NIST Report - Split from: The JREF Conspiracy Theory subforum appreciation thread

Yes, of course!

And you made me laugh... can't be bad!

Point is I got what I predicted.... I must be psychic..

Oh, that's right, that bugs JREFers too!
 
Childlike Princess:

This thread , drenched as it is in embarrassing obsequiousness, only serves to confirm my initial suspicion, going back to the days when I first posted here, that the JREF Conspiracy Theory sub-forum is nothing more than a vehicle for the authoritarian proclamations of a doctrinaire mutual admiration society.

But then again, perhaps I am being too harsh...


This was amusing in so many ways that it would be futile to list them.
 
I actually agree with Apollo20 on one of his points:

* They like to argue from authority - 200 NIST scientists can't be wrong!

I don't care what the FAA says, an object made of metal is simply not capable of flying.

And anyone trying to prove that metal objects can fly is obviously going to be arguing from authority if they use the FAA, or an aeronautical engineer.
 
Horatius et al.:

Secondly, please don't consider anything I am about to say as a personal affront.

Talk about your dubious disclaimers. This is like that quote from Talladega Nights, where Ricky Bobby prefaces "I didn't realize you'd gotten experimental surgery to get your balls removed" with "With all due respect", thinking it makes it less of an insult that way.

But having said all that, I still see the JRERer's debunking-batallion as having what I call a "one world view"

Go to the Politics, Religion & Philosophy, and Social Issues & Current Events subforums once in a while, and you'll see how wrong you are. Saying that our support of the official story is a "one world view" is, as has been stated before, equivalent to saying that those who believe the Earth is round have a "one world view". In fact, 9/11 might be the ONLY issue that everyone here generally agrees on. That's because there's a vast amount of facts on our side and zero on your side.

* They become very annoyed at those who do not share their one world consensus view.

No, we become very annoyed at those who insult us and call us "shills" and accomplices to mass murder. You'll notice we are very civil towards those who are civil to us.

More than can be said of your side, which BANS people from its forums for voicing even the slightest dissent.

* They tend to be bigoted.

Please don't make accusations like this without anything to back it up. Quote ONE instance where a JREFer has displayed bigotry.

* They believe they are always right and are therefore lacking in humility.
* They tend to be supercilious and smug.
* They have a mutual need to engage in self-satisfied ego stroking -as in the "appreciation" thread from which this thread devolved- because they have never experienced ego loss.

Bub, were you born under a rock or something? EVERYONE is like this. Even your side. Especially your side. Take a visit to Loose Change forums or Pilots for Truth forums once in a while and you'll see what I mean.

* They are incapable of thinking outside the box.

How so?

Seems to me the ones who are incapable of thinking outside the box are the ones who rationalize the slightest anomaly as being definitive proof of a grand conspiracy.

* They buy any story fed to them by government agencies.

Beg your pardon? We buy any story supported by evidence. If what you say is true, we would all believe there was a link between Saddam Hussein and 9/11. We don't.

Your side, on the other hand, swallows the Sacred Word or its ringleaders, such as Jones, Avery, and Balasmo, without hesitation and without question.

* They tend to be patriotic, and this is not just referring to your typical American's reaction to 9/11 - the Brits, Canajuns (Eh), and Aussies are just as bad.

Is there something wrong with that?

* They tend to give "smart-aleck" answers.

Ok, you got us on this one.

* They like to argue from authority - 200 NIST scientists can't be wrong!

Show me a person here who hasn't analyzed the evidence for themselves.

BTW, your side relies on authorities as well--just ones with much less credibility. If it's on Youtube it must be true, amirite? If Alex Jones said it, it must be the Gospel, amirite?

* They always ask you to "show me the evidence", but ignore it when they dont like what they see; then they turn around and claim you havn't shown them any evidence!

I'm gonna have to call your bluff again. Quote one instance of this happening.

* They are not much fun to debate because they are so predictable in their answers/ beliefs. Thus I already KNOW what to expect by way of objections to this post!

Yet you continue to debate us anyway. Why is that?

Now, I acknowledge that everyone is, of course, different to some degree; so some members of the conspiracy debunker's battalion may not have (or revealed) all of these traits; still others show traits I have not yet addressed. That's why I listed options in my last post to allow for some variability in the behavior patterns of JREF "one world viewers". But on the whole they represent a particular archetype that I see here in the same old crowd of one world view posters. I wont name names but let's just say posters such as T, E, P, L, G, P, C, U, R, H, etc, etc....

Yes, a veritable alphabet soup of reactionary thinking!

Now make me laugh - tell me I'm wrong!

Okay--you're wrong.

How was that?
 
In all seriousness, Dr. Greening, the reason that alternative theories are not received well here is that, with the exception of Gordon Ross and your own work, the "Truth" movement has not produced anything that rises to the level of scholarship. And even Ross' paper was shown to be wrong by R. Mackey.

As for NIST, I personally accept their conclusions because they fit well with the observations. If a Truther, any Truther, came up with an alternative explanation for the events of 9/11 that both fit the observations and did not do obvious violence to the laws of physics, thermodynamics, motion, etc., I (and I'd wager many of the other posters here) would at least give it a look. I am not aware of any such explanation.

Your concern regarding the lack of civility with which those holding alternative viewpoints are treated is, sadly, well founded. It's easy to point to the JREF banner and say "see? it should be friendly and lively!" but when you are confronted for the hundredth time by some 16-year-old kid who's just watched Loose Change and is spouting on about thermite and free-fall and put options and so on, I for one can understand how it is that civility goes out the window. That doesn't make it right, just understandable.
 
* They become very annoyed at those who do not share their one world consensus view.
Have you looked into the other sub-fora? People who agree to a consensus here are often on opposite sides of the fence on other issues. I suggest that the annoyance you see is not a characteristic of JREFers, but rather is a characteristic response to [at least some] unsubstantiated and ill-thought-out "alternative theories".
* They tend to be bigoted.
In general? I'd love to see the evidence for this. I am frankly surprised at this claim.
* They believe they are always right and are therefore lacking in humility.
I have seen them correct one another, both in the CT area and in others. I suspect that you are sampling an area in which a handful of JREFers quite simply have a better understanding of the evidence and arguments. And there is quite a difference between "belief that I am always right" and "belief that in this instance you are definitely wrong"--but witnessing dozens of the latter may make an observer innocently conclude the former, however incorrectly.
* They tend to be supercilious and smug.
Again, is this a characteristic of JREFers, or is it a general consequence of shooting fish in a barrel? When all life gives you is 4-inch putts, should you pretend they are difficult?
* They have a mutual need to engage in self-satisfied ego stroking -as in the "appreciation" thread from which this thread devolved- because they have never experienced ego loss.
Thank you, Dr. Freud. How about "they recognize the achievements of their fellows, and are comfortable acknowledging those achievements publicly."
* They are incapable of thinking outside the box.
Most of the now-experts here have become so by taking it upon themselves to do the research. They have gone outside of their respective boxes, and have converged on an opinion based on the evidence they have discovered.
* They buy any story fed to them by government agencies.
Ok, that one is funny. I invite you to look through the politics sub-forum. Again, your sample is biased--you have chosen topics where the available evidence is from mostly government sources. But you will see that other sources--media, personal interviews, etc.--have also been used; odd, if all they need to do is toe the government line.
* They tend to be patriotic, and this is not just referring to your typical American's reaction to 9/11 - the Brits, Canajuns (Eh), and Aussies are just as bad.
Patriotic as in "Back Bush", or patriotic as in "support our troops--bring them home"? You will find an astonishing degree of difference, if you look through the rest of the forum. One wonders what was able to bring such disparate people into agreement--oh, yes... evidence.
* They tend to give "smart-aleck" answers.
Sometimes. Sometimes they give answers that are so thorough, so well-sources, so overwhelmingly informative, that they are like smacking someone over the head with an encyclopaedia. But I suppose any smack feels smart-alecky.
* They like to argue from authority - 200 NIST scientists can't be wrong!
Would these be legitimate authorities? Or do they also say that the Pope agrees with them, and the US Poet Laureate, and the inventer of silly putty?
* They always ask you to "show me the evidence", but ignore it when they dont like what they see; then they turn around and claim you havn't shown them any evidence!
Could you cite examples? The ones that spring to my mind do not support your contention; they do not ignore it, but they subject it to critical analysis. A very different process, but a similar result.
* They are not much fun to debate because they are so predictable in their answers/ beliefs. Thus I already KNOW what to expect by way of objections to this post!
Too bad I already typed it, then.

I think you paint with too broad a brush--there are certainly posts I would complain about, myself, but as an overall picture, I do not agree with your assessment at all.

ETA: I gotta type faster. Left, just for amusement's sake.
 
* They are incapable of thinking outside the box.

Define "box". The parameters of your "box" seem to be very wide and ambiguous.

* They tend to be patriotic, and this is not just referring to your typical American's reaction to 9/11 - the Brits, Canajuns (Eh), and Aussies are just as bad.
Al Qaeda is responsible for 9/11, like it or not.

* They like to argue from authority - 200 NIST scientists can't be wrong!
In this case argument from authority is not a fallacy, NIST is a valid authority.
 
What I am trying to say is that all the JREF conspiracy debunkers appear to accept the NIST Report as true or certainly quite accurate and more than sufficient to explain why the Twin Towers collapsed.

That JREF conspiracy debunkers believe that anyone who thinks otherwise is (pick one or more) from the list: a fool, a liar, a non-scientist, a Bush hater, paranoid, delusional, etc.

(Am I right so far?.... hope this is not considered a derail of this thread, but I have been asked to elaborate!)

That conspiracy debunking is, (pick one or more from the list): a sign of intelligence, a noble cause, a public service, educational, pest control, patriotic....

That any of the following historical events could not possibly have involved anything that could be described as a conspiracy: the JFK assassination, the RFK assassination, the death of Marilyn Monroe, the death of Karen Silkwood, the Jonestown massacre, the death of Senator Wellstone, the assassination of Olaf Palme, the conviction of Abdel Basset Ali Mohamed al Megrahi, the death of Lady Diana, the crash of TWA 800, the OKC bombing, the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, the death of David Kelly, the Waco massacre, the assassination of Martin Luther King, the death of Danny Casolaro, the death of Pope John Paul I, the sinking of the MS Estonia, .... to mention but a few!

Apollo20,

Making sweeping statements is unlikely to help convince anyone so much, in my experience. I think it's good that JREF is here. It's exciting to debate with a load of people who are from totally a different position to my own. The main thing you can do is stay objective. My experience is that as many CT opposers are actually equally led by unconscious motivations as CTists. They are equally irrational in their assertions. Their objectivity and rational fly out of the window because they need to defend their position like they need to defend their sanity. You're dealing with big, big emotions here, and it's not so easy for most people to just debate this stuff like they were debating Plato's Cave or whatever. Make any sense?

Nick
 
So Apollo, what about that moon landing? Was it just Apollo 11 or are all NASA's moon missions a sham?
 
Disbelief:

No, it's ok for all you JREF conspiracy debunkers to be palls....

I just marvel at the sameness of your thinking, .... your one world view.


Frank, before I read anything on the subject of the JFK assassination, I harbored vague suspicions that the murder must have been mob-related, given the sleazy and nebulous web of connections linking the President, Sam Giancana, and the women they shared. Then I read Posner's book and learned who Lee Harvey Oswald really was. Nobody who understands Oswald can ever doubt that he killed Kennedy.

You present two distinct personas here. One of them, the coldly objective scientist who prizes truth and accuracy above all, is an admirable figure. The other, the maverick who adopts contrarian opinions for sake of being contrarian, reflects our society's ("our" being the West in general) willingness to entertain nonsense to avoid any hint of stuffiness. Better to be regarded a complete fool than--heaven forbid!--a traditionalist or a pedant: the credo of celebrities has taken hold in academia and journalism.

Why should anyone "marvel" at the sameness of thinking that arises from mastery of detail and clear understanding? Should there be a wider divergence of opinion on mathematical results? Do we need more alchemists in chemistry departments? Why exactly should we be so eager to applaud and encourage professional cranks who contradict each other, ignore and distort facts, and ultimately get everything wrong?

It's no coincidence that Jim Fetzer started out as a JFK conspiracy theorist. He remains what he has always been: agenda-driven, invincibly ignorant, and willfully ineducable. That's not what I'd call a scholarly ideal.
 
Pardalis said:
"It's much better to change your point of view in response to reality than to insist reality has got it wrong because it doesn't share your point of view." aggle-rithm

In the case of 911, the reality is that the towers were hit by planes and then they fell down. Whether you believe that the one caused the other, or not, is a construct. Constructs are finally entirely subjective. The assertion that a construct is reality occurs more through social instinct than anything else. If you just change your point of view because the majority believe something different, well, who actually are you then?

Nick
 
Wait a minute. NIST had the task to investigate the collapse of the Twin Towers, by definition that means that it will result in a proper set of papers (within its framework) and it will be the standard work, the standard reference. There is no other one, like a monopoly position.

What I personally don't get is that when Apollo for example came with the sphericules he got all the circle jerking over him. I can understand when a CDiot appears here that happenes, but when Apollo started here exactly the same happened, but he is no demolitionist and only wants to know the truth wherever that leads to. I have the feeling that in one way or another everything that disagrees with the NIST is seen as a kind of threat.
 
In the case of 911, the reality is that the towers were hit by planes and then they fell down. Whether you believe that the one caused the other, or not, is a construct. Constructs are finally entirely subjective. The assertion that a construct is reality occurs more through social instinct than anything else. If you just change your point of view because the majority believe something different, well, who actually are you then?

Nick

What on earth are you talking about?
 
In all seriousness, Dr. Greening, the reason that alternative theories are not received well here is that, with the exception of Gordon Ross and your own work, the "Truth" movement has not produced anything that rises to the level of scholarship. And even Ross' paper was shown to be wrong by R. Mackey.

Before you get raked over the coals, I don't believe Dr. Greening has ever identified himself with the Truth Movement, nor would I bin him there; and he also has produced one of the strongest criticisms of Gordon Ross.

I know, it's hard to keep score without a scorecard.

As for NIST, I personally accept their conclusions because they fit well with the observations. If a Truther, any Truther, came up with an alternative explanation for the events of 9/11 that both fit the observations and did not do obvious violence to the laws of physics, thermodynamics, motion, etc., I (and I'd wager many of the other posters here) would at least give it a look. I am not aware of any such explanation.

Let me just say (again) that I'm basically happy with the NIST results, although there are a few areas that I believe need to be reopened. They may be addressed in the upcoming WTC 7 report, and if not, then I will support a request for further investigations. I've written about this at length in my whitepaper.

But don't confuse me with those who simply belly-ache about it. It's a long and sometimes tortuous scientific process. The overwhelming majority of their work is of good quality, I'm just keen to tease out better results.

That's about all I have to say in this thread. :boxedin:
 
What on earth are you talking about?

Philosophy, dude! If no one has, beyond a reasonble doubt, demonstrated that the towers either did or did not fall down as a result of the planes hitting them, then when you quote your tagline it infers that people should believe what the majority believe.

Nick
 
Philosophy, dude!

It's engineering you should be reading.

Originally Posted by Garb
Nick, I'm going to just digress from this pointless discussion we are having, and ask you a question, which you haven't answered since the beginning of this thread.

What makes you not satisfied with the NIST evaluation of the Twin Towers collapse?
I haven't read it.

Nick

Why don't you read the NIST report for starters. :rolleyes:
 
Apollo 20, you have a point, but from what I have been able to see ALL groups tend to flock together to a degree. Your annoyance at this tendency seems to be a bit more extreme than usual. I could also imagine more constructive and effective ways to go about being the gadfly. I also see the need to have a gadfly and I really can't fault you for having the courage to take that role.

We can argue the merits of the fine points of NIST but the underlying theme here is not wheather NIST is correct on every point but wheather NIST is participating in a conspiracy to cover up the government's involvement in the attacks of 911. Something it seems even you cannot bring yourself to support. I think it is important to keep this point in perspective lest you end up seeming to support that view unwittingly.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom