NIST Report - Split from: The JREF Conspiracy Theory subforum appreciation thread

I'm pretty sure everyone here is more or less an adult. Also, the attacks are only verbal; you don't get hurt, not really; so why complain?


I am not complaining at all, but merely stating my own viewpoint, which is more or less in agreement with what Apollo20 stated earlier.

It's just the way I am - I usually like to give my opinion when I see bigotry, smugness, bullying, etc.
 
Note the bolded word. Lots of "tend" in there. Which leads me to think the you're overgeneralizing at the very least.

And what would your psychological analysis be of the CT proponents who keep coming back to this place over and over while making the same faulty arguments over and over?

There's all sorts people in this world with many different opinions, faults, what have you.
I sometimes don't like certain people's opinions, I somtimes don't like their attitudes... I see people doing all sorts of things I learned not to do long ago.

But I don't need to go out and systematically attack them - it would be a full time occupation, for starters :)
 
The JREFers in question seem to prefer what you describe as "4-inch puts ". Otherwise why would they perpetuate, rather than ignore, those threads where the main aim is to attack and feed off their out-numbered, 'easy' victim?

You wouldn't expect a group of golf champions to regularly seek out beginners in order to mock them - they don't feel the need to do that.

But that's exactly the sort of thing many JREFers do - and on a regular basis.
If there are arguments that are more challenging than 4-inch putts, I am certain they would be welcome. We cannot determine who comes here, and which arguments they bring. If no-planers, space-based energy beamers, mini-nukers, or free-fall speeders show up, those are the putts available. If challengers continue to quote out of context, misrepresent data, and repeat the unexamined errors of their parroted sources, then those are the putts available.
I can't say I have a very favourable opinion of people who come here mainly to gloat...
Some of you guys actually start new threads which have the sole aim of discussing and mocking your latest 'idiotic troother' find.
True.
All this is symptomatic of, amongst other things, insecurity.
Or confidence, if you don't care for outdated freudian armchair psychology.
 
My point is that the JREFers mentioned must be pretty insecure... they have to resort to coming here, day after day, to participate in dishing out a good bashing to some sucker whom they "despise", because he/she is a "twoooofer"...
Look, I could match you diagnosis for diagnosis, and make the CT side look like they were all just one signature shy of a padded cell, but the plain truth is that you are simply wrong. Freud is still popular among some circles, but not in psychology any more. It might make you feel better to believe this about the JREFers, but if you have any regard for truth, you will abandon that little fantasy.
 
There's all sorts people in this world with many different opinions, faults, what have you.
I sometimes don't like certain people's opinions, I somtimes don't like their attitudes... I see people doing all sorts of things I learned not to do long ago.

But I don't need to go out and systematically attack them - it would be a full time occupation, for starters :)

"Need" is your inference. "Enjoy" would give you the same behavior, but a vastly different interpretation.

ETA: Sorry-- I don't mean to come down on you. It is a pet peeve of mine, when people do the armchair diagnosis bit. I don't like it when either side does it.
 
There's all sorts people in this world with many different opinions, faults, what have you.
I sometimes don't like certain people's opinions, I somtimes don't like their attitudes... I see people doing all sorts of things I learned not to do long ago.
So you're going to leave your psychological analysis half-done. Okay then. I'm drawing a conclusion from that.
 
Horatius et al.:

<snip>
Now, I acknowledge that everyone is, of course, different to some degree; so some members of the conspiracy debunker's battalion may not have (or revealed) all of these traits; still others show traits I have not yet addressed. <snip>
Now make me laugh - tell me I'm wrong!
Apollo20
what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
And what meaning do you expect your delusionally self-important statements of unknowing, inexperienced opinion to have with us? What fantasy do you hold that you would believe that your tiny-fisted tantrums would have more weight than that of a leprous desert rat, spinning rabidly in a circle, waiting for the bite of the snake?
The only thing worse than your logic is your manners. I have snipped away most of what you wrote, because, well... it didn't really say anything. Your attempt at constructing a creative flame was pitiful. I mean, really, stringing together a bunch of insults among a load of babbling was hardly effective... Maybe later in life, after you have learned to read, write, spell, and count, you will have more success. True, these are rudimentary skills that many of us "normal" people take for granted that everyone has an easy time of mastering. But we sometimes forget that there are "challenged" persons in this world who find these things more difficult. If I had known, that this was your case then I would have never read your post. It just wouldn't have been "right". Sort of like parking in a handicap space. I wish you the best of luck in the emotional, and social struggles that seem to be placing such a demand on you.
 
So you're going to leave your psychological analysis half-done. Okay then. I'm drawing a conclusion from that.

Well, as a psychological analysis, I would say that your description "half-done" is rather generous...
My remark - those JREFers being insecure - was merely an observation of what I assumed was obvious.

As for the CT people, speaking generally of course, I think their psychology is quite different.
They probably see themselves as fighting for 'truth', trying to bring the 'evil perpetrators' to account... I'm sure it's quite complex.

But one difference is that they don't sit there, in that comfortable, safe, majority position, bashing their 'out-numbered' victims, which is what some of the above mentioned JREFers like to do
 
Apollo20 said:
Horatius et al.:

<snip>
Now, I acknowledge that everyone is, of course, different to some degree; so some members of the conspiracy debunker's battalion may not have (or revealed) all of these traits; still others show traits I have not yet addressed. <snip>
Now make me laugh - tell me I'm wrong!
Apollo20
what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
Quote:
And what meaning do you expect your delusionally self-important statements of unknowing, inexperienced opinion to have with us? What fantasy do you hold that you would believe that your tiny-fisted tantrums would have more weight than that of a leprous desert rat, spinning rabidly in a circle, waiting for the bite of the snake?
Quote:
The only thing worse than your logic is your manners. I have snipped away most of what you wrote, because, well... it didn't really say anything. Your attempt at constructing a creative flame was pitiful. I mean, really, stringing together a bunch of insults among a load of babbling was hardly effective... Maybe later in life, after you have learned to read, write, spell, and count, you will have more success. True, these are rudimentary skills that many of us "normal" people take for granted that everyone has an easy time of mastering. But we sometimes forget that there are "challenged" persons in this world who find these things more difficult. If I had known, that this was your case then I would have never read your post. It just wouldn't have been "right". Sort of like parking in a handicap space. I wish you the best of luck in the emotional, and social struggles that seem to be placing such a demand on you.



So, why do you bother give a reply at all?

Has he touched on the truth?

I think maybe he has.
 
So, why do you bother give a reply at all?

Has he touched on the truth?

I think maybe he has.
Not quite. Frankly (no pun intended), I've gotten utterly tired of the chip on his shoulder that he feels the need to project onto everyone that doesn't have the same vendetta that he does.

Your armchair psycho-analysis isn't doing much better.
 
Not quite. Frankly (no pun intended), I've gotten utterly tired of the chip on his shoulder that he feels the need to project onto everyone that doesn't have the same vendetta that he does.

Your armchair psycho-analysis babble isn't doing much better.

Fixed that for you. ;)
 
Horatius et al.:

First of all, because I like to please people, recognize that what I am about to say is simply what you guys EXPECT me to say, WANT me to say... Dare I say, NEED me to say! So I will try not to disappoint - after all, I too am archetypal in my behavior, (See below.)

expect..yes
want...can't say that it would apply to me
need..certainly not in my case

Secondly, please don't consider anything I am about to say as a personal affront.

Then you won't take my comments as an affront either. Good to know as I respect your intelligence and knowledge while not understanding your inability to, for brevity's sake, play well with others.


* They become very annoyed at those who do not share their one world consensus view.

Mostly just annoyed at the patently stupid ideas that get dropped here such as space based beams and no-planes. Yes, a few here jump on anyone speculating beyond the orthodox but it is not IMHO prevalent.

* They tend to be bigoted.
* They believe they are always right and are therefore lacking in humility.
* They tend to be supercilious and smug.

Forgive me for pointing out that a case certainly can be made for these 3 applying to you as well. So how could you complain about it then?

* They have a mutual need to engage in self-satisfied ego stroking -as in the "appreciation" thread from which this thread devolved- because they have never experienced ego loss.

I don't know about the ego loss part. Anyone over the age of 25 has likely had their ego bruised.
Mutual appreciation, well 'birds of a feather' and all that. I have no problem with that.


* They are incapable of thinking outside the box.

Nahhh, just cannot stand it when outside of the box means ignoring that the box might contain relevent information and the realization that what is in the box should be looked at first. You did that re: the reactor tubing did you not? You investigated the ideas in the box before going outside it.

* They buy any story fed to them by government agencies
.

I detect bitterness in your tone. IMHO rightly so re: the Canadian reactors.
I for one do not 'buy' all gov't proclamations and few if any here do. Your bitterness has pushed you to make this generalization

* They tend to be patriotic, and this is not just referring to your typical American's reaction to 9/11 - the Brits, Canajuns (Eh), and Aussies are just as bad
.

Yep, I like Canada. Am I supposed to like someting else instead?

* They tend to give "smart-aleck" answers.

Hmm I just did that in my last sentence.
I do note that I cannot think of a single poster here or at LCF or P4T that is not 'guilty' of it, including you.

* They like to argue from authority - 200 NIST scientists can't be wrong!

How about, '200 NIST scientists probably have a better handle on it than a philospoher, a physicist, and economist and various conspiracist radio jocks'


* They always ask you to "show me the evidence", but ignore it when they dont like what they see; then they turn around and claim you havn't shown them any evidence!

Very much in evidence as applying to the majority of denizens of LCF and P4T. Have you pointed this out to them too or are we getting special attention because you like us so much.(oh my smart aleck mouth)

* They are not much fun to debate because they are so predictable in their answers/ beliefs. Thus I already KNOW what to expect by way of objections to this post!

I assume you predicted that it would be pointed out that the 'other side' and you are just as 'guilty' of the greivences you list.

Now, I acknowledge that everyone is, of course, different to some degree; so some members of the conspiracy debunker's battalion may not have (or revealed) all of these traits; still others show traits I have not yet addressed. That's why I listed options in my last post to allow for some variability in the behavior patterns of JREF "one world viewers". But on the whole they represent a particular archetype that I see here in the same old crowd of one world view posters. I wont name names but let's just say posters such as T, E, P, L, G, P, C, U, R, H, etc, etc....Yes, a veritable alphabet soup of reactionary thinking!

Now make me laugh - tell me I'm wrong!

So the 'one world view' is actually a spectrum?
If its a homogeneous, one, view then it isn't a spectrum and therefore since you promote two contraditory positions at the same time, you must be wrong.
 
Last edited:
TerryUK,

Why is it that you have not addressed Mercutio's posts numbered 65, 66, and 67, which were specifically addressed to you from someone with expertise in the field that you are purporting to espouse upon?
 
Well, as a psychological analysis, I would say that your description "half-done" is rather generous...
My remark - those JREFers being insecure - was merely an observation of what I assumed was obvious.

As for the CT people, speaking generally of course, I think their psychology is quite different.
They probably see themselves as fighting for 'truth', trying to bring the 'evil perpetrators' to account... I'm sure it's quite complex.

But one difference is that they don't sit there, in that comfortable, safe, majority position, bashing their 'out-numbered' victims, which is what some of the above mentioned JREFers like to do

Hold it right there...VICTIMS??? You've got to be kidding me.

Anybody who comes to these forums comes of their own free will. We do not point a gun to anyone's head and force them to come here and challenge us. They CHOOSE to come because they believe they can defeat us in a debate. Anything they get, they bring upon themselves. There's nothing about any of it that makes them "victims", any more than we are "victims" when your buddies ban us from THEIR forums for nothing more than a little questioning and dissent.

Debate forums are for just that--debate. If the Troothers were as pitiful as you're making them out to be, they wouldn't come here in the first place.

They come here looking for a debate; we grant that request. Now tell me: what's so wrong about that?
 
Hold it right there...VICTIMS??? You've got to be kidding me.

Anybody who comes to these forums comes of their own free will. We do not point a gun to anyone's head and force them to come here and challenge us. They CHOOSE to come because they believe they can defeat us in a debate. Anything they get, they bring upon themselves. There's nothing about any of it that makes them "victims", any more than we are "victims" when your buddies ban us from THEIR forums for nothing more than a little questioning and dissent.

Indeed.

The claim that we're all gleefully pounding on weaker arguments, rather than taking on more sophisticated arguments, is predicated on the assumption that there are sophisticated arguments to be found. I've gone looking for those arguments, and found nothing. It also stands to reason that, out of all the conspiracy theorists who had ever come here, at least one of them would have heard of a valid argument. There's no reason to suppose these stunning, debunker-stumping positions are being jealously guarded and kept from sight.

After almost two years of this, I've concluded that we've seen the best the conspiracy set has or ever will have to offer. It's all rubbish. There are meaningful discussions of actual science, such as those Dr. Greening refers to (if you can catch him on a good day), but no conspiracies.

Prove me wrong. I've been asking for years now.
 
The NIST Report estimates the sensitivity of its results at numerous points in the narrative, and in most areas provides bounding cases as well.

Variation exists in the force of impact and relative strength of aircraft vs. building materials (NCSTAR1-2), the amount and distribution of flammable materials (NCSTAR1-5), the amount of fireproofing loss and coincident transfer of heat to the structure (NCSTAR1-5 especially 1-5G), and the structural response of the building (1-6). NIST also compares its results to no less than five independent studies (1-2 and 1-6) and attempts to reconcile the results. As I stated on the previous page, there are still some unanswered questions, but the overall conclusion of why and how the structures failed is explained to an extremely high degree of certainty.

You're welcome.

Thanks. Sounds great. Does it assess the possibility that the buildings were brought down by controlled demolition, as some other structural engineers are suggesting?

Nick
 
Thanks. Sounds great. Does it assess the possibility that the buildings were brought down by controlled demolition, as some other structural engineers are suggesting?

Nick

Who are these structural engineers. We could use a giggle.
 
Who are these structural engineers. We could use a giggle.

I see on the Net that a chap called Richard Gage is contesting the report. He's claiming, apparently, that there are now 192 professionals in the the fields of architecture and structural engineering backing him www.ae911truth.org.

Are you stating, for the record, 8Den, that his claims do not raise significant doubt in the OT?

Did the NIST report give a comparative analysis for controlled demolition?

Nick
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom