More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Not really important, but it's something I don't get...

Why is he posting as JamesGully? On other websites (Hawk/Handsaw, Wikipedia, SBM, ...) he uses his real name.
 
There IS nothing new in homeopathy IF you don't read or don't learn or don't want to learn because you spend all your time spewing against it instead of having a life and learning new things.

And people here should probably not want to learn about Darwin because he wanted to learn...and you don't.

And you don't have to buy a book to read it because there is a new invention called libraries...you really should try one...

If any of you do get around to reading my eCAM article, you may actually learn something (don't worry...it won't hurt).

Amen. Finding the same kind of problems on other topics here as well James. I've read your article and it's excellent. Oh, by the way, you were right, it didn't hurt.
 
Mechanisms

Actually, that's no real problem. There isn't much point in worrying about a mechanism for nonexistent effects.

Their problem is that they have resorted to trying to prove efficacy by reference to vaguely reported anomalies, and by arguments to antiquity, popularity, authority, and other irrelevancies.

And, of course, by misusing meta-analyses:

It's just amazing how dull this is Mojo. You seem to know even less about Darwin. For example, Darwin's theory of evolution is considered by some scientists to be a bit more superior to Newton's theory of gravity, but when Newton came up with his laws of inverse square he didn't have an explanation for why attraction between masses followed his mathematical formula rather than his formulas based on cosines, square roots or even astrologically observed events in nature.

Newton said he knew there was a mathematical "force" that existed, that was real between planetary bodies, but he could not explain the mechanism. So that is not "proof" that something exists. We know gravity exists, yes? But no mechanism has been validated to show "how" gravity works except for various kinds of theories.

And, it wasn't until Albert Einstein came along that a "mechanism" for gravity was even seriously pondered, and to this very day, theories of the "mechanism" of gravity still lacks ANY experimental support. No one mechanism of the force behind gravity has been validated - but we KNOW (do we not?) that gravity does exist?

Darwin also did not have a "mechanism" explained where he could prove without a doubt that evolution can occur. He only wrote that the mechanism was mutation of species but Darwin did not have any means to prove the inner workings of cells, DNA, genes, or even what the mechanisms were behind mutations. Darwin only said that evolution happens via natural selection, but had no proof of mechanism to show why changes occur in organisms. So let's give the "show me the mechanism" shtick you got going a break on homeopathy, okay? It's so tiring and quite boring Mojo.
 
Last edited:
Why is he posting as JamesGully? On other websites (Hawk/Handsaw, Wikipedia, SBM, ...) he uses his real name.

When he first showed up here, he pretended that he wasn't DUllman, but rather a bystander. Just one more small demonstration of his integrity.

Linda
 
It's just amazing how dull this is Mojo. You seem to know even less about Darwin. For example, Darwin's theory of evolution is considered by some scientists to be a bit more superior to Newton's theory of gravity, but when Newton came up with his laws of inverse square he didn't have an explanation for why attraction between masses followed his mathematical formula rather than his formulas based on cosines, square roots or even astrologically observed events in nature.

Newton said he knew there was a mathematical "force" that existed, that was real between planetary bodies, but he could not explain the mechanism. So that is not "proof" that something exists. We know gravity exists, yes? But no mechanism has been validated to show "how" gravity works except for various kinds of theories.

And, it wasn't until Albert Einstein came along that a "mechanism" for gravity was even seriously pondered, and to this very day, theories of the "mechanism" of gravity still lacks ANY experimental support. No one mechanism of the force behind gravity has been validated - but we KNOW (do we not?) that gravity does exist?

Darwin also did not have a "mechanism" explained where he could prove without a doubt that evolution can occur. He only wrote that the mechanism was mutation of species but Darwin did not have any means to prove the inner workings of cells, DNA, genes, or even what the mechanisms were behind mutations. Darwin only said that evolution happens via natural selection, but had no proof of mechanism to show why changes occur in organisms. So let's give the "show me the mechanism" shtick you got going a break on homeopathy, okay? It's so tiring and quite boring Mojo.

You need to read a bit more carefully. Mojo agreed with you that it wasn't necessary to ask for a mechanism.

Linda
 
You need to read a bit more carefully. Mojo agreed with you that it wasn't necessary to ask for a mechanism.

Linda

Yes, I did, however, not enough for it to be made quite clear that it is not necessary to explain the mechanisms of homeopathy to prove its validity. Also, there have been plenty of tests proving the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment.
 
Yes, I did, however, not enough for it to be made quite clear that it is not necessary to explain the mechanisms of homeopathy to prove its validity. Also, there have been plenty of tests proving the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment.

Astro Teacher. You are amusing when you pontificate in Astrology threads. Here you will have to do better than wave your arms and proclaim your brilliance. May I respectfully that you use your library card?
:dl:
 
There IS nothing new in homeopathy IF you don't read or don't learn or don't want to learn because you spend all your time spewing against it instead of having a life and learning new things.

And people here should probably not want to learn about Darwin because he wanted to learn...and you don't.

And you don't have to buy a book to read it because there is a new invention called libraries...you really should try one...

If any of you do get around to reading my eCAM article, you may actually learn something (don't worry...it won't hurt).

Something I don't get is why this seeming defense of homeopathy is necessary. If one's work truly has merit, shouldn't it be able to stand on its own? Shouldn't others be able to repeat the experiments and confirm the results? Would not a support campaign be completely redundant?
 
Yes, I did, however, not enough for it to be made quite clear that it is not necessary to explain the mechanisms of homeopathy to prove its validity. Also, there have been plenty of tests proving the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment.

Odd, I'd not heard that 'plenty' had been redefined to mean 'zero'.
 
Yes, I did, however, not enough for it to be made quite clear that it is not necessary to explain the mechanisms of homeopathy to prove its validity. Also, there have been plenty of tests proving the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment.

There haven't been plenty of studies which show (let alone prove) that homeopathy is effective. The combined effect of the studies show that any effect attributed to homeopathy is indistinguishable from placebo and bias. There isn't enough 'proof' to recommend any single treatment for homeopathy.

Linda
 
I have a confession to make (and information that saves others the same effort). I've always wondered how DUllman could have an MPH and display so little understanding of basic statistics and reliability/validity. I was reminded of my suspicions today when I needed confirmation of my oldest son's attendance as a full time student for insurance purposes. So I went ahead and placed a request for confirmation of Dana's MPH as well. And it was confirmed. Disappointing but expected. Which serves as a cautionary tale about depending upon authority.

Linda
 
He never stays around long enough to get pinned down these days.

...but it seems he has an acolyte in his place.

(well, you can tell where he got his "education" from)
 
Last edited:
Yes, I did, however, not enough for it to be made quite clear that it is not necessary to explain the mechanisms of homeopathy to prove its validity. Also, there have been plenty of tests proving the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment.

Did you go to the same classes as Dana when you learned reading comprehension? Mojo's point was very clear and you have expended a significant amount of effort grasping the wrong end of the stick.

As to your second point, please provide your single best example of a high-quality trial that demonstrates efficacy of homeopathy.

Please, also provide one, you only need one, incontrovertible example, accurately and honestly reported, of a non-self-limiting disease being cured by homeopathy.

Thank you.
 
p.s. If you mention the Banerji clinic or cite a meta-analysis published by Linde in 1997 or any trials published by someone called Frass, you will learn what is meant by the phrase "howls of derisive laughter".
 
Yes, I did, however, not enough for it to be made quite clear that it is not necessary to explain the mechanisms of homeopathy to prove its validity.

Agreed. However, if you think so, why is it that you are claiming, elsewhere, that a very thorugh knowledge of astrology is required to test that?

Basically, as long as any system makes a testable claim, it lends itself to testing. (And if a system doesn't make any testable claims, it admits to being a belief system.)


Also, there have been plenty of tests proving the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment.
No.[tm]

Hans
 
It's just amazing how dull this is Mojo. You seem to know even less about Darwin. For example, Darwin's theory of evolution is considered by some scientists to be a bit more superior to Newton's theory of gravity, but when Newton came up with his laws of inverse square he didn't have an explanation for why attraction between masses followed his mathematical formula rather than his formulas based on cosines, square roots or even astrologically observed events in nature.

Newton said he knew there was a mathematical "force" that existed, that was real between planetary bodies, but he could not explain the mechanism. So that is not "proof" that something exists. We know gravity exists, yes? But no mechanism has been validated to show "how" gravity works except for various kinds of theories.

And, it wasn't until Albert Einstein came along that a "mechanism" for gravity was even seriously pondered, and to this very day, theories of the "mechanism" of gravity still lacks ANY experimental support. No one mechanism of the force behind gravity has been validated - but we KNOW (do we not?) that gravity does exist?

Darwin also did not have a "mechanism" explained where he could prove without a doubt that evolution can occur. He only wrote that the mechanism was mutation of species but Darwin did not have any means to prove the inner workings of cells, DNA, genes, or even what the mechanisms were behind mutations. Darwin only said that evolution happens via natural selection, but had no proof of mechanism to show why changes occur in organisms. So let's give the "show me the mechanism" shtick you got going a break on homeopathy, okay? It's so tiring and quite boring Mojo.


Fail.
 
*snip* So let's give the "show me the mechanism" shtick you got going a break on homeopathy, okay? It's so tiring and quite boring Mojo.

You need not know the mechanism (and Mojo didn't say that), but the putative mechanism needs to have some plausibility. Otherwise, you have an extraordinary claim, which as you may know, requires extraordinary evidence.

For example, gravity has some pretty extraordinary evidence working for it. Electricity has. Evolution has.

Homeopathy has not. Astrology has not.

Hans
 
Why is he posting as JamesGully? On other websites (Hawk/Handsaw, Wikipedia, SBM, ...) he uses his real name.
When he first showed up here, he pretended that he wasn't DUllman, but rather a bystander. Just one more small demonstration of his integrity.

Linda


Indeed, here's his first post on the forum:
I appreciate good skeptical thinking, and yet, am I the only one who thinks that no one responded to the numerous basic science and clinical studies that Dana Ullman referenced?

Am I the only one who think that Ullman also gave a good, solid critique of that questionably done "meta-analysis" that sought to compare 110 homeopathic and allopathic studies? Am I the only one who is surprised that even the skeptics who did this study found that the homeopathic studies had a larger number of higher percentage of higher quality studies than the allopathic studies (by THEIR own definition of high quality studies).

At first blush, homeopathy seems weird to me too, but heck, nature is full of mysteries. Humility is a healthy scientific attitude.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom