My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

For me, the "cry of dereliction" is of great interest on at least a couple of levels. On the one hand, we can read the Gospel of Mark as a complete, self contained story with a unique message intended by its author. One the other hand, we have multiple accounts that claim to relate the life and death of Jesus of Nazareth. The fact that they contradict one another on so many points, some minor and some major and frankly irreconcilable, points to the fact that these books were not written by eyewitnesses as they have been traditionally attributed, but rather by people who used previous source material in the form of written texts and oral traditions to create individual stories that resonated with their authors. Piggy once described some of the Old Testament books as being like different drafts of a screenplay that were cut apart and spliced together. It's a bit like that with the New testament as well. By reading the various author's accounts in parallel we can see where each altered the story or made up different details to fit what he wanted to say.

When I was an evangelical Christian some twenty years ago, constantly bombarded with the doctrine of Biblical inerrancy, I wasn't aware of these contradictions. But now that I have abandoned the need to believe that the Bible is the infallible word of God I am able to start to really dig into the actual history of the Bible as a human document and I find it far more stimulating, far more fascinating than when I thought that the Gospel of Mark was really written by Mark.
 
Why would Jesus have said what he said? Why would the writer’s of the Bible have had Jesus say what he said?
He was quoting the Psalm, which is regarded as being prophetic of his death.

So rather than a cry of dereliction, a triumphant statement of prophecy fulfilled.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom