NIST Report - Split from: The JREF Conspiracy Theory subforum appreciation thread

Did the NIST report give a comparative analysis for controlled demolition?

Nick

Cut down to a specific question.

Answer: read it yourself. It's available. Then please report. Inquiring minds want to know.
 
I see on the Net that a chap called Richard Gage is contesting the report.

Are you stating, for the record, 8Den, that his claims do not raise significant doubt in the OT?

Ah yes, the nuclear bombs group.

He might not but I will. I am stating, for the record, that not a single word from ae911truth raises a significant doubt. Not even an insignificant doubt. If you disagree, let's talk about it. First, however, I -strongly- encourage you to use the search function, though, because they and their claims have been fairly systematically demolished repeatedly.

That being said, his anti-scientific method is an excellent case study in the psychology of conspiracism, though.
 
Nick, why is that all bar one the links provided by a&e911truth for their claims go to conspiracy websites and not to the work of structural engineers? The exception is a link to a paper published by Steven Jones in his own journal.
 
I see on the Net that a chap called Richard Gage is contesting the report. He's claiming, apparently, that there are now 192 professionals in the the fields of architecture and structural engineering backing him www.ae911truth.org.

Are you stating, for the record, 8Den, that his claims do not raise significant doubt in the OT?

Richard Gage is not a structural engineer, and his claims have been discussed in great detail here and found to have no merit. In effect he is as credible as if he were to state that the WTC towers were demolished by magic pixies using oofle dust, and the doubts his claims raise in the accepted version of history are no more significant. I suspect you'll find a very large number of people on this forum who will go on record as agreeing with that point of view.

Dave
 
Richard Gage is not a structural engineer, and his claims have been discussed in great detail here and found to have no merit. In effect he is as credible as if he were to state that the WTC towers were demolished by magic pixies using oofle dust, and the doubts his claims raise in the accepted version of history are no more significant. I suspect you'll find a very large number of people on this forum who will go on record as agreeing with that point of view.

Dave
Did they test for oofle dust? If not, this brings the OT into serious doubt, and a new investigation should commence forthwith.
 
Disbelief:

No, it's ok for all you JREF conspiracy debunkers to be palls....

I just marvel at the sameness of your thinking, .... your one world view.

Shocking. I've seen plenty of things here that I don't agree with, and I will speak up. I am not a debunker per se, as I have little expertise in the required fields. However, I will answer questions when I know what I am talking about from my own personal experience.

So, why the animosity? Are you just anti-government? Anti-authority? Anti-establishment? You say you are only looking at the science, but the tone of many of your posts hints at other things. Maybe you just never like to be wrong?
 
Well, as a psychological analysis, I would say that your description "half-done" is rather generous...
My remark - those JREFers being insecure - was merely an observation of what I assumed was obvious.

As for the CT people, speaking generally of course, I think their psychology is quite different.
They probably see themselves as fighting for 'truth', trying to bring the 'evil perpetrators' to account... I'm sure it's quite complex.

But one difference is that they don't sit there, in that comfortable, safe, majority position, bashing their 'out-numbered' victims, which is what some of the above mentioned JREFers like to do

I find people often use the label "insecure" as a belittling tactic, aimed to lessen the legitimacy of the arguer through a personal attack on their motive and stability. I have found noone here at JREF to post or behave in such a way as to exhibit insecurity.

As for the "complexity" of the truther persona/psychology, here are a few LABELS we could use...Rebellious, Anarchist, Idealist, Anti-Government, Cult-like....etc...

As for suggesting the truthers do not "sit there, in that comfortable, safe, majority position, bashing their 'out-numbered' victims", may I introduce you to the Loose Change Forum, or 9/11 Blogger...give me a break.

I see on the Net that a chap called Richard Gage is contesting the report. He's claiming, apparently, that there are now 192 professionals in the the fields of architecture and structural engineering backing him www.ae911truth.org.

Are you stating, for the record, 8Den, that his claims do not raise significant doubt in the OT?

Did the NIST report give a comparative analysis for controlled demolition?

Nick

I would state that his claims raise no more doubt than was already there. His audience, and those he impresses, is limited to the truth movement, who would buy his stuff lock stock and barrel anyway. He has rehashed the existing truther canards and re-inforced them through adding a false sense of legitimacy to them through his "authority" as a building structure and design professional.

As for a comparative analysis for CD, lol, see JimBenArm:

Did they test for oofle dust? If not, this brings the OT into serious doubt, and a new investigation should commence forthwith.

as well, I would add that they did not approach the "alien's did it" concept, or "Leprachauns did it" or "Time Travelers did it" either.

TAM;)
 
What I am trying to say is that all the JREF conspiracy debunkers appear to accept the NIST Report as true or certainly quite accurate and more than sufficient to explain why the Twin Towers collapsed.

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.

Having been told what I believe, I think some kind of response is reasonable. I don't accept the NIST report as the be-all-and-end-all of why the Twin Towers collapsed. Like any other piece of scientific investigation, it's the best we can do at the moment, and it should be open to debate. As far as I can see, there are two debates going on.

The first debate, which you yourself are contributing to, addresses the question of whether the specific mechanism of collapse described by NIST is accurate. In particular, the issue of whether the fireproofing removal was necessary for collapse, whether it occurred to the extent that NIST predicts, whether the structure of the building was suffucuently well-designed and the build quality sufficiently good to withstand a major fire, and whether there were significant other sources of chemical energy in the building that NIST overlooked. These are important concerns that affect the safety of steel-framed buildings everywhere; for example, the proliferation of IT equipment in the modern office may well present an underestimated fire hazard, or SFRM may perform less well than tests indicate, and if these concerns are reasonable then building codes should be adjusted to reflect them. However, all sides in this debate work consider the assumption reasonable that some combination of impact damage (whether only to the structure or to the fireproofing as well) were the causes of collapse.

The majority of the opposition in the second debate rejects the conclusions of NIST entirely and seeks to supplant them with a narrative based on highly dubious extrapolations from observations, suppositions, fallacious reasoning and deliberate deception, designed to support a predetermined conclusion that a shadowy controlling organisation is behind the WTC collapses, as it is behind all other major historical events. This narrative is frequently seen to contain enormous logical flaws, physically unreasonable assumptions and outright lies so obvious that their originators cannot possibly have generated them as innocent mistakes.

There is, it seems to me, a tendency on JREF to confuse the proponents of the two opposing positions, a tendency exascerbated by your own deliberate blurring of the distinction between the two for what I suspect is your own amusement. Not that I personally have a problem with that; I've worked as a scientist among scientists for most of my life, and I know our sense of humour can tend towards the bizarre. However, there is a kind of seige mentality that dubs anyone disagreeing with NIST as a woo merchant, sometimes unfairly. It's the sort of thing that happens in any highly polarised and emotive argument, and it's just people being human.

As for my view of people who reject the NIST report: if they reject it in whole or in part after studying it and present well-reasoned arguments for doing so, then I will generally respect their point of view, as I do yours. Those who reject it entirely based on no particular understanding because it disagrees with a pre-determined conclusion, I would assume fall into one or more of the categories you list, or one other: the innocently misinformed.

If you honestly believe that the JREF posters are a monolithic group with a single set of opinions on all conspiracy-related matters, I suggest a look at the "Conspiracy to steal the vote again in 2008" thread (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=82360), where there is at least some difference of opinion to be found.

That any of the following historical events could not possibly have involved anything that could be described as a conspiracy: the JFK assassination, the RFK assassination, the death of Marilyn Monroe, the death of Karen Silkwood, the Jonestown massacre, the death of Senator Wellstone, the assassination of Olaf Palme, the conviction of Abdel Basset Ali Mohamed al Megrahi, the death of Lady Diana, the crash of TWA 800, the OKC bombing, the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, the death of David Kelly, the Waco massacre, the assassination of Martin Luther King, the death of Danny Casolaro, the death of Pope John Paul I, the sinking of the MS Estonia, .... to mention but a few!

While I don't know enough about all of these to comment, the pro-conspiracy evidence for those I know enough about seems to be no better than the 9-11 pro-conspiracy evidence. I'm prepared to believe that others might involve a conspiracy; what I refuse at present to countenance is that they are all part of the same conspiracy.

Dave
 
I see on the Net that a chap called Richard Gage is contesting the report. He's claiming, apparently, that there are now 192 professionals in the the fields of architecture and structural engineering backing him www.ae911truth.org.

Are you stating, for the record, 8Den, that his claims do not raise significant doubt in the OT?

I will go on the record and state that yes, his claims do not raise any sort of doubt.

More than that, I highly suspect his claim that 192 professionals in the fields of architecture and structural engineering back him. Do a search for "SCAM" relating to ae911truth and you should find some enlightening information...
 
I will go on the record and state that yes, his claims do not raise any sort of doubt.

More than that, I highly suspect his claim that 192 professionals in the fields of architecture and structural engineering back him. Do a search for "SCAM" relating to ae911truth and you should find some enlightening information...

Indeed! The thread I was thinking of was this one, where we discussed the A&E911T debacle with their very own membership manager, Mr. Doug Plumb. His responses made it quite clear that he is no shape to argue on scientific or engineering grounds... particularly here where he starts going off the deep end, and here where he finishes, only a short time later. But the whole thread is quite an eye-opener.

This is their recruiter.

Even if we didn't have personal contact with them and experience with their unabated lunacy, the simple fact is that, no matter how many professionals they claim to have, none of them has ever produced a single paper -- not even a conference paper -- supporting their beliefs. There are dozens of papers (from real scientists and engineers) in refereed literature, and guess what? They don't all agree with each other, not at all, but not one lends the slightest credence to, ahem, "alternate" theories of Sept. 11th.

Their value as a professional body, since the sum total of their membership has produced exactly nothing on their chosen focus subject, is nil. Thus they raise no doubt with respect to the NIST conclusions whatsoever.
 
Indeed! The thread I was thinking of was this one, where we discussed the A&E911T debacle with their very own membership manager, Mr. Doug Plumb. His responses made it quite clear that he is no shape to argue on scientific or engineering grounds... particularly here where he starts going off the deep end, and here where he finishes, only a short time later. But the whole thread is quite an eye-opener.

This is their recruiter.

Even if we didn't have personal contact with them and experience with their unabated lunacy, the simple fact is that, no matter how many professionals they claim to have, none of them has ever produced a single paper -- not even a conference paper -- supporting their beliefs. There are dozens of papers (from real scientists and engineers) in refereed literature, and guess what? They don't all agree with each other, not at all, but not one lends the slightest credence to, ahem, "alternate" theories of Sept. 11th.

Their value as a professional body, since the sum total of their membership has produced exactly nothing on their chosen focus subject, is nil. Thus they raise no doubt with respect to the NIST conclusions whatsoever.
...but...but...they have questions. They have all kinds of unqualified bozos asking them. Why do you have to be so mean to them? You big meanie!
 
Indeed! The thread I was thinking of was this one, where we discussed the A&E911T debacle with their very own membership manager, Mr. Doug Plumb. His responses made it quite clear that he is no shape to argue on scientific or engineering grounds... particularly here where he starts going off the deep end, and here where he finishes, only a short time later. But the whole thread is quite an eye-opener.

Thanks for posting this, R. I don't have so much a problem with Doug's views in your "here" links, but the fact that he appears to go into this stuff when his professional opinion on the WTC collapse is questioned doesn't bode too good. Reads a little as though he's saying that imminent NWO takeover justifies fallacious science. He's out of it, imo.

Nick


This is their recruiter.

Even if we didn't have personal contact with them and experience with their unabated lunacy, the simple fact is that, no matter how many professionals they claim to have, none of them has ever produced a single paper -- not even a conference paper -- supporting their beliefs. There are dozens of papers (from real scientists and engineers) in refereed literature, and guess what? They don't all agree with each other, not at all, but not one lends the slightest credence to, ahem, "alternate" theories of Sept. 11th.

Their value as a professional body, since the sum total of their membership has produced exactly nothing on their chosen focus subject, is nil. Thus they raise no doubt with respect to the NIST conclusions whatsoever.[/QUOTE]
 
Thanks. Sounds great. Does it assess the possibility that the buildings were brought down by controlled demolition, as some other structural engineers are suggesting?

Nick

NIST said:
WTC towers collapsed because: (1) the impact of the planes severed and damaged support columns, dislodged fireproofing insulation coating the steel floor trusses and steel columns, and widely dispersed jet fuel over multiple floors; and (2) the subsequent unusually large jet-fuel ignited multi-floor fires (which reached temperatures as high as 1,000 degrees Celsius) significantly weakened the floors and columns with dislodged fireproofing to the point where floors sagged and pulled inward on the perimeter columns. This led to the inward bowing of the perimeter columns and failure of the south face of WTC 1 and the east face of WTC 2, initiating the collapse of each of the towers. Both photographic and video evidence—as well as accounts from the New York Police Department aviation unit during a half-hour period prior to collapse—support this sequence for each tower.

NIST’s findings do not support the “pancake theory” of collapse, which is premised on a progressive failure of the floor systems in the WTC towers (the composite floor system—that connected the core columns and the perimeter columns—consisted of a grid of steel “trusses” integrated with a concrete slab; see diagram below). Instead, the NIST investigation showed conclusively that the failure of the inwardly bowed perimeter columns initiated collapse and that the occurrence of this inward bowing required the sagging floors to remain connected to the columns and pull the columns inwards. Thus, the floors did not fail progressively to cause a pancaking phenomenon.

NIST’s findings also do not support the “controlled demolition” theory since there is conclusive evidence that:

-The collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC towers and nowhere else, and;

-The time it took for the collapse to initiate (56 minutes for WTC 2 and 102 minutes for WTC 1) was dictated by (1) the extent of damage caused by the aircraft impact, and (2) the time it took for the fires to reach critical locations and weaken the structure to the point that the towers could not resist the tremendous energy released by the downward movement of the massive top section of the building at and above the fire and impact floors.

Video evidence also showed unambiguously that the collapse progressed from the top to the bottom, and there was no evidence (collected by NIST, or by the New York Police Department, the Port Authority Police Department or the Fire Department of New York) of any blast or explosions in the region below the impact and fire floors as the top building sections (including and above the 98th floor in WTC 1 and the 82nd floor in WTC 2) began their downward movement upon collapse initiation.

In summary, NIST found no corroborating evidence for alternative hypotheses suggesting that the WTC towers were brought down by controlled demolition using explosives planted prior to Sept. 11, 2001. NIST also did not find any evidence that missiles were fired at or hit the towers. Instead, photographs and videos from several angles clearly show that the collapse initiated at the fire and impact floors and that the collapse progressed from the initiating floors downward until the dust clouds obscured the view.

NIST found no evidence to support a controlled demolition hypothesis, and found that their collapse mechanism was, in fact, in agreement with the available evidence (photographs, eyewitnesses etc).

What evidence have they overlooked that supports the theory that bombs were the cause of collapse?
 
NIST found no evidence to support a controlled demolition hypothesis, and found that their collapse mechanism was, in fact, in agreement with the available evidence (photographs, eyewitnesses etc).

What evidence have they overlooked that supports the theory that bombs were the cause of collapse?

Hyperviolet,

I have read that page of the NIST report, thanks to Garb, who kindly forwarded it to me. I am simply unable to give any meaningful level of opinion about it, or its truthfulness, because I'm neither qualified to do so nor sufficiently knowledgable about these kinds of engineering principles. You may or may not consider this a "cop out." That's up to you.

What concerns me is that there is a seemingly large group of qualified building professionals out there, under the ae911truth banner, who are claiming that the findings of the NIST report are incorrect. There's a wieldy-looking list of them up here. I say "looking" because for sure these things are not always what they seem. However, it does concern me and I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides.

Nick
 
Hyperviolet,

I have read that page of the NIST report, thanks to Garb, who kindly forwarded it to me. I am simply unable to give any meaningful level of opinion about it, or its truthfulness, because I'm neither qualified to do so nor sufficiently knowledgable about these kinds of engineering principles. You may or may not consider this a "cop out." That's up to you.

What concerns me is that there is a seemingly large group of qualified building professionals out there, under the ae911truth banner, who are claiming that the findings of the NIST report are incorrect. There's a wieldy-looking list of them up here. I say "looking" because for sure these things are not always what they seem. However, it does concern me and I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides.

Nick

it depends on what you mean by "large group". When compared to the number of architects and engineers you might personally be acquainted with it might seem large, but when it is compared with the total number of architects and engineers in the U.S. (let alone the world) the number of signers of Gage's petition is insignificant.

The number of members of AE9/11Truth is not as important as what they produce, and as far as I know they have yet to write any articles or produce any analyses that support their positions. I understand that you might not feel qualified to critique technical articles (whether supporting the "official story" or other alternatives) but there are plenty of people here who do. The lack of such articles does not bode well for Gage&Co's credibility with me, because I think that if they feel this strongly about their claims they should be able to back them up.
 
Hyperviolet,

I have read that page of the NIST report, thanks to Garb, who kindly forwarded it to me. I am simply unable to give any meaningful level of opinion about it, or its truthfulness, because I'm neither qualified to do so nor sufficiently knowledgable about these kinds of engineering principles. You may or may not consider this a "cop out." That's up to you.

What concerns me is that there is a seemingly large group of qualified building professionals out there, under the ae911truth banner, who are claiming that the findings of the NIST report are incorrect. There's a wieldy-looking list of them up here. I say "looking" because for sure these things are not always what they seem. However, it does concern me and I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides.

Nick

Nick,

Sorry, i did not see that Garb had already pointed you to that. My apologies.

AE911truth has already been exposed as a scam by MarkyX. The engineers listed did not need to show any credentials, or even have their identity verified. MarkyX listed himself as an engineer on their site, as did "George W Bush."

I recommend you have a watch at Gravy's video (Specifically from 6min 10 seconds onward, but watching the whole thing is advised).
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=2083421624495848233&hl=en
This video has clear visual evidence that corroborates the NIST findings that the sagging floors caused an inward bowing of the perimeter columns, which led to collapse initiation.

It is visually clear that the building was buckling from the impact point. What role did the bombs play in causing this?
 
However, it does concern me and I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides.

Nick

Part of the problem is that Gage&Co are not interested in debate. This was made clear when they closed their original open forum (the statement said that "the time for debate is past") and opened the members-only forum. You can't become a member unless you sign Gage's petition, so he is automatically ruling out discussion with people who don't agree with him.
 
I will go on the record and state that yes, his claims do not raise any sort of doubt.

More than that, I highly suspect his claim that 192 professionals in the fields of architecture and structural engineering back him. Do a search for "SCAM" relating to ae911truth and you should find some enlightening information...

The first google brought up this. It wasn't so conclusive. I didn't see Barney Rubble in Gage's list so I would have thought these guy's names could be at least checked out they exist and work in this field. For sure, he could have grabbed them from a directory, I guess.

Nick
 
What concerns me is that there is a seemingly large group of qualified building professionals out there, under the ae911truth banner, who are claiming that the findings of the NIST report are incorrect. There's a wieldy-looking list of them up here. I say "looking" because for sure these things are not always what they seem. However, it does concern me and I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides.

Why do you even want to see evidence on either side of this debate, since you just said you won't be able to understand squat?

Educate yourself or just leave this debate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom