DevilsAdvocate
Philosopher
- Joined
- Nov 18, 2004
- Messages
- 7,686
So the Bible says:
This is similar to:
The Psalm goes on about believing in God even though he doesn’t respond when you need him because God responds when you need him. (Doesn’t make sense to me either.)
Matthew goes on about someone giving Jesus a sponge of vinegar to drink, and how Jesus was calling for Elias to come save him and waiting to see if Elias comes to save him. Which he doesn’t. Jesus yells again and dies. A temple is split in two and the earth shakes. Zombies come out of their graves. Then a disciple comes and takes the body.
So, why was Jesus screaming about being forsaken? If he was the son of God, and God-embodied-as-man, and he died for our sins, and so forth, shouldn’t he have been all like, “Way cool! I’m dying on this cross to save everyone’s sin’s…just like I planned! This is so awesome! People should remember how great this is forever and ever…with a bunch of sculptures and necklaces and stuff showing how really great this moment is!!!”
But he didn’t. He was all like, “Wait! This is going all wrong!!!!”
Why would the writer’s of the Bible have Jesus say this? Why not have Jesus say, “I will now die so that everyone’s sins will be forgiven.” Or something plain like that. It seems clear the writer’s copied from Pslams, but why? Maybe if Matthew went on with something about how even Jesus could feel that God ignored him that you can too it would makes sense, but Matthew doesn’t do that. It just goes on to vinegar, will Elias save him, he dies, they take his body. No BIG LESSON like in Psalms.
Why would Jesus have said what he said? Why would the writer’s of the Bible have had Jesus say what he said?
Matthew 27:46 said:And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? that is to say, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?
This is similar to:
Psalm 22:1 said:My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? why art thou so far from helping me, and from the words of my roaring?
The Psalm goes on about believing in God even though he doesn’t respond when you need him because God responds when you need him. (Doesn’t make sense to me either.)
Matthew goes on about someone giving Jesus a sponge of vinegar to drink, and how Jesus was calling for Elias to come save him and waiting to see if Elias comes to save him. Which he doesn’t. Jesus yells again and dies. A temple is split in two and the earth shakes. Zombies come out of their graves. Then a disciple comes and takes the body.
So, why was Jesus screaming about being forsaken? If he was the son of God, and God-embodied-as-man, and he died for our sins, and so forth, shouldn’t he have been all like, “Way cool! I’m dying on this cross to save everyone’s sin’s…just like I planned! This is so awesome! People should remember how great this is forever and ever…with a bunch of sculptures and necklaces and stuff showing how really great this moment is!!!”
But he didn’t. He was all like, “Wait! This is going all wrong!!!!”
Why would the writer’s of the Bible have Jesus say this? Why not have Jesus say, “I will now die so that everyone’s sins will be forgiven.” Or something plain like that. It seems clear the writer’s copied from Pslams, but why? Maybe if Matthew went on with something about how even Jesus could feel that God ignored him that you can too it would makes sense, but Matthew doesn’t do that. It just goes on to vinegar, will Elias save him, he dies, they take his body. No BIG LESSON like in Psalms.
Why would Jesus have said what he said? Why would the writer’s of the Bible have had Jesus say what he said?