More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Does this answer your question?
That Dana uses a strawman? Frankly not.

Arguing for homeopathy must serve one or more of the following purposes:

1) Keep yourself convinced.

2) Keep believers convinced.

3) Convince skeptics.

Re #1: OK, I'm sure Dana can convince himself of practically anything. ;)

Re #2: I don't think the Darwin argument carries much weight with homeopathy believers; although many of them no doubt accept evolution, their god is not Darwin. It is Hahnemann.

Re #3: As demonstrated, skeptics are likely to spot strawmen, and denoting anything or anybody 'your god' is bound to turn a skeptic off.

... So I fail to see the idea, except the usual appeal to false authority.

Hans
 
Re #3: As demonstrated, skeptics are likely to spot strawmen, and denoting anything or anybody 'your god' is bound to turn a skeptic off.


I think I see your error. You are assuming Dana is smart enough to work this out.

Also, you missed a category. Create a generally favourable impression in the minds of the uncommitted general public. To most people, Darwin is a Great Scientist. So, implying that such a man thought highly on homoeopathy is good press, if you can pull it off.

Rolfe.
 
I think I see your error. You are assuming Dana is smart enough to work this out.

Also, you missed a category. Create a generally favourable impression in the minds of the uncommitted general public. To most people, Darwin is a Great Scientist. So, implying that such a man thought highly on homoeopathy is good press, if you can pull it off.

Rolfe.
Good points, especially #1 ;)

Yes, It must be on par with the UK Royal Family, etc....

Hans
 
"As an example of the odd letters he received..."

Did Dullman leave out that sentence, or did he not understand it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom