More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Remember this, which came after it had been amply demonstrated that Holmes was holding up Rush as an example of what was wrong with medical practice of his time?
How do you KNOW what I have changed or have not changed in my book?

As a matter of fact, I did change my reference to OW Holmes' opinion of Benjamin Rush.


I've found the text of the relevant passage on Google Books.

http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=BXZlprZRTJoC

See "Oliver Wendell Holmes and His Attack on Homeopathy" on page 50 onwards of the preview.

I've compared it with Dana's earlier post about Holmes.

As far as I can see, the only change to the text is that the word "good" has been removed from the phrase "Dr. Holmes wrote that the one physician who typifies the good American medical thinking and practice of that time was Benjamin Rush, MD (1745-1813)". It is still implicit in what Dana has put in the book that Holmes was holding up Rush as an example of good practice, though, because he has retained the claim about "Holmes’ glorification of Dr. Rush’s heroic medicine".
 
I’m not sure when he’ll be coming back. He seems to be a bit busy at the moment. Last week I put a simple question before him:
“If I was to peddle fake homeopathic remedies – i.e. by filling labeled vials with plain tapwater – how would you tell them apart from the real thing?”

He hasn’t gotten back to me yet.

I guess he though this was too easy a challenge - tap water with all those salts in it can be told apart from ddH2O/homeopathic remedies by someone attending primary school (OK, only if you tell them what they have to look for). Make it a little harder and ask him to tell apart some D30 remedy of his choice from ddH2O. Or plain sugar pills from magic ones.
 
I guess he though this was too easy a challenge - tap water with all those salts in it can be told apart from ddH2O/homeopathic remedies by someone attending primary school (OK, only if you tell them what they have to look for). Make it a little harder and ask him to tell apart some D30 remedy of his choice from ddH2O. Or plain sugar pills from magic ones.

You're assuming he attended primary school? :boggled: just :boggled:
 
Homeopathy works!

It is perfectly obvious how homeopathy works from the scientific point of view.

Theory: A fool and his money are easily parted.

Empirical support for the theory is provided by no end of examples: Enron, Abramoff, Ponzi, etc. etc.

In the initial condition the patient and their money are bound in a state of quantum entanglement called 'ownership'. After practice of homeopathic medicine in the approved manner the original quantum entanglement of money/patient has collapsed and a new quantum entanglement of money/practitioner has been established in accordance with the principle of conservation of wedge.
 
It is perfectly obvious how homeopathy works from the scientific point of view.

Theory: A fool and his money are easily parted.

Empirical support for the theory is provided by no end of examples: Enron, Abramoff, Ponzi, etc. etc.

In the initial condition the patient and their money are bound in a state of quantum entanglement called 'ownership'. After practice of homeopathic medicine in the approved manner the original quantum entanglement of money/patient has collapsed and a new quantum entanglement of money/practitioner has been established in accordance with the principle of conservation of wedge.


I think you're needlessly complicating matters. It all boils down to:

First, do no harm.
Second, ?
Third, PROFIT.
 
The need for mechanism

There would of course be no need to provide a mechanism for homeopathy if there was an effect that could be reliably observed. But in the case where we have no observational evidence of the effect, the absence of a credible theoretical mechanism is rather more serious.

When homeopathy was first cooked up, scientific medicine did not exist as an alternative. The doctors of the day caused more harm than good. In that environment a placebo cure was superior to the vast majority of remedies on offer. Diluting the quack cures of the day probably did save lives, but only by making them less dangerous.

I find Ullman's mode of discourse rather unpleasant. He attacks his critics as being guilty of 'ignorance' then proceeds to display his own ignorance by stringing together a psuedo-explanation in terms of quantum mechanics and nano-science. When attempting to defend oneself against a charge of talking complete nonsensr, it is well to avoid talking complete nonsense.

There are branches of engineering that proceed well ahead of scientific theory, Nano-engineering is not one of them. There is a great deal of difference between a theory of how mater behaves at very small scales and a theory of how something that is not there at all interacts.

Similarly with the talk of 'quantum entanglement', there is absolutely no observed quantum effect that provides the remotest support for the theory that water has a structure of any sort, let alone one that can preserve the memory of a particle that was once there.

And when you look further at the interaction of quantum mechanics with mechanics on the macro scale, what is quite striking is the fact that the world of the very small acts in sublime ignorance of the macroscopic world. For the common cold to respond to homepathic treatment we would either have to abandon our theory that it is caused by a virus that has been observed in countless laboratories or somehow explain the curious coincidence that the universe appears to have been structured in advance to favor the survival of homo sapiens over the virus when the former is presented with a sample of homeopathically 'structured' water.

Does it seem remotely likely that the universe is so conveniently structured? If so it would be a most remarkable blunder on the part of God since such a spectacularly unlikely circumstance could only be effectively explained by the existence of a God who wanted to get caught
 
Similarly with the talk of 'quantum entanglement', there is absolutely no observed quantum effect that provides the remotest support for the theory that water has a structure of any sort, let alone one that can preserve the memory of a particle that was once there.


They use the quantum entanglement of pratitioner/patient/remedy "theory" to explain why homoeopathy cannot be investigated by means of a DBRCT.
 
They use the quantum entanglement of pratitioner/patient/remedy "theory" to explain why homoeopathy cannot be investigated by means of a DBRCT.


Indeed. It's nothing but a post hoc excuse for it not working in DBPC trials. The only "evidence" that DBPC trials are not suitable to test homoeopathy is that they show it doesn't work. This relies on the assumption that it does.
 
I just noticed your tagline

"All blasphemies do not become great truths." - George Bernard Shaw


Did he also say "All great truths begin as blasphemies"
A poster quoted that line in response to criticism to an "Orbo" video recently.
My response was exactly the quote in your tagline, although I didn't know that it was a quote from GBS! I thought it was a BillyJoe original :D
 
I just noticed your tagline


Did he also say "All great truths begin as blasphemies"
A poster quoted that line in response to criticism to an "Orbo" video recently.
My response was exactly the quote in your tagline, although I didn't know that it was a quote from GBS! I thought it was a BillyJoe original :D
The full quotation from GBS is "All great truths begin as blasphemies, but all blasphemies do not become great truths." I thought I'd redress the balance.
 
I googled "All great truths begin as blasphemies, but all blasphemies do not become great truths."

The first link is your post above :D

The second link is to Bob Park:
(You're in good company :))

4. PERPETUUM MOBILE: "ALL GREAT TRUTHS BEGIN AS BLASPHEMIES."

This is the slogan of Steorn, a Dublin company that is assembling a jury of scientists to evaluate a device using moving permanent magnets to produce free energy. WN has exposed so many of these devices in the past that it gets depressing. So this time we examined the slogan instead. It's from George Bernard Shaw's Anajanska [1919], but the full quote must have been been lost. We've found the full quote: "All great truths begin as blasphemies, but all blasphemies do not become great truths."


So, I 've come full circle.
(Steorn, of course, is the Irish company that produced the Orbo to demonstrate free energy from magnets. That poster I referred to above must have been quoting that company's slogan.

BJ
 
Dana has an article in the Huffington Post that gives his views and sources he uses to show that the remedies can be shown different than water. The article is titled "How Homeopathic Medicine Works: Nanopaharmacology At Its Best" He seems to trying to fight all the negative comments that he gets for every article.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dana-ullman/how-homeopathic-medicines_b_389146.html

The blog seems to be nothing more than a commercial for his books etc., which is no surprise. It has to be annoying, when the negative comments give evidence that homeopathy is just placebo based.
 
Here is the first paragraph of his Huffington Post article:

It is commonly assumed that homeopathic medicines are composed of extremely small doses of medicinal substances. And yet, does anyone refer to an atomic bomb as an extremely small dose of a bomb? In actual fact, there is a power, a very real power, in having atoms smash against each other.


I'm not sure that I can read any more.
 
DUllman seems actually to be pretty angry, which is funny;

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dana-...tml?show_comment_id=36384117#comment_36384117

I have a HuffPo account but my comments don't seem to get past moderation. No idea why, they're less abusive than many that appear there. Maybe it's some glitch in my browser. Anyway...looking at DUllman's reaction it seems the sceptics posting there are managing just fine withou this monkey flinging poo at DU as well.
 
Dana is pissed.
Orac says he's an MD at his website, though he doesn't seem to have a backbone to say who he really is. What courage. What a statement on his own convictions. Ultimately, he is a shill for Big Pharma, protecting their interests at all costs (and it IS at all costs).

Isn't it a tad ironic that he insists upon double-blind placebo studies, but can he cite them for most common surgeries...or should we assume that he considers surgery to be "quackery" or "woo-woo."

Orac and his ilk misinform people...and they NEVER inform others about any positive studies on the various natural therapies...they only report on the negative studies. Is THIS the type of scientific attitude that you admire?
Who here doesn't know who Orac is? And who here doesn't know what the fundamental problem with double blinding surgeries is? He just spouting off stupid crap so that anyone who can't think will fall for it.
 
Last edited:
I don't. Although I'm sure I could find out easily enough if I cared to.
He coppies some of his posts word for word on his blog and posts them under his real name. Figured that out after I realized I was reading the same stuff twice.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom