NIST Report - Split from: The JREF Conspiracy Theory subforum appreciation thread

Also, in terms of his list of "members", you have to dig further, and find out what exactly each member on his list "believes" most of them may, or MAY NOT, believe in controlled demolition or any of the MIHOP theories.

TAM:)
 
Bingo - I meant a search of this site though. There's a thread from when MarkyX first realised that Gage not only wasn't checking names, but that a number of people appeared to not be qualified at all.

I would find any list put out by Gage suspect at the very least. And that's before you realise that no one in the group has written any peer reviewed literature about 9/11, and that they don't actually raise any valid points.
 
Why do you even want to see evidence on either side of this debate, since you just said you won't be able to understand squat?

Educate yourself or just leave this debate.

Pardolis,

I wrote "...I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides." Evidence of debate, recorded dialogue between qualified persons from either camp, this sort of thing.

BTW, while we're anyway here, perhaps you could expand for me what you mean by "educate yourself." Is it your belief that you'd have understanding enough of this field through reading a few books, attending courses, this kind of thing? I'm interested.

Nick
 
Pardolis,

pardalis

I wrote "...I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides." Evidence of debate, recorded dialogue between qualified persons from either camp, this sort of thing.

And yet you refuse to read the NIST report under the pretext that you won't understand it.

BTW, while we're anyway here, perhaps you could expand for me what you mean by "educate yourself." Is it your belief that you'd have understanding enough of this field through reading a few books, attending courses, this kind of thing? I'm interested.

I'm saying at least try to learn a little.

What are you here for?
 
Pardolis,

I wrote "...I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides." Evidence of debate, recorded dialogue between qualified persons from either camp, this sort of thing.
Gage refuses to debate anyone, his group has not produced a single paper detailing their "findings". We're here ready to debate all comers...

So who is avoiding debate exactly? Do you wonder why that is?
 
And yet you refuse to read the NIST report under the pretext that you won't understand it.

I'm saying at least try to learn a little.

What are you here for?

I'm not refusing to read it. I just haven't read more than a few pages yet and I'm also concerned about my ability to make an objective assessment of the material.

Could I ask you if you applied your eagle-eyed perception and cognitive sharpness, with the same degree of intensity, to the NIST report as you did to this thread?

Nick
 
Gage refuses to debate anyone, his group has not produced a single paper detailing their "findings". We're here ready to debate all comers...

So who is avoiding debate exactly? Do you wonder why that is?

I think this is a very good point. If I get some time I will email some of the guys on his list, and ask what their opinion actually is.

Nick
 
Could I ask you if you applied your eagle-eyed perception and cognitive sharpness, with the same degree of intensity, to the NIST report as you did to this thread?

I apologize if I seem harsh on you, but I have a very low tolerance for gibberish. Philosophical meanderings are fine, but at the end of the day it can go only so far, especially when the subject matter is as concrete as 19 terrorists killing thousands of people. You seem to give yourself the role of the eternal doubter, that's fine, there are plenty of those. But if you are really interested in finding out the truth about these events, cold hard facts are what you need.
 
Nick:

Read the executive summaries at the beginning of each NISTNCSTAR report. Some are 30-40 pages, others are 100 or so pages, but all are excellent summaries, that the average intelligent person can understand.

As for evidence of debate, you will not find much. Alot of mainstream academia have the truthers on ignore...sort of a "don't legitimize them by recognizing them" approach. As others have said here, they are free to come here and present their studies. I suspect they have little new, that hasnt been discussed here ad nauseum, to bring forward.

Apollo20, as crooked as he can be, is a good source for this, as is Gravy (less crooked).

TAM:)
 
I wrote "...I'm looking for more evidence of debate between the two sides." Evidence of debate, recorded dialogue between qualified persons from either camp, this sort of thing.

BTW, while we're anyway here, perhaps you could expand for me what you mean by "educate yourself." Is it your belief that you'd have understanding enough of this field through reading a few books, attending courses, this kind of thing? I'm interested.

Nick

So all you want to see is a debate about things that you admit you would have no way of understanding what was being debated?
Well search this forum Nick. Its all been done. People here have taken on ZENSMACK, Christopher 7, and several others. Fetzer and S.Jones' contentions have been discussed. Judy Woods and her off-the-wall idiocy has been roundly debunked.

Educate yourself in at least the basics of physics and fire engineering, how the hell else will you be able to tell if you are being given correct information or the remanants of feed after the bull is done with it?
 
As jaydee says, learn some physics and engineering. Doesn't need to be a lot.

If you know even a little bit about nuclear weapons, you'll realise that anyone who subscribes to the mini-nuke theory is deluded.
If you know even a little bit about the thermal and mechanical properties of steel, you'll know that anyone who spouts the line that "fire can't melt steel" is deluded.
If you know even a little bit about about gravity and acceleration, you'll know that all the "faster than free-fall" people are deluded.

And so on. In the majority of cases, the CTists are talking such utter rubbish that high-school physics is more than enough to sink their claims.
 
So all you want to see is a debate about things that you admit you would have no way of understanding what was being debated?

I work in management. It's a standard methodology. It's not possible to understand all the stuff I have to take decisions on. You get guys with different perspectives together and you put them head to head. Or you ask people to destroy their own arguments. The good ones can. Shows they're not over-identified with the subject matter. Which in this particular case is a big issue.

jaydeehess said:
Well search this forum Nick. Its all been done. People here have taken on ZENSMACK, Christopher 7, and several others. Fetzer and S.Jones' contentions have been discussed. Judy Woods and her off-the-wall idiocy has been roundly debunked.

Educate yourself in at least the basics of physics and fire engineering, how the hell else will you be able to tell if you are being given correct information or the remanants of feed after the bull is done with it?

Well, I guess I can do 'kinetic energy' and understand how the seat of a fire is located. I worked in forensic science for a few years a long time back. You think that's enough to rule out the Gage ideas?

Nick
 
I work in management. It's a standard methodology. It's not possible to understand all the stuff I have to take decisions on. You get guys with different perspectives together and you put them head to head. Or you ask people to destroy their own arguments. The good ones can. Shows they're not over-identified with the subject matter. Which in this particular case is a big issue.
<snip>Nick
Though I understand the methodology you are talking about, I would bring this up as a counter-point
me said:
Marginalization of Opposing Views
The 9/11 Truth Movement invariably describes the mainstream account of 9/11 as the "government version" or "the official version." In fact, the generally accepted account of 9/11 is made up of a multitude of sources: thousands of newspaper, TV, and radio reports produced by journalists from all over the world; investigations conducted by independent organizations and institutions, include the American Society of Civil Engineers, Purdue University, Northwestern University, Columbia University, the National Fire Protection Association, and Underwriters Laboratories, Inc.; eyewitness testimony from literally thousands of people; recordings and transcripts of phone calls, air traffic control transmissions, and other communications; thousands of photographs; thousands of feet of video footage; and, let's not forget the words of Osama bin Laden, who discussed the operation in detail on more than one occasion, including in an audio recording released in May 2006 that said: "I am responsible for assigning the roles of the 19 brothers to conduct these conquests ..."
The mainstream view of 9/11 is, in other words, a vast consensus. by presenting it instead as the product of a small coterie of insiders, conspiracists are able to ignore facts they find inconvenient and demonize people with whom they disagree.
I would add to this, that by doing so, they are also able to implant the idea that their ideas are on equal footing, have equal value, and are in similar standing in the relevant fields of expertise. This behavior was summed up nicely in Daniel C. Dennett's essay The Hoax of Intelligent Design and How It Was Perpetrated in the book Intelligent Thought: Science Versus the Intelligent Design Movement pgs 39-41
The campaigners for intelligent design have become adept at feeding off the difficulty of this idea, by starting with a straightforward counterclaim and then retreating into the fog of technical confusion when their counterclaims are refuted. For instance, the philosopher William Dembski, one of the two most prominent ideologues of the ID movement, has attempted to argue that a particular sort of design product does require an intelligent designer, and that the designs found in nature include such products, but his various expressions of the argument to date, which depend on some rather abstruse mathematical formulations, have been show to be technically flawed. Few, if any, theoreticians give his project any hope of success, since the flaws they have uncovered are central to his thesis.
...
How can non-scientists assess their own judgement in this case? Not by trusting wishful thinking. If you can just see that Dembski must be onto something even thought you can't follow the mathematics, you are falling right into the trap. ... Perhaps, then, you should wait with bated breath on the sidelines while the experts duke it out in the scientific arena. This would be fine, except that Dembski has left the playing field and is appealing directly to the spectators, instead of contending with the scientists on their own terms.
In his trade books, magazine articles, and popular lectures, Dembski makes it appear that there is scientific controversy - but there isn't, as we can see by comparing his path with others. ... Instead, he and his cohorts use a ploy that works like this. First you misuse or misdescribe some scientist's work, provoking an angry rebuttal. Then, instead of dealing forthrightly with the charges leveled, you cite the rebuttal as evidence there is a "controversy" to teach.
Note that the trick is content-free. You can use it on any topic. ... And here is the delicious part:You can often exploit the very technicality of the issues to your own advantage, counting on most of us to miss the point amid all the difficult details. ... Clever! What looks to scientists - and is - a knockout objection by Dr. Schneider is portrayed to almost everyone else as ridiculous hairsplitting.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-61915.html
 
I work in management. It's a standard methodology. It's not possible to understand all the stuff I have to take decisions on. You get guys with different perspectives together and you put them head to head. Or you ask people to destroy their own arguments. The good ones can. Shows they're not over-identified with the subject matter. Which in this particular case is a big issue.



Well, I guess I can do 'kinetic energy' and understand how the seat of a fire is located. I worked in forensic science for a few years a long time back. You think that's enough to rule out the Gage ideas?

Nick

What do you believe you would see if you asked Gage to destroy his own arguements?
I wager that he will say that it is not possible to do so and that his contentions stand and it is up to you to believe them or not. Illustrating that he is indeed over-identified with the subject matter.

Most of the looniest ideas such as faster than free fall and no planes and space beams can be debunked with just a little knowledge of physics.

Ask Judy Woods what the frequency or consistency of her supposed directed energy weapon would be and what power would have to be developed for it to work. She simply will not venture a guess. That puts her supposition squarely in the realm of sci-fi.
 
What do you believe you would see if you asked Gage to destroy his own arguements?
I wager that he will say that it is not possible to do so and that his contentions stand and it is up to you to believe them or not. Illustrating that he is indeed over-identified with the subject matter.

When I have a little time I'm going to check out some of the guy's on Gage's list, try and find emails and make contact. I'd like to hear their take on things.

Nick
 
Good idea Nick. I hope you have a supply of "Kool-Vax" with you, so when they start spewing the good old truther Canards to you, you recognize them for just that....snake oil in a kool-aid jug.

TAM:)
 
Thanks for posting this, R. I don't have so much a problem with Doug's views in your "here" links, but the fact that he appears to go into this stuff when his professional opinion on the WTC collapse is questioned doesn't bode too good. Reads a little as though he's saying that imminent NWO takeover justifies fallacious science. He's out of it, imo.

That's fair enough. Personally, once I see signs of enveloping paranoia (in Doug Plumb's case, he stated that the US Government was planning to tag everyone with RFID chips as a prelude to complete enslavement), I tend to write off the individual as potentially having serious medical problems and avoid teasing them any further. However, with respect to the claims of Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth, the fact that he chose these distractions rather than acknowledge the clear refutations of his claims is perhaps more significant.

Oh, regarding another of your questions:

Could I ask you if you applied your eagle-eyed perception and cognitive sharpness, with the same degree of intensity, to the NIST report as you did to this thread?

Quite a few of us have. In fact, I wrote a fifteen-page chapter as part of a much longer whitepaper (see this thread) wherein I criticize the NIST Report in several areas, synthesizing that criticism with the works of other scientists, and discuss the significance of those potential issues on the Report as a whole. Despite these issues, including one case where I feel NIST is likely to be incorrect, there remains absolutely no doubt in my mind that the impact, fire, and deterioration of the structure to collapse are adequately and accurately explained by NIST.

I have the benefit of being a scientist, with degrees in two relevant sciences (physics and aeronautics), considerable background in fluid and structures modeling, and previous experience with accident reporting. I have also corresponded with several other scientists, both here and privately. Still, I learned quite a few things from reading the Report.

For someone without a strong technical background, the sheer mass of the Report is daunting, and it is quite likely that you will not understand why certain things were done as they were, organizationally or computationally. Delivering a solid critique is difficult without the right background. However, you should be able to follow the basic structure of the report and the chain of logic that leads to their conclusions. The Report also contains a great deal of raw evidence along with its interpretation, which can be appreciated by anyone. You may find it more instructive and useful than you expect.
 
When I have a little time I'm going to check out some of the guy's on Gage's list, try and find emails and make contact. I'd like to hear their take on things.
Why not - as has been suggested - learn something and evaluate the claims yourself?
 
I'm not refusing to read it. I just haven't read more than a few pages yet and I'm also concerned about my ability to make an objective assessment of the material.

Could I ask you if you applied your eagle-eyed perception and cognitive sharpness, with the same degree of intensity, to the NIST report as you did to this thread?

Nick



To be honest you don't need to read the NIST report to understand the collapse of the WTC. Reading the NIST FAQ and watching a view videos/photographs is ample to see clearly that their version of events is accurate.

Plane hit building. Damaged columns and trusses. Started fires. Stripped fire-proofing. Office contents burned. Trusses heated and sagged. Pulled exterior columns in. Columns failed. Building fall down.

It really is that simple.

-Gumboot
 
Plane hit building. Damaged columns and trusses. Started fires. Stripped fire-proofing. Office contents burned. Trusses heated and sagged. Pulled exterior columns in. Columns failed. Building fall down.

It really is that simple.

If you want even simpler, look at the Trinity Church video, and see the exterior columns pull in as the collapse initiates. Then try and figure out how that could be achieved with explosives, which aren't noted for pulling things (except WTC7).

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom