My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

If it's obvious, back it up with Logos.
If society permits rape and genocide, than there is nothing preventing people from raping me or killing me. Out of self preservation and the preservation of those who are close to me, I reject rape and genocide and classify those behaviors as immoral.
 
I'll admit, I don't find anything morally reprehensible in the notion of total war. I'm okay with the idea of destroying an entire community in an appropriate situation -- for example, with completely annihilating cities with conventional and nuclear weapons, as occurred quite often during the twentieth century.
As such, I have no GENERAL problem with the idea of YHWH ordering the annihilation of a community. However, I may very well have a problem with the circumstances.
Which, again, is why I'm looking for logical rather than pathetic arguments. You're appealing to modern sensibility about acceptable and unacceptable conduct in war, but I think your moral standards are far from accurate and universal.
I'll also note without argument, because it's been argued before, that wiping out an ENEMY community is not properly called "genicide". Genicide is carried out in your own kingdom/empire on your own subjects.
 
Last edited:
I'll admit, I don't find anything morally reprehensible in the notion of total war. I'm okay with the idea of destroying an entire community in an appropriate situation -- for example, with completely annihilating cities with conventional and nuclear weapons, as occurred quite often during the twentieth century.
As such, I have no GENERAL problem with the idea of YHWH ordering the annihilation of a community. However, I may very well have a problem with the circumstances.
Which, again, is why I'm looking for logical rather than pathetic arguments. You're appealing to modern sensibility about acceptable and unacceptable conduct in war, but I think your moral standards are far from accurate and universal.
I'll also note without argument, because it's been argued before, that wiping out an ENEMY community is not properly called "genicide". Genicide is carried out in your own kingdom/empire on your own subjects.
Now I only wonder if you are really so callous, or if you are simply doing what you were indoctrinated to do, as I once was. Either way, I find your apologetic arguments to be morally bankrupt and I am further convinced that I want nothing to do with your particular version of Christianity.
 
That's not the definition of genocide I know. But at any rate, the Hebrews had already conquered Midian. I would think that executing any remaining inhabitants would fit your definition too.

But let's keep it simple, since you still dance around the issue with "sometimes", and "in an apropriate situation" and so on. The situation in Numbers is very clearly described. I don't even have to take my (supposedly emotional) description of it, you can take the official version in your own bible. I doubt that those would phrase it in a way that sounds worse. Right?

But anyway, on your particular subjective moral scale how would you rate the following:

1. Executing all the prisoners taken when conquering a neighbour country:
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

2. Mass-executing the non-combatants, including the women and children in a captured city, when you're the conquering aggressor
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

3. Rape of captured pre-teen girls:
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

4. Kidnapping and raping a complete stranger woman from another country:
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

5. Kidnapping a complete stranger woman from another country and selling her as a slave:
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

6. Beating a slave within an inch of his life, so he dies from internal bleeding a few days later (but not on the spot)
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

7. Beating a slave for doing something that he didn't know I didn't want done (e.g., buying some food I don't like for dinner, but he's new and didn't know it and I didn't tell him what to cook.)
A) a good and moral act, as long as it's less savagely than for something he knew
B) morally grey area
C) evil

8. Some people have defected to another religion, angering the Lord. So as a punishment the Lord sends a plague. But not to those who defected, but to his still loyal followers. According to your sense of justice this is,
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

9. Some people in a different country are behaving immorally. They're not in a war with you or anything, just behaving immorally in their own city, and apparently they like it that way. You think nuking two cities to make a point is,
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

10. The Pharaoh is willing to let the Hebrews go. But the Lord apparently finds that too boring, and He strengthens the Pharaoh's heart as an excuse to make the point more spectacularly by murdering a million or so Egyptian babies. Most of those and their parents having nothing to do with the Pharaoh's decision anyway. That is, obviously,
A) a good and moral act
B) morally grey area
C) evil

I could continue, but that should do for now, for a "on a scale of 0 to 10, where would your morals be" kinda test.
 
I'll admit, I don't find anything morally reprehensible in the notion of total war. I'm okay with the idea of destroying an entire community in an appropriate situation -- for example, with completely annihilating cities with conventional and nuclear weapons, as occurred quite often during the twentieth century.
Which is why religion enables the massive loss of life, because people like you think that way.

As such, I have no GENERAL problem with the idea of YHWH ordering the annihilation of a community.
A brutal person would have a brutal god.


Which, again, is why I'm looking for logical rather than pathetic arguments.
I gave a 100% cognent, logical reason for being against genocide and rape. Do you have a logical defense against my argument, or will you rely on emotional charged arguments like "Pathetic".

You're appealing to modern sensibility about acceptable and unacceptable conduct in war,
No, I made an appeal to self preservation and rationality.
but I think your moral standards are far from accurate and universal.
Saying so, doesn't make it so. You asked for a logical justification for my sense of morality. I provided it.
 
I'll admit, I don't find anything morally reprehensible in the notion of total war. I'm okay with the idea of destroying an entire community in an appropriate situation -- for example, with completely annihilating cities with conventional and nuclear weapons, as occurred quite often during the twentieth century.
As such, I have no GENERAL problem with the idea of YHWH ordering the annihilation of a community. However, I may very well have a problem with the circumstances.
Which, again, is why I'm looking for logical rather than pathetic arguments. You're appealing to modern sensibility about acceptable and unacceptable conduct in war, but I think your moral standards are far from accurate and universal.
I'll also note without argument, because it's been argued before, that wiping out an ENEMY community is not properly called "genicide". Genicide is carried out in your own kingdom/empire on your own subjects.

I don't think it requires a "pathetic" argument to suggest that if the best job God can do in administering the universe under his supposed authority is indistinguishable from the actions, motivations, attitudes, and even the language of a stone age war lord, then we are reasonable in questioning either the account that describes him so, or the worthiness of such a god for worship.

I do not think your understanding of genocide is very good. By that definition (sorry to hit the godwin button), the German slaughter of East European Jews, gypsies, and others would not be considered genocide. We're not talking about collateral damage here. The biblical operations being referred to here involved the systematic enslavement, rape and slaughter of non-combatant men, women and children, not in the course of battle, but after the battle had been decisively won. If that isn't genocide, nothing is.
 
Last edited:
The biblical operations being referred to here involved the systematic enslavement, rape and slaughter of non-combatant men, women and children, not in the course of battle, but after the battle had been decisively won. If that isn't genocide, nothing is.

You may be right on that point. Can somebody give me the decisive Scriptural references about exactly WHICH occasions you're talking about?
 
Numbers, chapters 25 to 31. The actual genocide of the conquered women and children in in 31, but the build up to war starts in 25. So you can start there if you want to have a more complete picture. You know, to remove that "sometimes" and "in the right circumstances" doubt.
 
The Canaanites didn't come out very well in Joshua 6:21 either. I think if you read through Joshua you'll find a few more. Accounts of genocides, some smaller than others, are not hard to come by.

Try 1 Samuel 27 for what happened to the Amalekites and a few others.

In Numbers 31, the Midianites didn't do too much better.

This stuff is dead easy to look up, and just as easy to check against a Bible.
 
I'll admit, I don't find anything morally reprehensible in the notion of total war. I'm okay with the idea of destroying an entire community in an appropriate situation -- for example, with completely annihilating cities with conventional and nuclear weapons, as occurred quite often during the twentieth century.
As such, I have no GENERAL problem with the idea of YHWH ordering the annihilation of a community. However, I may very well have a problem with the circumstances.
Which, again, is why I'm looking for logical rather than pathetic arguments. You're appealing to modern sensibility about acceptable and unacceptable conduct in war, but I think your moral standards are far from accurate and universal.
I'll also note without argument, because it's been argued before, that wiping out an ENEMY community is not properly called "genicide". Genicide is carried out in your own kingdom/empire on your own subjects.

Wait, wait... this entire argument still seems to be somehow basically stemming from the previous one (related to actions such as God ordering Israelites to kill Amalekites, even though the original Amalekites who killed the original group of Israelites lived several hundred years before). If this is the case, as it really seems to be, then this entire argument is really based on something other than a secular concept of total war. As such, the central question cannot be reduced to a search for arguments which are "logical vs. pathetic" or moral ideals which are supposedly more relevant to the ancient world.

I brought up one key error of that hideous Amalekite essay, which can also be seen here:

As such, I have no GENERAL problem with the idea of YHWH ordering the annihilation of a community.

The relative morality of certain behaviors in premodern times might make a lot of sense if we were talking about human beings, but we're not-- this is all being presented as the behavior, the judgment, the will, the omnipotence, and the morality of God. We can certainly talk about the many moral levels on which this is offensive, but a huge one, to me, is that it makes God into a serial killer, more evil than the worst human being. This is what happens when people insist on biblical inerrancy and then truly start analyzing what's in the Bible, because there's simply nowhere else to go with the nature of God in that case. If you want a logical argument, that's it (and it was in the seven-page essay, too.)
 
The relative morality of certain behaviors in premodern times might make a lot of sense if we were talking about human beings, but we're not-- this is all being presented as the behavior, the judgment, the will, the omnipotence, and the morality of God. We can certainly talk about the many moral levels on which this is offensive, but a huge one, to me, is that it makes God into a serial killer, more evil than the worst human being. This is what happens when people insist on biblical inerrancy and then truly start analyzing what's in the Bible, because there's simply nowhere else to go with the nature of God in that case. If you want a logical argument, that's it (and it was in the seven-page essay, too.)

I'm not understanding what your logical argument is here; can you try to clarify what your basic claim is and how you justify it?
 
I'm not understanding what your logical argument is here; can you try to clarify what your basic claim is and how you justify it?

Well, for one thing, it was originally here. Basically, though, it's that
divine nature is being equated with human nature. God's actions are being analyzed as if they were the actions of an Israeli military commander in, say, the 12th century B.C. (which I believe is around the correct era for the Israelite/Amalekite incident)-- and yet God is still presented as possessing both complete omnipotence and complete goodness. This is the context in which the relative morality of God's actions is being placed, and I have to say that I think this is inevitable whenever literal biblical inerrancy is followed through to its logical conclusion. Of course this is what you're going to get when reading a book written by human beings. And that's the fundamental fallacy of literal biblical inerrancy. The Bible did not drop from heaven fully written but is a product of the human beings who wrote it, which is why we get narratives such as the Israelite/Amalekite story, where God's motives are somehow mysteriously identical to the motives of the people who emerged victorious from the conflict.
 
Last edited:
Well, for one thing, it was originally here. Basically, though, it's that
divine nature is being equated with human nature. God's actions are being analyzed as if they were the actions of an Israeli military commander in, say, the 12th century B.C. (which I believe is around the correct era for the Israelite/Amalekite incident). This is the context in which the relative morality of God's actions is being placed, and I have to say that I think this is inevitable whenever literal biblical inerrancy is followed through to its logical conclusion. Of course this is what you're going to get when reading a book written by human beings and not by God, and that's the fundamental fallacy of literal biblical inerrancy.

If I'm understanding you correctly, the problem is that we're trying to evaluate God using human standards, and we shouldn't do that because God isn't human.
I entirely agree, but my conclusion is different -- if we can't evaluate God using human standards, then the entire argument goes away. Because the entire argument of God being immoral rests on trying to evaluate God using human standards.
If we evaluate God using human standards, then I claim he passes. But I agree that the evaluation itself is improper, and so the question is actually moot.
 
If I'm understanding you correctly, the problem is that we're trying to evaluate God using human standards, and we shouldn't do that because God isn't human.
.

Well-- that's part of it. The bigger problem, however, is inherent in using literal biblical inerrancy as one's interpretation of a historical event described in the Bible as occurring through God's will. It's where we get, for example, the suspiciously complete correlation between God's command to the Israelites to kill the Amalekites, and just how well it served the military interests of the Israelites to do the same thing. It's a matter of ascribing human motivations to God where they don't exist, and of attempting to cut God down to human size.

And I don't see how it's possible to avoid with biblical inerrancy. This line of interpretation makes it impossible to talk about these (or any other) events in terms of human beings-- fallible, sometimes brutal, sometimes cruel-- who created a narrative which included the way in which they understood God to be working in their lives and their national history and mythology. This is true even though this is a much more logical way to begin to discuss the meaning of what actually happened. (Bruto's argument, for example, makes perfect sense in this context.) John Shelby Spong examines these issues thoroughly in The Sins of Scripture, but a biblical literalist, of course, he is not. Clearly, I'm not either, which is probably not exactly a surprise. ;)
 
Last edited:
If I'm understanding you correctly, the problem is that we're trying to evaluate God using human standards, and we shouldn't do that because God isn't human.
I entirely agree, but my conclusion is different -- if we can't evaluate God using human standards, then the entire argument goes away. Because the entire argument of God being immoral rests on trying to evaluate God using human standards.
If we evaluate God using human standards, then I claim he passes. But I agree that the evaluation itself is improper, and so the question is actually moot.
All our standards are human, by definition, aren't they? So we can't evaluate God at all, and cannot attribute any qualities to him, including those that are, presumably falsely, attributed to him by religious writers and preachers, and in a few cases, by the writers of the Bible itself. If we cannot say God is not good when he orders genocide, we cannot judge when and whether he is ever good.
 
All our standards are human, by definition, aren't they? So we can't evaluate God at all, and cannot attribute any qualities to him, including those that are, presumably falsely, attributed to him by religious writers and preachers, and in a few cases, by the writers of the Bible itself. If we cannot say God is not good when he orders genocide, we cannot judge when and whether he is ever good.

JSS often explores ideas like this in his theological work, and a good example of some thoughts on the subject can be found here.

Here's a quote I particularly liked:

(interviewer) What is the basis for your faith?

(JSS) I have to start at the basics, and that's God. And the thing that I think you have to say about God first is that nobody knows who God is, nobody knows what God is. I don't care what they say--all any human being knows is how they believe they have experienced God. They do not know what God is.

That would be like a horse saying they know what a human being is. A horse knows how a horse experiences a human being. And even when you say, this is my "God experience," there is always the possibility that you're deluded. And a lot of deluded people think that they have had "God experiences" and hear voices. So I start with that--I can't tell you who God is or what God is; I can only share what I believe my God experience is.
 
All our standards are human, by definition, aren't they? So we can't evaluate God at all, and cannot attribute any qualities to him, including those that are, presumably falsely, attributed to him by religious writers and preachers, and in a few cases, by the writers of the Bible itself. If we cannot say God is not good when he orders genocide, we cannot judge when and whether he is ever good.

Exactly. If one can't judge god, then one can't judge god, period. It seems to me hypocritical to see a lot of the same people make judgments to the effect of "god is good" or "god loves you" but then retreat into "well, we can't really understand god" when an attrocity is mentioned.

Also, I think they can spare me the pretense that the bible has any claim to giving humanity morals, if, in fact, reverting to bible morality would be a step _backwards_.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom