More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

The sad thing is that he genuinely believes he's banned for being a homeopath instead of realizing that his "resistance" to anyone elses arguments might have something to do with it. Actually his behaviour on Wikipedia is how he first got my attention, and I guess it's needless to say that he didn't make a good impression on me.
 
From that Huffpo page;

"Dana lives, practices, and writes from Berkeley, California"

I thought that some old legal problem meant he didn't or couldn't actually practise homeopathy. Anyone know?
 
From that Huffpo page;

"Dana lives, practices, and writes from Berkeley, California"

I thought that some old legal problem meant he didn't or couldn't actually practise homeopathy. Anyone know?


According to this, he got into some trouble with the authorities back in the 70s, but
I won an important settlement in 1977 in the Oakland Municipal Court in which the court allowed my practice under two stipulations:

1) that I do not diagnose or treat disease and that I refer to medical doctors for the diagnosis and treatment of disease (practicing classical homeopathy does not require a specific diagnosis of disease in order to find the correct homeopathic medicine);

2) that I make contracts with my patients that clearly define my role as a non-medical homeopathic practitioner and the patient's role in seeking my care.

While the stipulation that he is not allowed to treat disease might appear to limit his practice somewhat, remember that "homeopathy treats the patient, not the disease".
 
My understanding is that he hasn't bothered to practise practised homoeopathy for a couple of decades now and that he spends his whole time flogging promoting his book sales on the internet.


Edited to add:
I think that's right, otherwise he'd be promoting his practice as furiously as he does his books.

Edited to add:
Wikipedia does not mention where he practises which suggests to me that he does not.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dana_Ullman


Edited to add:
Even his website, which tells you all about the books he's published, makes no mention of where he practises.
http://www.homeopathic.com/


Could it really be that Gregory Dana Ullman does not practise what he preaches???
 
Last edited:
i have had many personal experiences with skeptics, and i have found that a large number of them are hyper-rational "nerds" who were abused in high school...a*nd who now feel "empowered" by abusing others on the internet, usually anonymously.

Personally, i pity them because they seem to spend inordinate amounts of time abusing other people and feeling and showing deep hatred for virtually everyone else, except their small group of similarly abusive skeptics. They revel in their hyper-denialism of the wonder of life and of the everyday magic that surrounds them. They are a sad lot.
Dana. I don't hate everyone. I hate idiots who peddle crap like yourself.
 
Last edited:
By the way, he's currently trying to undermine the germ theory of disease (by an appeal to 19th century authority, of course) over on Wikipedia:
Dana Ullman said:
There is some short discussion about the "recantation" by Pasteur on the death-bed that may or may not have happened. However, what is real is the words of Rene Dubos in his seminal book, The Mirage of Health, Dubos confirms that Pasteur did not believe that germs directly “caused” disease.
 
"Neccesary, but not sufficient."

My first year HND students can understand that.

Rolfe.

Spooky! I was thinking those very same words as this page was loading having seen from my notification e-mail what Mojo had written.
 
Dana Ullman said:
There is some short discussion about the "recantation" by Pasteur on the death-bed that may or may not have happened.
Perhaps it is time for us to spread the rumour that Samuel Hahnemann recanted on his death-bed and admitted that he was a quack?
 
I love it. The "scholarship" of the people at this site is hilariously piss-poor. My comment at wikipedia did NOT reference Pasteur's deathbed statement. In fact, I specfically noted that it wasn't. I quoted Rene Dubos. Is anyone out there really suggesting that Dubos was a radical. Come on, say it. Say it! If so, everyone is a radical, and ONLY you folks are the real moderates. But heck, the only thing in the middle of the road these days is a double-line and dead armadillos.
 
I love it. The "scholarship" of the people at this site is hilariously piss-poor. My comment at wikipedia did NOT reference Pasteur's deathbed statement. In fact, I specfically noted that it wasn't. I quoted Rene Dubos. Is anyone out there really suggesting that Dubos was a radical. Come on, say it. Say it! If so, everyone is a radical, and ONLY you folks are the real moderates. But heck, the only thing in the middle of the road these days is a double-line and dead armadillos.

Who cares what a couple of long dead dudes had for breakfast?

Linda
 
Isn’t Dana banned? What are we doing, letting him back in for entertainment?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom