More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

The quotation from Twain is remarkably similar to the out-of-context quotations from Holmes:


Mark Twain as quoted by Ullman said:
When you reflect that your own father had to take such medicines as the above, and that you would be taking them to-day yourself but for the introduction of homoeopathy, which forced the old-school doctor to stir around and learn something of a rational nature about his business, you may honestly feel grateful that homoeopathy survived the attempts of the allopathists to destroy it, even though you may never employ any physician but an allopathist while you live.


Note that Twain isn't recommending homoeopathy here: he's saying (just as Holmes did) that homoeopathy (and other competing systems may have done good by making "allopathy" reconsider its treatments.


Dana's just quoted part of this out of context on his HuffPo blog (emphasis in original), making it look as if Twain was recommending homoeopathy:
I encourage everyone and anyone who is seriously interested in the science and art of real healing to explore what homeopathic medicine has to offer. As Mark Twain once asserted in 1890, "you may honestly feel grateful that homeopathy survived the attempts of the allopathists [conventional physicians] to destroy it."
 
I did start a thread on this, but it sank without trace.

I signed up to HuffPo to bait DUllman and I am one of the followers of whose number he seems inordinately proud not realising that a reason for becoming a follower is to be kept up to date with what a huge purple bell-end one of their bloggers is making of himself.

But, HuffPo has a very strange moderating policy I've had hardly anything accepted yet some contributors seem to be able to engage in long and vitriolic diatribes against each other with impunity. Does anyone else have experience of posting, or trying to post, there?
 
I did start a thread on this, but it sank without trace.

I signed up to HuffPo to bait DUllman and I am one of the followers of whose number he seems inordinately proud not realising that a reason for becoming a follower is to be kept up to date with what a huge purple bell-end one of their bloggers is making of himself.

But, HuffPo has a very strange moderating policy I've had hardly anything accepted yet some contributors seem to be able to engage in long and vitriolic diatribes against each other with impunity. Does anyone else have experience of posting, or trying to post, there?

I posted in response to his blog on fever. I had a few accepted, but the post I made pointing out that it may not be wise to trust someone who is trying to get your money, was rejected. I think it included a comment wondering why HuffPo was providing DUllman with free advertising.

Linda
 
HuffPo has a very strange moderating policy I've had hardly anything accepted yet some contributors seem to be able to engage in long and vitriolic diatribes against each other with impunity. Does anyone else have experience of posting, or trying to post, there?


I haven't even been able to log in!
I also tried to subscribe (in case I hadn't already done so), but it tells me they already have a user with that email address, so that can't be the problem.
 
DU just got a nice slap-down at HuffPo.

Do you really think that's going to hurt?

I think he has received some exquisite slap-downs here - in particular, your use of an excel spreadsheet to massacre the significance of the sepsis study and the letter to the editor presented by you et. al. which even the authors admitted refuted the study which Dana presented as dropping a bomb on skeptics. Yet none of that seemed to penetrate his shield of ****.

Linda
 
Do you really think that's going to hurt?

I think he has received some exquisite slap-downs here - in particular, your use of an excel spreadsheet to massacre the significance of the sepsis study and the letter to the editor presented by you et. al. which even the authors admitted refuted the study which Dana presented as dropping a bomb on skeptics. Yet none of that seemed to penetrate his shield of ****.

Linda

Fair points and thank you for the compliments.
 
I like Badly Shaved have encountered problems trying to post at the Huffo. I was trying to post to Dana's latest piece, where he was showing how popular homeopathy is. The post was something I wouldn't think would be a problem. I was giving my own ancedote dealing with nerve damage. I even tried a few days later with a different version of the same post. It looks like ancedotes are only OK if they favor homeopathy.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dana-ullman/homeopathic-medicine-euro_b_402490.html
 
I think some posters might be on a hit list and automatically rejected when they post.
Maybe if you post it here someone else could post it there instead - not me, though, I can't even get them to log me on!
 
My comment wasn't something that someone else could post. I was just giving my own experience with nerve damage. A poster had given an anecdote about how nerve damage can't be repaired. Homeopathy of course cured her nerve problems in spite of what real doctors had said. The only thing I can figure is they dumped me out because of all my previous negative comments.

My anecdote was that I had lost all use of the first digit of my thumb and the first two of my index finger. They were just like they had been glued on. It took about 18 months before I could move them at all. To get that movement my finger had to be sideways so it wasn't fighting gravity. Now it is like nothing had happened. I didn't use homeopathy, but drank some water during that recovery period. This hardly seems offensive or something that should be banned. There are several people who post long exchanges with the pro homeopathy people. I guess they have don't want any more.
 
I think authors at HuffPo have the option to be able to personally screen the comments to their articles. Obviously, cranks like Dana Ullman are all over that.
 
I was wondering that myself if Dana had anything to do with the comments. I'll try to post something on his next blog that he posts to see if I'm banned.
 
Dana's managed to get his Darwin stuff published again: The Curious Case of Charles Darwin and Homeopathy. He's puffing it in the Huffpo, where he of course plugs his big celebrity book of homoeopathy as well.

Mostly the same stuff that's already been repeatedly demolished here and elsewhere, but there's a new bit: apparently Darwin admired a German homoeopath. The reference Dana cites to support this "admiration" is from Francis Darwin's Life and Letters of Charles Darwin. The introduction to the 1862 letters says:
1862.

[Owing to the illness from scarlet fever of one of his boys, he took a house at Bournemouth in the autumn. He wrote to Dr. Gray from Southampton (August 21, 1862):--

"We are a wretched family, and ought to be exterminated. We slept here to rest our poor boy on his journey to Bournemouth, and my poor dear wife sickened with scarlet fever, and has had it pretty sharply, but is recovering well. There is no end of trouble in this weary world. I shall not feel safe till we are all at home together, and when that will be I know not. But it is foolish complaining."

Dr. Gray used to send postage stamps to the scarlet fever patient; with regard to this good-natured deed my father wrote--

"I must just recur to stamps; my little man has calculated that he will now have 6 stamps which no other boy in the school has. Here is a triumph. Your last letter was plaistered with many coloured stamps, and he long surveyed the envelope in bed with much quiet satisfaction."

The greater number of the letters of 1862 deal with the Orchid work, but the wave of conversion to Evolution was still spreading, and reviews and letters bearing on the subject still came in numbers. As an example of the odd letters he received may be mentioned one which arrived in January of this year "from a German homoeopathic doctor, an ardent admirer of the 'Origin.' Had himself published nearly the same sort of book, but goes much deeper. Explains the origin of plants and animals on the principles of homoeopathy or by the law of spirality. Book fell dead in Germany. Therefore would I translate it and publish it in England."]


Dana quotes the last paragraph, noting that the first section "was probably written by Francis Darwin", and describes it as "an August 20, 1862, letter to Asa Gray". I can't find any sign of this letter in the Darwin Correspondence project. It looks to me like a note of a letter Darwin received, rather than one he wrote.

Dana writes:
What is intriguing about Darwin's statement is that he asserted that this writing by a homeopathic doctor is similar to his own but ‘goes much deeper’.


I don't see any evidence that Darwin had actually read this German homoeopath's book, or even that the homoeopath had sent him a copy. It looks more as if Darwin is merely reporting the homeopath's opinion of his own work as expressed in his letter to Darwin.

It is hard to see how this support's Dana's assertion of "Darwin's Admiration of Another Homeopath".


I've just stumbled upon the letter that quotation comes from. It is actually to Joseph Hooker, not Asa Gray, and from 16 Jan 1862, not August 20 (which explains why I couldn't find it from Dana's information). The passage quoted comes from a postscript:
P.S. The letter with curious address forwarded by Mrs Hooker was from a German Homœopathic Doctor—an ardent admirer of the Origin—had himself published nearly the same sort of book, but goes much deeper—explains the origin of plants & animals on the principles of Homœopathy or by the Law of Spirality— Book fell dead in Germany— Therefore would I translate it & publish it in England &c &c?!


This makes it even more clear that Darwin was referring to the contents of the German homoeopath's letter rather than to his own opinion of the book.
 
Last edited:
So how do you go about publishing those facts to the same distribution as Dana is likely to use? Because if they can be informed before Dana releases his "seminal work", it pulls the rug right out from under him. No-one will buy his work if it is already discredited before it is published. Plus it demonstrates again his lack of research skills (as if we didn't know already!).
 
What IS this with plugging Darwin? Even IF Darwin thought well about homeopathy, heck even if he was a staunch believer in it, it would lend zero credibility to homeopathy.

In that era, medicine and pathology were nascent sciences and very little real knowledge existed of how the body functions and reacts to pathogens and medicines. And Avogadro's number was only found in the following century.

In the middle of the 19th century, even a completely serious scientist might well think that homeopathy had some merit. As much merit as the medieval practices still much in use at the time. They would even be right: At least homeopathy was harmless, something many of the other practices could not boast.

It is with our 20th century knowledge that we can understand that homeopathy was a failed idea.

Hans
 
Actually, as you know, homeopathy was comprehensively debunked in the 1850s, i.e. within a decade or so of Hahnemann's death. It all but died out as a medical practice after the 1920s, as medical knowedge expanded rapidly. It has only recently had any revival, and then only at the hands of plainly obvious snake-oil salesmen like Dullman.

Follow the money - that's ALL he is interested in.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom