writes and dates her first letter to me. This is also identified by a handwriting expert to have been written by Noreen Renier. She states in the letter “I’m confused about her abilities and need to know if she’s real or not.” I receive this first letter addressed directly to me in either late June or on July 1st or 2nd.

July 2: I respond to “Nancy Uzdavinis” and begin an extensive exchange including multiple phone calls. The record of my phone calls to the telephone of the home of Peter and Nancy Uzdavinis (in real life Noreen Renier’s brother and sister-in-law) show the longest call I made was 12 minutes followed immediately by a ten minute call. The first call was interrupted when Noreen Renier claimed her psychic power disconnected the phone that involved my questions about her claims. My phone records show other multiple calls to the home lasting from 3 minutes to 7 minutes into late fall of 1985.


At approximately the same time (late June) I also receive a letter from an attorney hired by Renier, Mr. Allen Drescher.

According to the testimony from my attorney made in the Oregon trial brought by Renier, “In June Mr. Drescher sent a letter to Mr. Penna [another attorney of mine] accusing Mr. Merrell of making some defamatory statements.” The letter included notice that I had hampered her ability to work directly with local police by being critical of her in letters written in early 1984. I knew this was an error as I had never written any such letters in 1984 which mentioned Noreen Renier as I never knew of her previous in 1984. I had however previously written letters to several law enforcement agencies letting them know about our organization and our efforts to balance any psychic involvement --- particularly when police psychics attempted to provide lectures on psychic use with police agencies --- with a balanced response from one or more of our members. None of those letters mentioned Noreen Renier.

July or August 1985: The attorney for Noreen Renier, Allen Drescher, after first indicating I was hampering business with local law enforcement personnel by writing letters critical of Noreen Renier to Oregon law enforcement agencies agreed that the letters were sent in 1984 well before Renier was known to me and none of the letters mention Renier upon his examination. Drescher agrees all the letters are unrelated to his client and simply critical of police psychics being involved in public law enforcement matters under pay, including paid lectures.

Shortly after providing this corrective/retraction letter Renier terminates Allen Drescher.

August/September 1985: Exchanges with “Nancy Uzdavinis” continue and she is becoming very concerned about psychic Noreen Renier and wants my continued help on investigating her.

October: Second newspaper article appears, I respond with my own “Letter to the Editor” which was never published by the newspaper. Renier sues for libel soon afterward when a friend and assistant at the Ashland Daily Tidings newspaper provides my original signed “Letter to the Editor” directly to Noreen Renier. The Ashland Daily Tidings has never apologized to this rather bizarre conduct as the letter also stated “This additional note not for publication…”

Approximately five years later, after the jury finds me libel for “publishing” my Letter to the Editor by duplicating approximately 14 Xerox copies and personally mailing them to others --- none of whom ever published my comments --- I make a discovery. During a discussion with Leroy Coppedge I discover “Nancy Uzdavinis” is the sister-in-law of Noreen Renier and the letters from “Nancy” were in fact written by Noreen Renier. The discovery comes too late to legally re-address the original verdict.

-Thanks, and sorry for the mistake.


 
May 17th: A person who is aware of Northwest Skeptics and is also a student involved with the upcoming test at Southern Oregon State calls Noreen Renier and in asking questions about the preparations for the test over approximately 40 minutes also references CSICOP and the group I co-founded, Northwest Skeptics. They also question her about some of her statements in the newspaper article. They let me know of some responses made by Renier by phone a few days later. I let them know that I will await the testing and be interested in hearing about the results.
Okay, thanks for the information, but I'm still confused about something. According to Renier's book: "Then one night, very late, Merrell called me. At the time, I didn't know he was connected to the skeptics. I was very tired, but I answered the phone anyway, and he started asking me questions about what cases I had solved and what I had worked on. Back then, I was even more trusting -- some would say naive -- than I am now, and I hate to disappoint people. So I tried my best to answer his questions."

I assumed that the call Renier referenced in her book was the 40-minute one in May 1985. Is that incorrect? If so, who made that call to Renier, and when did you first call her (as opposed to calling "Uzdavinis")?
 
I'll stand by on the name of the person also involved other than they were active at Southern Oregon State at the time. In an upcoming book I will address that and related timing sequences. As it's pretty evident Renier isn't going to hand over the money due this week I'm preparing to at least attempt to get some partial financial compensation to cover litigation expenses. Over the past year several people have come forward to further enhance what I knew was a pretty sophisticated game played. An intriguing question is was I actually responding to Renier's own incoming call message the very first time I dialed back the same number. And how did Renier manage to keep my calls straight at the same residence (a home owned by Nancy Uzdavinis and her husband Peter Uzdavinis) by answering as herself, without the real Nancy Uzdavinis not first picking up? If the call came "late at night" why didn't Peter or Nancy pick up their own phone. I don't think luck of the draw had anything to do with it and this was before "Caller ID" days in Phoenix, Oregon --- a town then of less than 2000 people. This has always been a puzzler until recently. I expect some resolution soon on that matter as the current litigation continues, and as an outcome of the Renier's first bankruptcy petition hearing next week (Friday, October 12, 2007). Meanwhile also consider the testimony she herself provided in court. And prepare to consider her remarks in coming weeks during her bankruptcy hearings. All should be of further interest.
 
I'll stand by on the name of the person also involved other than they were active at Southern Oregon State at the time. In an upcoming book I will address that and related timing sequences. As it's pretty evident Renier isn't going to hand over the money due this week I'm preparing to at least attempt to get some partial financial compensation to cover litigation expenses. Over the past year several people have come forward to further enhance what I knew was a pretty sophisticated game played. An intriguing question is was I actually responding to Renier's own incoming call message the very first time I dialed back the same number. And how did Renier manage to keep my calls straight at the same residence (a home owned by Nancy Uzdavinis and her husband Peter Uzdavinis) by answering as herself, without the real Nancy Uzdavinis not first picking up? If the call came "late at night" why didn't Peter or Nancy pick up their own phone. I don't think luck of the draw had anything to do with it and this was before "Caller ID" days in Phoenix, Oregon --- a town then of less than 2000 people. This has always been a puzzler until recently. I expect some resolution soon on that matter as the current litigation continues, and as an outcome of the Renier's first bankruptcy petition hearing next week (Friday, October 12, 2007). Meanwhile also consider the testimony she herself provided in court. And prepare to consider her remarks in coming weeks during her bankruptcy hearings. All should be of further interest.

A couple of points here: (1) In her book, Renier states that in the spring of 1985 and continuing for about eight months, she was living in "a little baby brick building in a trailer park. It was tiny -- really tiny. You had to turn sideways to enter the bathroom." If this is correct, she was not living with her in-laws in their home at that time. (2) You now acknowledge that someone affiliated with Northwest Skeptics called Renier on May 17, 1985, and engaged her in a 40-minute conversation, which was prior to the first letter that she signed as Nancy Uzdavinis in June 1985. Thus, this was not a case of Renier launching a preemptive strike on you in June 1985 -- she had been the recipient of a (presumably hostile) telephone call the previous month. Speaking of which, do you know what was said in that conversation? If it was not electronically recorded, you may have been misinformed about the content of that conversation. In fact, it's even possible that the caller posed as you, isn't it?
 
If it was not electronically recorded, you may have been misinformed about the content of that conversation. In fact, it's even possible that the caller posed as you, isn't it?
Entirely possible. Just as it is entirely possible Renier is lying in her book.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom