Meteor over Moscow

That's not correct (as the references I cited note).
I suggest you have misread them because they are not clear.

"A shock wave travels through most media at a higher speed than an ordinary wave" is not the same thing as "a shock wave travels through most media super-sonically." It means that most vibrational modes travel more slowly than the speed of sound in most media.
 
I suggest you have misread them because they are not clear.

"A shock wave travels through most media at a higher speed than an ordinary wave" is not the same thing as "a shock wave travels through most media super-sonically." It means that most vibrational modes travel more slowly than the speed of sound in most media.
I think it's logically obvious shock waves can and do exceed the speed of sound. Isn't that what a sonic boom is all about?

:confused:
 
I think it's logically obvious shock waves can and do exceed the speed of sound. Isn't that what a sonic boom is all about?

:confused:

Not quite.

Subsonic.png


An object moving through the air at sub-sonic speeds produces sound waves which can radiate out ahead of it at the speed of sound. An observer at a distance will hear the Doppler effect of the sudden onset of a high pitched sound that drops away very quickly. The faster the object is moving the more sudden the onset of the sound.


Transonic.png


As the object approaches the transonic range, the sound waves begin to "pile up" on the front of the object, effectively, they cannot "get away" in the direction the object is travelling. For the observer at a distance, the onset of the sound is very, very sudden. A closer observer may actually hear a transonic boom.

Supersonic.png


The object is now so fast that it is travelling faster than the sound waves it is generating. This creates a shock wave radiating out in a cone with the object at its apex. For an observer at any distance, the onset of the sound is an explosion, a loud bang. Effectively all of the sound waves that would have normally propagated ahead of the plane are combined together so at first you hear nothing, and then you hear the boom they create.


Watch this. The first couple are transonic booms, the rest are sonic booms, much louder, and you can see the formation of the compression wave
 
Just for clarity, from teh wiki article on shockwaves:
Shock waves form when the speed of a fluid changes by more than the speed of sound.[3] At the region where this occurs sound waves traveling against the flow reach a point where they cannot travel any further upstream and the pressure progressively builds in that region, and a high pressure shock wave rapidly forms.

A shock wave forms when the pressure front/blast/whatever exceeds the speed of sound in the material. At that point, it pushes the material in front of it. That is what builds the pressrue wave, and in large explosions (such as nuclear) creates the vacuum at the detonation point, leading to the inrush of air after the explosion.

While it is technially correct to say a wave can't propogate through a medium at faster than the speed of sound, it's misleading when dealing with fluids (gas and liquid). With fluids, this is technically true, but the shock front/shockwave will travel faster than that speed, simply by pushing the medium with itself.

That difference is what seperated a detonation (expansion speed greater than the speed of sound) from a deflagration (expansion speed less than the speed of sound).
 
I suggest you have misread them because they are not clear.

No, I didn't misread them and they are clear. The definition of detonation is that it is an explosion which produces a shock wave that travels faster than the speed of sound.

Have you seen the high-speed video of a real explosion (detonation) on Mythbusters? You can actually see the shock wave moving away faster than the sound of the explosion.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
I think it's logically obvious shock waves can and do exceed the speed of sound. Isn't that what a sonic boom is all about?

Yes, shock waves can travel faster than the speed of sound as they do in the case of a detonation, but the ones that produce sonic booms don't.

The shock wave that produces a sonic boom begins at the aircraft (or meteor or whatever) and radiates outward at the speed of sound. It forms a cone behind the object because the object continues to move forward. The cone gets longer as the object's speed increases above the speed of sound. (Smartcooky's diagrams show a two-dimensional representation of the cone.) You would hear the "boom" if and when the cone's edge intersects your location. The boom is caused by the abrupt change in air pressure as the shock wave passes.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
But doesn't compression cause heat because of air-on-air friction ?

No. The number of collisions of the air molecules increases as they are compressed into a smaller volume. Each collision causes the molecules to give up a little kinetic energy as heat. This is different from friction which is a force that tends to prevent two things in contact from moving relative to each other.

-- Roger
 
Yes, shock waves can travel faster than the speed of sound as they do in the case of a detonation, but the ones that produce sonic booms don't.

...

-- Roger


What is the math for this "faster than the speed of sound" travel in air? Your claim is not clear. How much faster does a shock wave travel? Why? Just because it is the abrupt change of pressure caused by an explosion?

Are you saying that the speed is dependent on intensity? Rise time or frequency? It's just audio, not anything more exotic than that. Certainly not radio frequency. What else is there? Sound is merely changes in air pressure at the location of detection. It is limited in its propagation speed in air or in any material (faster in denser materials like water or steel).

The wave front of an explosion that you see traveling along the ground is in fact the (definitely cool) leading edge of a pulse...traveling at the speed of sound. If not, what speed is it propagating at then? What is the multiplier that you claim to use to determine this speed? What is the cause of this increased speed?

It is possible that some sort of shock pulse could arrive through the ground earlier than the airborne pulse, if the explosion is well coupled to the ground, since the earth is much denser than air.

I may not be understanding the claim, but it seems to violate first principles. IMHO, of course. I also agree with other posters that the Wiki articles are very badly written and misleading in the extreme.

ETA: It just occurred to me that perhaps you are referring to the speed of the shock wave inside an explosive material such as detcord, gun cotton, or TNT. In that case, of course I would agree that such a propagation could well exceed the speed of sound.

ETA-2:
Have you seen the high-speed video of a real explosion (detonation) on Mythbusters? You can actually see the shock wave moving away faster than the sound of the explosion.
Then again, this statement is unambiguous.:) That shock wave is moving at the speed of sound. If not, then what speed is it moving at?
 
Last edited:
This video helped me understand it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlS6535HBNk

Also it just looks cool as can be.

Nice video. Note that he says that the shock wave travels "faster than 300 meters/second". i.e. the speed of sound.

The speed of sound is the distance travelled during a unit of time by a sound wave propagating through an elastic medium. In dry air at 20 °C (68 °F), the speed of sound is 343.2 metres per second (1,126 ft/s).
I like this video. Note that no sound is heard until the visible shock front hits the microphone. Get rid of the advertisement so you can see it in the bottom foreground. Camera was 1.2 miles away. 38,000 lbs of rocket fuel!




Here is the YouTube reference for viewing the comments: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KC7zdZ00eZ4
 
Last edited:
While this certainly won't solve the meteor conundrum, it should settle the shockwave speed issue.

explosive detonation

low explosive, subsonic combustion, deflagration speeds measured in hundreds of m/s
gunpowder (KNO3 or NaNO3 + C + S)
high explosive, supersonic combustion, detonation speeds measured in thousands of m/s
TNT (trinitrotoluene) 6,900 m/s
NG (nitroglycerine) 7,700 m/s — active ingredient in dynamite
TATB (triaminotrinitrobenzene) 7,350 m/s — used to trigger nuclear weapons, extremely insensitive to accidental detonation
RDX (research department explosive, cyclotrimethylenetrinitramine) 8,750 m/s — active ingredient in plastic explosives (e.g.; C-4)
HMX (high melt explosive, octogen, octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocane) 9,100 m/s — military explosive
http://physics.info/shock/
 
It seems a shockwave can travel a lot faster than the speed of sound.

Which makes sense. But what kind of pressure wave did the exploding meteor make?
 
In an atomic detonation, soft x-rays run out from the detonation at the speed of light and are absorbed by the air, which heats up tremendously. This air then starts expanding supersonically, but as it expands and cools, it slows within a few hundred meters to the speed of sound, which it then carries outward until it dissipates totally. The nature of the shockwave phenomenon was studied in detail during the first series of blasts at Bikini and at the NTS. Here is a video of the Grable shot, showing the rocket smoke columns moving in response to the invisible wave moving through them at about 0:04-0:08; also watch the shockwave travel over the ground to the cameras 6 miles from the blast. Note that the rumbling sound is false, added in by the studio:



Yes, a shockwave can travel faster than the SoS, if it is being pushed by an external force; it shouldn't really be called a sound wave under those conditions. On it's own, it propagates at the SoS, because it IS sound - a P wave through an elastic medium.

Shots photographed in the water show two shockwaves, one in the water and the other in the air. The one ion the water travels about 4.3 times faster than the air. Here is a video of those effects (the first few seconds of the video; pardon the music); note the water wave clears the frame within about a second, the air wave is slower:



The meteor, during entry was making the standard (though amplified, because of speed and size and aerodynamics, which probably sucked) sonic boom that supersonic aircraft make. At some point the meteor detonated, making an explosive shockwave. The two are separate phenomena.
 
Last edited:
I'm wondering if the rumbling that precedes the blast noise in the first video cold be the audio transmitted via the ground. I know some of those videos of explosions have certainly been fiddled with showing the sound at the same instant as the blast though.

The second video shows clearly the front propagated through the water, followed by the air shock wave. I've never noticed that before.
 
I'm wondering if the rumbling that precedes the blast noise in the first video cold be the audio transmitted via the ground. I know some of those videos of explosions have certainly been fiddled with showing the sound at the same instant as the blast though.

In 1953, magnetic recording wasn't standard as yet; the studio standard was optical recording, requiring equipment that was van sized. Almost all audio tracks were added in post processing. There is an interesting early (1953) recording of the Annie shot done with a TV camera (orthicon tube, I imagine), including auto lights and the sounding rockets, and recorded sound:



It appears that atomic bomb blasts didn't rumble as much as the ASAF's Lookout Mountain studio (in Hollywood) would like you to believe.
 
It seems a shockwave can travel a lot faster than the speed of sound.

Definitely.

Which makes sense. But what kind of pressure wave did the exploding meteor make?

Estimates put the explosion at about 30km in altitude and 40km south of Chelyabinsk. The shock wave reached Chelyabinsk about three minutes later. That puts the speed of the wave at about 1000km/hour which is in the ball park of the speed of sound in air (about 1200kph).

My original point, btw, was that the shock wave from the explosion would have travelled outwards in all directions from the point of the explosion and at a different speed than the shock wave experienced as a sonic boom along the path of the meteor.

But, after reading more about the event and the areas where the damage occurred, I think that my hypothesis that most of the damage on the ground was caused by the sonic boom, not the explosion's shock wave, was wrong.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
I want to know at what altitude do we first see it (in the videos), and what altitude does it glow brighter than the sun, and what altitude does the contrail stop.
 
Just a bump to see if anyone may have any new information. I have looked around, and the whole meteorite issue seems to have fallen off the radar except for a few, not very interesting, videos that I have not seen before. Maybe in a few months there will be analysis of the pieces found.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom