More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

So far, NO scholarship here. I love it when the worst that anyone can say about Rene Dubos is that he is dead.

The combination of ARROGANCE and IGNORANCE here is classic.
 
Ooh, he stamps his nano-feet and shakes his nano-fists.

Dana, give us one incontrovertible example, with references of a non-self-limiting condition being cured by homeopathy.
 
Or here's another one, Dana, take 20 Belladonna 30C and 20 sugar blanks that went through the whole process except no actual Belladonna was present at the start of the whole process of diluting and banging on bibles and evaporating onto the tablets.

Can you separate them accurately? You can do it anyway you like, but really you should give them to 40 people and identify who was given what by your whole history-taking shenanigans.

Take a month to do it.

Too scared to try? Too much of an armchair expert? Making too much money from homeopaths to risk being shown to be wrong?

Get out of your armchair, Dana, and show us some magic.
 
Last edited:
So far, NO scholarship here. I love it when the worst that anyone can say about Rene Dubos is that he is dead.

The combination of ARROGANCE and IGNORANCE here is classic.
Woah there Sparky, easy on the caps. Do you really need to kid yourself that badly?
 
So far, NO scholarship here. I love it when the worst that anyone can say about Rene Dubos is that he is dead.

I dunno. I wouldn't want someone to say that about me.

The combination of ARROGANCE and IGNORANCE here is classic.

Let's see...

Spend time studying research methodology and biostatistics, read well-performed research published in good-quality peer-reviewed medical journals, practice evidence-based medicine.

vs.

Spend time combing through the off-hand remarks of 19th century figures.

'Tis a tough choice.

Linda
 
I love it. The "scholarship" of the people at this site is hilariously piss-poor. My comment at wikipedia did NOT reference Pasteur's deathbed statement. In fact, I specfically noted that it wasn't.


Wasn't what? When you referenced it (remember, in the edit where you posted "There is some short discussion about the "recantation" by Pasteur on the death-bed") you said it "may or may not have happened".
 
Wasn't what? When you referenced it (remember, in the edit where you posted "There is some short discussion about the "recantation" by Pasteur on the death-bed") you said it "may or may not have happened".

As usual the armchair homeopath's thinking is childishly simplistic. He really does seem to be getting into quite a stew over his simplistic straw-man version of causality. Anyone who practices medicine is well-aware of the idea that diseases are multi-factorial. Of course, the funny thing about infectious disease is that it doesn't happen if there is no infectious agent.

As Rolfe has already said, the concept of "necessary but not sufficient" is not a hard one.
 
I took a quick look at the wikipedia talk and I'm less than impressed. René Dubos wrote two books on Pasteur, so why is it that none of those says that Pasteur didn't think germs caused a disease? All you can produce is ONE sentence in ONE book about ONE specific germ that Pasteur thought might not be the cause of ONE specific disease.

James/Dana, please stay on this thread, I really need something to laugh about and your homeopathic thinking might do the job.
 
I took a quick look at the wikipedia talk and I'm less than impressed. René Dubos wrote two books on Pasteur, so why is it that none of those says that Pasteur didn't think germs caused a disease? All you can produce is ONE sentence in ONE book about ONE specific germ that Pasteur thought might not be the cause of ONE specific disease.

James/Dana, please stay on this thread, I really need something to laugh about and your homeopathic thinking might do the job.

I'm afraid this has been typical of him. He wakes up in his armchair, works out who he is again, fires off a few self-serving posts then dozes off again while his nurse keeps an eye on the homeodollars rolling in from his website.

It's nice work if you can get it.
 
Dana’s also been trying to bash real medicine on the child abuse article. He’s definitely not behaving himself, but he is being careful – rather than editing articles directly, he’s just pushing his nonsense on talkpages and victimizing himself when anybody dares to object to including it in articles.…
 
Last edited:
I'm really beginning to hate Dana. The guy keeps on calling me an idiot even though I work in a chemistry lab studying the interaction of water with other molecules.
 
I'm really beginning to hate Dana. The guy keeps on calling me an idiot even though I work in a chemistry lab studying the interaction of water with other molecules.

I've just received my copy of Ben Goldacres book "Bad Science"
Here are a couple of relevant quotes from his introduction:

Today doctors and scientists find themselves outgunned by vast armies of individuals who feel entitled to pass judgement on matters of evidence without troubling themselves to obtain a basic understanding of the issues.

...we [the public] get our information from the very people who have repeatedly demonstrated themselves to be incapable of reading, interpreting, and bearing reliable witness to the scientific evidence.


I immediately thought of a certain D. Ullman


As far as I can make out, Ullman hasn't actually practised homoeopathy for at least two decades - maybe you could put the question to him next time you meet.

And about the hate thing...I don't think Ben Goldacre actually expresses hate, but he sure gets mad at the wilfully ignorant like Ullman.
 
As far as I can make out, Ullman hasn't actually practised homoeopathy for at least two decades - maybe you could put the question to him next time you meet.

And about the hate thing...I don't think Ben Goldacre actually expresses hate, but he sure gets mad at the wilfully ignorant like Ullman.

It's weird, isn't it. The only place I've seen any reference to him actually practising what he preaches is in the tagline on his Huffington Post pieces where it says "Dana works lives, practices and writes from Berkeley California". I've seen no other recent record of him being said to practise homeopathy even in his own writings, which is why I regard him as a meta-quack commenting from his armchair and making money from the true believers who actually hand out sugar pills to people. Didn't he have some legal problems that cramped his ability to work with patients?

Perhaps he'd like to come back and explain. He could comment on my 40-pill challenge at the same time. Unfortunately he seems to be avoiding us again. He seems very quick at appearing in other places when his name is mentioned. Someone suggested he has his own name plugged unto Google Alerts to keep an eye on his Internet profile. I don't know how that works exactly, but his speed of appearance suggests it works quite well.

Is he like Beetlejuice and you need to say his name three times.

Dana Ullman. Dana Ullman. Dana Ullman.

Listen out for the scary music that announces his arrival.

Is wilful ignorance the same as bull8ting where it has been described as acting in a manner utterly heedless of truth, in contrast to liars and frauds who identify the truth but act in opposition to it?
 
Last edited:
I’m not sure when he’ll be coming back. He seems to be a bit busy at the moment. Last week I put a simple question before him:
“If I was to peddle fake homeopathic remedies – i.e. by filling labeled vials with plain tapwater – how would you tell them apart from the real thing?”

He hasn’t gotten back to me yet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom