Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

As soon as you tell us exactly what you think they've done, I'll attempt to honor your request.

-Bri
They have each accurately re-directed missing person police investigations with, as far as can be determined, no inside (non-paranormal) information that was not available to the police. In each case, police officers involved in the respective investigations stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing persons would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of the psychic.
 
So you want us to provide an example of a person who has accurately re-directed missing person police investigations with, as far as can be determined, no inside information that was not available to the police?

And you require that a police officer involved in the investigation has stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing person would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of said person?

Is that what you're asking for?

-Bri
 
They have each accurately re-directed missing person police investigations with, as far as can be determined, no inside (non-paranormal) information that was not available to the police. In each case, police officers involved in the respective investigations stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing persons would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of the psychic.

Rodney, the police were still searching when Norm offered his guess. What is to say the police would not have searched this area after they had thoroughly searched their current positiion?
They were searching where the person was last seen, they could have been well aware that the body was not likely to be there, but had to thoroughly search that area before moving on.
Now if anyone were to try make an educated guess at where the body was, they would choose somewhere close to the location, but somewhere different to where had been searched. Norm guessed somewhere like this, and happened to be right. This does not prove he is psychic, as it may just have been a lucky guess. Or even an educated guess, perhaps he knows where a tramper is likely to venture, or get lost. The thing is, a psychic coming along is allowed to make guesses based on gut feeling, whereas the police are bound by rules, regulations and and have to proceed in a step by step manner.
There are many many psychics out there trying to offer information to the police, and usually the information is usesless. But by the law of chance, occaisionally you are going to get one who makes a lucky guess. This is why cases like this are so rare, because it takes a fluke. You hear about the flukes like this, but dont hear about the contstant failures.
If Norm is truly psychic and can do this, then he must be a very selfish person... there are so many murderers out there that he could be catching, why doesnt he?
I will tell you why, because he just makes guesses, like you or i could make, and this time he got lucky.

Think about how different the world would be if anyone were TRULY psychic. I know it is an appealing belief.. we all want it to be true, but it just doesnt stand up to scrutiny. Invariably everything "psychic" has another, more likely explanation.
 
Last edited:
It would be even more profoundly obvious if you, Bri, or Garrette could come up with an on-point example of a non-psychic doing what Norm Pratt and Annette Martin have done.

You know as well as I do that that's not true. We can find you the most exquisitely perfect example and you would still find some way to dismiss it, or you would ignore it, waiting for our attention to wane before picking up again right where you left off.

Your psychics don't even fulfill your criteria. Norm Pratt used inside information - he searched on his own until he found useful information (the clothes) to pass on to the police. Annette Martin didn't re-direct the investigation - she told them to look again in an area that had already been searched. The detective was already doing the same thing - covering old ground. I don't see why we have to assume that the detective wouldn't have found the body on her own.

And your criteria don't even make something paranormal. Almost by definition, anytime police follow up on a lead or tip it is pointing them in a new direction. If the lead or tip is about something the police have already thoroughly investigated and eliminated (i.e. an old direction), then that won't be something they follow up. And the links I listed earlier were of different kinds of information - some of it inside information, but some of it guesses, impressions, visions. People don't seem to limit themselves to calling in about stuff they know, otherwise there wouldn't be so many stories about tips that didn't pan out.

Linda
 
Your psychics don't even fulfill your criteria...

And your criteria don't even make something paranormal...

Nothing really new to add, just thought it bears repeating. Rodney will still somehow miss it, but it's still worth repeating.

That said, I think there are non-psychics who meet the criteria. Of course, if provided an example Rodney will just change the criteria again. So far I'm 100% when it comes to predicting Rodney's next move.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
So you want us to provide an example of a person who has accurately re-directed missing person police investigations with, as far as can be determined, no inside information that was not available to the police?

And you require that a police officer involved in the investigation has stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing person would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of said person?

Is that what you're asking for?

-Bri
For a missing person case, yes. Similar criteria would apply to other cases, such as unsolved murders.
 
Can you provide some evidence that the psychics you mentioned meet these criteria (particularly the first), and did so using psychic abilities?

If you can, then I'll look for an example of a non-psychic doing the same using no psychic abilities. If you can't, either of your psychics would serve nicely as my example.

-Bri
 
Can you provide some evidence that the psychics you mentioned meet these criteria (particularly the first), and did so using psychic abilities?
They seem to have convinced police officers who worked on the cases that they used psychic abilities. But, I suppose by your logic, if they directed police to the correct location, it must have been either a coincidence or they had inside information.

If you can, then I'll look for an example of a non-psychic doing the same using no psychic abilities. If you can't, either of your psychics would serve nicely as my example.

-Bri

So, when you stated in your previous post -- "That said, I think there are non-psychics who meet the criteria." -- you don't actually have an example of a non-psychic meeting my criteria?
 
They seem to have convinced police officers who worked on the cases that they used psychic abilities.
They seem to have convinced one officer who provides no details.

But, I suppose by your logic, if they directed police to the correct location, it must have been either a coincidence or they had inside information.
It remains a possibility. As fls has pointed out, the only difference between the actions of your psychic detectives and the actions of those not claiming psychic abilities is the claim itself.


So, when you stated in your previous post -- "That said, I think there are non-psychics who meet the criteria." -- you don't actually have an example of a non-psychic meeting my criteria?
Bri's point was that you don't have an example of a psychic meeting your criteria.

Your goalposts seem permanent set on rollers.
 
They seem to have convinced police officers who worked on the cases that they used psychic abilities.

At best, we know that they told the police they used psychic powers and a few police officers (if quoted correctly) didn't know any better than to believe them. Hardly something that inspires confidence in their opinions.

But, I suppose by your logic, if they directed police to the correct location, it must have been either a coincidence or they had inside information.

Why do you have the impression that making a guess is some powerfully amazing magical ability if it happens to be right?

Linda
 
They seem to have convinced one officer who provides no details.
At least one police officer with respect to the Norm Pratt missing person case and at least two police officers with respect to one of the Annette Martin missing person cases.

It remains a possibility. As fls has pointed out, the only difference between the actions of your psychic detectives and the actions of those not claiming psychic abilities is the claim itself.
That and the fact that neither you, Bri, or Linda has come up with even one example of an avowed non-psychic doing what Pratt and Martin did.

Bri's point was that you don't have an example of a psychic meeting your criteria.
So the avowed psychics aren't really psychics because you, Bri, and Linda say so?
 
At least one police officer with respect to the Norm Pratt missing person case and at least two police officers with respect to one of the Annette Martin missing person cases.
Okay. On average, 1 and a half police officers who provide no details.


That and the fact that neither you, Bri, or Linda has come up with even one example of an avowed non-psychic doing what Pratt and Martin did.
Yes, Rodney, we have. You simply refuse to see it.


So the avowed psychics aren't really psychics because you, Bri, and Linda say so?
No. They aren't psychics because they haven't demonstrated that they are. Simple as that.
 
That and the fact that neither you, Bri, or Linda has come up with even one example of an avowed non-psychic doing what Pratt and Martin did.

First of all, why should we? You are claiming that psychic powers exist because Pratt and Martin did what normal people cannot. However, you have not provided any evidence that normal people cannot do these things. We already realize that you cannot be persuaded off your support of the existence of psychic ability. The fact that you are still making your claims despite being quite thoroughly backed into a corner here, tells us that. What we are trying to tell you is that it is reasonable for us not to believe you until you provide evidence, and that what you have provided so far is not evidence. It does this conversation no good whatsoever for us to provide evidence to you.

Second of all (and this proves my first point), you honestly think it's reasonable to stick with your premise that people who continue to search for missing people never find them? Are you seriously expecting us to buy that? Do you really think examples like this are hard to find?*

So the avowed psychics aren't really psychics because you, Bri, and Linda say so?

The avowed psychics aren't psychics just because they say so.

Linda
*I realize, of course, that this example doesn't count due to some critical, but previously unspecified criterion.
 
*I realize, of course, that this example doesn't count due to some critical, but previously unspecified criterion.
No quotation from a police officer saying "I am convinced that the nameless private individual is not psychic."

Take heart, though: This case at least has the complete lack of substantiating evidence to commend it to Rodney.
 
They seem to have convinced police officers who worked on the cases that they used psychic abilities. But, I suppose by your logic, if they directed police to the correct location, it must have been either a coincidence or they had inside information.

Yes, so far the overwhelming evidence seems to indicate it far more likely that they may have helped to solve the case by non-psychic means. I asked for evidence that they solved the case by psychic means.

So, when you stated in your previous post -- "That said, I think there are non-psychics who meet the criteria." -- you don't actually have an example of a non-psychic meeting my criteria?

Yes, I think Pratt is an excellent example. But if you can show me evidence that Pratt used psychic abilities to help solve the case, I'll come up with a better one for you.

ETA: No need for me to look -- Linda already found one.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Do you really think examples like this are hard to find?
I commend you, Linda, on finally finding an example that at least has some potential for being relevant to my criteria, even if it is very murky as to how this individual came to find the body. However, if you, Bri, Garrette, or some other leading Randi Forum Luminary can show that the individual who found the body met my criteria, I'll stop talking about Pratt and Martin. Though that's a pretty big "if" . . .
 
It is clear that the police had stopped looking and felt that the person was responsible for solving the case. In what way does it not meet the criteria you set forth?

And when are you going to provide evidence that Pratt and Martin met the criteria you set forth using psychic means?

-Bri
 
It is clear that the police had stopped looking and felt that the person was responsible for solving the case. In what way does it not meet the criteria you set forth?

Okay, let's go through the criteria:

(1)" . . .accurately re-directed missing person police investigations . . " Did the individual in Switzerland do that? The article doesn't say.

(2)" . . . with, as far as can be determined, no inside (non-paranormal) information that was not available to the police . . . " Did the individual in Switzerland have no inside information? The article doesn't say.

(3)" . . . police officers . . . stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing persons would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of the psychic [or non-psychic]. . ." Did the Swiss police say that they doubted that the girl's body would have been found when it was found? I'll grant you that seems to be the implication, but the article doesn't say that. Further, we don't even know who the person is who found the body. For all we know, it was an avowed psychic!

And when are you going to provide evidence that Pratt and Martin met the criteria you set forth using psychic means?

-Bri
Again, that's what the police seem to believe, but that's not the issue here. You, Linda, and Garrette seem to think that what Pratt and Martin did was nothing special. If you're right, you should be able to find at least one example where a non-psychic assisted the police in the way that Pratt and Martin did.
 
Yup, Linda called it.

Rodney, to refresh your memory, here is what you claimed that Pratt and Martin did using psychic means:

So you want us to provide an example of a person who has accurately re-directed missing person police investigations with, as far as can be determined, no inside information that was not available to the police?

Pratt didn't do this. He only told the police to stop searching where they were searching, so he didn't accurately re-direct police, nor do we know that he had no inside information since none of the articles said one way of the other (imagine that!). Pratt simply continued to search for the body and found it -- no wait -- he found the clothing, not the body. The police found the body. And there is no evidence that Pratt found the clothing using psychic means.

On the other hand, the person in Linda's story apparently found the body by continuing to search after the police had given up, which is exactly what Pratt did. Of course, the person in Linda's story was more successful than Pratt was and actually found the body. All apparently without using any psychic means.

And you require that a police officer involved in the investigation has stated that they doubt that the bodies of the missing person would have been found when they were found, if not for the involvement of said person?

According to the statement made by the police, the person found the body by continuing to look after they had stopped looking.

Sounds like Linda's met your criteria better than Pratt did. Even if you can provide some evidence that Pratt used psychic means, he doesn't meet your criteria. But by all means please provide evidence that Pratt used psychic means to do whatever you think he did.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
By the way, here are five more:

http://www.knoxstudio.com/shns/story.cfm?pk=MISSING-CASES-10-04-05&cat=AN

And here's another:

http://www.courttv.com/news/hiddentraces/boyinthebox/tent_girl.html

And here's a whole site where amateurs help to solve crimes:

http://www.doenetwork.org/

Here's one example from that site:

http://www.doenetwork.org/media/news76.html:

Internet group led to ID of victim

Wednesday, January 19, 2005
The Daily Item
By James Haynes

Forensics and CSI is all the rage in television police dramas, but the tip that helped investigators identify Tina Leone came from volunteer investigators using nothing more complicated than a Yahoo chat room. "Based on what the detectives told me, the Doe Network had access to additional resources that may not have been available to law enforcement. The fact that they were able to scan various Web pages and keep a constant monitor on things that may not have otherwise been available to us was critical for us in identifying (Tina Leone)," said Harford County Sheriff's spokesman Edward Hopkins. "They were definitely on target for us."

Of course, I'm sure none of these will be acceptable either.

-Bri
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom