Badly Shaved Monkey
Anti-homeopathy illuminati member
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2004
- Messages
- 5,363
JamesGully
Scholar

Scholar


Woah there Sparky, easy on the caps. Do you really need to kid yourself that badly?So far, NO scholarship here. I love it when the worst that anyone can say about Rene Dubos is that he is dead.
The combination of ARROGANCE and IGNORANCE here is classic.
Wait, so JamesGully is Dana Ullman?
The rest of this thread suddenly makes so much more sense.
So far, NO scholarship here. I love it when the worst that anyone can say about Rene Dubos is that he is dead.
The combination of ARROGANCE and IGNORANCE here is classic.
I love it. The "scholarship" of the people at this site is hilariously piss-poor. My comment at wikipedia did NOT reference Pasteur's deathbed statement. In fact, I specfically noted that it wasn't.
Wasn't what? When you referenced it (remember, in the edit where you posted "There is some short discussion about the "recantation" by Pasteur on the death-bed") you said it "may or may not have happened".
I took a quick look at the wikipedia talk and I'm less than impressed. René Dubos wrote two books on Pasteur, so why is it that none of those says that Pasteur didn't think germs caused a disease? All you can produce is ONE sentence in ONE book about ONE specific germ that Pasteur thought might not be the cause of ONE specific disease.
James/Dana, please stay on this thread, I really need something to laugh about and your homeopathic thinking might do the job.
I'm really beginning to hate Dana. The guy keeps on calling me an idiot even though I work in a chemistry lab studying the interaction of water with other molecules.
I'm really beginning to hate Dana. The guy keeps on calling me an idiot even though I work in a chemistry lab studying the interaction of water with other molecules.
Today doctors and scientists find themselves outgunned by vast armies of individuals who feel entitled to pass judgement on matters of evidence without troubling themselves to obtain a basic understanding of the issues.
...we [the public] get our information from the very people who have repeatedly demonstrated themselves to be incapable of reading, interpreting, and bearing reliable witness to the scientific evidence.
As far as I can make out, Ullman hasn't actually practised homoeopathy for at least two decades - maybe you could put the question to him next time you meet.
And about the hate thing...I don't think Ben Goldacre actually expresses hate, but he sure gets mad at the wilfully ignorant like Ullman.