NIST Report - Split from: The JREF Conspiracy Theory subforum appreciation thread

Apollo20

Banned
Joined
Mar 28, 2007
Messages
1,425
Childlike Princess:

This thread , drenched as it is in embarrassing obsequiousness, only serves to confirm my initial suspicion, going back to the days when I first posted here, that the JREF Conspiracy Theory sub-forum is nothing more than a vehicle for the authoritarian proclamations of a doctrinaire mutual admiration society.

But then again, perhaps I am being too harsh...
 
Childlike Princess:

This thread , drenched as it is in embarrassing obsequiousness, only serves to confirm my initial suspicion, going back to the days when I first posted here, that the JREF Conspiracy Theory sub-forum is nothing more than a vehicle for the authoritarian proclamations of a doctrinaire mutual admiration society.

But then again, perhaps I am being too harsh...

So, people can't be friendly with each other here? Something wrong with being nice amidst the technical threads? A lot of people have learned new and different things here and can communicate with people from other countries and cultures. Nothing wrong with saying thanks.
 
Childlike Princess:

This thread , drenched as it is in embarrassing obsequiousness, only serves to confirm my initial suspicion, going back to the days when I first posted here, that the JREF Conspiracy Theory sub-forum is nothing more than a vehicle for the authoritarian proclamations of a doctrinaire mutual admiration society.

But then again, perhaps I am being too harsh...

No, come on now - tell us what you really think!
 
We are witnessing the most self-important Kindergarten on the net. Ever. Ever.

Please look at Rule 11 of the Membership Agreement you agreed to. Do not derail this thread.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady

Why does the creepy German guy who pretends he's a woman only come out in threads that don't deal with the facts about 9/11? Is it because he knows he's completely clueless?
 
Childlike Princess:

This thread , drenched as it is in embarrassing obsequiousness, only serves to confirm my initial suspicion, going back to the days when I first posted here, that the JREF Conspiracy Theory sub-forum is nothing more than a vehicle for the authoritarian proclamations of a doctrinaire mutual admiration society.

But then again, perhaps I am being too harsh...

We love you too, you curmudgeonly teddy bear, you!
 
Disbelief:

No, it's ok for all you JREF conspiracy debunkers to be palls....

I just marvel at the sameness of your thinking, .... your one world view.
 
Disbelief:

No, it's ok for all you JREF conspiracy debunkers to be palls....

I just marvel at the sameness of your thinking, .... your one world view.

Like how we all have exactly the same political views? Or like how we all believe that the world is round?
 
Disbelief:

No, it's ok for all you JREF conspiracy debunkers to be palls....

I just marvel at the sameness of your thinking, .... your one world view.

Really? Because we believe the official (logical) version of the events of 9/11 is more or less true, we all think the same? Is that the only thing that constitutes one's world-view, whether he thinks 9/11 was an "inside job" or not?

How very simplistic.
 
Like how we all have exactly the same political views? Or like how we all believe that the world is round?

Touche.

I'm guessing that since we don't buy into the "9/11 was an inside job" mantra that means we have "one world view."

You have no idea what my "world view" is Doc nor would I guess that you do of most of the others here either. How can you make a blanket statement like that and still expect to be taken seriously?
 
Like how we all have exactly the same political views? Or like how we all believe that the world is round?
I'm wondering the same thing... perhaps Apollo20 will clear things up by being more precise in his critique.
 
What I am trying to say is that all the JREF conspiracy debunkers appear to accept the NIST Report as true or certainly quite accurate and more than sufficient to explain why the Twin Towers collapsed.

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.

(Am I right so far?.... hope this is not considered a derail of this thread, but I have been asked to elaborate!)

That conspiracy debunking is, (pick one or more from the list): a sign of intelligence, a noble cause, a public service, educational, pest control, patriotic....

That any of the following historical events could not possibly have involved anything that could be described as a conspiracy: the JFK assassination, the RFK assassination, the death of Marilyn Monroe, the death of Karen Silkwood, the Jonestown massacre, the death of Senator Wellstone, the assassination of Olaf Palme, the conviction of Abdel Basset Ali Mohamed al Megrahi, the death of Lady Diana, the crash of TWA 800, the OKC bombing, the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, the death of David Kelly, the Waco massacre, the assassination of Martin Luther King, the death of Danny Casolaro, the death of Pope John Paul I, the sinking of the MS Estonia, .... to mention but a few!
 
What I am trying to say is that all the JREF conspiracy debunkers appear to accept the NIST Report as true or certainly quite accurate and more than sufficient to explain why the Twin Towers collapsed.
no it is the best explanation we have so far- there will always be room for improvement. There has been criticism of NIST here, but just because some questions remain unanswered does not mean that therefore all other explanations are equally plausible. The fact that there is some ambiguity over some aspects of the collapse mechanism doesn't mean that 9/11 was an inside job, or that crashing airliners into tall buildings doesn't make them fall down.

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.
No anyone who thinks otherwise without providing any evidence is basing their decision on something other than evidence.

(Am I right so far?.... )
no.

That conspiracy debunking is, (pick one or more from the list): a sign of intelligence, a noble cause, a public service, educational, pest control, patriotic....
can it not be any of those things?

That any of the following historical events could not possibly have involved anything that could be described as a conspiracy: the JFK assassination, the RFK assassination, the death of Marilyn Monroe, the death of Karen Silkwood, the Jonestown massacre, the death of Senator Wellstone, the assassination of Olaf Palme, the conviction of Abdel Basset Ali Mohamed al Megrahi, the death of Lady Diana, the crash of TWA 800, the OKC bombing, the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, the death of David Kelly, the Waco massacre, the assassination of Martin Luther King, the death of Danny Casolaro, the death of Pope John Paul I, the sinking of the MS Estonia, .... to mention but a few!

Nope, we have repeatedly drawn a distinction between "a conspiracy" (any criminal act involving more than one person) and the grand paranoid conspiracy theories . We will go where the evidence leads.
 
So our "one world view" is selected from a list of:

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.

...at least 6 different options, compounded with choices from a further list of:


That conspiracy debunking is, (pick one or more from the list): a sign of intelligence, a noble cause, a public service, educational, pest control, patriotic....


...at least 6 more options, of which we can mix-n-match more than one.


I know you're bright enough to do the math to show the actual number of "world views" this constitutes.


But here's a hint: It's more than one.
 
What I am trying to say is that all the JREF conspiracy debunkers appear to accept the NIST Report as true or certainly quite accurate and more than sufficient to explain why the Twin Towers collapsed.

Not I. I have contended that the NIST report is the best investigation to date, and appears to be valid (from what I have read others post) in what it attempts to explain. I have also expressed interest in your suggestion that other heat sources, such as various plastic and polymer compounds may have played a role. I have also been quite interested in the iron spherules and their origins.

Where we part, I feel, is in the need to entertain outlandish theories that have little scientific merit, and even less evidence to support them. I am not saying you are a proponent of such theories, but you seem to encourage their exploration, and in so do, indirectly encourage the accusations carried with them.

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.

You think otherwise, and I have not called you a fool, liar, non-scientist, Bush Hater, or delusional. I cannot remember if I called you paranoid or not...I doubt it.

(Am I right so far?.... hope this is not considered a derail of this thread, but I have been asked to elaborate!)

You are wrong simply because you are generalizing without admitting to it.

That conspiracy debunking is, (pick one or more from the list): a sign of intelligence, a noble cause, a public service, educational, pest control, patriotic....

I think it takes intelligence to effectively debate either side. I think it is noble to defend those I feel are innocent. I do feel we are performing a public service, the same way a man exposing a snake oil salesman would be. I think there is a lot of education that goes on here at JREF, in all the forums. In SOME cases, what we do here MOST DEFINITELY is pest control...Patriotism...less so, as almost 50% of the posters here are not from the USA.

That any of the following historical events could not possibly have involved anything that could be described as a conspiracy: the JFK assassination, the RFK assassination, the death of Marilyn Monroe, the death of Karen Silkwood, the Jonestown massacre, the death of Senator Wellstone, the assassination of Olaf Palme, the conviction of Abdel Basset Ali Mohamed al Megrahi, the death of Lady Diana, the crash of TWA 800, the OKC bombing, the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, the death of David Kelly, the Waco massacre, the assassination of Martin Luther King, the death of Danny Casolaro, the death of Pope John Paul I, the sinking of the MS Estonia, .... to mention but a few!

Bring the evidence on either and debate with someone on it. I personally have little interest in any of the CTs you mention above.

TAM:)
 
That any of the following historical events could not possibly have involved anything that could be described as a conspiracy: the JFK assassination, the RFK assassination, the death of Marilyn Monroe, the death of Karen Silkwood, the Jonestown massacre, the death of Senator Wellstone, the assassination of Olaf Palme, the conviction of Abdel Basset Ali Mohamed al Megrahi, the death of Lady Diana, the crash of TWA 800, the OKC bombing, the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, the death of David Kelly, the Waco massacre, the assassination of Martin Luther King, the death of Danny Casolaro, the death of Pope John Paul I, the sinking of the MS Estonia, .... to mention but a few!

The problem is that you believe all of them were conspiracies.

You seem to be the one with the fantasy-proned personality, and you seem to be the one with no critical thinking skills beyond your field of expertise.

I'm not saying none of these events are not conspiracies, I haven't researched them all, but all of them?

Strangely enough, you forgot the moon landing, have you change your mind about that one? Given your username, I would have expected it to have been mentioned.
 
Last edited:
What I am trying to say is that all the JREF conspiracy debunkers appear to accept the NIST Report as true or certainly quite accurate and more than sufficient to explain why the Twin Towers collapsed.

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.
It took me five minutes of research to find papers that cite 1000 degrees as well within the realm of an office fire. Not a petroleum fire but an office fire. Five minutes.... That's why we call people: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc. In fact I'll add one more: lazy.
the JFK assassination,
The JFK assassination is special in the fact that it happened the original story but it was really dam freaky. A group of people actually showed a doctor the dummies they shot and even he believed it was the work of two bullets. .
 
Last edited:
So, people can't be friendly with each other here? Something wrong with being nice amidst the technical threads? A lot of people have learned new and different things here and can communicate with people from other countries and cultures. Nothing wrong with saying thanks.
Friendly?

holy mackerel
 
What I am trying to say is that all the JREF conspiracy debunkers appear to accept the NIST Report as true or certainly quite accurate and more than sufficient to explain why the Twin Towers collapsed.
Should I take the above to mean you find the NIST report less than sufficient to explain why the towers collapsed?

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.
Well, from where I'm sitting, plenty of CT proponents who have posted here have made comments which are decidedly anti-Bush. Some CT proponents who have posted here have offered theories which border on the delusional (e.g. no jets hit the towers, the towers were destroyed by a space-based beam weapon of some kind).

It seems to me there is some justification for the reaction, though you perhaps have a point if the reaction occurs before someone has had the chance to fully spell out their views.

That conspiracy debunking is, (pick one or more from the list): a sign of intelligence, a noble cause, a public service, educational, pest control, patriotic....
Each person's motivations are different, but I suspect if you asked enough people you'd eventually have all the items on your list mentioned. So what? Is that any better or worse than CT proponents coming here and wanting to spread what they think is the truth?

That any of the following historical events could not possibly have involved anything that could be described as a conspiracy...
Seems to me the key words there are "not possibly." How should that be interpreted? Exactly as you state it, meaning an absolutely 0% chance of a conspiracy being involed in any of the events you listed? Or do you mean it in the more common beyond a reasonable doubt that a conspiracy was involved?

Two very different burdens of proof there. It's rather difficult to demonstrate events such as you mentioned are not conspiracies beyond any doubt. It is possible though to demonstrate they are not conspiracies beyond a reasonable doubt.
 
Horatius et al.:

First of all, because I like to please people, recognize that what I am about to say is simply what you guys EXPECT me to say, WANT me to say... Dare I say, NEED me to say! So I will try not to disappoint - after all, I too am archetypal in my behavior, (See below.)

Secondly, please don't consider anything I am about to say as a personal affront. Just as I can't help being what I am, and saying what I HAVE TO SAY, you can't help being what you are! Nevertheless, I am sure you are all "good" persons, who love your kids (if you have any), give to charities and dislike Bush (don't we all!).

But having said all that, I still see the JRERer's debunking-batallion as having what I call a "one world view" and would claim that this cohort of posters is not engaged in a nobel cause but a reactionary act of supression. There are many reasons I say this. I have already mentioned a few... here are a few more:

* They become very annoyed at those who do not share their one world consensus view.
* They tend to be bigoted.
* They believe they are always right and are therefore lacking in humility.
* They tend to be supercilious and smug.
* They have a mutual need to engage in self-satisfied ego stroking -as in the "appreciation" thread from which this thread devolved- because they have never experienced ego loss.
* They are incapable of thinking outside the box.
* They buy any story fed to them by government agencies.
* They tend to be patriotic, and this is not just referring to your typical American's reaction to 9/11 - the Brits, Canajuns (Eh), and Aussies are just as bad.
* They tend to give "smart-aleck" answers.
* They like to argue from authority - 200 NIST scientists can't be wrong!
* They always ask you to "show me the evidence", but ignore it when they dont like what they see; then they turn around and claim you havn't shown them any evidence!
* They are not much fun to debate because they are so predictable in their answers/ beliefs. Thus I already KNOW what to expect by way of objections to this post!

Now, I acknowledge that everyone is, of course, different to some degree; so some members of the conspiracy debunker's battalion may not have (or revealed) all of these traits; still others show traits I have not yet addressed. That's why I listed options in my last post to allow for some variability in the behavior patterns of JREF "one world viewers". But on the whole they represent a particular archetype that I see here in the same old crowd of one world view posters. I wont name names but let's just say posters such as T, E, P, L, G, P, C, U, R, H, etc, etc....

Yes, a veritable alphabet soup of reactionary thinking!

Now make me laugh - tell me I'm wrong!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom