Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

Entirely possible. Just as it is entirely possible Renier is lying in her book.
Even if some of Renier's claims in her book are not 100% accurate, it may be for the same reason that some of Merrell's statements here have not been 100% accurate: Incorrect recollection. However, the crucial fact that has now been established is that there was a 40-minute phone call to Renier by a skeptic in May 1985, which was a month prior to her writing her first letter as Nancy Uzdavinis. So, the notion that Renier hatched a diabolically clever preemptive plot to entrap Merrell can be discarded.
 
Even if some of Renier's claims in her book are not 100% accurate, it may be for the same reason that some of Merrell's statements here have not been 100% accurate: Incorrect recollection.
Could be, yes.


However, the crucial fact that has now been established is that there was a 40-minute phone call to Renier by a skeptic in May 1985, which was a month prior to her writing her first letter as Nancy Uzdavinis. So, the notion that Renier hatched a diabolically clever preemptive plot to entrap Merrell can be discarded.
No, the second does not follow from the first. Merrell did not make the call in May. There are multiple possibilities to explain what happened following that call, but two of them include Renier hatching a diabolically clever preemptive plot. (What the heck; if you're going to put words in my mouth I may as well get mileage out of 'em.):

1. Renier knew it was not Merrell but decided he was prominent enough to go after anyway before this thing got any bigger and word of the hollowness of her claims got out.

2. Renier thought it was Merrell and therefore hatched up a way to respond in a way that seemed she was not responding.
 
Could be, yes.
I'm glad that we can agree on something. :)

No, the second does not follow from the first. Merrell did not make the call in May.
You're not being a good skeptic, Garrette. According to Merrell's October 1985 letter to the Ashland Daily Tidings, in May of 1985 Renier had a 40-minute telephone conversation with "Northwest Skeptics personnel." Merrell states that he didn't make that call to Renier and I'm not charging that he did, but I think it's safe to say that "Northwest Skeptics personnel" narrow the possibilities to just a few candidates, including Merrell.

There are multiple possibilities to explain what happened following that call, but two of them include Renier hatching a diabolically clever preemptive plot. (What the heck; if you're going to put words in my mouth I may as well get mileage out of 'em.):

1. Renier knew it was not Merrell but decided he was prominent enough to go after anyway before this thing got any bigger and word of the hollowness of her claims got out.

2. Renier thought it was Merrell and therefore hatched up a way to respond in a way that seemed she was not responding.
(1) My point is that this whole chain of events appears to have been set in motion by the phone call from a skeptic to Renier in May 2005; and (2) Fess up, Garrette: When Merrell posted here - "As her own statements acknowledge my phone call came in late fall 1985 and her first letter signed as Nancy Uzdavinis was written the previous spring it showcases the kind of creative fantasies she spins" - were you not convinced that there never had been a call to Renier from a skeptic in May 1985?
 
I'm glad that we can agree on something. :)
We already agreed that I'm devastatingly handsome and incisively brilliant, so the precedent was there...


Rodney said:
You're not being a good skeptic, Garrette.
Nah. I'm a GREEEEEEEAAAATE skeptic.


Rodney said:
According to Merrell's October 1985 letter to the Ashland Daily Tidings, in May of 1985 Renier had a 40-minute telephone conversation with "Northwest Skeptics personnel." Merrell states that he didn't make that call to Renier and I'm not charging that he did, but I think it's safe to say that "Northwest Skeptics personnel" narrow the possibilities to just a few candidates, including Merrell.
Which is why I included my possibility #2.


Rodney said:
(1) My point is that this whole chain of events appears to have been set in motion by the phone call from a skeptic to Renier in May 2005;
Another agreement!


Rodney said:
and (2) Fess up, Garrette: When Merrell posted here - "As her own statements acknowledge my phone call came in late fall 1985 and her first letter signed as Nancy Uzdavinis was written the previous spring it showcases the kind of creative fantasies she spins" - were you not convinced that there never had been a call to Renier from a skeptic in May 1985?
Convinced? No. Inclined to believe Merrell over Renier? Yes. When Merrell corrected himself, I believed the May phonen call; one might even say I was "convinced."
 
It would be tough for the caller to pose as me. She was female. You're looking in the wrong places for answers to find a defense for a woman who obviously had no problem with attempting to bend the truth that I had written letters critical of her at a time when I didn't know her. Or signing letters as someone else. Or telling jury members that people found the plane and the victims just as she visioned. Or that she was "instrumental" in locating the plane. Or writing a book and including chapters critical of me and then claiming she didn't breach a settlement. But you can continue your up hill battle as I watch on the sidelines. You aren't skeptical. Your climbing your own hill.
 
From Merrell - One other point. If I'm correct, and my memory is hopefully reasonably accurate, why would Noreen Renier target me? After all the first critical published response was the published 'Letter to the Editor' from Leroy Coppedge. And some embarrassment at the hands of a collection of students and instructors. And frustration with her first attorney at backing away from attempting to build a case for damaging her opportunities to lecture with local police departments. So why would a call from anyone and at anytime --- and she obviously was receiving them from many in the community after her own promotions and news article --- suddenly send her my way? My longest call lasted 22 minutes with a 2-3 break in the middle when the line went dead and I attempted to call her back. Frankly that was also a pretty innocent call and VERY polite. I'm quite sure she was far more concerned by the attitudes of some folks on the campus and local police officers who knew there had never been letters from me specificly mentioning Renier. No folks, what I have long suspected is that she was going for a $250,000 pot of gold offered at the time by James Randi. In the very first deposition I took she thought I was a representative of CSICOP and connected with Randi. She was going for what she thought was a pot of available MONEY. Students don't have money. And instructors are pretty lean at times. Remember my biggest fault was making some Xerox copies of my concerns and sending them out to people who likely tossed them immediately into the waste. No public media coverage. In fact the first time my letter was ever "published" in the sense most of us have of publication was in Noreen Renier's own book in 2005. But in 1985 no one knew but a very few people who received a copy in a hand-addressed envelope. It never made a newspaper. So what was the level of damage for this? She could not cite any loss of income, no loss of business, no loss of a job. Just libel. And what was the figure she came up with for damages when she filed. $250,000. Now ain't that just a odd coincidence.
 
From Merrell - One other point. If I'm correct, and my memory is hopefully reasonably accurate, why would Noreen Renier target me? After all the first critical published response was the published 'Letter to the Editor' from Leroy Coppedge. And some embarrassment at the hands of a collection of students and instructors. And frustration with her first attorney at backing away from attempting to build a case for damaging her opportunities to lecture with local police departments. So why would a call from anyone and at anytime --- and she obviously was receiving them from many in the community after her own promotions and news article --- suddenly send her my way? My longest call lasted 22 minutes with a 2-3 break in the middle when the line went dead and I attempted to call her back. Frankly that was also a pretty innocent call and VERY polite. I'm quite sure she was far more concerned by the attitudes of some folks on the campus and local police officers who knew there had never been letters from me specificly mentioning Renier. No folks, what I have long suspected is that she was going for a $250,000 pot of gold offered at the time by James Randi. In the very first deposition I took she thought I was a representative of CSICOP and connected with Randi. She was going for what she thought was a pot of available MONEY. Students don't have money. And instructors are pretty lean at times. Remember my biggest fault was making some Xerox copies of my concerns and sending them out to people who likely tossed them immediately into the waste. No public media coverage. In fact the first time my letter was ever "published" in the sense most of us have of publication was in Noreen Renier's own book in 2005. But in 1985 no one knew but a very few people who received a copy in a hand-addressed envelope. It never made a newspaper. So what was the level of damage for this? She could not cite any loss of income, no loss of business, no loss of a job. Just libel. And what was the figure she came up with for damages when she filed. $250,000. Now ain't that just a odd coincidence.
Thanks, John. We obviously cannot know this for a fact, but it is as consistent with what is known as is any other scenario, and a bit more suspiciously so. So my first option after the May call to Renier:

"1. Renier knew it was not Merrell but decided he was prominent enough to go after anyway before this thing got any bigger and word of the hollowness of her claims got out."

jives with your suggestion though it doesn't include an apparent misconception on Renier's part about a link between you and CSICOP.
 
It would be tough for the caller to pose as me. She was female. You're looking in the wrong places for answers to find a defense for a woman who obviously had no problem with attempting to bend the truth that I had written letters critical of her at a time when I didn't know her. Or signing letters as someone else. Or telling jury members that people found the plane and the victims just as she visioned. Or that she was "instrumental" in locating the plane. Or writing a book and including chapters critical of me and then claiming she didn't breach a settlement. But you can continue your up hill battle as I watch on the sidelines. You aren't skeptical. Your climbing your own hill.
Does "skeptical" mean accepting your version of events? Again, I must note that Renier prevailed in the original libel case. But I look forward to following developments in the current case, in which you prevailed. I'll be away until Sunday, and so I'll check back here then.
 
I believe there will some fireworks as the current proceedings where Renier has petitioned for bankruptcy. It will really be the first review of her income sources to my knowledge in a public forum where at least many filings are public. The initial hearing on her petition is Friday next week (October 12, 2007). From there it should get interesting. This isn't going to be a "slam dunk" basic filing with no questions asked.
 
Here's the text of the email I received yesterday from the Mount Olive Police Department:

Any more updates? I realize you probably would have told us if there were, but I'm impatient and I somehow think asking you about it makes a difference.

Linda
 
Any more updates? I realize you probably would have told us if there were, but I'm impatient
No updates, but it's probably my fault. In my response I said that there is no rush (his email made him sound harried). If I am reading the process correctly, the next contact will be him saying "We have discovered X pages relating to your request. The cost is Y to copy and mail them. Upon receipt of your money order in that amount, we will forward them to you."

Which means it could still be a while.


and I somehow think asking you about it makes a difference.
Always. It always makes a difference. I'm a-tingle.
 
No updates, but it's probably my fault. In my response I said that there is no rush (his email made him sound harried). If I am reading the process correctly, the next contact will be him saying "We have discovered X pages relating to your request. The cost is Y to copy and mail them. Upon receipt of your money order in that amount, we will forward them to you."

Which means it could still be a while.

Thanks. We need a fund for this sort of stuff.

Always. It always makes a difference. I'm a-tingle.

It's the fellow in the Mount Olive Police department we need all a-tingle to speed up the process.

Linda
 
I believe there will some fireworks as the current proceedings where Renier has petitioned for bankruptcy. It will really be the first review of her income sources to my knowledge in a public forum where at least many filings are public. The initial hearing on her petition is Friday next week (October 12, 2007). From there it should get interesting. This isn't going to be a "slam dunk" basic filing with no questions asked.
Any update on Friday's hearing?
 
Renier attended Oct 12 hearing, no action

Sorry for delay here. I have continued to post updates on the website at www.amindformurder.com Renier attended the hearing on October 12, 2007, and was questioned on a number of issues including why she did not list her book (A Mind for Murder) as an asset. I filed a lengthy document which questions whether she has properly listed all of her income in 2005, 2006 and 2007. The Bankruptcy Trustee will now take several weeks --- perhaps several months --- to investigate the differences I have pointed out (sizeable!) and make a decision as to whether she can proceed with her bankruptcy. I'll keep you updated. I have added a sizeable new group of background incidents about her on the website this past week, including several older photographs. And several new people have responded with additional information about her that I intend to post in the next few weeks.
 
I just received some further information from previous clients of Noreen Renier. Payments have been made which are not identified to these sources in her bankruptcy filing. It just gets better and better. I'll be informing the Bankruptcy Trustee.
 
Yeah it's pretty cool, maybe they would have never found her
???

Who is "they", and who is "her?"

Are you talking about the original post and Norman Pratt? If so, read the follow on links. Nothing psychic here.

Noreen Renier and the plane crash in Massachusetts? Nothing psychic there.

Noreen Renier and the bankruptcy court? Something shady there, but definitely nothing psychic.
 
Sort of an update

In emailed the Mount Olive PD requesting an update on my information request regarding Nancy Orlen Weber. Here is the response:

Officer Cordileone said:
I have not forgotten your request. I was away in training last week and
am currently working on a budget deadline. I apologize for the delay,
but rest assured I have not forgotten about your request.

Respectfully,

Mike

Ofc. Mike Cordileone
Mt. Olive Twp Police
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom