NIST Report - Split from: The JREF Conspiracy Theory subforum appreciation thread

That's fair enough. Personally, once I see signs of enveloping paranoia (in Doug Plumb's case, he stated that the US Government was planning to tag everyone with RFID chips as a prelude to complete enslavement), I tend to write off the individual as potentially having serious medical problems and avoid teasing them any further. However, with respect to the claims of Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth, the fact that he chose these distractions rather than acknowledge the clear refutations of his claims is perhaps more significant.

Oh, regarding another of your questions:



Quite a few of us have. In fact, I wrote a fifteen-page chapter as part of a much longer whitepaper (see this thread) wherein I criticize the NIST Report in several areas, synthesizing that criticism with the works of other scientists, and discuss the significance of those potential issues on the Report as a whole. Despite these issues, including one case where I feel NIST is likely to be incorrect, there remains absolutely no doubt in my mind that the impact, fire, and deterioration of the structure to collapse are adequately and accurately explained by NIST.

I have the benefit of being a scientist, with degrees in two relevant sciences (physics and aeronautics), considerable background in fluid and structures modeling, and previous experience with accident reporting. I have also corresponded with several other scientists, both here and privately. Still, I learned quite a few things from reading the Report.

For someone without a strong technical background, the sheer mass of the Report is daunting, and it is quite likely that you will not understand why certain things were done as they were, organizationally or computationally. Delivering a solid critique is difficult without the right background. However, you should be able to follow the basic structure of the report and the chain of logic that leads to their conclusions. The Report also contains a great deal of raw evidence along with its interpretation, which can be appreciated by anyone. You may find it more instructive and useful than you expect.

Hi R,

Thanks for the link. I am going to invite the other professionals who are linked on the ae911truth site here to join the debate. I got a list of the ones who filled in the "personal 911 statement" bit, as I figured they could be up for discussion, and will get some email addresses for them. I would like to see if they are up for it.

Nick
 
good maybe we will actually get a couple of them to show us with scientific calculations (that others here can verify) how the towers could only have come down by Controlled Demolition. I eagerly await their arrival.

TAM:)
 
good maybe we will actually get a couple of them to show us with scientific calculations (that others here can verify) how the towers could only have come down by Controlled Demolition. I eagerly await their arrival.

TAM:)

That would be very nice. Because, as you know, the idea that the towers could only have come down by fire and the plane damage can NEVER be demonstrated to be true, can it now?
 
Last edited:
That would be very nice. Because, as you know, the idea that the towers could only have come down by fire and the plane damage can NEVER be demonstrated to be true, can it now?

There's no need for that to be demonstrated to be true to validate the conclusions of NIST. Unless you're a no-planer nutter, the fact that planes did crash into the building and cause structural damage is self-evident, as is the existence of large fires that burned within the buildings for some time before the collapses. There's simply no reason to postulate CD charges or anything else unless it can be shown that the buildings couldn't be brought down by the fires and structural damage alone, absent other evidence for the CD hypothesis. Is there any direct evidence for CD that isn't predicated on the assumption that the buildings couldn't have collapsed from fire and structural damage alone? Besides accounts of people (Rodriguez) hearing loud noises that they think are bombs, I've seen none.
 
That would be very nice. Because, as you know, the idea that the towers could only have come down by fire and the plane damage can NEVER be demonstrated to be true, can it now?
Even if, purely for the sake of argument, your statement was correct; it would, in no way whatsoever, lend any logical support to any other hypothesis.
 
That would be very nice. Because, as you know, the idea that the towers could only have come down by fire and the plane damage can NEVER be demonstrated to be true, can it now?

No, just the most likely cause, and the ONLY theory with any REAL evidence behind it.

i suppose we could entertain the idea of Leprachauns or Space Aliens also, if you want to include other wild hairbrained possibilities.

TAM;)
 
i suppose we could entertain the idea of Leprachauns or Space Aliens also,

They are not at all in the bracket of probability.

if you want to include other wild hairbrained possibilities.

TAM;)
Explosives planted in buildings are "hairbrained possibilities" are they?

Thanks for explaining that.
 
enough explosives to take down a 110 storey office building that is open almost 24/7, with hundreds of workers, no thousands of workers within, and noone noticing the planting of said explosives...yah, hairbrained pretty much sums it up nicely thanks.

TAM;)
 
enough explosives to take down a 110 storey office building that is open almost 24/7, with hundreds of workers, no thousands of workers within, and noone noticing the planting of said explosives...yah, hairbrained pretty much sums it up nicely thanks.

TAM;)

Only if you think of it in terms of conventional methods of CD.
 
So get a REAL DEMOLITION EXPERT (not Torin "I exaggerate to the max my credentials" Wolf) to produce a statement, backed up with a valid professional explanation, of how many people it would take, and over what period of time, it would take to perform such an atypical, untried untested form of demolition...

TAM:)
 
Sorry, but there's no "ifs" as far as my statement is concerned.



As long as you bear in mind that it can't be disproved.
Way to entirely miss the point of my single-sentence post. Secondly, your claim is unsubstantiated. Ergo, the extent that I will be "bear[ing it] in mind" will be that it is your opinion.
 
They are not at all in the bracket of probability.


Explosives planted in buildings are "hairbrained possibilities" are they?

Thanks for explaining that.

Interesting that you chose T.A.M.'s post to respond to rather tha Slayhamlet's.
So on the off chance that you missed it

There's no need for that to be demonstrated to be true to validate the conclusions of NIST. Unless you're a no-planer nutter, the fact that planes did crash into the building and cause structural damage is self-evident, as is the existence of large fires that burned within the buildings for some time before the collapses. There's simply no reason to postulate CD charges or anything else unless it can be shown that the buildings couldn't be brought down by the fires and structural damage alone, absent other evidence for the CD hypothesis. Is there any direct evidence for CD that isn't predicated on the assumption that the buildings couldn't have collapsed from fire and structural damage alone? Besides accounts of people (Rodriguez) hearing loud noises that they think are bombs, I've seen none.

Crash - fact
Fires - fact
what are the facts in evidence to support the idea of explosives or incindiaries?(I assume you mean incindiary agents when you mention non-conventional means. If you mean nukes or beam weapons you are as loony as the no-planers)
 
The Fireproofing seems to be the key...NIST has said the collapse likely would not have occured without its removal. Greening contests the assumption of removal without proof, but then counter theorizes that removal of said fireproofing may not have been needed, if other factors caused the temperatures in places to exceed NISTs estimates (he speculates certain chemicals and their reactions may have done so).

TAM:)
 
The Fireproofing seems to be the key...NIST has said the collapse likely would not have occured without its removal. Greening contests the assumption of removal without proof, but then counter theorizes that removal of said fireproofing may not have been needed, if other factors caused the temperatures in places to exceed NISTs estimates (he speculates certain chemicals and their reactions may have done so).

TAM:)

Not to mention that the insulation may not have been up to the assigned task due to loss of insulation in retrofit construction and by other means, since its installation.
 
I think we can take this as an admission by TerryUK that there is no strong evidence for the CT "hypothesis".
 
Only if you think of it in terms of conventional methods of CD.

Can someone explain to me just why the NWO, if we imagine for a moment they exist, would actually want to demolish the WTC, beyond having just flown two jet-liners into it? Why bother? I've heard a few tales that they blew up the towers to conceal evidence but I'm not much convinced.

I mean, you fly the jet-liners in. This is the major part of the operation. This is what grabs the headlines. This is what tips the balance in getting the public to back your evil plan. Why then blow them up? What for? I mean, surely in terms of op strategy it's a major risk for little real gain. Is there a reason?

Nick
 
I mean, you fly the jet-liners in. This is the major part of the operation. This is what grabs the headlines. This is what tips the balance in getting the public to back your evil plan. Why then blow them up? What for? I mean, surely in terms of op strategy it's a major risk for little real gain. Is there a reason?

The fact that you're even capable of asking this question suggests that you're not as much of a conspiracy theorist as you think you are. The answer is that no hard core conspiracist can give a sensible answer to this one, because they never look at the story from beginning to end; they're simply starting from the end, which is a statement of what happened, and trying to work backwards to their preferred beginning, which is that their chosen bogeyman is the most evil person ever to have existed. A good test of how plausible a CT really is, is to try telling the story forwards. Try it with the Pearl Harbor conspiracy theory some time; it works just as well. One reason the JFK CT's are still popular, I suspect, is that they are just about amenable to a narrative that isn't entirely preposterous from start to finish.

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom