More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

:eye-poppi

OK, I guess he thought it was worth a try, but his trademark words "heck" and "humility" in one paragraph? He didn't even try to make it sound like it wasn't him, lol.
 
Well aparently Dana Ullman neglected to mention something that is hysterically funny. Charles Darwin grandfather actually thought that inhaling metal vapors was a good idea.
 
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dana-ullman/dont-confuse-real-healing_b_360747.html
Painkillers, on the other hand, may provide great reduction in pain, but this may result in the person continuing to walk on that injured ankle and cause increased injury. The person with arthritis, as another example, may continually take one or more painkilling drugs that provide some relief but these drugs also create their own tolerance, addiction, or pathology, usually leading to much more serious health problems.
Or you know Dana they could suck it up like my 96 year old grandpa who doesn't take any painkillers for his arthritis despite literally missing a few joints.
The human body can and will defend its most vital functions first before defending its more superficial functions.
No it won't. My grandpa's heart stopped beating two or three years ago. You can't get much more vital having a beating heart.
 
Last edited:
No it won't. My grandpa's heart stopped beating two or three years ago. You can't get much more vital having a beating heart.

And Dana's brain stopped working many years ago, yet he's still up and about, smiling that horrid smile with his shiny shiny eyes and annoying people.
 
His recent posts certainly seem to be sticking the boot into the idea of "integrative" or "complementary" medicine, with their accusations of "doctatorship", "medical child abuse" and now the old favourite of "suppression" by conventional medicines.

In recent edits on Wikipedia he seems to be thinking of an attack on antivirals as well as pushing the idea of "medical child abuse".
 
Last edited:
Just as a side note. My grandpa is still alive. His heart only stopped beating for a few seconds due to his pacemaker failing. He is a testament as to how well medical science works and the only regret he has is not having another hip replacement surgery when he could have had the chance.
 
His recent posts certainly seem to be sticking the boot into the idea of "integrative" or "complementary" medicine, with their accusations of "doctatorship", "medical child abuse" and now the old favourite of "suppression" by conventional medicines.

In recent edits on Wikipedia he seems to be thinking of an attack on antivirals as well as pushing the idea of "medical child abuse".

I though he was banned from wikipedia. Was it just from homeopathy?

Linda
 
It's just a topic ban, but since pretty much everything he's ever posted on Wikipedia is something to do with homoeopathy it amounts to much the same thing. As "TabASlotB" suggests, at least one of the recent edits is flying pretty close to the banned topic.
 
Last edited:
He's trotted this one out yet again...

Ok...you want one trial...here's one on COPD....This study was conducted at the University of Vienna...

Frass, M, Dielacher, C, Linkesch, M, Endler, C, Muchitsch, I, Schuster, E, Kaye, A. Influence of potassium dichromate on tracheal secretions in critically ill patients, Chest, March, 2005.

The journal, "Chest," is the most respected journal in respiratory medicine.

It is sadly too typical of skeptics to insist that there is "no research that confirms that homeopathy works" and yet, they simply don't do any simple homework to know what does exist.
 
And here he is complaining about Wikipedia:

As much as I love wikipedia, it is NOT an objective or even a good source of information on homeopathy or many alternative treatments because this site is completely overrun by skeptics and fundamentalists (the hyper-denialists) who pose as "pro-science" but who have major axes to grind. Heck, they have outlawed homeopaths from editing just because they are homeopaths (the anti-homeopathy people say that homeopaths have a "confict of interest"...and yet, MDs and Big Pharma employees have no conflicts of interest!).
 
He's trotted this one out yet again...

Ok...you want one trial...here's one on COPD....This study was conducted at the University of Vienna...

Frass, M, Dielacher, C, Linkesch, M, Endler, C, Muchitsch, I, Schuster, E, Kaye, A. Influence of potassium dichromate on tracheal secretions in critically ill patients, Chest, March, 2005.

The journal, "Chest," is the most respected journal in respiratory medicine.

It is sadly too typical of skeptics to insist that there is "no research that confirms that homeopathy works" and yet, they simply don't do any simple homework to know what does exist.

Has anyone here read the article? I admit that I'm too lazy, but that's because I don't expect it to be as spectacular as Ullman makes it sound. According to ISI WoS it's been cited 3 times. Shouldn't a study that "confirms that homeopathy works" be cited a gazillion times (at least by homeopaths)?
 
Has anyone here read the article? I admit that I'm too lazy, but that's because I don't expect it to be as spectacular as Ullman makes it sound. According to ISI WoS it's been cited 3 times. Shouldn't a study that "confirms that homeopathy works" be cited a gazillion times (at least by homeopaths)?

It's only referenced widely by DUllman because it's use of homeopathy in those patients was so tangential to the patients' clinical condition it provides very feeble support for homeopathy even if its results could be taken at face value.

The study is of a type we often see with homeopaths where they use a complicated unstable biological situation that will necessarily create very noisy data in which to trial their remedies. They seem pathologically fearful of simple studies that could yield clear-cut answers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom