NIST Report - Split from: The JREF Conspiracy Theory subforum appreciation thread

Then don't apply some philosophical mumbojumbo to explain things you don't understand.

I'm not. I'm pointing out the reality of the situation the best I can. If I had a real hard, experiential understanding of just what happens when large flying objects hit steel and concrete towers I could make an accurate judgment and stand behind it. I don't.

Do you have a real, experiential understanding of this stuff? Do you know to what degree an absolute cause can be ascribed to the event of the towers collapsing from the existing data? Can you quote realistic margins of error in the different areas of examination that fused together to provide your assessment?

In the case that you can't, I suggest that understanding a little more of the philosopy of reasoning might serve you well.

Nick
 
Before you get raked over the coals, I don't believe Dr. Greening has ever identified himself with the Truth Movement, nor would I bin him there; and he also has produced one of the strongest criticisms of Gordon Ross.

I know, it's hard to keep score without a scorecard.

I assumed (from his taking the opposite side in the debate with you, as well as his criticism of JREF posters) that Dr. Greening, if not an outright Truther, at least had some leanings in that direction. Apparently this assumption was false. My bad.

Dr. Greening is correct that we should not blindly accept anything anyone, government or otherwise, tells us without applying critical thinking. However, I don't see such blind acceptance at JREF. The NIST report has been scrutinized by a good many posters here and found to mesh well with observation. The Truthers' "evidence", on the other hand, is almost always shown to be erroneous, falsified, quote-mined, cherry-picked, or otherwise deficient. This is why Truthers get the treatment they do here; facts talk, (rule10) walks.
 
Thanks. Could you link me to where it assesses the possibility of other causes, and to where it details the degree of certainty it has in its establishment of causation? Other factors that could be taken into consideration?

You can easily find them yourself. Start with this one.

You really must have a hard time getting around, since you probably aren't a cartographer you must need to check 10 different maps every time you want to go some place.
 
Thanks. Could you link me to where it assesses the possibility of other causes, and to where it details the degree of certainty it has in its establishment of causation? Other factors that could be taken into consideration?

Nick

The NIST Report estimates the sensitivity of its results at numerous points in the narrative, and in most areas provides bounding cases as well.

Variation exists in the force of impact and relative strength of aircraft vs. building materials (NCSTAR1-2), the amount and distribution of flammable materials (NCSTAR1-5), the amount of fireproofing loss and coincident transfer of heat to the structure (NCSTAR1-5 especially 1-5G), and the structural response of the building (1-6). NIST also compares its results to no less than five independent studies (1-2 and 1-6) and attempts to reconcile the results. As I stated on the previous page, there are still some unanswered questions, but the overall conclusion of why and how the structures failed is explained to an extremely high degree of certainty.

You're welcome.
 
It's probably foolish of me to admit this. I haven't read NIST or similar engineering reports, and don't plan to. Rather, I believe in relying on those who can read and understand (and I hope explain) the technical documents. I have no technical experience or education, and it would be futile of me to try. Instead, I look to others -- a good example being the Pop Mech book. How do I decide on whom to rely? A mix; credentials, obvious skills at rational exposition, an apparent rational world view, and yes, authorities. I had a academic engineer as a dad, and a civil engineering contractor as a grandfather, but I inherited zero skills or insight. Fortunately as a boy I figured this out and headed for the humanities.

I do something similar at work. I run a department of about 30 semi-academic, semi-civil service bureaucrats. I definitely don't try to do their jobs, or understand all their tasks down to a detailed level. In my experience, in my kind of work, the thing to do is to find people who can do the jobs, or see that those are trained who are capable of doing the jobs, and setting them to work.

End of true confessions. I will not read the NIST report. Please don't hit me.
 
It's probably foolish of me to admit this. I haven't read NIST or similar engineering reports, and don't plan to. Rather, I believe in relying on those who can read and understand (and I hope explain) the technical documents. I have no technical experience or education, and it would be futile of me to try. Instead, I look to others -- a good example being the Pop Mech book. How do I decide on whom to rely? A mix; credentials, obvious skills at rational exposition, an apparent rational world view, and yes, authorities. I had a academic engineer as a dad, and a civil engineering contractor as a grandfather, but I inherited zero skills or insight. Fortunately as a boy I figured this out and headed for the humanities.

I do something similar at work. I run a department of about 30 semi-academic, semi-civil service bureaucrats. I definitely don't try to do their jobs, or understand all their tasks down to a detailed level. In my experience, in my kind of work, the thing to do is to find people who can do the jobs, or see that those are trained who are capable of doing the jobs, and setting them to work.

End of true confessions. I will not read the NIST report. Please don't hit me.

Excellent. This sentiment is EXACTLY what I try to instill in people whom I debate with. I am a layman. I have to rely on experts to help me understand the science involved in the events of that day. I do, however, know how to tell a real expert from a wannabe.

Call it a gift.

What the majority of relevant experts say is of utmost importance to me. So far, the VAST majority of true experts do not believe that the official explanation of the events of that day are impossible.

Until the truth movement brings forth some real experts, they will never be able to count on THIS layman for his support.
 
I agree, the finer points, the major parts of the reports...to advanced for a lot of people. However, I think all 9/11 truth debunkers here, who have the time, should try and read the executive summaries (first 30-100 pages) of each of the reports. They are less detailed, and very good at summarizing.

TAM:)
 
I agree, the finer points, the major parts of the reports...to advanced for a lot of people. However, I think all 9/11 truth debunkers here, who have the time, should try and read the executive summaries (first 30-100 pages) of each of the reports. They are less detailed, and very good at summarizing.

I would agree. The executive summaries are at least understandable to somebody like me.

But, they are summaries. The real meat comes later, and that's where I curse the day I decided to NOT follow an engineering path ;)
 
I agree, the finer points, the major parts of the reports...to advanced for a lot of people. However, I think all 9/11 truth debunkers here, who have the time, should try and read the executive summaries (first 30-100 pages) of each of the reports. They are less detailed, and very good at summarizing.

TAM:)

Well, that's what I've done. You're right.

Thanks. I feel better now.
 
I'm a little late to this thread but Frank. Who is Childlike "Princess'?


I'm the Empress of Phantasien. Apollo20 is not a citizen of that empire, so he has the right and the duty to choose a name for me. As the wise man he is he gently fought the rise of nothingness. You, on the other hand, HAVE TO RESPECT MY AUTHORITY! :mad:
 
YOUR ALL SHILLZOR. ROUND WORLDERS ARE GOV. BLACK OPS tryiNG NOT TO TRUTH!

OBLATE SPHEROID!
 
Apollo20: said:
* They tend to be supercilious and smug.
Again, is this a characteristic of JREFers, or is it a general consequence of shooting fish in a barrel? When all life gives you is 4-inch putts, should you pretend they are difficult?



The JREFers in question seem to prefer what you describe as "4-inch puts ". Otherwise why would they perpetuate, rather than ignore, those threads where the main aim is to attack and feed off their out-numbered, 'easy' victim?

You wouldn't expect a group of golf champions to regularly seek out beginners in order to mock them - they don't feel the need to do that.

But that's exactly the sort of thing many JREFers do - and on a regular basis.

I can't say I have a very favourable opinion of people who come here mainly to gloat...
Some of you guys actually start new threads which have the sole aim of discussing and mocking your latest 'idiotic troother' find.

All this is symptomatic of, amongst other things, insecurity.
 
The JREFers in question seem to prefer what you describe as "4-inch puts ". Otherwise why would they perpetuate, rather than ignore, those threads where the main aim is to attack and feed off their out-numbered, 'easy' victim?

You wouldn't expect a group of golf champions to regularly seek out beginners in order to mock them - they don't feel the need to do that.

But that's exactly the sort of thing many JREFers do - and on a regular basis.

I can't say I have a very favourable opinion of people who come here mainly to gloat...
Some of you guys actually start new threads which have the sole aim of discussing and mocking your latest 'idiotic troother' find.

All this is symptomatic of, amongst other things, insecurity.

It's hard to sympathize with the self-pity expressed in this posting.

I'll admit I feel no pity for those who come and make statements, often quite erroneous, or at least unfounded; who make "technical" claims that come down to, in fact, a person untrained or uneducated in a particular area arguing from his/ her own incredulity ("I just don't believe it."). As for the golf analogy ... I'm trying to figure Tiger Woods out there with a duffer. No, it's a poor analogy, unless the duffer comes swaggering out claiming he can beat poor Tiger, and then sets out to try and prove it.

Nah, lousy analogy. Actually, if you don't want to get attacked, then improve your arguments. And if your feelings are hurt, don't expose yourself to attacks. I'm pretty sure everyone here is more or less an adult. Also, the attacks are only verbal; you don't get hurt, not really; so why complain?
 
Last edited:
It's hard to sympathize with the self-pity expressed in this posting.

I'll admit I feel no pity for those who come and make statements, often quite erroneous, or at least unfounded; who make "technical" claims that come down to, in fact, a person untrained or uneducated in a particular area arguing from his/ her own incredulity ("I just don't believe it."). As for the golf analogy ... I'm trying to figure Tiger Woods out there with a duffer. No, it's a poor analogy, unless the duffer comes swaggering out claiming he can beat poor Tiger, and then sets out to try and prove it.

Nah, lousy analogy. Actually, if you don't want to get attacked, then improve your arguments. And if your feelings are hurt, don't expose yourself to attacks. I'm pretty sure everyone here is more or less an adult. Also, the attacks are only verbal; you don't get hurt, not really; so why complain?

My point is that the JREFers mentioned must be pretty insecure... they have to resort to coming here, day after day, to participate in dishing out a good bashing to some sucker whom they "despise", because he/she is a "twoooofer"...
 
* They tend to be bigoted.
* They tend to be supercilious and smug.
* They tend to be patriotic, and this is not just referring to your typical American's reaction to 9/11 - the Brits, Canajuns (Eh), and Aussies are just as bad.
* They tend to give "smart-aleck" answers.
Note the bolded word. Lots of "tend" in there. Which leads me to think the you're overgeneralizing at the very least.

My point is that the JREFers mentioned must be pretty insecure... they have to resort to coming here, day after day, to participate in dishing out a good bashing to some sucker whom they "despise", because he/she is a "twoooofer"...
And what would your psychological analysis be of the CT proponents who keep coming back to this place over and over while making the same faulty arguments over and over?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom