My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

HansMustermann,

You are seriously, seriously failing to read what I write. If this continues, I will simply start to ignore what you say, and only engage with any forum members who put forward thoughtful intelligent points. It would appear that you are merely skimming very briefly, with a pre-formed idea of what I've said, and responding to your own preconceived notions of what I said, rather than to the text of what I did say. Frankly, your entire post is a non sequitur.

Apart from the fact that what you said has no relation whatsoever to what I said, and that you are flinging out straw men without even considering my arguments - i.e. I did not suggest that Christianity might be the only thing that had a possibility of working, you haven't even picked up on the very, very basic premise of my post - that the idea that Old Testament stories - which are in fact Jewish, incidentally, - might move some people to turn away from violent behaviour, is only, as yet, a theory.

And now I'll tell a children's story. This story is called TCO, the Christian and the bully.

This story, children, did, or could have, happened on this very forum. Possibly long, long ago; possibly recently.

Once upon a time, there was a forum member called The Classy One - people called them TCO for short. You might think the name The Classy One is a strange name to give a child. But it seems this had always been TCO's name, at least as far back as forum members could remember.

There was another forum member whose name was The Bully - yes children, another strange name. You may wonder what kind of cruel parents would name a child The Bully, but still, this had been this person's name, again, as far back as forum members could remember.

There was another forum member whose name was The Christian - yes children, yet another strange name!

When The Christian first joined the forum, she put a message on the board about the Bible. The Bully came along and tried to bully her, hoping it would make her be quiet, and that it would convince the other forum members that she was stupid and that The Bully was a superior class of being. But it didn't work. The Christian, and in fact all the other forum members watching, just thought The Bully was just a lout, with little intelligence.

So The Christian remained just as convinced by her ideas as she ever had been.

but then :eek: came The Classy One (TCO)! TCO was wiser and more intelligent than The Bully, and could think of better tactics than a simple outpouring of venom. TCO was clever enough to actually assess The Christian's arguments, and point out reasons why they might not work as well as The Christian had assumed they would. In fact, TCO told the Christian in no uncertain terms that the Bible was used by certain sectors of the population to do harm! :shocked: Because TCO approached the matter with tact and wisdom, and pinpointed exactly why it was that The Christian's arguments were flawed, what TCO said got through to The Christian far better than The Bully had, and The Christian was put off the idea of talking about the Bible, in a way they'd never have been if all they'd encountered was The Bully's venomous outpourings, which had simply made The Christian talk about the Bible more in defence. In fact, when The Christian decided to talk about the Bible again, she didn't mind the idea of meeting The Bully, but she hoped to goodness she wouldn't meet TCO again, since she suspected TCO was far more likely to be able to put a spanner in the works of a few of her arguments and be a far more intimidating opponent.

That, dear children, is a little allegory. Make of it what you will.

And now, I'm going to say something about the importance of tailoring your message to your audience. Or is that next time? Ah yes. But this little lesson hints at it. Here's another little lesson from the thread Religion's Value Questioned.

Are you sitting comfortably, children? Then I'll begin.

... Ah, no hang on, it seems this story, like the Old Testament, is not suitable for children. Never mind. I'll tell you another story, another time.

As for everyone else: From a collection of reports on the deaths of a couple of missionaries in the late 1960s:

... The society is one of several mission groups working in the interior of West Irian among tribes just emerging from a stone-age culture. A phenomenal response to the message of the Gospel has been witnessed among some of those warring cannibal tribes.

Notably, in the Swart Valley alone, since 1960, some 8,000 of the Dani tribe have become Christians, weapons and fetishes have been discarded and literacy has become widespread.

A lot of people!

Now, who can tell how much of the New Testament and how much of the Old Testament was preached to them. It could have been a combination of both, specially tailored to try to make the message be what was likely to appeal to them most.

Naturally, there might have been more to the tribes' turning away from violence than just attraction to the Christian message. Perhaps much of it was non-religious. This can be seen in another post from that thread, where I talk about a programme that had just been on the television, where an atheist - yes, a full-blooded atheist, had done a two-part historical documentary about how Christianity brought a certain amount of peace and prosperity to Ireland, England and Scotland after the Roman Empire fell, when warriors aplenty decided to put down their arms and resort to peace.

He said much of the civilising influence came from the literacy skills and new technologies the Christians brought with them, which those in authority wanted. Thus, much of the civilising influence could have been equally achieved by non-religious means. Still, a remarkable story. See an interview with the documentary-maker: Dan Snow: How Britain nearly became the Irish Isles

Interestingly, however, Snow is no fan of Christianity per se: “I’m an atheist,” he says, “so I’m fairly harsh on the idea that Christianity is a self-evidently brilliant creed that everyone adopts as soon as they’re told about it.”

Through making this series, however, Snow says that in fact his regard for Christianity has grown. “It is fascinating, ideologically, to watch the Iron Age warrior ethos being transformed by Christian thought,” he says. “The old belief was that it was basically only really the warriors who were special. But Christianity told people that they were all special now. Even in this period, it was quite emancipating.” ...

Of course Christianity has been used as an excuse for violence as well, even horrific violence. Those Christians clearly didn't know, or want to know, their New Testaments, did they! Otherwise, they'd have obeyed all the many verses in it like the ones here: What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other.
 
...that the idea that Old Testament stories - which are in fact Jewish, incidentally...
As if the fact that the OT is about the covenant that god established with his people obviates something...

...might move some people to turn away from violent behaviour, is only, as yet, a theory.
That funny deity. Mass murder, filicide, infanticide, sibilcide, slavery, incest... it was all a trick to get people not to be violent...

God is crazy like a fox, or a demented schizophrenic. You choose.

When The Christian first joined the forum, she put a message on the board about the Bible. The Bully came along and tried to bully her, hoping it would make her be quiet, and that it would convince the other forum members that she was stupid and that The Bully was a superior class of being.
Jack Chick logic. Ad hominem. Poisoning the well (not to mention a combination of both persecution and messiah complex.

That, dear children, is a little allegory. Make of it what you will.
Soap box pop psychology. Presumptuous and arrogant.


Are you sitting comfortably, children? Then I'll begin.
Patronizing and condescending [insert lame excuse here]
 
Of course Christianity has been used as an excuse for violence as well, even horrific violence. Those Christians clearly didn't know, or want to know, their New Testaments, did they! Otherwise, they'd have obeyed all the many verses in it like the ones here: What The Bible Says About Violence, Anger, Jealousy, Arguments, And Living In Peace With Each Other.
The problem is that Bible is incoherent. It is clear about prescriptions. Lot's of "thou shalt nots" in there. And Christ said that he had not come to do away with the law. But you hold the Bible up to a rarefied light, tilt your head and squint and suddenlty the Bible is a source of reason and morality. Never mind all of those nasty OT prescriptions. You can ingore them. Oh... wait, that doesn't apply to the 10 commandmants. Oh, and it doesn't apply to homosexuality.

Think of the Bible as a Chinese menu and just pick out the parts that fit with your morality and ignore those that shock your conscience. Murdering fathers for trying to feed their children is OT. Stoning adolecents for misbehaving or having sex is OT so we can ignore that. Never mind.

IOW: Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain who says "thou shalt".
 
BN, so... a vague ad hominem, a non-sequitur, a biased sample, hasty generalization, and a couple more things that really don't really support that hypothesis either way? :p

BTW, incidentally, that would be a _hypothesis_ as long as it's unsupported. A theory is a bit past that point.

And no kidding? Out of all the things that happened in Indonesia since then, _Christianity_ _alone_ is somehow responsible of all that? Did Christianity end the cycles of overpopulation that caused those wars? And who judges those changes anyway? Is there some unbiased source, or it's the same evangelists doing the preaching? Hint: in the article you linked it's the latter. I see that more than one of their missionaries there got ambushed and killed. By whom, if they got those tribes so peaceful and they discarded weapons? By the heathens? I hope I can be excused if I exercise some skepticism at a classification boiling down to "those converted = good, those non yet converted = evil" done by the very people doing the converting. And how did those good converted tribes live without weapons or war in the middle of other tribes who had weapons and were not yet converted, if that converted/non-converted thing was the only difference?
 
Last edited:
There's no arguing that many people find in their religion, and in scripture, the inspiration and motivation to do good works. This does not make scripture less ambiguous or less filled with questionable content.

I'm reminded of a short conversation about biblical interpretation I had with a Jehovah's Witness cousin. "We don't interpret," said he with supreme confidence. There is no ambiguity for the stupid and shallow. The rest of us, however, admit to cherry picking. Good people pick the good ones. Others do not. Plenty of cherries to go around.
 
But are they really motivated by religion, or are they naturally nice people and would do that stuff anyway?

And, again, what makes Christianity special?

E.g., Shintoism _could_ be credited with 200 years of peace in Japan, at a time when in Europe we thought that war is just another tool of diplomacy and used it liberally.

E.g., old Egyptian religion produced not only even more centuries of peace between Narmer's unification and the Hyskos invasion, it also produced effectively the world's first welfare programs. Those gigantic construction programs were, much like the British follies in the 19'th century, a way to give those down on their luck a chance to earn a living by honest hard work. Plus the concept of Ma'at put limits on taxes and ensured that the peasants get a decent nutrition, among other things. Plus it inspired people like Imhotep (who really didn't deserve to be made a villain in The Mummy;)) who devised an irrigation system apparently just so the poor don't starve on poor innundation years. He _was_ the high priest, so a case could be made that religion must have had _some_ influence on him. Etc.

E.g., Zoroastrism caused Persia to drop slavery before any other nation on Earth. Xerxes and his father Darius only used paid workers and soldiers. And Cyrus before him, another devout Zoroastrian, and for that matter the first Zoroastrian emperor, is even praised in the OT.
 
Here's the post where this entire thread got hijacked, back on page 3:

Introduction of a topic that had nothing at all to do with the OP

and here's Randfan's completely logical response to it:

Originally Posted by Baby Nemesis
Can you really claim Christianity is not good when it has all this inspirational material to offer?:

Randfan:

Fallacy and entirely beside the point.

My argument stands.
The derail has been answered over and over again, and now the dead horse has been dragged out for some more beating. I submit that unless a relationship between the topic of all of the inspirational material to supposedly be found in Christianity and the topic of the actual OP is somehow found, demonstrated, or posted by BN (which has not happened so far), then a mod needs to split off that entire derail into a separate thread.
 
Here's the post where this entire thread got hijacked, back on page 3:

Introduction of a topic that had nothing at all to do with the OP

and here's Randfan's completely logical response to it:


The derail has been answered over and over again, and now the dead horse has been dragged out for some more beating. I submit that unless a relationship between the topic of all of the inspirational material to supposedly be found in Christianity and the topic of the actual OP is somehow found, demonstrated, or posted by BN (which has not happened so far), then a mod needs to split off that entire derail into a separate thread.
Agreed.
 
But are they really motivated by religion, or are they naturally nice people and would do that stuff anyway?

And, again, what makes Christianity special?

E.g., Shintoism _could_ be credited with 200 years of peace in Japan, at a time when in Europe we thought that war is just another tool of diplomacy and used it liberally.

E.g., old Egyptian religion produced not only even more centuries of peace between Narmer's unification and the Hyskos invasion, it also produced effectively the world's first welfare programs. Those gigantic construction programs were, much like the British follies in the 19'th century, a way to give those down on their luck a chance to earn a living by honest hard work. Plus the concept of Ma'at put limits on taxes and ensured that the peasants get a decent nutrition, among other things. Plus it inspired people like Imhotep (who really didn't deserve to be made a villain in The Mummy;)) who devised an irrigation system apparently just so the poor don't starve on poor innundation years. He _was_ the high priest, so a case could be made that religion must have had _some_ influence on him. Etc.

E.g., Zoroastrism caused Persia to drop slavery before any other nation on Earth. Xerxes and his father Darius only used paid workers and soldiers. And Cyrus before him, another devout Zoroastrian, and for that matter the first Zoroastrian emperor, is even praised in the OT.

I think you're likely right, but I'm not really sure it matters for my point, or perhaps it is my point, from a different angle. which is that one can cherry pick one's way into using religion for high ideals and good purposes or for mischief. Whether it's a motivation, an inspiration, an excuse, or simply a framework for people unsure of themselves to do what they would do anyway, it can be done, and done very well indeed. The fact that it can be done does not prove anything about scripture or any specific religion, except that we can find what we need if we look for it hard enough.

I guess I'm trying to say that interesting as some of them are, Babynemesis's examples do not make the case that he seems to think they do.

e.t.a....I guess this horse is getting a bit gamey. Perhaps we should give it a rest now.
 
Last edited:
Well, it wasn't supposed to argue your point, but merely add for BN's benefit that even that's not especially an excuse of Christianity. It can be said about any religion. And yes, you're right, even the cherry-picking part.

But yeah, Maia is right, it's not like this detour adds anything.
 
II guess I'm trying to say that interesting as some of them are, Babynemesis's examples do not make the case that he seems to think they do.

e.t.a....I guess this horse is getting a bit gamey. Perhaps we should give it a rest now.

(shrug) I don't know. It's not that this whole derail discussion doesn't have any interest, but rather that it's not related to the OP at all, and it hasn't been since it first came up on page 3. If it were connected in some way, then it would be one thing, but it never has been. And there are so many interesting places where the original topic could go. Such as: What happens when we stop looking at the Marcan narrative from the perspective of biblical inerrancy? What are the implications then? What kind of message was it meant to send to its original readers? It's awfully hard to think of how the "does Christianity have an inspirational message or not?" question could possibly be related to any of this.
 
(shrug) I don't know. It's not that this whole derail discussion doesn't have any interest, but rather that it's not related to the OP at all, and it hasn't been since it first came up on page 3. If it were connected in some way, then it would be one thing, but it never has been. And there are so many interesting places where the original topic could go. Such as: What happens when we stop looking at the Marcan narrative from the perspective of biblical inerrancy? What are the implications then? What kind of message was it meant to send to its original readers? It's awfully hard to think of how the "does Christianity have an inspirational message or not?" question could possibly be related to any of this.
So, if we drop the assumption of biblical inerrancy, we're left pretty much with whatever interpretation suits our purpose.

The explanation I've most often heard at the sunday school and sermon level is that the statement proves Jesus' humanity, which is, for doctrinal reasons, an important consideration. He was so human that he suffered so much he even had a moment of doubt. That makes a certain amount of sense if you allow the basic story of Jesus' mission on earth to have any sense. Whether it makes sense or not is almost beside the point. If you regard the story as you would a work of fiction (and that's applicable even if you believe it true), then it works according to the internal rules of the story even if it doesn't make sense outside of it.

As a sort of general aside, I would add that of all the gospels, Mark is my favorite, again as a story rather than as a basis for faith, because the Jesus portrayed there has an edge. He's a wise guy, and the narrative itself shows the occasional hint of a kind of irreverent wit. As a kid, I was always turned off by the "baby Jesus meek and mild" crap. If you're going to stretch your credulity enough to believe that this story makes any sense at all, then let's credit God with sending down someone smart. I like the guy who baits Pharisees and wins the argument because he knows his beans.
 
So, if we drop the assumption of biblical inerrancy, we're left pretty much with whatever interpretation suits our purpose.

The explanation I've most often heard at the sunday school and sermon level is that the statement proves Jesus' humanity, which is, for doctrinal reasons, an important consideration. He was so human that he suffered so much he even had a moment of doubt. That makes a certain amount of sense if you allow the basic story of Jesus' mission on earth to have any sense. Whether it makes sense or not is almost beside the point. If you regard the story as you would a work of fiction (and that's applicable even if you believe it true), then it works according to the internal rules of the story even if it doesn't make sense outside of it.
One of the biggest problems that I see is the tendency of so many believers to conflate the four gospels into one narrative. So even though John is the only gospel account to explicitly state the divinity of Jesus, many people assume that they all do. It seems most likely that the author of Mark portrayed Jesus as very human because he saw him as fully human. His Jesus was a righteous man, but certainly not divine.

As a sort of general aside, I would add that of all the gospels, Mark is my favorite, again as a story rather than as a basis for faith, because the Jesus portrayed there has an edge. He's a wise guy, and the narrative itself shows the occasional hint of a kind of irreverent wit. As a kid, I was always turned off by the "baby Jesus meek and mild" crap. If you're going to stretch your credulity enough to believe that this story makes any sense at all, then let's credit God with sending down someone smart. I like the guy who baits Pharisees and wins the argument because he knows his beans.
When I read Mark, I have a hard time not picturing Jesus as a little bit like Exidor from Mork & Mindy.
 
Except Jesus being the fully human Son Of God is the Arian heresy, and if you take even the Son Of God away (which I don't think he ever claimed other than in the sense of being a human and possibly a Hebrew) you get Pellagianism and the Ebionites. Even taking the human and divine aspects of Jesus as fundamentally separate and unrelated aspects gives you Nestorianism, which is another condemned heresy.

What I'm getting at is that taking Jesus as divine isn't just an _assumption_, it's official doctrine for any major flavour of Christianity. And it's been so since 325 AD when Christianity was formally defined.

(Though apparently taking him as _too_ divine, gives you Apollinarism and Eutychianism, which are heresies too. Go figure;))

But anyway, the church basically deals with it by making him both, so it can pretend that the contradiction doesn't exist. Whether that makes any sense, that's another question.
 
I've come back, temporarily! Here's one more argument.

But firstly: Congratulations Joobz, You've won an award! It's been given you by the author of the article on argument by outrage, the meaning of which you so grossly mangled. I wrote to him and told him.
What award? I didn't see anything but a post in another thread.

Interesting, that you haven't been able to support your argument and have only relied on insults.

Why not go back and explain how genocide is acceptable? You are free to invent any alein species you wish to support your argument.
 
Lets not start personalising this thread as well. Keep to the topic and don't breach your Membership Agreement.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Why make a silly suggestion for a plan of action that won't and can't be implemented?

"Give them a different religion."

A religion ain't like a six pack of beer, I hope you understand.

DR

So can we give each of them a six pack of beer instead?
 
One of the biggest problems that I see is the tendency of so many believers to conflate the four gospels into one narrative. So even though John is the only gospel account to explicitly state the divinity of Jesus, many people assume that they all do. It seems most likely that the author of Mark portrayed Jesus as very human because he saw him as fully human. His Jesus was a righteous man, but certainly not divine.


When I read Mark, I have a hard time not picturing Jesus as a little bit like Exidor from Mork & Mindy.

Snerk. ;) As I understand it, though, "why hast thou forsaken me" has actually been used a lot as material for trying to prove the Trinity. This makes sense (I guess) if Jesus addressed God as a separate person, but if we also have to keep Jesus as divine. Where the Holy Spirit comes in, I really don't know.

Why not go back and explain how genocide is acceptable?

Joobz, I don't know how far you're going to get by asking this one in terms of getting a reply, but I still think it really goes back to the question of literal biblical inerrancy. If everything has to be interpreted from that POV, then there's really nowhere to go with anything in the Bible except "Because God said so." For instance, here we have a site that interprets the Marcan material from that POV. One of the few places to go is in the direction of "well, we all have moments in our lives when we feel like God has forsaken us, and then what we need to do is to pray like Jesus did." It all sounds very familiar from Bible study classes, let's just say that.
 
Last edited:
Joobz, I don't know how far you're going to get by asking this one in terms of getting a reply, but I still think it really goes back to the question of literal biblical inerrancy. If everything has to be interpreted from that POV, then there's really nowhere to go with anything in the Bible except "Because God said so." For instance, here we have a site that interprets the Marcan material from that POV. One of the few places to go is in the direction of "well, we all have moments in our lives when we feel like God has forsaken us, and then what we need to do is to pray like Jesus did." It all sounds very familiar from Bible study classes, let's just say that.
I agree, that's what it boils down to. But that should ring dishonest in a person's ear. Especially if they attempt some type of "God had no other choice...Sometimes god must make hard choices.." I'm simply waiting for some type of logic that can meld the two notions together. the only thing I can think is that god isn't "All powerful" or "All knowing".
 
Last edited:
I agree, that's what it boils down to. But that should ring dishonest in a person's ear. Especially if they attempt some type of "God had no other choice...Sometimes god must make hard choices.." I'm simply waiting for some type of logic that can meld the two notions together. the only thing I can think is that god isn't "All powerful" or "All knowing".

Well, there's your problem. You can't have that logic with literal biblical inerrancy, because God has to be all-powerful, all-knowing, all-good, and always right. (Switching over to Catholic-style spiritual biblical inerrancy doesn't solve the problem either, but at least it doesn't tend to create the kind of mess we had here.) "God had no other choice" also really doesn't make any sense, so the only thing left to do is to end up with weird, indefensible arguments that eventually sort of implode in on themselves. And that's exactly what we saw in this thread.

Actually, I can see how the entire thing could have revolved around the OP rather than incidents in the Old Testament (maybe some variant of "if God is all-knowing and all-wise, then why did he allow his son to be tortured and then die a horrible death?") So really, I think it's the principle of how events as literally presented in the Bible are supposed to be morally understood given a certain interpretation of the nature of God. And literal understanding of the Bible has to be consistent if it's going to be used at all. It can't be logically picked up when convenient ("Everything in the Bible is literally true!") and then dropped when it isn't ("No, what really counts is if Christianity helps people; never mind if anything in the Bible is literally true or not, because we're not talking about that now!")
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom