Norm Pratt: Split from: Psychics and Missing People

I would be impressed if a body were found.

Would you think I must have used special powers?

Are you saying: (a) you are the author of that book? or (b) you have an uncommon (at least somewhat) last name, and it was an interesting coincidence?

It was an interesting coincidence.

Linda
 
Are you saying: (a) you are the author of that book? or (b) you have an uncommon (at least somewhat) last name, and it was an interesting coincidence?

What? You don't think it was some sort of supernatural event? Why not, Rodney? My your bouts of lucidity are puzzling!

If a police officer had witnessed the event and had proclaimed that the clerk was psychic, would that change your mind? How about if the event was reported in a newspaper and the police officer was quoted?

-Bri
 
If a police officer had witnessed the event and had proclaimed that the clerk was psychic, would that change your mind? How about if the event was reported in a newspaper and the police officer was quoted?

-Bri
I'd still ask for theh police report.

I mean, come on. Linda's bound to be the Unsub in at least one.
 
What? You don't think it was some sort of supernatural event? Why not, Rodney? My your bouts of lucidity are puzzling!

If a police officer had witnessed the event and had proclaimed that the clerk was psychic, would that change your mind? How about if the event was reported in a newspaper and the police officer was quoted?

-Bri
Garrette has convinced me that the only thing that matters is the police report. If the police report said that it was a supernatural event, then it clearly was. Surely, you agree with that, don't you, Bri? . . . Bri?
 
No, but I'm still looking for an example of a non-psychic assisting the police in a similar way to a psychic.
Because you shift goalposts when such examples are provided.


Rodney said:
Garrette has convinced me that the only thing that matters is the police report. If the police report said that it was a supernatural event, then it clearly was. Surely, you agree with that, don't you, Bri? . . . Bri?
Then you are either twisting my comments or sorely misunderstanding. As the closest thing to primary source material, it has primacy of evidence. It is not necessarily conclusive.

That is not shifting goalposts as police reports are never considered conclusive, else there would never be a trial, and we know that sometimes the police get it wrong.

Two things are crucial here:

First, when supporters of the psychic-detective claim repeatedly do not show the police reports and do not make the attempt to get them and do rely almost solely on media reports and the claims of the psychic-detectives themselves, the evidence is not only lacking but insufficient for any reasonable person to draw a conclusion in favor of the psychic-detective.

Second, show me one police report, just one, that says the case was solved via supernatural means and you may just have grounds to begin building your argument. Until then, you're still just blowing air.
 
Garrette has convinced me that the only thing that matters is the police report. If the police report said that it was a supernatural event, then it clearly was. Surely, you agree with that, don't you, Bri? . . . Bri?

I do agree with what Garrette wrote, but I disagree with your mischaracterization of what Garrette wrote.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
No, but I'm still looking for an example of a non-psychic assisting the police in a similar way to a psychic.

Do you mean guessing at initials? I'm sure there are few if any non-psychics who have done that, given that it appears to be next to useless in helping to solve crimes.

But of course I've given you many examples of non-psychics who have aided police in solving crimes. There are far more examples of non-psychics aiding police than psychics. Therefore, given the track records, it would be far more reasonable for a police officer to ask random people off the street where they think the body is than to consult psychic detectives. Or goats. At least goats don't make claims they can't substantiate. Goats are great that way.

-Bri
 
No, but I'm still looking for an example of a non-psychic assisting the police in a similar way to a psychic.

Where are you looking? I searched the phrase "based on a tip" on google news and lots of stuff comes up. I can find a wide variety of stuff, all of which looks like the same stuff psychics come up with. There doesn't seem to be any distinction made by the reporter or law enforcement, only by the informant. That is, they don't seem to find it unusual to receive useful and useless information from the public. The only mention of whether the information was gained in an unusual manner came from the informants. I'm not sure that it's possible to tell from the kind of information that's received that the source was "psychic". It seems more likely that the police only know this by being told.

http://starbulletin.com/2007/09/19/news/story06.html
http://www.hindu.com/2007/09/17/stories/2007091760250400.htm
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/09/14/MN0LS60VN.DTL
http://www.tucsoncitizen.com/daily/local/63261.php
http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcon...tcdeath_08met.ART.North.Edition1.42b719b.html
http://www.imedinews.ge/en/news_read/63293

Missing persons:
http://www.thekansascitychannel.com/news/14077808/detail.html
http://origin.sltrib.com/ci_6824492
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0108/01/bn.05.html
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/03/31/earlyshow/main1458699.shtml
http://www.operationlookout.org/lookoutmag/CDA_Police_Assist_FBI.htm
http://www.findkatherinefry.com/news.php
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2004/07/10/tamra040710.html
http://www.jsonline.com/story/index.aspx?id=620775

Linda
 
Garrette has convinced me that the only thing that matters is the police report. If the police report said that it was a supernatural event, then it clearly was. Surely, you agree with that, don't you, Bri? . . . Bri?

I realize that you're being sarcastic, but the problem with this emphasis on the opinion of the police is that the police do not have expertise in this area. They do not have training in the understanding of the various psychological techniques that are used by psychics and ourselves to make patterns in the clouds. So their opinion is inadequate without further support.

One of the reasons that I do not find Jerry Lewis' and Ross English's endorsements of Nancy Weber's abilities compelling is that they do not mention the sorts of things that would need to be mentioned when reporting on a proper investigation. If you read a scientific report on a research study, you will notice that they mention all the stuff they took in to consideration and all the stuff they ruled-out when drawing their conclusions. As I read a research report, a number of questions arise as I go along. A good report anticipates those questions and answers them for you. When I read the reports of Jerry Lewis and Ross English, a number of questions arise that are never answered. This makes me wonder whether or not they took these issues into consideration when they formed their conclusions. One thing that I do expect a police officer to do well is to form a proper report. They should know that part of the purpose of a report is to answer those questions, so the lack suggests that their investigation was not adequate to determine whether Nancy Weber gains information in a psychic manner. Now the way to be sure is to put those questions to them directly, but if I recall correctly, the responses that were received from them were inadequate or dismissive. I remember finding them unsatisfactory, but I'll have to refresh my memory on the details.

Linda
 
Do you mean guessing at initials? I'm sure there are few if any non-psychics who have done that, given that it appears to be next to useless in helping to solve crimes.

But of course I've given you many examples of non-psychics who have aided police in solving crimes. There are far more examples of non-psychics aiding police than psychics. Therefore, given the track records, it would be far more reasonable for a police officer to ask random people off the street where they think the body is than to consult psychic detectives. Or goats. At least goats don't make claims they can't substantiate. Goats are great that way.

-Bri

You know what else is great about goats? Cashmere!

Linda
 
My 2c worth. I remember reading recently that the police in the Maddie case have received hundreds of 'leads' from crackpots, psychics etc. Each has to be followed up in case it is actually from the kidnapper and contains useful information (no suggestion that they are expecting 'psychic' leads to be of use.)
So it is also an absolute waste of police time and money as well a being nonsense.
And none have actually lead to finding her.

Surprise!
 
My 2c worth. I remember reading recently that the police in the Maddie case have received hundreds of 'leads' from crackpots, psychics etc. Each has to be followed up in case it is actually from the kidnapper and contains useful information (no suggestion that they are expecting 'psychic' leads to be of use.)
So it is also an absolute waste of police time and money as well a being nonsense.
And none have actually lead to finding her.

Surprise!
It's been said many times on these forums that this is an excellent example of self-proclaimed psychics actually causing harm.

It bears repeating, so good on you for pointing it out.
 
I realize that you're being sarcastic, but the problem with this emphasis on the opinion of the police is that the police do not have expertise in this area. They do not have training in the understanding of the various psychological techniques that are used by psychics and ourselves to make patterns in the clouds. So their opinion is inadequate without further support.

One of the reasons that I do not find Jerry Lewis' and Ross English's endorsements of Nancy Weber's abilities compelling is that they do not mention the sorts of things that would need to be mentioned when reporting on a proper investigation. If you read a scientific report on a research study, you will notice that they mention all the stuff they took in to consideration and all the stuff they ruled-out when drawing their conclusions. As I read a research report, a number of questions arise as I go along. A good report anticipates those questions and answers them for you. When I read the reports of Jerry Lewis and Ross English, a number of questions arise that are never answered. This makes me wonder whether or not they took these issues into consideration when they formed their conclusions. One thing that I do expect a police officer to do well is to form a proper report. They should know that part of the purpose of a report is to answer those questions, so the lack suggests that their investigation was not adequate to determine whether Nancy Weber gains information in a psychic manner. Now the way to be sure is to put those questions to them directly, but if I recall correctly, the responses that were received from them were inadequate or dismissive. I remember finding them unsatisfactory, but I'll have to refresh my memory on the details.

Linda
Do you write textbooks?

You should write textbooks.
 
Where are you looking? I searched the phrase "based on a tip" on google news and lots of stuff comes up. I can find a wide variety of stuff, all of which looks like the same stuff psychics come up with. There doesn't seem to be any distinction made by the reporter or law enforcement, only by the informant. That is, they don't seem to find it unusual to receive useful and useless information from the public. The only mention of whether the information was gained in an unusual manner came from the informants. I'm not sure that it's possible to tell from the kind of information that's received that the source was "psychic". It seems more likely that the police only know this by being told.

http://starbulletin.com/2007/09/19/news/story06.html
http://www.hindu.com/2007/09/17/stories/2007091760250400.htm
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/09/14/MN0LS60VN.DTL
http://www.tucsoncitizen.com/daily/local/63261.php
http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcon...tcdeath_08met.ART.North.Edition1.42b719b.html
http://www.imedinews.ge/en/news_read/63293

Missing persons:
http://www.thekansascitychannel.com/news/14077808/detail.html
http://origin.sltrib.com/ci_6824492
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0108/01/bn.05.html
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/03/31/earlyshow/main1458699.shtml
http://www.operationlookout.org/lookoutmag/CDA_Police_Assist_FBI.htm
http://www.findkatherinefry.com/news.php
http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2004/07/10/tamra040710.html
http://www.jsonline.com/story/index.aspx?id=620775

Linda

None of the above stories have any relevance to what I'm talking about. Of course, non-psychic tipsters are besieging the police day and night, and in some cases have worthwhile information. But what I'm asking is whether a non-psychic has done what you seem to think that you might be able to do; i.e., examined the same evidence the police have and pointed them in a new, accurate direction. For example, in the case of the missing Canadian woman, if a non-psychic had examined the evidence and concluded that the police were looking in the wrong place for her body and pointed them to the correct location, as Norm Pratt did, I would be impressed. However, I don't know of any cases like that. Do you?
 
Rodney,

Norm Pratt said that he thought they were looking in the wrong place (which is a fairly safe bet given that they had been looking in the same area for some time and hadn't found anything) and then Pratt himself searched for the body for several weeks (was it months?) before finding the clothing (not the body).

What exactly did Norm Pratt do that hasn't been done before by non-psychics? People search and find missing people after the police have given up and moved on to other cases. What do you think Norm Pratt did that would constitute evidence of psychic abilities?
 
Last edited:
None of the above stories have any relevance to what I'm talking about. Of course, non-psychic tipsters are besieging the police day and night, and in some cases have worthwhile information. But what I'm asking is whether a non-psychic has done what you seem to think that you might be able to do; i.e., examined the same evidence the police have and pointed them in a new, accurate direction.

Why this requirement when it has yet to be established that this is what any psychics do?

I will concede that there have probably been individual police officers that have, on their own initiative, called a psychic and asked them to review the case. There may even be police departments that, depending upon the personality of those in charge, do this on a regular basis. But all we have been presented with evidence of is that occasionally, some of what they say can be retrofitted as accurate after the police have found the perpetrator through normal methods, and that police officers are subject to the same cognitive biases as everyone else. What you have failed to provide is any evidence that this is different from what would happen using a control. You may claim that a control is not needed because the results are too amazing, but over and over again you have shown us that you are a poor judge of what is amazing, and a poor judge of what those of us without psychic powers can do.

For example, in the case of the missing Canadian woman, if a non-psychic had examined the evidence and concluded that the police were looking in the wrong place for her body and pointed them to the correct location, as Norm Pratt did, I would be impressed. However, I don't know of any cases like that. Do you?

Every friend and family that keeps looking for someone that is missing is doing just that. I have been involved in a couple of cases (through working in the medical examiners office) of bodies found by laypeople who have continued looking for someone weeks after the person had gone missing. Norm Pratt was simply someone who kept looking for the missing woman in the same general area that she had gone missing. Of course one moves on after they have thoroughly searched an area. You keep treating this idea as some sort of profound revelation instead of the profoundly obvious.

Linda
 
Why this requirement when it has yet to be established that this is what any psychics do?

I will concede that there have probably been individual police officers that have, on their own initiative, called a psychic and asked them to review the case. There may even be police departments that, depending upon the personality of those in charge, do this on a regular basis. But all we have been presented with evidence of is that occasionally, some of what they say can be retrofitted as accurate after the police have found the perpetrator through normal methods, and that police officers are subject to the same cognitive biases as everyone else. What you have failed to provide is any evidence that this is different from what would happen using a control. You may claim that a control is not needed because the results are too amazing, but over and over again you have shown us that you are a poor judge of what is amazing, and a poor judge of what those of us without psychic powers can do.



Every friend and family that keeps looking for someone that is missing is doing just that. I have been involved in a couple of cases (through working in the medical examiners office) of bodies found by laypeople who have continued looking for someone weeks after the person had gone missing. Norm Pratt was simply someone who kept looking for the missing woman in the same general area that she had gone missing. Of course one moves on after they have thoroughly searched an area. You keep treating this idea as some sort of profound revelation instead of the profoundly obvious.

Linda
It would be even more profoundly obvious if you, Bri, or Garrette could come up with an on-point example of a non-psychic doing what Norm Pratt and Annette Martin have done.
 
It would be even more profoundly obvious if you, Bri, or Garrette could come up with an on-point example of a non-psychic doing what Norm Pratt and Annette Martin have done.

As soon as you tell us exactly what you think they've done, I'll attempt to honor your request.

-Bri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom