I bet the war-mongering thugs who wrote much of the stuff in Joshua and such books never dreamed that twits would be starting arguments about it 3000 years later!
OK RandFan, I'll give you your debate, much as I'd prefer to be spending the time embracing the benefits of progress and modernity, and no matter how gory and off the original thread topic it takes this thread!
I'll respond to your points in due course. First, though, a case study. You might not immediately understand the relevance of this, but bear with me, because all will eventually become clear.
Having finally got me to agree to having this debate with you, reluctant as I was, please do me the courtesy of reading everything I say:
Here's an example of a man who was outraged at the violence in the Bible! A man who saw it as primitive thuggery of the worst order! A man who heartily and very publicly condemned it! A man who was outraged at the thought that people had to hear about that stuff! ...
And Yet: ...
He greatly influenced
two bloody revolutions! Oh yes, this man was no pacifist! He might have thought he had good cause. But did he argue for negotiated settlements? Did he argue that peace should be maintained to protect the lives of innocent parties who might be caught up in the fighting? Did he make any efforts to mediate between the two sides to try to get things settled peacefully? Did he say that surely there must be a better way to solve the problems than fighting? No! He encouraged and even fuelled the fighting! I'm sure I could find articles on the Internet that go into great gory detail about the people who suffered as a result, that would be just as disturbing as the worst descriptions of violence in the Bible and worse. And yet he thought it was all in a good cause!! He fuelled it with his writing!
Paine threw his lot in with those Americans who were thirsting for independence from Britain. In January 1776 he published a short pamphlet that earned him the title The Father of the American Revolution. ...
Paine worked in various positions in America's early revolutionary government. But he was never accepted as one of the founding fathers largely because his restless spirit and appetite for revolution led him to another mass revolt, this time in France.
I'm talking, of course, of Thomas Paine.
See a BBC article about him.
He might have been admirably progressive and compassionate
on paper in his thinking. But oh, the irony of the means he supported to further that compassion! Would you be any different? One of the comments with that article says:
Thomas Paine is over-rated as a political thinker whose main asset was a smart turn of phrase, akin to a tabloid editorial writer today. As a serial revolutionary
who was always preaching change, he was bound to be right at some point and his calls during the American Revolution were right for that moment. He was
though comprehensively out thought and out argued over the French Revolution by Edmund Burke, "Reflections on the Revolution in France" (1790). Paine had
sought to legitimise the French Revolution by quoting the en vogue justifier "the Rights of Man". Burke demonstrated that such unrestricted orgies of destruction
destroyed more liberty than they created, throwing out the good with the bad and led inexorably towards violence and dictatorship, for which the French
suffered for many decades to come. Burke is the true political visionary who should be lauded as having, in many ways, saved Britain from Paine's foolishness.
Yes, the irony!
No wonder his obituary said he "did some good and much harm".
If you'd been there at the time, do you think you might have been enthusiastically supporting his views on the Bible, but equally enthusiastically and frankly hypocritically supporting his calls for the war? "Yes, come on boys! There might be bloodshed. Many widows and children left without the support their menfolk provided. Women and children left grieving for years because their menfolk have been killed. Innocent women and children injured and killed because they've been caught up in the fighting, or left destitute after troops needing food have looted everything in their homes; there might be a great deal of maiming and killing of young men in their prime, some of the injured ones never recovering to be able to work for a living again and always being in chronic pain, left with the indignity of needing help with even basic functions for the rest of their lives; there might be hundreds of men left with trauma disorders who have nightmares for years to come, and flashbacks that disturb their waking hours and fill them with anxiety.
But boys! Let's fight!
Do you think you might have supported the fighting no matter what the possible consequences? Do you think you might have worked for peace, or called for war? Do you think you would have been happy if a compromise deal had been reached and America had remained British to this day, if it had meant no fighting? Or do you think bloodshed was necessary? Really necessary, despite all the suffering that might have made gorier reading than anything in the Bible?
And really, did the American Revolution do good in the long term? Here's a post I put on here some time ago. (It's possible that it contains a few inaccuracies, but I think the basic theory stands.) I'll re-quote it. Again, there is a point to this, so bear with me:
... But the American Revolution should never have happened. Both sides should have negotiated. The American Revolution led to global tragedy on an immense scale. Of course those who caused the later tragedies have to take responsibility. But the tragedies wouldn't have happened if it hadn't been for the American Revolution.
Here's why the American Revolution indirectly led to millions and millions of deaths:
Firstly: If it hadn't happened, all the terrible suffering and slaughter of the American Civil War wouldn't have happened, because when slavery was abolished by the British parliament in the early 1830s, America being a British dominion, slavery would have been abolished in America as well, and American slave owners would have received handsome compensation from the British tax payer in return for giving up their earnings got from slaves.
When the First World War started in 1914, it wouldn't have gone on for anywhere near as long if America had still been a British dominion, because like Canadian troops did, Americans would have flocked to the war at the beginning, and the amount of manpower would have been too much for the Germans, who would have been forced to surrender much earlier.
If they had been, there would have been no humiliating Treaty of Versailles. The Germans would not have been forced to pay so much in reparations and forced to accept such humiliating terms that their country was run-down for years and in a ripe state for a group like the Nazis who promised hope and rejuvenation of national pride to come along and flourish. There were eyewitnesses to the Treaty of Versailles who said they saw the seeds of another war in it.
So if America had been a British dominion and thus Americans had flocked to the First World War at the beginning, there wouldn't have been a second one. No Holocaust. No millions of other lives lost.
And no Cold War either. No. In fact, with Russia unweakened by its battles during the First World War with the Germans, chances are the Russian Revolution wouldn't have succeeded. No Communism. The Tsars might have been pressured to become more enlightened and less tyranical, and not defeated. No millions of deaths under Stalin. No Stalinist crusade to rule Eastern Europe. No mistaken tactical collusion by Roosevelt with Stalin against Churchill which gave Stalin the impression he could get away with taking over Eastern Europe without America objecting. No Vietnam War. No crushing of a secular modernising government in Afghanistan in the 1980s that's caused misery for the people there up until this day. No cultivation of Bin Laden and his followers that led to them being a force to be reckoned with when they turned against America. No 9/11 attacks.
Britain wouldn't have had to give up its colonies after the Second World War because it was too financially drained to be able to afford to hold on to them. So while Britain was becoming more socially progressive and modernising, it would probably have given all its colonies in Africa similar privileges - modern healthcare accessible to all in all those countries, and better living standards. So much of the poverty and death in Africa wouldn't still be around.
[Additional to the original] Britain might not have been so keen to drop its rule of India in a hurry. So there would have been no devastating bloody war between India and Pakistan due to the hurried drawing up of new borders between India and the newly-created Pakistan. Several countries now known for conditions that propagate extremist Islam, including Pakistan, would have remained British as Britain became a more socially-progressive society. Those countries too might have been modernised with healthcare systems much more advanced than they have now. There might have been quite a bit of Westernisation in those countries. And radical Islam might have become a thing of the past, because religious fervour in a society tends to disappear where people are content with life and don't feel they need to look to supernatural sources for anything. See
a post someone put in my old thread Desperation fuels belief in the supernatural.
Oh yes, and just look at a quote from that post:
Code:
"With its low taxes, relatively high rate of poverty and huge disparity between incomes of the poor and rich, the United States displays greater income
disparity than any other industrialized democracy."
"It is no coincidence that religiosity is low in every first-world nation with universal health coverage and high in the only one without it."
Perhaps America would be more like Britain, in the sense of having more social equality, equal access to healthcare, and much less religiosity,
if only it had remained British.
Yes. If America had remained British, the world would have been a much more peaceful and better place until this day.
So, it seems the war-mongering of that ostensible progressive Thomas Paine (who so condemned the Bible for its violence), led to massive tragedy! (Of course, he can't have foreseen the long-term consequences and so can't be held culpable for those in any way.) It seems your own probable hypocritical support of the American Revolution up until this second and into the future is support for a bloody uprising which resulted in enormous ongoing tragedy! Do you still think it was a good thing nevertheless? You still think it was a good thing, even though it could have led to thousands and thousands of times the amount of killing and suffering than anything in the Bible? Yes? You don't think there was an acceptable peaceful alternative that it would have been much better to strive for?
Illustration over. Now, to my point:
If you think the bloodshed of the American Revolution was still necessary, despite the fact that peaceful alternatives would have been possible if only some of the people involved weren't so belligerent, can you still hold up your head and vehemently argue that the Bible's a totally different case - that no seeming atrocity in that could have been justified at all?
You need to debate your case on more than just an appeal to emotion - more than just an appeal to our sense of horror. That would be committing the logical fallacy of
Argument by Outrage. Have a browse of that article, and take in some of the issues it raises, before continuing this debate. It may be that some are examples of faulty reasoning. But you'll have to prove that to make a good case.
Basically, no matter how horrifying we find something in the Bible, you need to argue that there could have been no possibility of something worse happening if what we think of as the biblical atrocity in question hadn't taken place.
For instance, the article argues that the Canaanites were an aggressive race who inflicted suffering on their neighbours. Can you be sure that if the Israelite invasion of Canaan hadn't taken place, everyone would have ended up better off?
Killing a man for collecting sticks on the Sabbath sounds like a gross and barbaric atrocity. But can we be sure that if it hadn't happened, the people would have been better off? What if it had led to many people in the community thinking it was perfectly OK to violate the command about not working on the Sabbath because nothing would happen if they did, so they started making their servants go out to gather sticks, and then to do all kinds of other work on the Sabbath - basically pushing them to work seven days a week. What if it had led to significant exploitation through overwork of servants/slaves?
In order to argue that something was unjustified, you will have to argue that it isn't possible that something worse could have happened if the atrocity hadn't taken place.
From the article on Argument by Outrage:
But if inaction, or a different action -- leaving the Canaanites alone; moving the Amalekites to Southeast Asia -- had ended up in the historical view making matters worse, then critics would in hindsight accuse God of being immoral for allowing the worse things to happen (see point below) and it would be an
example of non-love or even hatred.
I like a point a friend of mine made about this. One Skeptic asked why God simply did not kill Hitler as a baby. Yet if "baby Hitler" had died, the Skeptic would ask why God did not prevent the death of this innocent baby. This shows that a far more critical view is needed than "argument by outrage." Indeed, "argument by outrage" often assumes a form of omniscience by the critic. ...
By the same token, it is not enough for critics to object that there "must have been some other way" for an omnipotent God to have avoided these events that they find morally outrageous. Until they have loaded up their Turtledove Time Machine, such an argument is based merely on emotional speculation.
I put this point to you once some time ago in a light-hearted form, didn't i.
Remember this conversation?? (posts 41-42 and 46)