My God, why hast thou forsaken me?

That would be like a horse saying they know what a human being is. A horse knows how a horse experiences a human being. And even when you say, this is my "God experience," there is always the possibility that you're deluded. And a lot of deluded people think that they have had "God experiences" and hear voices. So I start with that--I can't tell you who God is or what God is; I can only share what I believe my God experience is.

Yes, Maia, but then the same horse can't flip back and forth between

A) humans are good and pure love, and

B) well, who am I to judge humans? I can't even fully understand them.

Pick one or the other. Not both.
 
Yes, Maia, but then the same horse can't flip back and forth between

A) humans are good and pure love, and

B) well, who am I to judge humans? I can't even fully understand them.

Pick one or the other. Not both.

I don't know. JSS said it, and I'm not completely sure what he even meant by it. Maybe it would depend on the individual horse and its particular set of experiences. On the whole, I don't think I would have personally used the example of a horse to begin with.
 
This thing is suddenly not letting me edit the post... ETA that anyway, the theology makes more sense without the horse example in a way, but I would guess it was included in the interview because it's a concrete example that would at least seem to make sense to a lot of people. The point where the analogy breaks down in a major way, of course, is that we certainly do know both the actual relationship between horses and human beings and the nature of humanity. But still, I don't see any reason why the same horse couldn't flip back and forth between the two opinions (well, assuming that a horse could be capable of doing this in the first place.) That's probably just what it would do, and maybe that's why the example was included.
 
Last edited:
I've come back, temporarily! Here's one more argument.

But firstly: Congratulations Joobz, You've won an award! It's been given you by the author of the article on argument by outrage, the meaning of which you so grossly mangled. I wrote to him and told him.

Anyway, to the serious stuff. Those who've previously antagonised me need not read, since I won't read the responses of anyone who's made or implied a personal attack against me in this thread, whether they wish to be malicious or otherwise.

Yesterday evening, there was a programme on television which was part of a series called Unreported World. The programmes are about terrible things that are happening in the world which aren't making the news.

Yesterday's programme was called Liberia: Stolen Childhood

It was about how since the recent civil war in Liberia, a lot of children are being traumatised and injured by being raped. Hospitals have seen children as young as two. Children are often brought to hospital with internal injuries because of it, and some have even died.

I'll get to the point of talking about this in a minute. But here's a quote from the programme review. If you follow the link, you can watch the programme for yourself if you like.

Unreported World reveals how Liberia is facing a child rape crisis.

Six years after the end of a brutal civil war in which rape was routinely used as a weapon, children still face the daily fear of being attacked, and the West African country's hospitals are overwhelmed with child victims, a quarter of them under four years old.

In the Liberian capital, Monrovia, reporter Jenny Kleeman and director Matt Haan meet Mercy, a six-year-old girl who was abducted and raped by a stranger two weeks previously. Mercy is taking a course of drugs to try to stop her from contracting HIV. She lives in a safe house run by a Liberian charity, which is filled with other child rape victims. ...

The team visits a children's hospital run by the charity Médecins Sans Frontières. Elias Abi-Aad tells Kleeman that his unit saw 771 child rape victims in 2008 and in the first six months of 2009 had already seen 422 victims, but he estimates this is only a small fraction of the total number of cases in Liberia. Victims suffer serious medical problems as a result of their ordeal and the hospital saw three recent cases where children died as a direct consequence of rape.

Tikka, a nurse, tells Kleeman she thinks the crisis may be caused by Liberia's years of civil war, when both government forces and rebel factions terrorised communities by raping at will. Liberians had become used to living in a lawless and violent world, she says. ...

Liberia's civil war has left the country with a culture of impunity, and a culture where men want to have sex with very young girls. Until that changes, Liberia can't escape its tragic past.

I think the programme's available to watch for the next thirty days - I'm not quite sure, but some time anyway.

--------------

Now, these men clearly don't have the attitudes we might have to violence against children - that goes without saying. They probably don't find war repulsive but actually committed a lot of the atrocities during the civil war. What might stop them?

What If one thing that could stop them was fear of divine punishment? And what if that fear could best be instilled in them by reading the kinds of things we ourselves would find repulsive - things where Old Testament prophets warn of a greater power invading and conquering the land and carrying off prisoners and killing many, because of sins like attacks on the people most vulnerable? What if they need to be scared before they'll stop? And what if the thing most likely to scare them is fear that a God with the power to bring invaders to crush their country might sit in judgment on them one day?

Here's an example of something in the Old Testament that sounds horrifying and disgusting; and yet who's to say it might not be just what's needed to scare them into changing their ways? Bear in mind that in most Western countries, this stuff might not be taken very seriously, but in Africa, the thought of God is often taken much more seriously:

Habakkuk chapter 1 (NLT)

1 This is the message that the prophet Habakkuk received from the LORD in a vision.

2 How long, O LORD, must I call for help? But you do not listen! "Violence!" I cry, but you do not come to save. 3 Must I forever see this sin and misery all around me? Wherever I look, I see destruction and violence. I am surrounded by people who love to argue and fight. 4 The law has become paralyzed and useless, and there is no justice given in the courts. The wicked far outnumber the righteous, and justice is perverted with bribes and trickery.

5 The LORD replied, "Look at the nations and be amazed! Watch and be astounded at what I will do! For I am doing something in your own day, something you wouldn't believe even if someone told you about it. 6 I am raising up the Babylonians to be a new power on the world scene. They are a cruel and violent nation who will march across the world and conquer it. 7 They are notorious for their cruelty. They do as they like, and no one can stop them. 8 Their horses are swifter than leopards. They are a fierce people, more fierce than wolves at dusk. Their horsemen race forward from distant places. Like eagles they swoop down to pounce on their prey.

9 "On they come, all of them bent on violence. Their hordes advance like a wind from the desert, sweeping captives ahead of them like sand. 10 They scoff at kings and princes and scorn all their defenses. They simply pile ramps of earth against their walls and capture them! 11 They sweep past like the wind and are gone. But they are deeply guilty, for their own strength is their god."

12 O LORD my God, my Holy One, you who are eternal - is your plan in all of this to wipe us out? Surely not! O LORD our Rock, you have decreed the rise of these Babylonians to punish and correct us for our terrible sins. 13 You are perfectly just in this. But will you, who cannot allow sin in any form, stand idly by while they swallow us up? Should you be silent while the wicked destroy people who are more righteous than they? 14 Are we but fish to be caught and killed? Are we but creeping things that have no leader to defend them from their enemies? 15 Must we be strung up on their hooks and dragged out in their nets while they rejoice? 16 Then they will worship their nets and burn incense in front of them. "These nets are the gods who have made us rich!" they will claim. 17 Will you let them get away with this forever? Will they succeed forever in their heartless conquests?

Ezekiel chapter 22 (GWT)

1 The LORD spoke his word to me. He said, 2 "Will you judge, son of man? Will you judge the city of murderers? Then tell it about all the disgusting things that it has done. 3 Tell it, 'This is what the Almighty LORD says: [Jerusalem,] you are the city that murders people who live in you. Your time has come. You dishonor yourself with disgusting idols. 4 You are guilty because of the people you have killed. You are dishonored because of the disgusting idols you have made. You have brought an end to your days, and you have come to the end of your years. That is why I will make you a disgrace to the nations and a joke in every land. 5 Those near and those far away will mock you. Your name will be dishonored, and you will be filled with confusion.

6 "'See how all the princes of Israel who live in you have used their power to murder people. 7 People in you hate their fathers and mothers. They oppress foreigners in you. They oppress orphans and widows in you. 8 You have despised my holy things and dishonored the day to worship me. 9 Some of your people slander. They want to kill people. People who live in you eat food sacrificed to idols at the worship sites on the hills, and they sin sexually. 10 Men have sex with their father's wives. … 11 Men do disgusting things with their neighbors' wives. Some men sexually dishonor their daughters-in-law. Other men who live in you have sex with their sisters, their father's daughters. 12 Other people take bribes to murder people. You collect interest and make excessive profits. You make profits by mistreating your neighbors. You have forgotten me, declares the Almighty LORD.

13 "'I will use my power against you because of the excessive profits you have made and the murders you have committed. 14 Will you still be brave? Will you remain strong when I deal with you? I, the LORD, have spoken, and I will do it. 15 I will scatter you among the nations and force you into other countries.

You get the picture. It isn't beyond the bounds of possibility that such Bible passages could scare people, like threats of earthly punishment wouldn't. I once read a book by a bishop in Uganda at the time when president Idi Amin was committing all his many atrocities. He said one day, a few men met him outside his church and seemed to be going to kill him. He said to them,

"In reality, you are in far more danger than me. If you kill me, I will go off to heaven; but when you die, your soul could be in terrible danger."

He says it actually stopped them. In fact he says later, they even came to him and asked about Christianity.

Now, being an anecdote, that naturally doesn't prove a thing. But what if such arguments resonate sufficiently with enough violent men in that part of the world to actually make a difference? Accounts of biblical atrocities disgust us; but what if for some men who've actually participated in war as aggressors, the horror of divine wrath in the shape of a more powerful enemy as a punishment for their horrific actions, and possible punishment after death as well, is just what will influence them to change their ways and stop hurting children and others?

Here's another anecdote. Again, of course it's impossible to prove anything by it; but what if it's an indicator that there might be many people with a similar mind-set who might be influenced to change dramatically?:

I once read a story by a black man in America who said he'd been so angry with the way black people had been treated he wanted to launch a campaign of terror/revenge by making bombs and putting them in the streets. But before he completed any plans, one of his friends spoke to him, saying he'd been reading the Bible. He said he'd been reading about how Israelites were taken into Babylon as slaves because Israel had been so sinful. He said he thought that maybe the fact that black people had been brought across as slaves from Africa was God's judgment for their sins. The man who'd been going to plant the bombs thought that might well be the case, so he decided not to after all.

*********

The possibility that people can be inspired to change their ways by the Bible is the reason that, no matter how often someone calls me stupid, no matter how often my opponents use the fallacy of argument by fatuous misrepresentation and simplification of the points I've made to mock me, and no matter how much I myself might think the argument that it's illogical that the God of the Bible could be loving given biblical atrocities holds water, I will speak up for the Bible.

Anyone who wants to convince me not to do so will have to do more than just appeal to emotion by putting gory details on here about exactly what might have been involved in the murder of a child. They will have to convince me that there is so little evidence that people could be scared by reading about divinely-ordered wars into changing their ways so they no longer harm others, that it isn't valid to use it as a reason for reserving judgment on the God of the Bible. In fact, they will have to convince me that there is evidence that such biblical accounts have actually done harm in the modern day by inspiring atrocities.

I might stick around for a little while in this thread, but I won't read the posts of anyone who's antagonised me in it up until now, since the likelihood is that they'll only be doing it again, and I don't want to feel constrained to ignore them or to be nice to them after I've been provoked by them. So a few people here have lost any chance they would have had of influencing my thinking. too bad.

But perhaps I'll stay around for a little while to see if anyone else can do what I said would have to be done to convince me I'm wrong. To do so, you'll have to put concerns for pragmatism above those of ideology - i.e. stop talking about how biblical atrocities are just terrible, and give me some idea of the evidence on how the stories have influenced people over the years for good or bad. If you don't believe it's possible to collate convincing evidence on either side, I don't need to know you don't believe it's possible, so there's no need to tell me so.
 
What If one thing that could stop them was fear of divine punishment? And what if that fear could best be instilled in them by reading the kinds of things we ourselves would find repulsive - things where Old Testament prophets warn of a greater power invading and conquering the land and carrying off prisoners and killing many, because of sins like attacks on the people most vulnerable? What if they need to be scared before they'll stop? And what if the thing most likely to scare them is fear that a God with the power to bring invaders to crush their country might sit in judgment on them one day?

BN, I'm quoting this snippet from you lon post because I think this is the heart of your argument. I would he to say that fear of divine retribution as a motivation to act with mercy and justice, or at keast as a motivation refrain from committing atrocities has a checkered and unreliable history. Read for example the history of the Christianized Merovingian Franks. It's filled with atrocities. Or one could use Charlemagne as an example. He committed what can only be considered genocide against the pagan Saxons as a way to break the power of their pagan beliefs. Obviously, fear of divine retribution didn't stop either the Merovingians or Charlemagne. once belief is wedded to whatever action is taken, that sort of fear seemingly goes by the board. The same can be said of the Roman Catholic Croats and the Eastern Orthodox Serbs in the twentieth century.

I don't recall the name of the man wo wrote the hymn "Amazing Grace." However, as I remember the story of his life, he went from being a slaver to one campaigning against the evils of the slave trade, due to his conversion experience. It's possible that fear of divine retribution was at work in him, and it would seem to be something that works better on an individual basis, whereas group evil may be impervious to it. In this regard, you may want to reference Scott Peck's chapter on group evil from his book People of the Lie. Of course in the case of someone who has experience a dramatic conversion, it might well be the compassion generated from his new beliefs, rather than the fear of damnation, that motivates his behavior.
 
Congratulations Joobz, You've won an award! It's been given you by the author of the article on argument by outrage, the meaning of which you so grossly mangled. I wrote to him and told him.
Award? I see where he linked to a couple of posts in this thread but I see no other response regarding Joobz's criticisms of his argument.
 
What If one thing that could stop them was fear of divine punishment? And what if that fear could best be instilled in them by reading the kinds of things we ourselves would find repulsive - things where Old Testament prophets warn of a greater power invading and conquering the land and carrying off prisoners and killing many, because of sins like attacks on the people most vulnerable? What if they need to be scared before they'll stop? And what if the thing most likely to scare them is fear that a God with the power to bring invaders to crush their country might sit in judgment on them one day?

What if you actually had evidence that it actually worked that way, instead of just "what if" wishful thinking?

I'm serious, BN. Read the list of fallacies. Because what you do in that message is a classic textbook example of "appeal to consequences". You don't actually provide any evidence that religion actually works that way. You just argue that the consequences would be nice if it did.

If you want to argue the proposition X="religion stops people from doing that", then please do present evidence for that. A long post based on just wishful thinking and "how nice it would be if X were true", do not a proof make.

'Nuff said.
 
Also...

Anyone who wants to convince me not to do so will have to do more than just appeal to emotion by putting gory details on here about exactly what might have been involved in the murder of a child. They will have to convince me that there is so little evidence that people could be scared by reading about divinely-ordered wars into changing their ways so they no longer harm others, that it isn't valid to use it as a reason for reserving judgment on the God of the Bible. In fact, they will have to convince me that there is evidence that such biblical accounts have actually done harm in the modern day by inspiring atrocities.

while we're at it, you may want to look up "burden of proof". Nobody owes you a disproof of your delusions: it's up to _you_ to prove your claims that the bible actually has the effects you claim there.

Oh, and check out "ad hominem" and "argument from fear." Just that you try to handwave a lame and stupid link between Joobs and child rapists, doesn't automatically make you right and him wrong. You still need to support your claims.
 
What If one thing that could stop them was fear of divine punishment? And what if that fear could best be instilled in them by reading the kinds of things we ourselves would find repulsive - things where Old Testament prophets warn of a greater power invading and conquering the land and carrying off prisoners and killing many, because of sins like attacks on the people most vulnerable? What if they need to be scared before they'll stop? And what if the thing most likely to scare them is fear that a God with the power to bring invaders to crush their country might sit in judgment on them one day?
So are you arguing now that the bible is just a grown-up Struwwelpeter?
 
BN, I'm quoting this snippet from you lon post because I think this is the heart of your argument. I would he to say that fear of divine retribution as a motivation to act with mercy and justice, or at keast as a motivation refrain from committing atrocities has a checkered and unreliable history. Read for example the history of the Christianized Merovingian Franks. It's filled with atrocities. Or one could use Charlemagne as an example. He committed what can only be considered genocide against the pagan Saxons as a way to break the power of their pagan beliefs. Obviously, fear of divine retribution didn't stop either the Merovingians or Charlemagne. once belief is wedded to whatever action is taken, that sort of fear seemingly goes by the board. The same can be said of the Roman Catholic Croats and the Eastern Orthodox Serbs in the twentieth century.

I don't recall the name of the man wo wrote the hymn "Amazing Grace." However, as I remember the story of his life, he went from being a slaver to one campaigning against the evils of the slave trade, due to his conversion experience. It's possible that fear of divine retribution was at work in him, and it would seem to be something that works better on an individual basis, whereas group evil may be impervious to it. In this regard, you may want to reference Scott Peck's chapter on group evil from his book People of the Lie. Of course in the case of someone who has experience a dramatic conversion, it might well be the compassion generated from his new beliefs, rather than the fear of damnation, that motivates his behavior.

I agree; I'm not suggesting I think fear of divine retribution would work on everyone. In fact, I've speculated in the past on how much the church leaders in power hundreds of years ago really believed in the God they claimed to be serving, since they clearly weren't intimidated by the thought of hell into behaving in the compassionate way the New Testament says Christians should.

But I've heard of people who were convinced their hell-fire sermons were what was most effective in motivating people to change. It's been argued that even Karl Marx thought the equivalent of hell-fire-type sermons were what was really needed to get people moving for change. And William Booth, the founder of the Salvation Army, said something similar, apparently. see this article:

Ann Woodall's study of William Booth and Karl Marx is prompted by a striking coincidence: the founder of the Salvation Army and the father of Marxism both moved to London in 1849. Furthermore, she argues, what goaded each of them into action was horror at the intractable poverty of the London residuum - what Booth called the "submerged tenth" of the population and Marx dubbed the lumpen-proletariat.

Both men were domineering, impatient characters with a taste for fire-and-brimstone sermons. "Nothing moves people like the terrific," Booth wrote. "They must have hell-fire flashed before their eyes, or they will not move." Marx thought so too, portraying capital as "dead labour which, vampire-like, lives only by sucking living labour". ...

A group under a dynamic leader who urges them to do something that opposes the sentiments of such sermons will probably not be nearly as open to being moved by that kind of thing as a group of separate individuals who have to think about it for themselves.

I once heard that after the Second World War, some of the Nazi prisoners of war in Britain were given the chance to have lessons in critical thinking. One of them was on the television talking about how much he enjoyed them. He said they could freely ask questions, and beginning to think for themselves made them start questioning Naziism. They'd never done that before, under the Nazi leadership who'd told them what to believe.

On the other hand, if a dynamic leader who'd been preaching sentiments opposed to compassion and decency were to one day say he'd had a dramatic conversion to the opposite kind of thinking and go on to preach to his followers on why, a lot of them might have dramatic alterations in thinking too, because they trust his judgment.
 
Neither Karl Marx nor William Booth were psychologists, so that would be at best an appeal to misleading authority.
 
What we were all discussing before this thread hijack came along was interesting. The hijack itself is not. Also, once its arguments have been thoroughly demolished, there will be nothing but more goalpost-moving anyway. How about getting back to what we were talking about earlier?
 
What we were all discussing before this thread hijack came along was interesting. The hijack itself is not. Also, once its arguments have been thoroughly demolished, there will be nothing but more goalpost-moving anyway. How about getting back to what we were talking about earlier?

Good call.

Since the "cry of dereliction" is unique to the Gospel of Mark, It would be interesting to get into the unique message that the author of Mark was trying to get across as opposed to the authors of the other gospels.
 
Good call.

Since the "cry of dereliction" is unique to the Gospel of Mark, It would be interesting to get into the unique message that the author of Mark was trying to get across as opposed to the authors of the other gospels.

One post and then I'll go to bed, because I have to get up early... :)

I will have to go back to some info I have on that question. One idea I've seen, however, is that this message is central to the Marcan message that Jesus is being rejected by the Jews and that they will be judged even as the gentiles will be taken into the fold and enlightened (through the symbolism of the Roman centurion who proclaims that "truly this man was the son of God"). The themes would then be:

"the Son as predetermined sufferer and judge, rejection both by and of the Jews, and acceptance both of and by the gentiles"

and there's a very good example of this argument here.

Clearly, though, if we took a poll of the U.S. population, most don't really care about this question because of any great interest in some kind of theoretical biblical scholarship. It really comes back to the point of literal biblical inerrancy. Did Jesus literally say "My God, why hast thou forsaken me?" as he hung on a cross? Was a veil actually rent from top to bottom? Did darkness actually fall? Etc., etc., etc....

And if the crucifixion narratives are inerrant, then everything else is inerrant; nobody gets to pick and choose. So how to justify everything that's in the Bible? Well, we could say that the Bible has spiritual rather than literal inerrancy (and that's certainly what Father Ian said in my tenth grade World Religions class.) But
this really doesn't solve anything, because that's exactly how you get to the dilemma of:

"God is good, wonderful, great"

until something awful happens...
and then we're back to

"Well, we can't understand the incomprehensible ways of God."

I don't think horses would constantly vacillate between the two choices, but an awful lot of people do seem to be doing just that. I still think it's preferable to deciding that whatever God decides to do must be good and that's the end of the argument, though.
 
Last edited:
Neither Karl Marx nor William Booth were psychologists, so that would be at best an appeal to misleading authority.

The constructive thing to do would be to discuss whether there is any evidence that their claims had any merit. I wasn't saying I could be sure they knew what they were talking about. But my guess is that they were judging the effectiveness of hell-fire-type sermons on previous observable results - i.e. "It's only when I preach like this that I get a large number of volunteers coming up to me afterwards offering to help with my poverty relief projects". It wouldn't take psychology, but simply a bit of extremely basic mathematics, to make that kind of observation.

We can in fact be fairly sure that Marx's inflammatory rhetoric worked for him, based on the huge influence of Marxism in the world to this day. Would you be prepared to argue that Marxism would have taken off to the extent it did if his rhetoric had been turgid and unemotional?

Basically, the fact that inflammatory rhetoric can have a huge influence over people is a given and an extremely well-established fact. Could Hitler, for instance, have held sway over the masses, if his speeches had been boring and technical?

What is really at issue is whether, in that case, hell-fire sermons would be any more effective in changing the behaviour of child rapists and the like than non-religious inflammatory rhetoric, which perhaps appealed to the emotions in an attempt to bring to awareness the suffering of the children. I would suspect that hell-fire sermons might well be much more effective, since appeals to the empathy of these people are very unlikely to work, because their empathy won't be highly developed at all, if they even have any. They must be well aware of the suffering of those children. They see it right in front of their faces, although rapists will typically lie to themselves and others in an attempt to fool themselves and others into believing their victims don't suffer.

No, impassioned appeals to empathy would not work in those types of situations. What might, is appeals to self-interest. I.e. when they feel their own well-being is being threatened, that's when they might well sit up and take notice.

In fact, veteran researcher into psychopathy Robert Hare developed a program for Canadian prisons that would attempt to rehabilitate psychopaths based on appeals to there self-interest. Aggravatingly for him, it was scrapped, at least for a long long time, because people who apparently hadn't researched the matter were convinced appealing to people's goodness was always the key to rehabilitation.

An article called Psychopaths Among Us relates the information:

So many of these awkward questions would vanish if only there were a functioning treatment program for psychopathy. But there isn't. In fact, several studies have shown that existing treatment makes criminal psychopaths worse. In one, psychopaths who underwent social-skills and anger-management training before release had an 82 percent reconviction rate. Psychopaths who didn't take the program had a 59 percent reconviction rate. Conventional psychotherapy starts with the assumption that a patient wants to change, but psychopaths are usually perfectly happy as they are. They enrol in such programs to improve their chances of parole. "These guys learn the words but not the music," Hare says. "They can repeat all the psychiatric jargon -- 'I feel remorse,' they talk about the offence cycle -- but these are words, hollow words."

Hare has co-developed a new treatment program specifically for violent psychopaths, using what he knows about the psychopathic personality. The idea is to encourage them to be better by appealing not to their (non-existent) altruism but to their (abundant) self-interest.

"It's not designed to change personality, but to modify behaviour by, among other things, convincing them that there are ways they can get what they want without harming others," Hare explains. The program will try to make them understand that violence is bad, not for society, but for the psychopath himself. (Look where it got you: jail.) A similar program will soon be put in place for psychopathic offenders in the UK.

"The irony is that Canada could have had this all set up and they could have been leaders in the world. But they dropped the ball completely," Hare says, referring to his decade-old treatment proposal, sitting on a shelf somewhere within Corrections Canada. ...

It could be argued, "In that case, wouldn't stern talks about how they could be imprisoned for life if they keep up their behaviour be just as effective?"

I would suspect no. When they see that so few of their fellow rapists have been imprisoned, such a threat is likely to be laughed off. In relation to the example of frequent child rape in Liberia I provided, the government of Liberia seems near-absolutely ineffective in dealing with the problem so far. A punishment beyond the grave, however, would be a lot more difficult for many people to assess as an empty threat. And in a culture like Africa's where belief in the supernatural is taken very seriously, that might be much more of a concern than it would be here.

So the question remains one of whether hell-fire-type sermons really can change behaviour.
 
And there you summed it perfectly yourself: the question remains. That's it. There is no evidence either way.
 
And there you summed it perfectly yourself: the question remains. That's it. There is no evidence either way.

There may very well be evidence either way. And there may very well be people here with insights into the matter who'd be prepared to discuss them.

I, as I myself have suggested, am willing to be convinced either way, by anyone who actually has something informative to say, which is certainly possible.

The reason I phrased my argument on the possible transforming effects of hearing hell-fire-type preaching about things like prophecies of divinely-inflicted disaster in the Old Testament on some people who practice brutality in terms of a what if scenario was because I don't have any evidence myself of how often it might work. What I do know, however, is that many people have been moved over the years to transform their lives by giving up lifestyles that were harming themselves or others when they've been exposed to New Testament teaching. Thus the reasons I gave for being willing to speak up for the Bible stand. Anyone interested in the arguments can look at some of my posts in the Religion's Value Questioned thread in the Latest Commentary Issues section.

Here are some basic arguments from it:

There's a Christian organisation called Teen Challenge that works to rehabilitate drug addicts and criminals. The program is strongly influenced by biblical principles of recognising harmful behaviours as wrong and displeasing to God and giving them up. It claims an 86% success rate. From their website:

Teen Challenge has grown to include 173 residential programs and numerous evangelism outreach centers in the United States, and 241 centers in 77 other countries. The program's cure rate of 86% has been recognized and substantiated by the U.S. Government's National Institute on Drug Abuse. All Teen Challenge centers operate autonomously.

Teen Challenge graduates include former drug addicts, alcoholics, gang members, prostitutes and others with life-controlling habits.

If their claim about their high rehabilitation rate is true, on the face of it, it seems way higher than that of many secular rehabilitation set-ups. Obviously there might be confounding factors that would have to be looked into by anyone who wanted to know more; but it would seem in any case to be an organisation with a good reputation. Unless one can't infer that from American government approval.

The organisation was started by a preacher called David Wilkerson, who claims that a number of gangsters have turned from violence when they've been influenced by the Bible message. He's written a book called The Cross and the Switchblade about his experiences with them.

Many books have been written about how people and even whole communities have left harmful lifestyles when they've been influenced to become Christians by the Bible message. Another book about gangsters turning from violence and drug addiction is Chasing the Dragon by Jackie Pullinger, about Hong Kong.

In fact, I posted a message there about how secular therapists might even be able to get some ideas for new non-religious suggestions to make to clients, from gleaning something about the motives of those who become attracted to Christianity in their adulthood and the things that attracted them to it, from their stories.

... And before you say it, no, in fact psychology differs from other sciences, in that in order to maintain fluidity of response, not every little detail of every proposed treatment will be subjected to a double-blind trial before it's tried on clients, nor should it be. If psychologists are basically responsible in their practice, they should be allowed room to experiment a little. See this post of mine where I illustrate to another poster just why this is.

The point of all this is that just as many people have apparently been moved by New Testament teaching to give up lifestyles where they were harming others, I theorise that another type of person might be more likely to be moved by Old Testament stories to give them up. The jury, however, is still out on that one, until someone - me or someone else, comes up with more information, either to confirm or to cast doubt on the idea.
 
1. Bzzt. Wrong. You still don't know whether it'll work on psychopaths, which is the canard you brought up earlier. At best you know it works on some kid who was just depressed and wanting attention.

But we knew the same about regular psychotherapy, and, as per your own message, it turns out it only made it _worse_ when applied to psychopaths.

So wake me up when you actually have data about that, not just wild unsupported extrapolations.

2. And then the next logical step would be: which religion? Even if I wanted to believe you that empty threats for the afterlife actually worked on the kind of person who'd rape a baby, there is no reason to automatically assume that _Christianity_ is the best answer there. If I'm to support a bullcrap religion just because it might help the 1% of the population who are psychopaths, then at least I'll want the best bang for my money. And I want to know which religion gives me that, then.

E.g., why not the Islam? If you're proposing to keep those people under control with threats and promises about the afterlife, then we already know that the Islam has some pretty good promises. People actually go blow themselves up for that promise of plenty of virgin pussy in the afterlife, so, hey, maybe it also works to convince someone to just refrain from antisocial behaviour. Be good, get 72 virgins. Maybe it works better than promising them a harp ;)

E.g., why not Judaism? Hey, if fear of Yahweh makes those people refrain even from turning on the lights or answering the phone on 1/7 of the days, maybe it can make people refrain from the easier stuff too.

E.g., why not Buddhism? I don't know, I hear pretty good things about their meditation and stuff. Maybe we can get those people to concentrate on their own breath and spiritual progression instead of the cute ass on that 6 year old. Worth a try, wouldn't you agree?

E.g., for that matter, why not Shintoism? It worked (and still works) well enough for the Japanese, you know?

E.g., why not Wicca? If you're telling me that fear of being judged by a bearded virgin guy in the sky will keep them away from rape, why not tell them they'll be judged by a goddess? Hey, she's a woman and she'll be mightily miffed if you've raped women. And do you want to risk being judged for that when she's PMS-ing? So that's another thing worth a try.

E.g., speaking of Wicca, there is this other bullcrap modernization of some ancient ideas, invented by a wiccan "priestess": the Kemmet Orthodoxy. A.k.a., walk like an Egyptian. Err, I mean, worship like an Egyptian. I dunno, the sense of Ma'at has kept Egypt in line and prosperous for 3000 years. Plus, if we're talking threats for the afterlife, maybe they'll find the prospect of eternal death if you're bad scarier than getting eternal life in Hell. It may sound far fetched, but we're talking about people who are wired differently. Let's try it, I say.

And speaking of modern inventions: let's try Scientology on some of them too. You never know. Maybe it works better.

And for that matter, bring on the (several flavours of) Hinduism. Neo-druidism. Asatro. Taoism. Bring back the cult of Marduk. And for that matter of Inanna, and Sin, and Enki and all the Mesopotamian lot. Bring back the Greek gods, and the old (pre-Greek) Roman gods, and the cult of Ba'al, and the mysteries of Mythras, and the mysteries of Eleusis, and of Zalmoxis, and the whole lot.

So here's what I propose: in the USA, quoth Wikipedia, "As of year-end 2007, a record 7.2 million people were behind bars, on probation or on parole. Of the total, 2.3 million were incarcerated." Let's take those 7.2 million and give them some different religion each. Maybe 100-200 thousand can get various flavours of Christianity, and about 7 million would get one of a hundred other religions. Then we can compare notes and see which of them did better.
 
So here's what I propose: in the USA, quoth Wikipedia, "As of year-end 2007, a record 7.2 million people were behind bars, on probation or on parole. Of the total, 2.3 million were incarcerated." Let's take those 7.2 million and give them some different religion each. Maybe 100-200 thousand can get various flavours of Christianity, and about 7 million would get one of a hundred other religions. Then we can compare notes and see which of them did better.
Why make a silly suggestion for a plan of action that won't and can't be implemented?

"Give them a different religion."

A religion ain't like a six pack of beer, I hope you understand.

DR
 
Mostly taking the piss.

But, hey, BN was proposing to give them Christianity. I don't know how he plans to give them _that_ sixpack, but as soon as he figures out a plan, I figure we can use it to give them Wicca just as well. I mean, right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom