Mojo
Mostly harmless
Remember this, which came after it had been amply demonstrated that Holmes was holding up Rush as an example of what was wrong with medical practice of his time?
I've found the text of the relevant passage on Google Books.
http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=BXZlprZRTJoC
See "Oliver Wendell Holmes and His Attack on Homeopathy" on page 50 onwards of the preview.
I've compared it with Dana's earlier post about Holmes.
As far as I can see, the only change to the text is that the word "good" has been removed from the phrase "Dr. Holmes wrote that the one physician who typifies the good American medical thinking and practice of that time was Benjamin Rush, MD (1745-1813)". It is still implicit in what Dana has put in the book that Holmes was holding up Rush as an example of good practice, though, because he has retained the claim about "Holmes’ glorification of Dr. Rush’s heroic medicine".
How do you KNOW what I have changed or have not changed in my book?
As a matter of fact, I did change my reference to OW Holmes' opinion of Benjamin Rush.
I've found the text of the relevant passage on Google Books.
http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=BXZlprZRTJoC
See "Oliver Wendell Holmes and His Attack on Homeopathy" on page 50 onwards of the preview.
I've compared it with Dana's earlier post about Holmes.
As far as I can see, the only change to the text is that the word "good" has been removed from the phrase "Dr. Holmes wrote that the one physician who typifies the good American medical thinking and practice of that time was Benjamin Rush, MD (1745-1813)". It is still implicit in what Dana has put in the book that Holmes was holding up Rush as an example of good practice, though, because he has retained the claim about "Holmes’ glorification of Dr. Rush’s heroic medicine".
just