My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

After all these years you skeptics/atheists still have to argue your point of view from the negative, it's like your not sure, back to the OP, it’s simply a fact that hanging on the cross for even a brief moment would be tremendously painful let alone take on all the sins of the world past, present and future.
Wait a sec. Are you a Universalist, then? All the sins? All covered?
He wanted to be done and die ... relief.
He knew when that moment had come as he stated, “into your hands I commit my spirit.”
Also the father tests our faith to the end even Jesus.
When he says why have you forsaken me, it was because he was still living, he was being tested even then.
Why would God test Jesus? However you want to define the "son" part of this, is Jesus not supposed to be God's special project, specially ordained, magically conceived, etc.? And still, God can't be sure he got it right without screwing around with tests of faith? What a bumbler!
Jesus was part of the father and so are all living beings and all that is alive, everything is part of the creator… just so happens he is called son because he excelled beyond any before or after, or any that are to come that is why he is called the son.
So now his only distinction is that he excels? How about the virgin birth, the prophecies, the resurrection and all that stuff? Are you really just saying that excellence is the only special thing about him?
Jesus has become what we all truly desire.
Not quite all.
 
The evil one tested him in the desert so he Jesus had free will and choice.
You are leaving free will out of it.
All sins that are repented are done by our free will.
There are plenty that won't be forgiven.
All of us are tested every day, skeptic and believer a like.
We are all part of the creator.
Even the best of believers are a failure to a point.

So now his only distinction is that he excels? How about the virgin birth, the prophecies, the resurrection and all that stuff? Are you really just saying that excellence is the only special thing about him?

The prophecies are more so we could recognize him, He still could have failed.
That excellence was the man that was the whole point of letting this creation go on and he also after a while recognizes the signs, just like any other man, but he has a hedge, God the Father, because of the purity of Jesus God answers him directly.
It all had to unfold for him too…. to know.
Everything else is a plus for us, everything about him was special.
 
The evil one tested him in the desert so he Jesus had free will and choice.
You are leaving free will out of it.
All sins that are repented are done by our free will.
There are plenty that won't be forgiven.
All of us are tested every day, skeptic and believer a like.
We are all part of the creator.
Even the best of believers are a failure to a point.



The prophecies are more so we could recognize him, He still could have failed.
That excellence was the man that was the whole point of letting this creation go on and he also after a while recognizes the signs, just like any other man, but he has a hedge, God the Father, because of the purity of Jesus God answers him directly.
It all had to unfold for him too…. to know.
Everything else is a plus for us, everything about him was special.

If even the best of believers fail and even Jesus needs constant testing, then God's requirements are impossible. New covenant or not, he's the same passive-aggressive SOB he was in the old testament.

If things are really as your muddled explanation suggests, then God is a model of inefficiency and incompetence, on top of being gratuitously vicious. A disturbingly human little god you have.

The thing you describe sounds more like a kid playing with a dollhouse or a train set than a deity.
 
Based on what we know of early Christianity, it seems unlikely that an historical Jeshua would have thought himself the son of God in the sense that Christians use it. He may have referred to himself as a son of God in the "we are God's children sense", but the idea of Jesus as divine and the idea of the trinity were not created until long after his death.

Interesting. Can you direct me to any online resources that discuss early Christianity and a non-divine Jesus? I'd like to learn more.
 
After all these years you skeptics/atheists still have to argue your point of view from the negative, it's like your not sure...
That's like a complete non-sequitur.

Jesus has become what we all truly desire.
Jesus has become a blonde with big tits?
 
I bet the war-mongering thugs who wrote much of the stuff in Joshua and such books never dreamed that twits would be starting arguments about it 3000 years later!

OK RandFan, I'll give you your debate, much as I'd prefer to be spending the time embracing the benefits of progress and modernity, and no matter how gory and off the original thread topic it takes this thread!

I'll respond to your points in due course. First, though, a case study. You might not immediately understand the relevance of this, but bear with me, because all will eventually become clear.

Having finally got me to agree to having this debate with you, reluctant as I was, please do me the courtesy of reading everything I say:

Here's an example of a man who was outraged at the violence in the Bible! A man who saw it as primitive thuggery of the worst order! A man who heartily and very publicly condemned it! A man who was outraged at the thought that people had to hear about that stuff! ... And Yet: ...

He greatly influenced two bloody revolutions! Oh yes, this man was no pacifist! He might have thought he had good cause. But did he argue for negotiated settlements? Did he argue that peace should be maintained to protect the lives of innocent parties who might be caught up in the fighting? Did he make any efforts to mediate between the two sides to try to get things settled peacefully? Did he say that surely there must be a better way to solve the problems than fighting? No! He encouraged and even fuelled the fighting! I'm sure I could find articles on the Internet that go into great gory detail about the people who suffered as a result, that would be just as disturbing as the worst descriptions of violence in the Bible and worse. And yet he thought it was all in a good cause!! He fuelled it with his writing!

Paine threw his lot in with those Americans who were thirsting for independence from Britain. In January 1776 he published a short pamphlet that earned him the title The Father of the American Revolution. ...

Paine worked in various positions in America's early revolutionary government. But he was never accepted as one of the founding fathers largely because his restless spirit and appetite for revolution led him to another mass revolt, this time in France.

I'm talking, of course, of Thomas Paine. See a BBC article about him.

He might have been admirably progressive and compassionate on paper in his thinking. But oh, the irony of the means he supported to further that compassion! Would you be any different? One of the comments with that article says:

Thomas Paine is over-rated as a political thinker whose main asset was a smart turn of phrase, akin to a tabloid editorial writer today. As a serial revolutionary
who was always preaching change, he was bound to be right at some point and his calls during the American Revolution were right for that moment. He was
though comprehensively out thought and out argued over the French Revolution by Edmund Burke, "Reflections on the Revolution in France" (1790). Paine had
sought to legitimise the French Revolution by quoting the en vogue justifier "the Rights of Man". Burke demonstrated that such unrestricted orgies of destruction
destroyed more liberty than they created, throwing out the good with the bad and led inexorably towards violence and dictatorship, for which the French
suffered for many decades to come. Burke is the true political visionary who should be lauded as having, in many ways, saved Britain from Paine's foolishness.

Yes, the irony!

No wonder his obituary said he "did some good and much harm".

If you'd been there at the time, do you think you might have been enthusiastically supporting his views on the Bible, but equally enthusiastically and frankly hypocritically supporting his calls for the war? "Yes, come on boys! There might be bloodshed. Many widows and children left without the support their menfolk provided. Women and children left grieving for years because their menfolk have been killed. Innocent women and children injured and killed because they've been caught up in the fighting, or left destitute after troops needing food have looted everything in their homes; there might be a great deal of maiming and killing of young men in their prime, some of the injured ones never recovering to be able to work for a living again and always being in chronic pain, left with the indignity of needing help with even basic functions for the rest of their lives; there might be hundreds of men left with trauma disorders who have nightmares for years to come, and flashbacks that disturb their waking hours and fill them with anxiety. But boys! Let's fight!

Do you think you might have supported the fighting no matter what the possible consequences? Do you think you might have worked for peace, or called for war? Do you think you would have been happy if a compromise deal had been reached and America had remained British to this day, if it had meant no fighting? Or do you think bloodshed was necessary? Really necessary, despite all the suffering that might have made gorier reading than anything in the Bible?

And really, did the American Revolution do good in the long term? Here's a post I put on here some time ago. (It's possible that it contains a few inaccuracies, but I think the basic theory stands.) I'll re-quote it. Again, there is a point to this, so bear with me:

... But the American Revolution should never have happened. Both sides should have negotiated. The American Revolution led to global tragedy on an immense scale. Of course those who caused the later tragedies have to take responsibility. But the tragedies wouldn't have happened if it hadn't been for the American Revolution.

Here's why the American Revolution indirectly led to millions and millions of deaths:

Firstly: If it hadn't happened, all the terrible suffering and slaughter of the American Civil War wouldn't have happened, because when slavery was abolished by the British parliament in the early 1830s, America being a British dominion, slavery would have been abolished in America as well, and American slave owners would have received handsome compensation from the British tax payer in return for giving up their earnings got from slaves.

When the First World War started in 1914, it wouldn't have gone on for anywhere near as long if America had still been a British dominion, because like Canadian troops did, Americans would have flocked to the war at the beginning, and the amount of manpower would have been too much for the Germans, who would have been forced to surrender much earlier.

If they had been, there would have been no humiliating Treaty of Versailles. The Germans would not have been forced to pay so much in reparations and forced to accept such humiliating terms that their country was run-down for years and in a ripe state for a group like the Nazis who promised hope and rejuvenation of national pride to come along and flourish. There were eyewitnesses to the Treaty of Versailles who said they saw the seeds of another war in it.

So if America had been a British dominion and thus Americans had flocked to the First World War at the beginning, there wouldn't have been a second one. No Holocaust. No millions of other lives lost.

And no Cold War either. No. In fact, with Russia unweakened by its battles during the First World War with the Germans, chances are the Russian Revolution wouldn't have succeeded. No Communism. The Tsars might have been pressured to become more enlightened and less tyranical, and not defeated. No millions of deaths under Stalin. No Stalinist crusade to rule Eastern Europe. No mistaken tactical collusion by Roosevelt with Stalin against Churchill which gave Stalin the impression he could get away with taking over Eastern Europe without America objecting. No Vietnam War. No crushing of a secular modernising government in Afghanistan in the 1980s that's caused misery for the people there up until this day. No cultivation of Bin Laden and his followers that led to them being a force to be reckoned with when they turned against America. No 9/11 attacks.

Britain wouldn't have had to give up its colonies after the Second World War because it was too financially drained to be able to afford to hold on to them. So while Britain was becoming more socially progressive and modernising, it would probably have given all its colonies in Africa similar privileges - modern healthcare accessible to all in all those countries, and better living standards. So much of the poverty and death in Africa wouldn't still be around.

[Additional to the original] Britain might not have been so keen to drop its rule of India in a hurry. So there would have been no devastating bloody war between India and Pakistan due to the hurried drawing up of new borders between India and the newly-created Pakistan. Several countries now known for conditions that propagate extremist Islam, including Pakistan, would have remained British as Britain became a more socially-progressive society. Those countries too might have been modernised with healthcare systems much more advanced than they have now. There might have been quite a bit of Westernisation in those countries. And radical Islam might have become a thing of the past, because religious fervour in a society tends to disappear where people are content with life and don't feel they need to look to supernatural sources for anything. See a post someone put in my old thread Desperation fuels belief in the supernatural.

Oh yes, and just look at a quote from that post:

Code:
"With its low taxes, relatively high rate of poverty and huge disparity between incomes of the poor and rich, the United States displays greater income
disparity than any other industrialized democracy."
"It is no coincidence that religiosity is low in every first-world nation with universal health coverage and high in the only one without it."

Perhaps America would be more like Britain, in the sense of having more social equality, equal access to healthcare, and much less religiosity, if only it had remained British.

Yes. If America had remained British, the world would have been a much more peaceful and better place until this day.

So, it seems the war-mongering of that ostensible progressive Thomas Paine (who so condemned the Bible for its violence), led to massive tragedy! (Of course, he can't have foreseen the long-term consequences and so can't be held culpable for those in any way.) It seems your own probable hypocritical support of the American Revolution up until this second and into the future is support for a bloody uprising which resulted in enormous ongoing tragedy! Do you still think it was a good thing nevertheless? You still think it was a good thing, even though it could have led to thousands and thousands of times the amount of killing and suffering than anything in the Bible? Yes? You don't think there was an acceptable peaceful alternative that it would have been much better to strive for?

Illustration over. Now, to my point:

If you think the bloodshed of the American Revolution was still necessary, despite the fact that peaceful alternatives would have been possible if only some of the people involved weren't so belligerent, can you still hold up your head and vehemently argue that the Bible's a totally different case - that no seeming atrocity in that could have been justified at all?

You need to debate your case on more than just an appeal to emotion - more than just an appeal to our sense of horror. That would be committing the logical fallacy of Argument by Outrage. Have a browse of that article, and take in some of the issues it raises, before continuing this debate. It may be that some are examples of faulty reasoning. But you'll have to prove that to make a good case.

Basically, no matter how horrifying we find something in the Bible, you need to argue that there could have been no possibility of something worse happening if what we think of as the biblical atrocity in question hadn't taken place.

For instance, the article argues that the Canaanites were an aggressive race who inflicted suffering on their neighbours. Can you be sure that if the Israelite invasion of Canaan hadn't taken place, everyone would have ended up better off?

Killing a man for collecting sticks on the Sabbath sounds like a gross and barbaric atrocity. But can we be sure that if it hadn't happened, the people would have been better off? What if it had led to many people in the community thinking it was perfectly OK to violate the command about not working on the Sabbath because nothing would happen if they did, so they started making their servants go out to gather sticks, and then to do all kinds of other work on the Sabbath - basically pushing them to work seven days a week. What if it had led to significant exploitation through overwork of servants/slaves?

In order to argue that something was unjustified, you will have to argue that it isn't possible that something worse could have happened if the atrocity hadn't taken place.

From the article on Argument by Outrage:

But if inaction, or a different action -- leaving the Canaanites alone; moving the Amalekites to Southeast Asia -- had ended up in the historical view making matters worse, then critics would in hindsight accuse God of being immoral for allowing the worse things to happen (see point below) and it would be an
example of non-love or even hatred.

I like a point a friend of mine made about this. One Skeptic asked why God simply did not kill Hitler as a baby. Yet if "baby Hitler" had died, the Skeptic would ask why God did not prevent the death of this innocent baby. This shows that a far more critical view is needed than "argument by outrage." Indeed, "argument by outrage" often assumes a form of omniscience by the critic. ...

By the same token, it is not enough for critics to object that there "must have been some other way" for an omnipotent God to have avoided these events that they find morally outrageous. Until they have loaded up their Turtledove Time Machine, such an argument is based merely on emotional speculation.

I put this point to you once some time ago in a light-hearted form, didn't i. Remember this conversation?? (posts 41-42 and 46)
 
I bet the war-mongering thugs who wrote much of the stuff in Joshua and such books never dreamed that twits would be starting arguments about it 3000 years later!
Ignoring your petulant insults, are we to understand that the horrors of the Old Testament are not the work of the god of Abraham? If we excise all the suffering caused by YHWH from the Bible it will make for a much faster read. So what are we to make of your above statement? Are you a Gnostic, a Marcionite? Are the stories of cruelty and horror found in the Bible to be declared abominations and rejected? Does the Bible need a major edit?

OK RandFan, I'll give you your debate, much as I'd prefer to be spending the time embracing the benefits of progress and modernity, and no matter how gory and off the original thread topic it takes this thread!
And no matter how uncomfortable it makes you to have to address the fact that the Bible describes a god who orders genocides and punishes those yet unborn for the crimes of those long dead?

Here's an example of a man who was outraged at the violence in the Bible! A man who saw it as primitive thuggery of the worst order! A man who heartily and very publicly condemned it! A man who was outraged at the thought that people had to hear about that stuff! ... And Yet: ...
Ha ha ha! Paine was a revolutionary and he was appalled by the abuses described in the Bible. Therefor RandFan is a morally hypocrite because obviously the advocacy of violent revolution is a trait common to all those who protest the atrocities described in the Bible.

I'll bet RandFan is none too fond of the smell of cat pee either. And do you know who else didn't like the smell of cat pee? That's right, Genghis Kahn!

But thanks for showing us what you mean by a good argument.


As to the main thrust of your argument: It was a good thing that God ordered those babies to be cut from their mother's wombs because it was the lesser of two or more evils. Ironically, since you mention Hitler, the Nazis claimed that the unpleasant business of exterminating Jews was the lesser of two evils. They had to throw those Jewish children alive onto the fires because otherwise they might have had to learn how to live with them.
 
Last edited:
Foster Zygote said:
It's funny, but you almost sound like some of those early Christian sects that were at odds with the proto-orthodox church.

The atrocities of the book of Joshua are relevant because orthodox Christianity claims that it describes the actions of the just and loving god of the
New Testament. Trying to dismiss descriptions of such terrible, capricious and malevolent cruelty as being the "old covenant" doesn't remove the problem.
It is basically saying "God was evil back then, but he had a change of heart".

No it isn't. It's like saying that Christianity is a way of life, not some simple craven dependence on a God, and like saying that some very bad things happen, but we don't need to let them influence us in any way, especially since they happened a long long time ago. We might not know all the answers as to why they happened, but assuming there was no valid reason and that what happened was just mindless brutality is just argument by outrage. Can I be forgiven for suspecting you're regurgitating the spin on things you've gained from lapping up things on skeptics' sites with the zeal of the freshly deconverted, rather than thinking for yourself, and doing a little research into the cultural background of the day?

Foster Zygote said:
What can make the act of splitting a three year old girl's skull open with a bronze sword and then turning to plunge the blade into the belly of her pregnant
mother seem warranted? I'd really like to know.

Could you contextualise, so I know what you're talking about? If you're talking about something you imagine might have taken place in a broader context, like a war, can you say so, and can you be sure that this is again not argument by outrage? Could you perhaps be talking about the Amalekites?

Foster Zygote said:
Maybe you'd like to have a look at Joobz's Slavery and the Bible thread?

Not unless you give me a few hints as to what to look at. Its 15 pages long or more. Are you suggesting that all those pages are full of worthwhile information? If not, give me a few tips about where to look. And would those posts refute what the articles I posted links to said? You know, the ones Does God condone slavery in the Bible? (Old Testament) and Does God condone slavery in the Bible? (New Testament)? Bear in mind that one of the basic arguments in that was that the institution of slavery was far too varied in type for a blanket condemnation to have been appropriate. For instance, it included a whole range of types of slavery from the brutal to the benign where slaves could be well-off and even own slaves themselves! Does anything in the slavery thread refute the information that the institution of slavery was immensely varied, or the rest of what those articles say?

I have begun to wonder, are the people who cry out vociferously against the outrages in the Bible equally concerned about atrocities going on today, some of which they might be able to do something to prevent? I wonder, are they as interested in preventing modern atrocities as they are in repeating outraged complaints about ancient ones they can't do anything about?

Those same people might make the accusation that if God exists, he must be cruel to allow all the suffering that goes on in the world. Most of them probably won't take into consideration that by the same worldview, God created the mechanism for millions and millions of people to come into being who could actually do things to help relieve that suffering.

So are you showing just as much concern for the suffering of the living as you do for the ancients who are now dead and gone and no one can help them?

Here are some examples of modern suffering and efforts that are being made to help relieve it. Are you involved with concerns such as these, either financially or giving your time or other resources, or do you just let the plight of such people go by while you complain about atrocities committed against people who have long-since ceased to be vulnerable to attack? If so, what's the point? Why the double standard? Why does the suffering of people long-since gone strike you as more of a concern than the suffering of men, women, children and babies now living? I hope your attitude isn't like that and you do in fact have an active concern for such people. But if not, why not? This isn't just addressed to you, but to everyone like you.

Here's some information about modern-day suffering and efforts being made to relieve it that anyone here could get involved in, with the suffering being equally as gory as anything in the Bible:

Children are targets of Nigerian witch-hunt

The rainy season is over and the Niger Delta is lush and humid. This southern edge of West Africa, where Nigeria's wealth pumps out of oil and gas fields
to bypass millions of its poorest people, is a restless place. In the small delta state of Akwa Ibom, the tension and the poverty has delivered an opportunity
for a new and terrible phenomenon that is leading to the abuse and the murder of hundreds, perhaps thousands, of children. And it is being done in the
name of Christianity.

Almost everyone goes to church here. Driving through the town of Esit Eket, the rust-streaked signs, tarpaulins hung between trees and posters on boulders,
advertise a church for every third or fourth house along the road. Such names as New Testament Assembly, Church of God Mission, Mount Zion Gospel, Glory
of God, Brotherhood of the Cross, Redeemed, Apostalistic. Behind the smartly painted doors pastors make a living by "deliverances" -- exorcisms -- for
people beset by witchcraft, something seen to cause anything from divorce, disease, accidents or job losses. With so many churches it's a competitive market,
but by local standards a lucrative one.

But an exploitative situation has now grown into something much more sinister as preachers are turning their attentions to children -- naming them as witches.
In a maddened state of terror, parents and whole villages turn on the child. They are burnt, poisoned, slashed, chained to trees, buried alive or simply
beaten and chased off into the bush.

Some parents scrape together sums needed to pay for a deliverance -- sometimes as much as three or four months' salary for the average working man -- although
the pastor will explain that the witch might return and a second deliverance will be needed. Even if the parent wants to keep the child, their neighbours
may attack it in the street.

This is not just a few cases. This is becoming commonplace. In Esit Eket, up a nameless, puddled-and-potholed path is a concrete shack stuffed to its fetid
rafters with roughly made bunk beds. Here, three to a bed like battery chickens, sleep victims of the besuited Christian pastors and their hours-long,
late-night services. Ostracised and abandoned, these are the children a whole community believes fervently are witches.

From an old article about a charity which is still going: Charity puts food on tables and children in schools

Kieu grew up in a slum in District Four of Ho Chi Minh City, an area notorious for its criminal gangs, prostitutes and drug pedlars. Every rainy season
the tiny one-room hut she shared with her mother, father and two brothers would be flooded with black, putrid water that overflowed from the drain outside
their door.

When Kieu's father suddenly left home, her future looked even more dismal.

Her mother, who earned a pittance as a cleaner, could no longer afford to send Kieu to school, so she was forced to abandon her education and sell cakes
by the roadside.

Kieu is now 17 years old, speaks good English and reports bright and eager every morning at the Hong Kong & Shanghai Bank, where she works as a trainee
in general administration. Once faced with the constant risk of falling into the hands of loan sharks, pimps or drug dealers, Kieu's dream of a stable
job looks likely to come true.

Kieu is one of more than 4,000 children helped so far by the Saigon Children's Charity, which is financially supported by Hope for Children, the British
aid agency chosen by The Independent as this year's recipient of the newspaper's Christmas appeal.

Based in the former capital of south Vietnam, which was renamed Ho Chi Minh City in 1975 after the Vietnam War, SCC aims to give Vietnam's most disadvantaged
children - the poor, the deaf and the disabled - the prospect of a brighter future through education and training.

You get the picture. There are lots more of those where that came from, with much worse stories to tell.

So, are such issues as those more important to you than atrocities against people you can't possibly do anything to help, or is railing against biblical atrocities a far higher priority for you? If so, why?

Foster Zygote said:
Baby Nemesis said:
I bet the war-mongering thugs who wrote much of the stuff in Joshua and such books never dreamed that twits would be starting arguments about it 3000 years
later!

Ignoring your petulant insults,

You're right; it was just a petulant insult. What I should have said was something a bit more cultured and circumspect, like:

I'm wondering what kind of mind-set a person has to be stuck in to want to spend possibly years of their life often repeating things like, "God commanded the rape of women and little children". Apart from the fact that that's a misrepresentation of what the Bible says, what kind of person would want to spend their lives repeating that kind of thing over and over again?

It's not as if my objection is just a religious thing. If someone spent months regularly repeating things like, "Vlad the impaler horribly killed lots of people", I'd wonder why on earth they wanted to spend their lives doing that. Such people wouldn't appear to be the visionaries and innovators of the world!

Perhaps you could reply to that query?

I'll respond to the rest of your post later. Right now, I'm off to do something else. Just a hint: My next comment will be something about a false dichotomy.
 
Last edited:
Foster Zygote said:
Baby Nemesis said:
I bet the war-mongering thugs who wrote much of the stuff in Joshua and such books never dreamed that twits would be starting arguments about it 3000 years
later!

... are we to understand that the horrors of the Old Testament are not the work of the god of Abraham? If we excise all the
suffering caused by YHWH from the Bible it will make for a much faster read. So what are we to make of your above statement? Are you a Gnostic, a Marcionite?
Are the stories of cruelty and horror found in the Bible to be declared abominations and rejected? Does the Bible need a major edit?

Because I suggested the likes of the Book of Joshua were written by war-mongering thugs, that doesn't mean anything so sweeping as that any act of atrocity recorded in the Old Testament couldn't have had anything to do with God. Just think of the old addage, "You just can't get the staff these days!" What cultured, well-educated person with delicate sensibilities would have wanted to write about the gory details of war?

As for whether the Bible needs an edit, it certainly does, though not for the reason you're suggesting. I'd explain the reason, but you know how it is - pearls; swine and all that.

Foster Zygote said:
And no matter how uncomfortable it makes you to have to address the fact that the Bible describes a god who orders genocides and punishes those yet unborn
for the crimes of those long dead?

Does he? Shocking! Where does it say that? Oh, I bet this is the Amalekites again! No, it didn't make me feel uncomfortable to link to that in the least. It is not skeptical to presume discomfort in your opponent, rather than tentatively speculating that they just might be feeling something of the kind.

It's interesting that you should talk about the punishment of the unborn, as if killing them would be a crime when it's ordered by God, but ... are you anti-abortion? No? Thought not. Then you're not against the killing of the unborn when the choice is the mother's, no matter if it's done so late the fetus can actually feel pain while they're being killed? I don't mean to turn this into an abortion debate. I just find the double standard I presume you to have rather interesting.

And where do you draw the line? What about sins of ommission - wrongdoing by failing to help people which will in turn aid generations yet unborn? Is that OK while what the Bible said God ordered was in a terrible standard all of its own? I mean, aren't people somewhat culpable, even where God has nothing whatsoever to do with the matter, if they spend their lives and resources on themselves, rather than on helping others and thus improving the lot of the newborn yet to come? Is ordering the deaths of a few hundred Amalekite men, women and children thousands of years ago so much worse than several million people living the whole of their lives without doing things to help those much less fortunate and so relieve the suffering of newborn babies and children yet to come?

Here's another example of children and other people in need: Human trafficking

There are more people enslaved worldwide today than there were 200 years ago in the lead up to the abolition of the transatlantic slave trade. Human trafficking,
the modern day slave trade, is the fastest growing form of international crime with an estimated 600,000 – 800,000 people trafficked across international
borders each year. The number of people trafficked internally is currently unknown.

People are bought and sold into the sex industry, forced labour, domestic servitude and forced organ donation to name a few.

The CARE campaign focuses on human trafficking for sexual exploitation – tackling the demand for prostitution, ensuring that trafficking survivors are
given adequate care and protection, and raising awareness of the issue.

From another of their pages: The problem today

Lea Kna, from Cambodia, was sold at the age of 6 by her parents who lived in poverty.*The buyer, a family friend, transported her across the border into
Thailand where she was re-sold to a brothel and forced into child prostitution.*
Anna, 15, arrived in Heathrow airport thinking she would be spending her summer holiday babysitting in London to earn some extra pocket money.*The man who
met her took her to a coffee shop in the airport where he sold her to a brothel owner for £3000.*Forced into prostitution, Anna was told that if she tried to escape, her family back home in Russia would be harmed.

Every year men, women and children are bought and sold.*Often traffickers will use threats, manipulation and debt bondage to ensure that their victims do
not escape.*CARE is focussing on the plight of women, children and men trafficked into prostitution in the UK and across the world.*Many are kept in appalling
conditions and are forced to see dozens of clients a day.*Research shows that those who are rescued often share similar symptoms with survivors of torture.*
The CARE campaign focuses on three areas:*demand, victim support and education

Here's an example of some of the intimidation tactics some trafficking victims can suffer:

'If you break your promise lightning will kill you'

First they had to eat some raw chicken liver, followed by a cola nut, some white chalk and a piece of alligator pepper. All of it was washed down with a hot drink with a worm in it.

The five girls stood in the middle of a clearing in a wood some 50 miles from Lagos in Nigeria, surrounded by small statues dressed in rags torn from other people's clothing.

The native doctor cut the girls' arms, drawing blood, and scarred their chests. He told them to swear they would not run away, that they would work to pay
back the money they owed and that they would never tell who had helped them. The man then took locks of their head and pubic hair and pared their finger
and toe nails, warning them that he was keeping a part of them and if they broke their word they would die.

All of this was supposed to be a blessing for their travels abroad. It turned out to be a voodoo curse.

Charity Osatin was just 14 when her uncle's wife's brother - known to her as "Uncle Sam" - offered to take her on a holiday. But Charity soon found herself
in a brothel in Lagos, where she was first raped then forced into prostitution. Now, here she was in a wood with a native doctor, frightened out of her
wits.

"They cut us and told us it would be a secret. They made us swear that if we start working we would have to pay the money back," she said.

"It was scary because of the statues and the blood everywhere. They gave us something to wash your body, and some leaves. I believed that I was going to
die if I told anybody. If you swear and you don't keep your promise, the thunder will come and you will be hit by lightning and you will die. I have seen
it happen and I thought that that would happen to me. They kept some of my body stuff, my hair and nails, and it is still with them so I am still frightened
of them."

On her way to the airport, Charity was surprised to see her picture in a passport with the name Elizabeth on it. With the other voodoo girls, she was heading
for London's Gatwick airport. They had a photograph of a man who would meet them at the airport. He would be wearing a suit, black and white shoes and
have scars on his face.

Upon arrival at Gatwick, the girls were told to go to the toilet and destroy their passports, then they would go to the counter and claim asylum, telling
the officers that they had come from Sierra Leone. Eventually, they would hook back up with the black and white shoes, get a new passport and head for
Italy, where - though they did not know this - they would be forced into prostitution.

Is lifetime failure to try to help victims of exploitation like that in whatever way possible really so much less of a crime than once ordering the killing of Amalekite raiders and their families?

Foster Zygote said:
Ha ha ha! Paine was a revolutionary and he was appalled by the abuses described in the Bible. Therefor RandFan is a morally hypocrite because obviously
the advocacy of violent revolution is a trait common to all those who protest the atrocities described in the Bible.

I'll bet RandFan is none too fond of the smell of cat pee either. And do you know who else didn't like the smell of cat pee? That's right, Genghis Kahn!

As to the main thrust of your argument: It was a good thing that God ordered those babies to be cut from their mother's wombs because it was the lesser
of two or more evils. Ironically, since you mention Hitler, the Nazis claimed that the unpleasant business of exterminating Jews was the lesser of two
evils. They had to throw those Jewish children alive onto the fires because otherwise they might have had to learn how to live with them.

And now I am feeling discomfort. Not because you have a point, but because your attempt at responding to what I said sank so far below boorish misconstruing of the point that I felt a big twinge of mental pain at the thought of sticking around and continuing with a response. Please try to be more analytical.
 
Point of order..

If there’s going to be a semblance of a debate here, can we at least get a declaration of positions? I think I got RandFan’s position, that God is a bit of a bastard, but the counter-position seems to be…Charity is good? I’ve kind of lost track…
 
If there’s going to be a semblance of a debate here, can we at least get a declaration of positions? I think I got RandFan’s position, that God is a bit of a bastard, but the counter-position seems to be…Charity is good? I’ve kind of lost track…

No, part of the counter-position at least, is, "It's fair enough that you should want to condemn God, but why wallow in condemnation of biblical war and atrocity for years on end? Do you care just as much about the living as the dead? And would you actually condemn atrocities that are affecting and have affected people still alive just as vociferously as you condemn those involving people long dead who can't be helped now no matter what you say? Would you condemn the actions of your own government just as vociferously as you condemn the Bible?"

Take the nuking of Hiroshima, for instance. Would you be interested in condemning that at all?

From an article called On the 50th anniversary of Hiroshima

That morning, my grandfather was working in the city about a kilometer from where the bomb exploded. He never came back home.

My uncles went to the city to look for their father. What they found was my grandfather's white bones, identified by the signs of old surgery he had had.
My uncles, whom I never met, suffered nightmares ever after that. They were still young, just teenagers. What they saw in the city then searching for their
father was hell -- too terrible to be true.

The victims were severely burned, their skin falling apart and hanging from their hands, their internal organs bursting from holes in their bodies, their
eyes popped out -- some even had their eyeballs in their hands, dreadful creatures stumbling around crying out for water...

My uncles died years later of leukemia because they were exposed to the radiation in the search for their father. Even when they were alive, their lives
lay in ruins under the shadow of the nightmare of the Atomic Bomb, their family life was wrecked.

Do you ever speak out against the nuking of Hiroshima, protesting that America, powerful as it was, could have at least done more to evacuate women and children first? Do you ever make the case that although an American invasion of Japan might have cost more lives than nuking them, surely there must have been a third, more humane option, if only it had been looked for? Do you never question any of what happened at all? Do you tend to just accept without question that it was what had to be done and no matter how many women and children and babies were killed, it was necessary? If so, why do you care so little about the women and children and babies of Hiroshima? Surely America could have done more to help them?

Could it be said that you tend to feel little for victims who died in war recently, but are filled with outrage about those who died thousands of years ago? Several conflicts have gone on in the past few years where millions of children have been injured, tortured and killed. Have you no desire to help them? Are they just another news story you can happily forget about as soon as you've mulled it over a bit by reading a few posts about it on an Internet forum? Is the suffering of children from the dim and distant past so, so much more real to you that you'll protest that for months on end, while hardly giving the victims of modern conflicts a thought?

The article continues:

But I hold no hatred against American people. On the contrary, I stayed in the US for a year as an exchange student, a joyful year with my host family
and my friends there. ...

I believed I knew more about the war than most Japanese students. I knew about the Japanese occupation of this region, the cruelty of the solders in the
Nanjing massacre, the "live" experiments on 731 troops, the treatment of the prisoners-of-war, and the many other evil things they had done.

Since my childhood, I have heard and read many terrible stories inside and also outside of Japan. In those days, there were plenty of books and historical
material about what the Japanese army did in China and Southeast Asia. Most of my knowledge about the war came from my own reading and listening, not from
school textbooks.

Still, it was only after I came to Hong Kong that I learned how terrible the suffering was in real life, and realized that what I had learnt in Japan was
only a dim knowledge of the war with no real meaning for me.

On July 7th this year, I followed the demonstration of war victims from Chater Garden to the Japanese Consulate, demanding that Japan apologize and compensate
the victims. I was to cover the story as a reporter.

The demonstrators did not know I was a Japanese, but I knew it very well that I was the only Japanese among angry Chinese people. I could deeply understand
their anger against Japan.

Are you just as interested as that person seems to be in trying to get redress for injustices done to people still alive? Are you more interested in doing that than you are about complaining about perceived injustices done to the long-since-dead? Or are atrocities committed against the long-since-dead who no one can help a far greater issue for you?

Children still living are still suffering because of war and atrocity. Are they just as important to you as the ones killed in the Bible? Do you care enough about injustices done to them to speak out about their plight as much as you do about the plight of the long-since-gone?

Children of war: the generation traumatised by violence in Iraq

Parents, teachers and doctors contacted by the Guardian over the past three months cite a litany of distress signals sent out by young people in their care
- from nightmares and bedwetting to withdrawal, muteness, panic attacks and violence towards other children, sometimes even to their own parents.

Amid the statistical haze that enshrouds civilian casualties, no one is sure how many children have been killed or maimed in Iraq. But psychologists and
aid organisations warn that while the physical scars of the conflict are all too visible - in hospitals and mortuaries and on television screens - the
mental and emotional turmoil experienced by Iraq's young is going largely unmonitored and untreated.

In a rare study published last week, the Association of Iraqi Psychologists (API) said the violence had affected millions of children, raising serious concerns
for future generations. It urged the international community to help establish child psychology units and mental health programmes. "Children in Iraq are
seriously suffering psychologically with all the insecurity, especially with the fear of kidnapping and explosions," the API's Marwan Abdullah told IRIN,
the UN-funded news agency. "In some cases, they're found to be suffering extreme stress," he said.

Sherif Karachatani, a psychology professor at the University of Sulaymaniya, said: "Every day another innocent child is orphaned or sees terrible things
children should never see. Who is taking care of the potentially enormous damage being done to a generation of children?"

There are well-founded fears, he said, that the "relentless bloodshed and the lack of professional help will see Iraq's children growing up either deeply
scarred or so habituated to violence that they keep the pattern going as they enter adulthood".

Do you ever speak out in protest against the violence in Iraq, and especially the effect it's had on women, children and babies? These children are still living. Do you care just as much about them as you do about ones who died 3000 years ago who it's impossible to help now? Would you care about modern victims enough to actually do something to help them, such as giving time or money to a charity that helped Iraqi children, or would you just content yourself with putting forward snippets of protests against the violence on an Internet forum, if that?

That article highlights the possible dangers of children growing up to repeat the violence they've witnessed as children if nothing is done to stop that happening.

An article from a survivor of the Hiroshima attacks speaks of growing up being indoctrinated with militaristic beliefs: Story of Hiroshima

I was in the eighth grade when I learned of the outbreak of the Sino-Japanese War, a war which was destined to change our lives, and even our minds. I
was not aware of the evil of war at that time, so I could not foresee what would happen to us. Living in a militaristic system as I did, I became a little
militarist without even being aware of it.
During the so-called "Fifteen-year War", from the Manchurian Incident to the surrender of Japan on August 15, 1945, we were not taught about such things
as the aggression against China and Southeast Asia, the Nanking Massacre, the bombing of Chongging, the repression on the Korean Peninsula, or the real
war situation that developed after the attack on Pearl Harbor and throughout the Pacific War, not the fact that Japan had been the aggressor all those
years. In the name of a "holy war", "nationalism", "justice", and "victory", we shouted phrases like "Hakkoh ichi-u(One world under the sky)," "Ichioku
isshin hi-no-tama ni nare. (Be united in one mind like a fireball, 100 million people!", "Zeitaku wa teki da. (Luxury is the enemy)", "Hoshigari masen,
katsu made wa. (We will endure anything until we defeat the enemy)". We uncritically obeyed orders and made every effort for victory in the war.
When I was in the tenth grade, I was mobilized to serve at a military arsenal, where students in the seventh, eighth, and ninth grades rubbed rust off
cannon balls for five days from July 14, 1939. Instead of our school uniforms with their middy blouses, we wore knee-length trousers, training uniforms
canvas shoes without socks and white cotton work gloves. Not realizing that the war was warping our very minds, I was actually proud of being engaged in
the "honorable" work of supporting the war, though I was only a girl student. I wanted to rub that rust off those cannon balls as quickly as I could. I
worked hard, spurred on by the hope that those balls would kill the enemy, enabling Japan to win the war. Long after the end of the war, this experience
made me reflect on the fearful power of education, and I learned to reconsider the war from both sides, that of the perpetrators and that of the victims.

The article goes on to describe her own experience of the day Hiroshima was nuked. Will you be just as outraged by that as by the killing of the Amalekite children?:

I don't know how long it was, but the next thing I remember was being in the dark, trapped under something extremely heavy. Then I lost consciousness again.
Although I had been standing in the hallway, I had been blown by the blast into a different room. Everything in the room had collapsed with the blast and
my left ankle had been almost severed from my leg. While I was unconscious, an evacuee in the yard thought of me, seeing smoke with a strange smell spreading
inside the building. With my ankle severed to the bone, it was all my rescuer could do to get me out, carrying me on his back from the fourth to the first
floor. Later, my father told me that flames were blowing out the window like red curtains. If my rescue had come even a second later, I would not have
survived, but would have perished there in anguish and tears of hate.
When I was brought to the yard, I could hardly see or hear. Panic reigned, and even the injured ran around, in a frenzy. My father was in the crowd, running
around half-crazy and shouting, "Where is my daughter? I can't find my daughter!" He was shocked to see my severed ankle and begged those around him, who
were themselves injured, for help. Someone at last managed to find a tatami-mat from somewhere. I was laid on it and brought to a safer place. Although
I lost consciousness a number of times, when the bleeding stopped I regained consciousness and my life was saved. When my sight and hearing became more
clear, the figures I saw where hardly even human beings' and the cries and screams they uttered in their death agony -- "water!" "help!" "mother!" were
out of a living hell. There was someone with a blackened face crouching in pain at my right foot. It was my younger sister, bleeding from the glass fragments stuck in all over
her head and arms. It was because she called me "Sister!" that I knew who it was.

I hope you feel just as sympathetic towards her, even though she once polished canon balls with a fierce glee at the thought of them killing the enemy of the Japanese, as you do for Amalekite children. Are you just as willing to speak up about the suffering caused by American actions as the suffering in the Bible?

From another article about Iraq: Iraqi children suffering 'alarming' malnutrition: survey

Malnutrition among Iraqi children has reached alarming levels, according to a UN-backed government survey showing people are struggling to cope three years
after US-forces overthrew Saddam Hussein.

The report on food security and vulnerability in Iraq said almost one child in every 10 aged between six months and five years, suffered acute malnourishment.

"Children are... major victims of food insecurity," it said, describing the situation as "alarming".

A total of four million Iraqis, roughly 15 per cent of the population, were in dire need of humanitarian aid including food, up from 11 per cent in a 2003
report, the survey of more than 20,000 Iraqi households found.

Saddam's 35-year rule was marked by ruinous wars - first against Iran in 1980-88 and then against US-led forces in 1991 and again in 2003 - as well as crippling
economic sanctions in the 1990s.

The aftermath of the US-led invasion has seen widespread violence, with militant and sectarian attacks and killings preventing a return to normal life for
many Iraqis and hindering humanitarian aid efforts.

Do you even speak out against this kind of thing on the Internet, or are your efforts all focused on protesting about children who died 3000 years ago so no one can help them? If they are, why is it that the lives of dead children are so much more important to you than the lives of the living, who can be helped? Or do you in fact criticise the Americans for their invasion of Iraq, and the United Nations for their strict sanctions, and the Iraqi leadership for their policies prior to their overthrow? Is the plight of the living just as important to you as the plight of the dead? Any more important?

Still, hopefully things are improving now. The woman who used to polish the canon balls with glee at the thought of them killing the enemy of the Japanese now campaigns for peace. Are you interested in joining any movements that try to further peace in the world? Do you just wallow in stories of old wars, or are you doing your bit to campaign for a better future? If not, why not? What's the point in just condemning atrocities for the sake of it? How can you be so passionate about selectively condemning certain wars, but not be interested in doing your bit to try to make the world a better and more peaceful place, to try to reduce the chances of such atrocities being committed in the future, even if you can only have a very small impact?
 
I think it wouild be fair to say that we are predisposed to object to genocides that occured as direct fiat of a None existent God and that certain people claim they were necessary and part of God's plan.

The other wars you mentioned are just as horrific; on a scale of human suffering they surpass the sacking of Jericho or the slaughter of the Amelakites. But no sane person claims the atomic bomb was dropped at the direct command of God. We recognise how bestial we can be but we don't make supernatural excuses for it.
 
We might not know all the answers as to why they happened, but assuming there was no valid reason and that what happened was just mindless brutality is just argument by outrage.
An argument by outrage is only a fallacy if the outrage isn't clearly defined and defended.

Your source convieniently discusses exactly this argument about the biblical slaughter of infants, so I will use it. Your source attempts to claim that Position 3, "The killing of children can never be a 'just' act, regardless of competing ethical demands in a given situation," is unjustified and therefore the whole argument is an argument by outrage.


The author's page uses the following example to prove that this is the case:
  1. "Blekthorp" is the leader of the Harlanian race, a peaceful people who only wish to be left alone.
  2. The "Refrons" are a predatory and parasitical race -- say like Star Trek's Borg -- whose only goal is to assimilate others into their culture or destroy those they consider inferior.
The attempt here is to show that there ARE times when killing kids is OK.

But, of course, when you have to invent Star trek races to defend your position, then your position is likely to be equally fanciful. In other words, unless you can show that the Canaanite children were like parasitic aliens (and not the human children that we know exist), the entire argument is nullified.

I'm actually shocked that you would think such an apologetic was a rational position to take.
 
Wow, you've got a fair bit of explaining to do!

Hux said:
I think it wouild be fair to say that we are predisposed to object to genocides that occured as direct fiat of a None existent God and that certain people
claim they were necessary and part of God's plan.

Why? Really, so what if some people claim a non-existent God ordered genocide? Really, how does that affect you? Why is it so disgusting to believe that a God ordered the Canaanites to be driven from their land? Do you presuppose that such a person will be more likely to believe God ordered Bush to invade Iraq? Do you presuppose that it means they'll be more sadistic? Or what? Just what is the objection?

And do you, for example, believe it's more disgusting to believe such a thing, than it is to be totally indifferent to, and not do anything to try to speak out against or attempt to help people involved in wars nowadays, such as children caught up in the atrocities in Iraq? Why is that?

Hux said:
The other wars you mentioned are just as horrific; on a scale of human suffering they surpass the sacking of Jericho or the slaughter of the Amelakites.
But no sane person claims the atomic bomb was dropped at the direct command of God. We recognise how bestial we can be but we don't make supernatural excuses
for it.

The point is not that anyone would claim such things were commands of God - unless you're George Bush of course, - but that there's a question of why anyone who would claim it's disgusting for someone to believe, for instance, that the deaths of the children as well as the others were part of God's plan for whatever reason, would not be equally as vociferous in condemning the American invasion of Iraq and the attack on Hiroshima because women, children and babies have suffered on a large scale because of those; and just as God is claimed to be omnipotent so he could have stopped the suffering of civilians in wars thousands of years ago, it could easily be argued that the Americans are powerful enough to have stopped the suffering of the women, children and babies of Hiroshima and Iraq if they'd wanted to. They could have moved those women and children out of the way, surely! They could surely have assimilated them into American society!

The question is: Why are the people who are so ostensibly disgusted, horrified and appalled that anyone should dare to suggest that they accept that there might have been reasons why the invasion of Canaan might have been a good strategical move etc., not equally as outraged about the treatment of living civilians by modern governments? Or if they are, perhaps they'd like to stand up in their defence and tell us what they're doing to try to improve the plight of those affected.
 
No it isn't. It's like saying that Christianity is a way of life, not some simple craven dependence on a God, and like saying that some very bad things happen, but we don't need to let them influence us in any way, especially since they happened a long long time ago. We might not know all the answers as to why they happened, but assuming there was no valid reason and that what happened was just mindless brutality is just argument by outrage.
But we do know why those things happened, according to the authors of the Bible, at least. They happened because God willed it.

Can I be forgiven for suspecting you're regurgitating the spin on things you've gained from lapping up things on skeptics' sites with the zeal of the freshly deconverted, rather than thinking for yourself, and doing a little research into the cultural background of the day?
You may speculate all you like. I'm sure it makes you feel better to dismiss my position using the above assumption, however, you are incorrect.

Could you contextualise, so I know what you're talking about?
It's quite simple. You suggested that we needed to "delve into the cultural background of the day so you could reel off atrocities without making it look as if you're making things look worse than is warranted". This implies that there are mitigating circumstances that make acts that seem to be atrocious more acceptable once one is aware of the contemporary context. So I would like to know what further information can help to justify genocide. Again, what can make the act of splitting a three year old girl's skull open with a bronze sword and then turning to plunge the blade into the belly of her pregnant mother seem warranted? I'd really like to know.

If you're talking about something you imagine might have taken place in a broader context, like a war, can you say so, and can you be sure that this is again not argument by outrage? Could you perhaps be talking about the Amalekites?
I am talking about the vast majority of the Old Testament. The book of Joshua alone describes the genocide of no less than thirty three communities. The Gibeonites would have been slaughtered as well except that they tricked the Hebrews into signing a treaty promising not to kill them. When they realized the deception they did the next best thing: they enslaved the Gibeonites.

I have begun to wonder, are the people who cry out vociferously against the outrages in the Bible equally concerned about atrocities going on today, some of which they might be able to do something to prevent? I wonder, are they as interested in preventing modern atrocities as they are in repeating outraged complaints about ancient ones they can't do anything about?
Yes, I am outraged by the atrocities happening now. What could possibly cause you to assume otherwise other than a need to denigrate those who disagree with you. But I am not going to ignore the past. I am not going to ignore someone who claims that the Holocaust is a Zionist fiction simply because the death camps were closed sixty four years ago. It is a fact that the Bible is rich with descriptions of genocide and horrific punishments. It is a fact that these terrible events are not portrayed as acts of evil, but rather as the divine retribution of a perfect and just god. And it is a fact that many Christians believe this to be the same God that they worship.

Those same people might make the accusation that if God exists, he must be cruel to allow all the suffering that goes on in the world. Most of them probably won't take into consideration that by the same worldview, God created the mechanism for millions and millions of people to come into being who could actually do things to help relieve that suffering.
But according to the Bible God doesn't just allow people to suffer, he causes it.

So are you showing just as much concern for the suffering of the living as you do for the ancients who are now dead and gone and no one can help them?
Yes, I am.

So, are such issues as those more important to you than atrocities against people you can't possibly do anything to help, or is railing against biblical atrocities a far higher priority for you? If so, why?
You really don't want to talk about the awful things written in the Bible, do you. I assure you that there is nothing that you can say that will shame me regarding my efforts to help others in my community and around the world. I will no longer respond to this attempt at misdirection. We are discussing the Bible as a source of morality. You are welcome to participate.



You're right; it was just a petulant insult. What I should have said was something a bit more cultured and circumspect, like:

I'm wondering what kind of mind-set a person has to be stuck in to want to spend possibly years of their life often repeating things like, "God commanded the rape of women and little children". Apart from the fact that that's a misrepresentation of what the Bible says, what kind of person would want to spend their lives repeating that kind of thing over and over again?

It's not as if my objection is just a religious thing. If someone spent months regularly repeating things like, "Vlad the impaler horribly killed lots of people", I'd wonder why on earth they wanted to spend their lives doing that. Such people wouldn't appear to be the visionaries and innovators of the world!

Perhaps you could reply to that query?
My response is that you are attempting to avoid the actual argument. I have not spent months regularly repeating anything. A discussion has developed into a debate. Do you care to participate?
 
An argument by outrage is only a fallacy if the outrage isn't clearly defined and defended.

Your source convieniently discusses exactly this argument about the biblical slaughter of infants, so I will use it. Your source attempts to claim that Position 3, "The killing of children can never be a 'just' act, regardless of competing ethical demands in a given situation," is unjustified and therefore the whole argument is an argument by outrage.


The author's page uses the following example to prove that this is the case:
  1. "Blekthorp" is the leader of the Harlanian race, a peaceful people who only wish to be left alone.
  2. The "Refrons" are a predatory and parasitical race -- say like Star Trek's Borg -- whose only goal is to assimilate others into their culture or destroy those they consider inferior.
The attempt here is to show that there ARE times when killing kids is OK.

But, of course, when you have to invent Star trek races to defend your position, then your position is likely to be equally fanciful. In other words, unless you can show that the Canaanite children were like parasitic aliens (and not the human children that we know exist), the entire argument is nullified.

I'm actually shocked that you would think such an apologetic was a rational position to take.

Blimey! How can you have so, so missed the point there!

I'll quote the entirety of what it says on the issue, and you'll understand that the position it takes is mind-blowingly different from the position you allege it's taking! How can you have so missed it?

From the article on the fallacy of Argument by Outrage:

In light of repeated use of this tactic by critics, it's a good time to issue some advisories on what such an arguer truly needs to do to make their "argument by outrage" more than just an emotional appeal. This world is not their (the Biblical writers') world; our thoughts are therefore not their thoughts; their
values are therefore not our values. The critic tends to assume that people who lived in this day and age were "just like us" and would have reacted with the same immediate moral outrage as they did. That is simply not the case.

Mere statement of data on a broad level argues for nothing; a moral hierarchy must be examined and established. Take these two statements:

• Hitler exterminated 6 million Jews.
• Blethkorp exterminated 6 million Refrons.

We are rightly filled with moral outrage at the first one. But why? The obvious reason is that we know about Hitler and we know about his Master race schemes; we know about his attempt to seize power; we know from the data that he was morally wrong.

The core of "argument by outrage" is to take something like the second item, however, and shake out the "least common denominator" so that the moral equivalency is made to seem to be the same.

However, what if we start defining out the second one so that:

1. "Blekthorp" is the leader of the Harlanian race, a peaceful people who only wish to be left alone.
2. The "Refrons" are a predatory and parasitical race -- say like Star Trek's Borg -- whose only goal is to assimilate others into their culture or destroy those they consider inferior.

Now that we have the context, whence is the "argument by outrage"? I have chosen a clearly extreme illustration, but between these extremes of black and white lie shades of gray which are a combination of black and white. We would suppose that any critic would agree that the Harlanians have a right to defend themselves. If the Refrons refuse to give up -- are willing to fight to the last to achieve their goal -- is it a moral outrage that the Harlanians exterminated
6 million of them? How indeed if the total population of Refrons was somewhere around 70 billion and executing 6 million was the only way to get the Refrons to decide that the cost of conquest was too high?

The article's simply making the point there that things may well be more complex than they seem on the surface, so any outrage has to be based on more than just an appeal to emotion.

OK, take an entirely non-fanciful example, and it's just the same:

The Americans killed hundreds of thousands of Japanese, including women, children and babies, by dropping a nuclear bomb on Hiroshima.

Now, if you'd never heard of that before, and then someone told you of it, just like that, totally devoid of the context in which they did it, wouldn't you be outraged? Wouldn't you be shocked that an American government could apparently psychopathically order the deaths by nuking of thousands of Japanese? If you knew nothing of the provocation, wouldn't you be appalled that such a thing could ever be done?

You see how outrage can be generated by a totally distorted picture of the circumstances. That's the point the article's making. In order to justify the outrage, it has to be established that there cannot possibly have been a legitimate reason for what happened, or else that there were far better alternatives. It's not good enough to just say, "There must have been!" Unless plausible ones can be suggested, how do we know that? See my post here in another thread for some idea of possible issues. ... No, why not, I'll quote it here:

Baby Nemesis said:
RandFan said:
Oh, I like this post. Yes, why is it that we ordinary mortals could think of so many better solutions to problems than god. Could it be that humans are
problem solving beings and it is easier to solve problems by learning from past mistakes and our modern solutions are ever so much better than ancient
bronze age ones?

It seems so.

But then, if I was God, I might discover there were dilemmas when I was thinking of interfering to change something in the world that I'd never dreamed I'd have as a mortal imagining I was God. Here's an example of the kinds of dilemmas I might face, from this philosophy humour page: Trolley problem: Consider the following case:

Code:
A brain in a vat on Twin Earth is at the wheel of a runaway trolley. There are only two options that the brain can take: the right side of the fork in the track or the left side of the fork. There is no way in sight of derailing or stopping the trolley and the brain is aware of this, for the brain knows trolleys.
The brain is causally hooked up to the trolley such that the brain can determine the course which the trolley will take. 

On the right side of the track there is a single railroad worker, Jones, who will definitely be killed if the brain steers the trolley to the right. If the railman on the right lives, he will go on to kill five men for the sake of killing them, but in doing so will inadvertently save the lives of thirty
orphans (one of the five men he will kill is planning to destroy a bridge that the orphan's bus will be crossing later that night). One of the orphans that will be killed would have grown up to become a tyrant who would make good utilitarian men do bad things. Another of the orphans would grow up to become
G.E.M. Anscombe, while a third would invent the pop-top can. 

If the brain in the vat chooses the left side of the track, the trolley will definitely hit and kill a railman on the left side of the track, "Leftie" and will hit and destroy ten beating hearts on the track that could (and would) have been transplanted into ten patients in the local hospital that will
die without donor hearts. These are the only hearts available, and the brain is aware of this, for the brain knows hearts. If the railman on the left side of the track lives, he too will kill five men, in fact the same five that the railman on the right would kill. However, "Leftie" will kill the five as
an unintended consequence of saving ten men: he will inadvertently kill the five men rushing the ten hearts to the local hospital for transplantation.
A further result of "Leftie's" act would be that the busload of orphans will be spared. ... Also assume that if the brain chooses the right side of the fork, an unjust war free of war crimes will ensue, while if the brain chooses the left fork, a just war fraught with war crimes will result. ...

Obviously that isn't an exact analogy with God, but you hopefully get the idea. Things might be more complex than they may seem.
 
Last edited:
This isn't an argument that you want to make, really. The logical progression is:

-we should be doing more to prevent these attrocities.
-most of these attrocities, as evidenced in both Scholarly history and Biblical History, are a result of religion.
Therefore, the only logical response is to abandon religion. And before you start, I will agree that not all of bad things are a result of religion. But it is still a leading cause, and abandoning it is still the logical thing to do based on your arguments.

Really, I don't think this is going to end where you want it.
 
Because I suggested the likes of the Book of Joshua were written by war-mongering thugs, that doesn't mean anything so sweeping as that any act of atrocity recorded in the Old Testament couldn't have had anything to do with God.
So God can commit atrocities like commanding his worshipers to slaughter children. How is that not evil?

Just think of the old addage, "You just can't get the staff these days!" What cultured, well-educated person with delicate sensibilities would have wanted to write about the gory details of war?
Yes, anyone who could brag about the slaughter of women and children would have to be the worst sort of monster.

As for whether the Bible needs an edit, it certainly does, though not for the reason you're suggesting. I'd explain the reason, but you know how it is - pearls; swine and all that.
I've come to expect such petulance from you. It's sad that you are unable to debate those who disagree with you without feeling contempt and anger. There are quite a few theist on this forum who posses the emotional maturity to debate issues with those who hold differing views while showing respect and even friendship. Personally, I think they shame you.

Yes, he does.

Shocking!
That's what I thought.

Where does it say that?
Exodus 20:5 You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, punishing the children for the sin of the fathers to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me.

Deuteronomy 5:9 You shall not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God, punishing the children for the sin of the fathers to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me.

Oh, I bet this is the Amalekites again!
Nope.

It is not skeptical to presume discomfort in your opponent, rather than tentatively speculating that they just might be feeling something of the kind.
Foster Zygote said:
And no matter how uncomfortable it makes you to have to address the fact that the Bible describes a god who orders genocides and punishes those yet unborn
for the crimes of those long dead?
Did you note the question mark? It was a question, not an assumption.

It's interesting that you should talk about the punishment of the unborn, as if killing them would be a crime when it's ordered by God, but ... are you anti-abortion? No? Thought not.
It's especially interesting that you would erroneously berate me for making an assumption and then proceed to make another assumption about me (the first being that I have no concern for present human suffering and the second being that I make no effort to lessen the suffering of others). Not to mention that, even if you were correct about me, your argument amounts to nothing but a tu quoque fallacy.
 
Blimey! How can you have so, so missed the point there!
I didn't miss the point at all. It was quite clear that it tried to say there are mitigating circumstances where killing children is excusable. The author attempted to highlight this point by creating an "extreme" (read completely fictional) analogy to the killing off of a entire species.

Now, do you have any actual argument that can justify the slaughter of children?

OK, take an entirely non-fanciful example, and it's just the same:

The Americans killed hundreds of thousands of Japanese, including women, children and babies, by dropping a nuclear bomb on Hiroshima.
and it was horrible. one could claim it was justified, but that makes it no less horrible or divinely right.


Remember (It seems you are forgetting this point), the issue here is that supposedly god ordained these actions. God who is supposedly good and just. If you can come up with a good argument for a soldier to kill a child, an infant. then do so.

But if your best defense is, "Well they could have been parasites, or America did it too", that's not convincing argument for a divinely just and benevolent being.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom