My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

I also notice that there are a ton of legends surrounding the blood of Christ, but nowhere does anyone attribute mystical properties to the contents of his bowels, which would have voided themselves at the moment of death, and thus, logically, should be more potent relics than the True Cross itself. Strange how nobody seems to have a phial or two of that in a shrine somewhere.
Simple answer:

He told His disciples something along these lines:

"This bread is my body, eat my body",
He did not say "Eat my ****"

He told his disciples "This wine is my blood, drink my blood,

He did not say "Drink my piss."

Glad to be of help. :)

DR

Swearwords must not be partially masked
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Professor Yaffle
 
Last edited by a moderator:
He also didn't say "Venerate the macabre device that was used to torture me to death." Besides, if the Body of Christ is so awesome, how much more awesome would it be if it's already passed through the actual Body of Christ? You've got the Shroud of Turin? Groovy, we've got the Last Supper! Ibnezia daughter of Bumshachalacha caught it in this very bucket as it oozed down the True Cross two thousand years ago!
 
Last edited:
He also didn't say "Venerate the macabre device that was used to torture me to death." Besides, if the Body of Christ is so awesome, how much more awesome would it be if it's already passed through the actual Body of Christ? You've got the Shroud of Turin? Groovy, we've got the Last Supper! Right here in this bucket!
True, but He also didn't prohibit doing that. ;)
 
And neither did he prohibit the veneration of solid or liquid waste. ^^
 
BN, the Bible says a lot of things: some gentle and inspirational, some bloodthirsty and horrifying. We can quote hundreds of verses that are warm and fuzzy and loving. But we can also quote hundreds of verses that indicate a cruel, wrathful and malevolent god. Why do we find this contradiction? Because the Bible was written by many different humans over many centuries. It is not the inspired word of God. These "core values" of which you speak are not unique to Christianity. I have no problem with Christianity. The majority of the people I love most in this world are Christians. But when some of those Christians point to the Bible as a divinely inspired source of universally objective morality it begs the comment regarding the cruelty attributed to God within the Bible. Given that the Bible contains glorifications of cruelty and genocide, and that the "core values" contained in the Bible are not unique to it, why should we see the Bible as any more a basis for morality than the Epic of Gilgamesh? Why should we choose Christianity?
 
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 12 removed.


joobz said:
I didn't miss the point at all. It was quite clear that it tried to say there are mitigating circumstances where killing children is excusable. The author
attempted to highlight this point by creating an "extreme" (read completely fictional) analogy to the killing off of a entire species.

Sorry, but you are still missing the point.

OK, I will repeat the argument you referred to, with a little commentary this time:

Firstly, he isn't specifically referring to children, but to anyone who might have been caught up in a biblical invasion assumed by critics to be unjust, as you will see.

So here we go again:

The article on the logical fallacy of argument by outrage says:

In light of repeated use of this tactic by critics, it's a good time to issue some advisories on what such an arguer truly needs to do to make their "argument
by outrage" more than just an emotional appeal. This world is not their (the Biblical writers') world; our thoughts are therefore not their thoughts; their
values are therefore not our values. The critic tends to assume that people who lived in this day and age were "just like us" and would have reacted with
the same immediate moral outrage as they did. That is simply not the case.

Whether that is true or not, it's clear that your first statement in the post where you first brought this up, that, "An argument by outrage is only a fallacy if the outrage isn't clearly defined and defended", is superfluous, since he said that himself, and in fact that was the entire basic point he was making - that people need to do more than just appeal to emotion.

Your first post then claims,

Your source convieniently discusses exactly this argument about the biblical slaughter of infants, so I will use it. Your source attempts to claim that
Position 3, "The killing of children can never be a 'just' act, regardless of competing ethical demands in a given situation," is unjustified and therefore
the whole argument is an argument by outrage.

And you haven't proved it wrong. Here's an example of why you are wrong. Take Hiroshima. I could use argument by outrage and say that even one death of a Japanese child made the Americans culpable - even if there had only been one child in the city, they should have gone in and hunted for it till they found it, no matter how long it took, and then have taken it to safety. The fact that there were thousands in the city makes America more culpable than you can believe. No matter how many American lives may have been lost on the shores of Japan while they launched an evacuation plan, they should have gone in there and evacuated all the women and children before they dropped the bomb. Never mind how long it took to round them all up, and how many Americans were being killed in the process. Perhaps they should have given warning of their intent in the hope that the population of the city evacuated by themselves. But what if a large number didn't? Should the Americans have gone in there and forced them to evacuate? Should they have torn screaming babies from the arms of crying mothers who refused to leave and spirited them away to safety, having first spent some time making complicated logistical arrangements to house the large population of children in the city who might have refused to evacuate so they had to be forced to go? Or should they have forced the mothers, perhaps at gun-point if necessary, to go with them?

Where should they have housed all the thousands of people they forcefully evacuated from Hiroshima? Should they have trudged around Japan for ages till they found enough people letting rooms who were willing to put people from Hiroshima up indefinitely, while all the time their ships were being targeted by kamikaze pilots who were killing quite a number of Americans every day? Should they have looked around till they found wasteland where they could build huge camps to house all the people, while their troops were dying?

You see why the issues are so complex that it's essential to consider issues of competing ethical demands, and that refusal to do so, but to simply say killing a child will always be unjust no matter what, is indeed just an argument by outrage, as the article claims and you're disputing. It's just an appeal to emotion. What the article is arguing is that the complexities of conflicting ethical demands have to be considered before a valid argument can be made that something is unjust.

The article goes on to say:

Edited by LibraryLady: 
Please be aware that quoting more than a paragraph or two of an article violates Rule 4.


The fact that it is a fictional example is irrelevant. The points it makes would apply to very real races.

Firstly, take the statements:

•*Hitler exterminated 6 million Jews.
•*Blethkorp exterminated 6 million Refrons.

You claim the author's example relates entirely to children; but you must be well aware that not all of the 6 million Jews who died were children. Then the other things he says should make it obvious this example doesn't just refer to children:


Edited by LibraryLady: 
Please be aware that quoting more than a paragraph or two of an article violates Rule 4.
shouldn't the butchering of the Amalekite children be considered war crimes?

So, what options would Israel might have had concerning the fatherless Amalekite family, once the warriors had been eliminated in battle?

There are ONLY four options to consider:

1. Take them back as slaves (or to be sold as slaves)

2. Take them back and turn them over to social relief programs/processes in Israel.

3. Leave them there in the desert to their fate

4. Kill them there in the desert

Option 1: Take them back as slaves (or to be sold as slaves).

This was, of course, what some other nations would have done. In fact, this is what many nations would have initiated the conflict for (see my discussion
on OT Slavery for more documentation and discussion of this, and especially the horrors of being a foreign/POW female slave). The Amalekites alone would be an example of raids to produce slaves for re-sale in the slave trade:

Code:
"On of the most valuable spoils of battle was the people. In the UR III period some tablets recorded long lists of women and children...Sometimes women and children were included as part of the general massacre, but usually they became slaves."
[ OT:DLAM:
236-7]

This was (1) against God's strong anti-slavery theme for Israel, who forbade them to make slaves, engage in slave-trade, or turn over runaways, etc. But more importantly, (2) it was practically impossible at the time--the country/people did not have resources to assimilate this many new people, ALL of whom would have needed to be fed and clothed at a difficult period of Israel's history (still at the height of Philistine warfare and Transjordanian aggression).
At a practical level--as actual ancient "slave societies" have taught us-- adult slaves generated by foreign wars often harbor revenge, and wait for that night in which they can kill you in your sleep. The effects on societies of these types of internal hostile elements are well-known. [Indeed, to some historians,
this is why the Pharaoh suppressed the Israelites so abusively in Egypt at the end. There were major external threats at the time, and if a significant block of "unhappy insiders" sided with the outsiders, then the nation would easily fall.] This is a purely-practical consideration, but one that has to be considered in understanding why this option was not open to the Israelite nation. ...

Option 2: Take them back and turn them over to social relief programs/processes in Israel (or anywhere else, for that matter):

Similar problem here: there were no social relief programs/processes adequate to take care of this many dependent people. [Remember, most of these people would have been nomadic dependents (without agricultural or industrial skills) or minor children (consumers without the ability to contribute to their upkeep), at a time before the agricultural surpluses of Israel could support such a large group of resident aliens. ...

So you see again why competing ethical issues have to be weighed up before a judgment can be made about the situation. Those who would argue that killing children can never be justified need to suggest plausible options that could be, or could have been, resorted to instead, and they will have to think of them every time they make the argument.

joobz said:
Now, do you have any actual argument that can justify the slaughter of children?

The point was not that straightforward arguments can be made that can justify the killing of children. Most people would agree that ideally, such a thing should always be avoided. The articles are making the point that when there are complex issues involved with conflicting ethical demands, then sometimes the killing of children might be more expedient than the alternatives. I think I've illustrated that with my Hiroshima example and by quoting the one about the Amalekites.

Joobz said:
Baby Nemesis said:
OK, take an entirely non-fanciful example, and it's just the same:

The Americans killed hundreds of thousands of Japanese, including women, children and babies, by dropping a nuclear bomb on Hiroshima.

and it was horrible. one could claim it was justified, but that makes it no less horrible or divinely right.

Of course it doesn't make it any less horrible, or divinely right. But in a parallel to the quality of omnipotence attributed to God, the Americans were theoretically powerful enough to have saved all the women and children before they dropped the bomb. But there were reasons why they seem to have thought it was expedient not to, possibly because there was no way of doing it without creating big difficulties that might even have resulted in more suffering overall. And I don't see that there's any reason to suppose that even a being as powerful as God is taken to be wouldn't have conflicting ethical demands and limited options, without taking control of the human race or part of it, to an extent that would make people more like robots than independently-thinking beings.

joobz said:
Remember (It seems you are forgetting this point), the issue here is that supposedly god ordained these actions. God who is supposedly good and just. If
you can come up with a good argument for a soldier to kill a child, an infant. then do so.

But if your best defense is, "Well they could have been parasites, or America did it too", that's not convincing argument for a divinely just and benevolent
being.
*
But of course, again you're appealing to emotion, because you're stripping all context from the actions, and again, you're accusing me of making an argument I didn't make. I hope I have clarified the issues.

To go further with my discussion of why even an omnipotent God might not have found it easy to put into operation alternative processes that would have spared the children, without taking control of humanity to an extent that would make people more robot-like, I'll quote part of a post I put on another board once in response to someone who said that taking God's existence as a given for the time being, he should soften the hearts of violent people so they just don't want to be violent any more, and then there would never have been any need for God to supposedly decree violence on them. I raised a few issues that might get in the way:

... That might be nice, but where would you like God to draw the line? And if he softened people's hearts so they would no longer be violent, he'd also have to take temptation out of everyone's way so no one was provoked to violence or committed it under the influence of chemical stimuli. Thus, there would have to be a prohibition on alcohol, since it releases people from their inhibitions and thus makes them more likely to commit violent actions. Would you appreciate a prohibition on alcohol?

Then, people would have to be prevented from seriously annoying one another. This ties in with the issue of where God would draw the line when it comes to preventing people from sinning. Should he only stop people wanting to be violent to each other, or should he, as he would actually have to do in order to prevent people whose hearts may be softened under normal circumstances but who might nevertheless be tempted to violence under provocation, stop people from burgling houses, stop people from evicting others unfairly, prevent people from committing adultery no matter how unsatisfied they were in their marriages, prevent people from seriously verbally harassing others, etc. etc.? Should God soften people's hearts so much that they would never do anyone any harm? That might be nice, but what you basically have in the end is a society where people don't have free will. If it was announced that from tommorrow, everyone would be brought under God's control and he would change our reactions so no one ever wanted to harm anyone again, would you welcome it? Of course, it would be wonderful that it would eliminate the worst excesses of cruelty, but would you be happy knowing you'd be giving up anything you might decide to do that might harm another?

If you would be, well and good. But there are a lot of people who complain, even as it is, that God doesn't allow his people to take personal responsibility for their choices in life, simply because there are instructions on how Christians should live in the Bible.

joobz said:
Oh. I missed that one about abortion.

So far, then, we have:

It is OK for god to demand genocide and the slaughter of infants and babies because...

1.) They could be an evil parasitic alien species.
2.) America dropped the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
3.) abortion is legal.
*
Wow, what a way to crashingly miss points over and over again! I hope I've clarifide a few things sufficiently that you understand them better now. If not, just illustrate the fact by putting another post like that on the board, and I will try to clarify them further.

joobz said:
It's a bit amusing that you just created two fictional scenarios in order to defend a fictional book.

Wow, again, I was doing no such thing! If this was a duel, you'd be ... Well, perhaps God should have prevented all duels from ever taking place. In fact, perhaps he should prevent all mean-spirited debate on Internet forums, lest it leads to people becoming so angry they bully co-workers, snap at their wives, kick the dog, haven't got so much time to spend with their children because they're so busy furiously typing out responses, and so on. Would you like God to intervene in people's lives to stop that kind of thing? Would you be happy if your own life came more under such control? Again we have the issue of where the line should be drawn, and the complexities of the technicalities involved in doing so.

joobz said:
Excellent we can now add two more to the list:

It is OK for god to demand genocide and the slaughter of infants and babies because...

1.) They could be an evil parasitic alien species.
2.) America dropped the bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
3.) Abortion is legal.
4.) God didn't kill everyone, just almost everyone (so it wasn't genocide.
5.) killing all the children will prevent future wars.

that last one is just priceless. The Cut off my nose to spite my face defense.

Wow, the way you crashingly miss points is becoming so repetitive and common it's getting like the sound of waves crashing against the shore! Are you going to provide more waves of missed points?

joobz said:
Baby Nemesis said:
It's the utter failure of some skeptics to take such issues as these into account and provide counter-arguments to the specific issues that makes their arguments seem simplistic, when all they muster up is yet more emotional outrage at the idea that children could be killed.
So god's best policy is scortched earth? It's better to punish the kids for things the MAY do, rather than things they will do? Are you telling me that god couldn't come up with a better way than simply demanding the death of children?

:i: Oh, the irony, the irony! I complain about people making simplistic points, and what does joobz go and do? Right on cue, he proves my point by illustrating that he has a very simplistic understanding of the points that have been made. Please provide better competition if you insist on responding further to this thread.

joobz said:
Nowadays, the world community denounces and fights agaisnt such totalitarian methods. So, the answer is, There are other more noble moral ways and people have discovered them. Why couldn't god have taught us this then?

Without you actually elaborating on what you're complaining about, it's impossible to answer that question.

If you respond with points equally simplistic and fatuously mocking as the ones you've made up until now, I think I'll have to put you on ignore, since having clarified my points, if there proves to be no need to clarify them further but a simple lack of willingness on your part to consider them before responding, there won't be any point in continuing this discussion other than for me to have fun quipping at your expense; and doing that on as tightly moderated a board as this one can be unwise, so I may simply take the temptation to do so out of my way.

For instance, if I don't put you on ignore, I could find myself being tempted to either respond with irritation or mockery to more crashing point-misses like this:

joobz said:
You seem to be suggesting taht the good stuff outweighs the bad stuff.

If I was to donate all my money to the poor, selflessly help everyone arround me and killed a homeless person because I felt like it...am I any less a murderer?

Every single argument you have put in this thread is as simplistic as that one. And that one is grossly simplistic. Of course I wasn't saying the good outweighs the bad. I was saying that if Christians are living their lives as if atrocities in the Old Testament have absolutely no influence at all over their lives, then it doesn't seem rational that some people should be fiercely decrying Christianity as if Christians in fact seek to do similar things as were done in Old Testament times.

joobz said:
You can teach all of the "core values" without needing the bible. it's not inherent or exclusive to the religion.

Oh wow, a straw man to add to the arguments by simplicity. I have never claimed that that cannot be done. My point was more along the lines of:

"Christians who focus on negative aspects of Christian-type belief could perhaps be encouraged to dwell more on the positive things that could make a real difference in their lives if they were emphasised more."

joobz said:
Besides, your claim of "trying to squash" is a straw man. I do not attempt to squash religion. Only that religion is held accountable like everyone else.

LOL. As if that paragraph was directed to you personally.

Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Rule 12 removed.



Please remember to be civil and polite as well as to obey the copyright rules.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Right joobz, time to crush you under my foot like a grape in a wine-press! ... Oh no hang on, perhaps a bit of Christian decorum wouldn't go amiss. :p OK then.
Now I must play gardner and prune your post to the argument you are trying to make...

[regarding god's requestinig the slaughter of children and infants]Of course it doesn't make it any less horrible, or divinely right.
You could have saved yourself all that hassle by just admitting that. (instead of repeating failed arguments and horrible logic)

that's the whole point here. Of course in reality, sometimes terrible things must happen. But we aren't discussing reality. We are discussing a supposed omnipotently divine being who is claimed to be the source of all that is good and moral. If that being demands the slaughter of children and infants, regardless of the reason, that being ISN'T moral or good. It is no better than we are.


ETA:
I did chuckle at your repeated claim that it didn't matter the "parasite species" argument is ficticious. Please continue your bluster, it's funny.
 
Last edited:
Several posts moved to AAH - please keep to the topic - which is not your personal views about, or with other Members.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Swearwords must not be partially masked
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Professor Yaffle
[/QUOTE]

Oops, my bad. :blush:
 
Actually, I think you're not understanding the whole "appeal to emotion" thing, Baby Nemesis.

What makes it a fallacy is that it uses irrelevant emotion to "prove" that a conclusion is correct or incorrect, without actually supporting that particular conclusion.

E.g., "Truman was for national health insurance. But the same Truman dropped the atom bomb on the Japanese, murdering thousands of children with it. Therefore national health insurance is evil too."

Often used in a more roundabout way than that, but that's the gist. It manipulates people's emotions instead of addressing the actual issue. In the example above, it links healthcare to the emotional issue of the nuclear bombing, although the latter really doesn't have any logical implication on the former.

Discussing the morality of God's actions, when the topic _is_ the morality of God, is _not_ an appeal to outrage. If those actions are outrageously immoral, then, yes, it is very relevant to the topic at hand and not just manipulating emotions.

Seriously, BN, at least read the freaking list of fallacies on Wikipedia, if nothing else. It would save a lot of these broken pseudo-logic arguments, and a lot of those links to broken pseudo-logic apologies that you keep posting.
 
Discussing the morality of God's actions, when the topic _is_ the morality of God, is _not_ an appeal to outrage. If those actions are outrageously immoral, then, yes, it is very relevant to the topic at hand and not just manipulating emotions.

The whole idea of "outrageously immoral", I think, belies the fact that there's an appeal to emotion going on here.
The question is simple: is there an objective standard of morality being applied to God's actions, are are you using your own emotions towards certain actions as the basis of judging them as moral or immoral?
If it's the latter, the appeal to emotion is clear.
Either way, of the three main argument types (Logos, Ethos, and Pathos), I rarely find arguments about "God's horrible crimes" that don't rely substantially on Pathos (emotion) for their persuasive strength.
 
You seem to have trouble with it too. No offense. Yes, the moral judgment may be subjective and emotional, but the argument itself relies on facts relevant to the topic at hand.

You may have a better case if you claimed the "Misleading Vividness" fallacy, even though that also doesn't apply in this particular case. That particular fallacy relies on applying, yes, enough pathos and vividness in describing one isolated incident to justify generalizing it as a rule. But the key word is: generalizing. It's really a subclass of the Hasty Generalization fallacy.

E.g., it would be Misleading Vividness if I described in tear-wringing detail the Mai Lai Massacre to conclude that the USA and the US Army as a whole are a bunch of murdering thugs and no better than the Nazis.

But you have to pay attention to the difference between "generalization" and "counter-example."

- Using one Bible incident to generalize that God is _always_ evil and only does evil stuff, that would be a generalization and a fallacy. Misleading Vividness or Appeal To Emotion may or may not be involved in trying to make the case.

- Using one Bible incident to claim that God isn't always good and loving, and commands evil and immoral stuff too, that's just a counter-example. It's not a fallacy.
 
Also, I just can't let this pass...

Either way, of the three main argument types (Logos, Ethos, and Pathos), I rarely find arguments about "God's horrible crimes" that don't rely substantially on Pathos (emotion) for their persuasive strength.

Really?

Tell me, how much pathos is need to make the genocide and rape of Midian in Numbers sound bad? Is it a good thing for you, and only excessive emotional rhetoric makes it sound bad? Or is genocide and rape a moral grey area for you? or what?

To recap: Midian's only crime was being nice and hospitable to the migrating Hebrews. So some Hebrews took wives from Midian, and some even took their wives' religion. Which angered the lord. So it was commanded that Midian be attacked, and all captives, including the non-combatant male children and non-virgin women, be slaughtered wholesale. The virgin girls (presumably most pre-pubescent in that age, but anyway there is no minimum age commanded) get raped instead.

I'm not going to apply any more emotional stuff to it, because for me no more is needed. For me it's an undefendable atrocity. How is it for you? Do you see it as good? Do you think excessive use of pathos is needed to make it sound bad?

Or let's take this scenario: Let's say I drive abroad and kidnap a Czech girl (have you seen how some of them look?) and sell her as a slave. Then I go kidnap a second, shave her head, keep her locked in a room for a few days, then rape her. But she's not as good in bed as I had hoped, so I kick her out in the street. (But can't sell her as a slave any more since I raped her.) So I go kidnap a third, shave her head, keep her locked a few days, rape her. And decide I like this one in bed. So I keep her locked in further and call her my wife, even though she might disagree.

It's not just allowed by the OT, it's commanded.

Do you think that kind of act is good? Or just a moral grey area? Do you think only excessive use of pathos can make it sound kinda bad?
 
The whole idea of "outrageously immoral", I think, belies the fact that there's an appeal to emotion going on here.
The question is simple: is there an objective standard of morality being applied to God's actions, are are you using your own emotions towards certain actions as the basis of judging them as moral or immoral?
If it's the latter, the appeal to emotion is clear.
Either way, of the three main argument types (Logos, Ethos, and Pathos), I rarely find arguments about "God's horrible crimes" that don't rely substantially on Pathos (emotion) for their persuasive strength.
Except that one can describe the narrative from the book of Joshua in very dry terms and it doesn't sound any better.

"The book of Joshua describes the systematic killing of all the inhabitants of over thirty cities and towns."

State the above in an unemotional monotone and it doesn't change the fact the the Bible portrays YHWH as a god who commands his militant followers to kill whole communities, men, women and children. A completely unemotional statement about the numbers killed during the Holocaust doesn't make the death camps more acceptable.
 
None of you have answered my question: Is there an objective standard of morality being applied to God's actions, are are you using your own emotions towards certain actions as the basis of judging them as moral or immoral?

If there's an objective standard, what is it?
Until we agree that some kind of behavior is intrinsically evil, without exception, how can we claim that God did evil?
It seems that your arguments really are boiling down to "this behavior FEELS evil to me; doesn't it to you?" That's a Pathos argument.

EDIT: The really ironic thing is that your responses are also Pathos driven. "But Avalon, these behaviors are SO bad, how can ANYONE not feel, emotionally, that they are evil? Isn't it obvious?"
If it's obvious, back it up with Logos.
 
Last edited:
None of you have answered my question: Is there an objective standard of morality being applied to God's actions, are are you using your own emotions towards certain actions as the basis of judging them as moral or immoral? If there's an objective standard, what is it?
The objective standard is the comparison of the biblical description of divine morality with modern standards of morality observed in our culture. Despite the subjective nature of our cultural standards of moral behavior we still agree virtually universally regarding the morality of specific behaviors. It is a fact that our culture condemns acts of genocide. It is a fact that the Bible attributes to God commandments to commit genocide.

Until we agree that some kind of behavior is intrinsically evil, without exception, how can we claim that God did evil?
Can you provide a scenario in which it is morally acceptable, even just, to attack every settlement in a given territory and slaughter every man, woman, child and infant?

It seems that your arguments really are boiling down to "this behavior FEELS evil to me; doesn't it to you?" That's a Pathos argument.

EDIT: The really ironic thing is that your responses are also Pathos driven. "But Avalon, these behaviors are SO bad, how can ANYONE not feel, emotionally, that they are evil? Isn't it obvious?"
If it's obvious, back it up with Logos.
I'm stunned by your callousness. Do you have any children? I have a little boy. When I think of horrors like the Holocaust, in which even little children are killed and tortured by evil people, I can't help but imagine my little boy as one of the victims. When I read about the death camps I can't help but picture myself with my wife and son being unloaded from the train. That could have been me watching the guards separate us from our child. We'd hold out hope of being reunited with him, but it would be the last time we'd ever see him because he would be taken straight to his death. He'd be nothing but ashes by the time I was assigned to my barracks. Of course I'd be separated from my wife shortly after we lost our son, never to see her again either. The people who experienced the Holocaust were people just like you and me. How can I not feel strong emotions when I think about such nightmares of brutality and hate?

The same goes for the genocide that is so vividly described in the book of Joshua. Can you avoid an emotional response when you think of a soldier finding a three year old girl crying over her dead mother and then raising his sword high and bringing it down to split her skull? Are you completely dispassionate when you think that the cities and towns listed in Joshua must have contained quite a few pregnant young women who were slaughtered?

Frankly, I'm appalled by your suggestion that emotion in the face of such horror is somehow inappropriate.
 
None of you have answered my question: Is there an objective standard of morality being applied to God's actions, are are you using your own emotions towards certain actions as the basis of judging them as moral or immoral?

As morality is subjective, I'd have to go with the second option.
 
None of you have answered my question: Is there an objective standard of morality being applied to God's actions, are are you using your own emotions towards certain actions as the basis of judging them as moral or immoral?

If there's an objective standard, what is it?
Until we agree that some kind of behavior is intrinsically evil, without exception, how can we claim that God did evil?
It seems that your arguments really are boiling down to "this behavior FEELS evil to me; doesn't it to you?" That's a Pathos argument.

EDIT: The really ironic thing is that your responses are also Pathos driven. "But Avalon, these behaviors are SO bad, how can ANYONE not feel, emotionally, that they are evil? Isn't it obvious?"
If it's obvious, back it up with Logos.

I notice that in you haven't answered the questions, and are building a bit of a strawman too. I simply asked how do those actions feel to _you_. Or is the above the answer? What are you trying to say above is that you really don't see anything wrong with those two scenarios other than the (supposedly emotional) way it's narrated?
 
None of you have answered my question: Is there an objective standard of morality being applied to God's actions, are are you using your own emotions towards certain actions as the basis of judging them as moral or immoral?

If there's an objective standard, what is it?
Until we agree that some kind of behavior is intrinsically evil, without exception, how can we claim that God did evil?
It seems that your arguments really are boiling down to "this behavior FEELS evil to me; doesn't it to you?" That's a Pathos argument.

EDIT: The really ironic thing is that your responses are also Pathos driven. "But Avalon, these behaviors are SO bad, how can ANYONE not feel, emotionally, that they are evil? Isn't it obvious?"
If it's obvious, back it up with Logos.

Is there such a thing as objective standards of morality (other than the assumptions of such by those who derive their morality from scripture)?

That aside, I think we can observe what is commonly accepted as morality in our own time and place, and other times and places which we might identify as "civilized," and compare some of the actions and guidance attributed to God in scripture, and find a discrepancy worth noting. Whether or not we feel outrage, whether or not we let these observations color our perception of God, our faith or lack of it, or we simply accept, as many do, the notion that the perpetrators lied when they attributed them to god, the quality of those actions is such that their presence in scripture is hard to reconcile with the notion of a benevolent god if scripture is taken at face value. I don't think we need to come to some perfect agreement on whether this or that action is absolutely, intrinsically evil all the time. It seems troublesome to me that one should even be thinking in the terms of morality for mankind when evaluating the actions of a deity. What good is a god who can handle complex moral issues no better than we can, or for that matter, no better than a stone age war lord? Is it reasonable to revere a deity so clearly a creature of his own time and place? The only arguments I see that attempt to reconcile this rely on a degree of moral relativism that many Christians find abhorrent on principle when applied to anything but their own scriptures.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom