Meteor over Moscow

It's seems obvious that a short amount of friction from air isn't going to cause a fireball brighter than the sun.
 
There's a nice set of images here of the meteor trail.

This one in particular shows a red glow within the trail. Is this the remnant of the explosion itself and the glowing debris?
 
It's hard to believe 12 seconds of friction with air can cause 10,000 tons of rock/metal or whatnot to glow brighter than the sun then explode.

Isn't it a great universe in that regard? Lots of things are true even if they're hard to believe.

ETA: And similarly, plenty of things that are easy to believe are false.
 
It's seems obvious that a short amount of friction from air isn't going to cause a fireball brighter than the sun.

This is also not a logical objection. Things may or may not seem obvious to different people (especially depending on the degree of knowledge or ignorance on a subject different people have).

My favorite observation on this point is that when something really is self evident, it doesn't require saying. If it's in controversy--that is, if you disagree with someone on this point--, then by definition it's not self evident (or obvious).

ETA: I'm not sure physicists would even be able to parse your term "short amount of friction".
 
Last edited:
Whatever. It's obvious it wasn't friction that caused the heat.
 
Whatever. It's obvious it wasn't friction that caused the heat.
At everyday pressures and speeds, it is not that obvious at all. It was during the research for reentry methods for the Mercury Program (I expect that much the same was done for Soyuz) that these details of aerodynamics were worked out. Between the experience with high altitude aircraft, heat shield testing, and a re-assessment of the observations of meteors, they were able to put together a better model of what goes on at those speeds and altitudes.
 
Why? And if it wasn't friction, what was it?

When a blunt object moves at supersonic speeds through the air, the air cannot get out of the way and so it is compressed. According to the ideal gas law a gas compressed will heat up, and the gas in front of the meteor (or the space shuttle or a thermonuclear warhead) heats up dramatically. It is in super-intimate contact with the object, and heat conducts to the object.

If the object gets hot enough, the surface will ablate (melt or vaporize), and the sloughed material carries off heat with it. That's how the Mercury capsule heat shields worked.
 
Last edited:
This thing or pieces of it at least landed in a relatives city. Knocked over brick walls and even punched a nice round hole into a frozen lake. I have asked her to get out and recover all the pieces of it she can find...she thinks I'm joking that its more valuable than gold...
 
This thing or pieces of it at least landed in a relatives city. Knocked over brick walls and even punched a nice round hole into a frozen lake. I have asked her to get out and recover all the pieces of it she can find...she thinks I'm joking that its more valuable than gold...

There is some sort of law regarding the sale of meteorites, and combined with a serious mistrust of the government, one gets the impression that it is more trouble than it is worth to collect them. In some cases, people are just outright cheated.

New York Times
Ever since the meteor exploded somewhere over this impoverished Siberian town, Larisa V. Briyukova wondered what to do with the fist-size stone she found under a hole in the roof tiles of her woodshed.

On Monday, a stranger knocked on her door, offering about $60, Ms. Briyukova said. After some haggling, they settled on a price of $230. A few hours later, another man pulled up, looked at the hole in the roof and offered $1,300.
“Now I regret selling it,” said Ms. Briyukova, a 43-year-old homemaker. “But then, who knows? The police might have come and taken it away anyway.”
 
It's seems obvious that a short amount of friction from air isn't going to cause a fireball brighter than the sun.

Another great example of a person declaring their intuition to be more accurate than the science. Your statement totally ignores the distances involved.

The Russian meteor disintegrated at an altitude of about 25 kilometres.

The Sun is 150 million kilometres away.

From the standpoint of an observer directly under the meteor, the Sun is six million times further away.

Light intensity falls off by an amount that is inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the source; its called the Inverse Square Law

Your "short amount of friction from air" only has to make the fireball one six-millionth as bright as the Sun for them to appear equal brightness in the sky.
 
The meteor blew up over the Russian city, with the force of 400 kilotons.

And yet the worst damage was windows being smashed and doors blown in.

What was the altitude of the meteor when it blew?
 
The meteor blew up over the Russian city, with the force of 400 kilotons.

And yet the worst damage was windows being smashed and doors blown in.

What was the altitude of the meteor when it blew?

That energy would have been spread out over a few seconds, if not longer. And the trail it left doesn't really show any sort of "explosion." It may have fragmented, but it wouldn't have been like a nuclear blast.

Steve S
 
The meteor blew up over the Russian city, with the force of 400 kilotons.

And yet the worst damage was windows being smashed and doors blown in.

What was the altitude of the meteor when it blew?

25km, and again intuition might make you think that being only 25km from a 400kt explosion ought to level buildings and kill thousands, but you have to remember that the meteor didn't explode in a single 400kt blast. The explosion was spread out over some distance and a short period of time, so the intensity of the pressure wave was hugely reduced.

Imagine a string of 400 x 1kt conventional explosive devices set to go off in rapid progression over a period of five seconds. The total energy released is 400kt, but the pressure wave would only have the equivalent power of a 1kt blast
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom