My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

DevilsAdvocate

Philosopher
Joined
Nov 18, 2004
Messages
7,686
So the Bible says:

Matthew 27:46 said:
And about the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani? that is to say, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?

This is similar to:

Psalm 22:1 said:
My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? why art thou so far from helping me, and from the words of my roaring?

The Psalm goes on about believing in God even though he doesn’t respond when you need him because God responds when you need him. (Doesn’t make sense to me either.)

Matthew goes on about someone giving Jesus a sponge of vinegar to drink, and how Jesus was calling for Elias to come save him and waiting to see if Elias comes to save him. Which he doesn’t. Jesus yells again and dies. A temple is split in two and the earth shakes. Zombies come out of their graves. Then a disciple comes and takes the body.

So, why was Jesus screaming about being forsaken? If he was the son of God, and God-embodied-as-man, and he died for our sins, and so forth, shouldn’t he have been all like, “Way cool! I’m dying on this cross to save everyone’s sin’s…just like I planned! This is so awesome! People should remember how great this is forever and ever…with a bunch of sculptures and necklaces and stuff showing how really great this moment is!!!”

But he didn’t. He was all like, “Wait! This is going all wrong!!!!”

Why would the writer’s of the Bible have Jesus say this? Why not have Jesus say, “I will now die so that everyone’s sins will be forgiven.” Or something plain like that. It seems clear the writer’s copied from Pslams, but why? Maybe if Matthew went on with something about how even Jesus could feel that God ignored him that you can too it would makes sense, but Matthew doesn’t do that. It just goes on to vinegar, will Elias save him, he dies, they take his body. No BIG LESSON like in Psalms.


Why would Jesus have said what he said? Why would the writer’s of the Bible have had Jesus say what he said?
 
Same reason the night before he prayed to god not to have to do this thing.

He really didn't seem all that into saving us all.
 
But even if Jesus was all like, “Oh heck. I’m going to have to die a painful crucifixion death and stuff to save everyone’s sins forever. This is really going to suck hard and I would much rather not do it.” Then why does he say that God has “forsaken” him? Praying for it not to happen is just more support for the idea that Jesus knew EXACTLY what was going to happen. Why would he feel “forsaken” if he feels everything is going as planned?
 
But even if Jesus was all like, “Oh heck. I’m going to have to die a painful crucifixion death and stuff to save everyone’s sins forever. This is really going to suck hard and I would much rather not do it.” Then why does he say that God has “forsaken” him? Praying for it not to happen is just more support for the idea that Jesus knew EXACTLY what was going to happen. Why would he feel “forsaken” if he feels everything is going as planned?

Pick the answer which you think feel fits better. For my own part. I think Jesus, in part, didn't want to do it. He was part human and he knew the burden he was experiencing and going to experience would be unbelievable. But he loved us so much that he went through all of it for us. God loved humans so much that he gave up the riches of heaven, became a man, and suffered and died on the cross for us.

That is the message of the Cross.

http://www.hcna.us/columns/foresaken jesus02.htm

The most common and traditional answer to this question has to do with the nature of God and the nature of sin.... It’s the perfect in goodness and righteousness that’s the key to understanding who God is in relation to sin. According to this tradition, because of God’s holiness, that is, because of God’s perfect goodness, God is unable to abide the presence of evil or sin. Indeed, included in the ancient understanding of the word holy is a sense of separation from evil. I’ve had it explained that it’s sort of the matter/anti-matter theory that if ever the two come together then the two may cease to exist completely (actually, it’s a more complicated theory than that, but this is the basic concept). In any case, this tradition teaches that God can be nowhere near evil because God is so holy.

So, when Jesus was crucified, according to this tradition, he took all the sins of the world upon himself. This being so, God had to turn from him, literally abandoning him to this “sinfulness.” Jesus, left without the support of his heavenly father, cried out in anguish, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” And the answer apparently was, “Because you are so filled with sin and evil that I cannot fellowship, help, or even look upon you. You’re on your own.”

I think the answer is best summed up by a bumper sticker I saw sometime ago: “If you feel far from God, who moved?” Jesus, the son of God, was abandoned by his closest friends, arrested and tried for treason, battered by the temple soldiers, beaten and crucified by the Roman soldiers, and ridiculed and taunted by the passersby. If anyone has ever faced a dark night of the soul, then Jesus faced that from the cross. Whether it was from the sin of the world, or from the crushing agony of emotions run amuck, Jesus must have felt just as you or I might have felt in similar circumstances—totally and utterly abandoned by God.

For God’s part, there was no turning away. Not then, not ever. God must have been experiencing every bit of the agony as he watched his own child slowly and painfully suffering and dying. How much more the hurt as Jesus cried out from his own inner darkness, reaching for a God who seemed so far away. But just because we can’t “feel” God’s presence, that doesn’t mean that God is not there.
 
But even if Jesus was all like, “Oh heck. I’m going to have to die a painful crucifixion death and stuff to save everyone’s sins forever. This is really going to suck hard and I would much rather not do it.” Then why does he say that God has “forsaken” him? Praying for it not to happen is just more support for the idea that Jesus knew EXACTLY what was going to happen. Why would he feel “forsaken” if he feels everything is going as planned?

When I was religious, I was taught that as he hung there, he took on our sins, and god could not stand him, was forced to reject him, because god cannot abide sin.

But then, the whole fairy tale is pretty sadistic and cruel.
 
DevilsAdvocate said:
So, why was Jesus screaming about being forsaken? If he was the son of God, and God-embodied-as-man, and he died for our sins, and so forth, shouldn’t
he have been all like, “Way cool! I’m dying on this cross to save everyone’s sin’s…just like I planned! This is so awesome! People should remember how
great this is forever and ever…with a bunch of sculptures and necklaces and stuff showing how really great this moment is!!!”

Oh come on, at least give us good arguments! You make crucifixion sound like a drug high! The reality of crucifixion would be very different and very painful: A Physician Analyzes the Crucifixion.
 
When I was religious, I was taught that as he hung there, he took on our sins, and god could not stand him, was forced to reject him, because god cannot abide sin.

But then, the whole fairy tale is pretty sadistic and cruel.

It was sadistic that humans did that to God, but it was love that caused him to suffer for us. I don't see how that can be cruel and sadistic.

When you die for someone else it is the greatest love you can show. Which is why Jesus died on the cross.

God could have, if he wanted, chosen a different path to salvation that didn't involve Jesus dying on the cross. We don't know what that would be, but it could have been an infinite number of things, no doubt.

So then one has to ask why God choose the path he did, and we don't have an answer for that, and God doesn't have to answer either.
 
It was sadistic that humans did that to God, but it was love that caused him to suffer for us. I don't see how that can be cruel and sadistic.

When you die for someone else it is the greatest love you can show. Which is why Jesus died on the cross.

God could have, if he wanted, chosen a different path to salvation that didn't involve Jesus dying on the cross. We don't know what that would be, but it could have been an infinite number of things, no doubt.

So then one has to ask why God choose the path he did, and we don't have an answer for that, and God doesn't have to answer either.



I don't think anyone did anything to any god, because I don't believe any gods exist.

So I don't have to ask any of that nonsense up there.
 
But even if Jesus was all like, “Oh heck. I’m going to have to die a painful crucifixion death and stuff to save everyone’s sins forever. This is really going to suck hard and I would much rather not do it.” Then why does he say that God has “forsaken” him? Praying for it not to happen is just more support for the idea that Jesus knew EXACTLY what was going to happen. Why would he feel “forsaken” if he feels everything is going as planned?

Knowing this god fellow I suspect he told Jesus one thing and then of course did the exact opposite:

God: OK sonny-boy I need you to undergo one of the most painful forms of execution ever devised.
J-Boy: Won't that hurt?
God: No - I'll be there with you and I'll make sure no harm comes your way.
J-Boy: Like when you said "I need a word with you - go into the desert so we can have a bit of privacy" and then you never turned up and it took me 40 bloody days to find my way back?
God: Look - I said I'm sorry about that, you know how it is you get busy, you forget to check your calendar and I'd totally forgotten I'd said to Zeus and Odin I'd go on that fishing trip. I couldn't let them down.
J-Boy: OK... so you absolutely promise if I go ahead with this you'll make sure no harm comes to me?
God: Absolutely, 100%.

Next day:

J-Boy: You barstool!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
How can an immortal god die?

I've heard the pathetic excuse, again here, that god was in the form of a man.

Well is just doesn't cut it.

It's exactly like me sending an old car to be scrapped.

The car, like Gods human form called Jesus, was just a device to perform a function. The car to get me from A to B, the Jesus body, Gods device for fooling people. The car is not me and Jesus body is not God, just a shell inhabited for a while.

I get out of the car as it's being scrapped, God pops out of his Jesus body as it's being scrapped crucified.

I have a little trick planned for my friends so bolt all the bits back on my car and drive by a few of their houses for them to see although they think it's scrapped, God jumps back in his Jesus body and goes "Woooo! Look at me" to the poor saps that were his friends that thought he was dead.

I hide the car and get out, back to my normal life, trick completed, God hides the Jesus body, trick completed and goes back to Godding, smiting and being a bastard.

If he changed himself completely into a man, who was looking after the universe while he was playing Jesus and how can an ordinary man turn himself (back) into a God? Who was Jesus talking to?

For the fairy story to work, God must have just been hiding inside something that looked like a man. A bit like me saying "Hey! I'm a car". He was still God and still immortal and cannot die.

The whole idea is deeply flawed as most five year old know but get told "It just IS!". I'm astounded grown-up think this is real.

Am I missing something?
 
Last edited:
I personally like the hypothesis that Jesus faked his own death because he was trying to get people to believe he was the fabled messiah and not another one of the dozens of people who had and have claimed to be the messiah.
 
I think IF there was a Jesus, (big if), he may have been some guy deluded into thinking he was god's son. He basked in the celebrity. Then one day, while they were driving nails through his feet, he slowly faced the fact that his delusion wasn't real. His last thoughts would have been "damn, betrayed" because his delusional god didn't rescue him.
 
And for an alternative apologetic, see this: :p

Even more surprising is the apparent lapse of faith that Jesus seems to have experienced during his ordeal on the cross when he cried out: "My God, my God,
why hast thou forsaken me?" (Matthew 27:46; Mark 15:34).

Morgan here works with what is again an errant definition of pistis. Even so, as we have noted elsewhere, one of the long-standing customs of Hebrew thought
and language is to refer to a particular prayer, Psalm, blessing, etc. by the first word(s) of the prayer, Psalm, blessing, etc. When Jesus cried "My God,
My God, why has Thou forsaken Me?", He was drawing the attention of the Jews who were present at the crucifixion to Psalm 22. In effect, Jesus was saying
that He is the fulfillment of Psalm 22, a Psalm which the Jews had always seen as a Messianic Psalm. As the Messiah, Jesus was not only concerned with
fulfilling the role of the Messiah but also with making His identity known to His followers.

In this regard, Jesus drew the attention of the Jews to Psalm 22 while He was hanging on the cross. The observant Jew immediately knew what Jesus was referring
to. The observant Jew also knew that Psalm 22 was a Messianic Psalm.
 
Uh-huh. What does Luke say he said?

"And when Jesus had cried with a loud voice, he said, Father, into thy hands I commend my spirit: and having said thus, he gave up the ghost." (Luke 23:46)

And what does John say?

"When Jesus therefore had received the vinegar, he said, It is finished: and he bowed his head, and gave up the ghost." (John 19:30)

Not only do the biblical accounts differ, they differ in a systematic way. Matthew and Mark say the same thing - this is obvious, because Matthew copies Mark rather a lot. In Mark, Jesus' divinity is hidden - he is constantly exhorting people (and demons) not to tell anyone who he really is. Luke and John start developing the theme of the divine being - specifically, in this case, eliminating the doubt expressed in Mark and Matthew in favour of words that better reflect Jesus' status as the willing sacrifice.

This progression shows clearly the inflation of circumstances that is common in much folklore. Jesus' divinity is gradually built up over the course of many years until by John (the latest Gospel to have been written) he is a fully divine being, willing and capable of performing many miracles and showing his divinity to all.

The other event in which this is clear is Jesus assumption into heaven after the resurrection. In Mark, this is described only very briefly (and I understand that many scholars believe that Mark 16 is a later addition to the original Gospel). Matthew adds earthquakes and lightning as an angel comes down from heaven. Luke adds more detail - about the discarded clothes in the tomb, and showing his hands and feet to the Apostles. Finally, by John, there's the story of Doubting Thomas, and Jesus appearing on the shores of the sea of Galilee - two whole chapters worth of post-resurrection appearances - cementing his appearance as divine. The stories get better and better as they go along! Which is exactly what we see with all folklore, especially that derived from oral histories.
 
When I was religious, I was taught that as he hung there, he took on our sins, and god could not stand him, was forced to reject him, because god cannot abide sin.

But then, the whole fairy tale is pretty sadistic and cruel.

At its best, religion offers expiation for the guilt one feels, from time to time--an 'opiate of the people', as Karl Marx observed.

At its worst, religion insidiates itself into one's life and dramatizes the guilt in order to make itself more potent.
 
As Arthwollipot says, the versions of this event differ in the different gospels. Bart Ehrman discusses this at length in Misquoting Jesus, and shows how this was a matter of considerable dissent in the early Christian sects.
Some groups felt that Jesus was merely possessed by the "spirit" of God, and that this spirit left him on the cross. Thus the "forsaken" bit.
Later, this was changed to indicate a fully-godlike Christ who was in control of the whole show.
 
Uh-huh. What does Luke say he said?

"And when Jesus had cried with a loud voice, he said, Father, into thy hands I commend my spirit: and having said thus, he gave up the ghost." (Luke 23:46)

And what does John say?

"When Jesus therefore had received the vinegar, he said, It is finished: and he bowed his head, and gave up the ghost." (John 19:30)

Not only do the biblical accounts differ, they differ in a systematic way. Matthew and Mark say the same thing - this is obvious, because Matthew copies Mark rather a lot. In Mark, Jesus' divinity is hidden - he is constantly exhorting people (and demons) not to tell anyone who he really is. Luke and John start developing the theme of the divine being - specifically, in this case, eliminating the doubt expressed in Mark and Matthew in favour of words that better reflect Jesus' status as the willing sacrifice.

This progression shows clearly the inflation of circumstances that is common in much folklore. Jesus' divinity is gradually built up over the course of many years until by John (the latest Gospel to have been written) he is a fully divine being, willing and capable of performing many miracles and showing his divinity to all.

The other event in which this is clear is Jesus assumption into heaven after the resurrection. In Mark, this is described only very briefly (and I understand that many scholars believe that Mark 16 is a later addition to the original Gospel). Matthew adds earthquakes and lightning as an angel comes down from heaven. Luke adds more detail - about the discarded clothes in the tomb, and showing his hands and feet to the Apostles. Finally, by John, there's the story of Doubting Thomas, and Jesus appearing on the shores of the sea of Galilee - two whole chapters worth of post-resurrection appearances - cementing his appearance as divine. The stories get better and better as they go along! Which is exactly what we see with all folklore, especially that derived from oral histories.

Please try to make your analyses more sophisticated and less open to easy refutation than that.

1. Just why couldn't Jesus have said all those things before he died and during his life?

2. Luke doesn't have a very well-developed concept that Jesus is divine, when it's Luke and Matthew, rather than John, that talk about the miraculous birth narrative, and in the detail you're suggesting only happens when folklore gets well-developed?

3. John's gospel contains far more miracles than the others? Actually it contains far, far fewer, possibly because he wanted to include many more of Jesus' words than the others did in limited space.

4. Jesus was trumpeting his divinity in John? I suppose that's why he spoke in code so much, eh? "I am the good shepherd", and so on. John's gospel does say the Pharisees took offence at him because it sounded like he was claiming to be divine towards the end of his life; but how different is that really from the other gospels, where, for example, Mark's account of Jesus' trial has him responding to the question:

"Are you the Messiah, the Son of the blessed God?"

by saying,

"I am, and you will see me, the Son of Man, sitting at God's right hand in the place of power and coming back on the clouds of heaven."

And I think all the synoptic gospels have the pharisees plotting to kill him from very early on for doing rebellious things like healing on the Sabbath.

5. The fact that John's gospel has the Pharisees trying to stone Jesus for blasphemy more than once for hinting at divinity hardly indicates he was "willing to show his divinity to all"! It also suggests a very good reason why the others wouldn't have had him do it more, as well as the reason they themselves actually give - the crowds were too big for him to handle already. Luke also has an attempt on his life, when he proclaims himself the fulfilment of an Isaiah prophecy in the synagogue in Nazareth.

6. All four gospels have the resurrection narrative, and so on, with no explanation as to how that could happen if Jesus wasn't somehow special. You know, is it credible that they could have it happen if they weren't suggesting Jesus was divine? What difference does a few extra post-resurrection stories make?! The idea that they in themselves could mean a better-developed folklore is like saying more icing on a cake could signify the cake was meant to have more nutrients.

And there are other things that refute the notion. You need better arguments.
 
As Arthwollipot says, the versions of this event differ in the different gospels. Bart Ehrman discusses this at length in Misquoting Jesus, and shows how this was a matter of considerable dissent in the early Christian sects.
Some groups felt that Jesus was merely possessed by the "spirit" of God, and that this spirit left him on the cross. Thus the "forsaken" bit.
Later, this was changed to indicate a fully-godlike Christ who was in control of the whole show.

It seems that old Ehrman's views have been hotly disputed, to the extent that he's being accused of intellectual dishonesty. See Bart Ehrman, Jesus Interrupted -- Detailed Refutation

... And even when it does come to his specialty, he has repeatedly been dishonest to the extent that he fails to tell the "whole story." This is especially
disgraceful inasmuch as a clear dichotomy can be found in how he presents the truth in his more academic works, versus how he presents only as much truth
as he wants readers to see in his popular works.

With Jesus, Interrupted Ehrman has stepped far over the line of intellectual honesty and decency, using his platform as a popular author to disseminate
much that he surely knows is incomplete and misleading information. The benefit of the doubt is now exhausted. Despite his pretense at scholarship, Bart
Ehrman has proven himself, by this book, to be someone not in the least interested in truth, but only in using whatever means are necessary to deconvert
as many Christians as possible.

Shocking! :p Then the refutation begins.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom