Meteor over Moscow

But, because you used the term, "re-magnetized" I know what mistake you are making. The iron and other metals which attract a magnet in igneous rocks are aligned with the N-S poles depending on when the lava was first extruded. A large meteorite impact melts the rocks allowing the metals to be realigned with the current N-S poles.

will you stop with the I know better crap ......that is NOT what I'm talking about at all and YOU don't get it which is obvious from your post.
The link was in the previous post and works fine and if you had read it you MIGHT understand that there was no "mistake" in my post as the subsequent posters have confirmed and NASA states.....I'll reiterate in case you missed it the first time...

Quote:
Explosive shock or meteorite impact are significant remagnetization processes. The mechanisms of remagnetization associated with the dynamic processes depend on the peak shock pressure, the nature of the shocked materials, and the behavior of the shock in the material. Magnetic measurements can be used to classify products formed during a shock process, and magnetic measurements can be used to investigate the process itself because of the special characteristics of the remanent magnetization vectors. The magnetic coercive force increases more rapidly in quenched and annealed iron-nickel alloys as nickel is added than it does in the alloys which have been shocked.
http://naca.larc.nasa.gov/search.jsp...earch+Center

just to make it perfectly clear....

remagnetization - Wiktionary
en.wiktionary.org/wiki/remagnetization[edit] Noun. remagnetization (plural remagnetizations). The act or process of remagnetizing, of restoring magnetism to something

geez - the "I know better" sniping does your cred not one bit of good. Are you still in recovery from your "metallic comet" face plant? :boggled:
 
Last edited:
I saw a video of a group successfully looking for meteorite pieces in the desert a while back, and they all had a magnet on a stick to check likely rocks as they hiked across the desert.

ETA: I remember wondering at the time what percentage of meteorite fragments they were missing because of not being magnetic material.
Magnet on a stick is the low cost metal detector for finding meteorites.

They would miss only the extremely rare meteorite.


BTW, the meteorites I own attract a magnet much more strongly than any typical terrestrial rocks which have iron in them. It's a very noticeable difference.
 
Last edited:
....
geez - the "I know better" sniping does your cred not one bit of good. Are you still in recovery from your "metallic comet" face plant? :boggled:
WTF metallic comet are you talking about? I was talking about the dust fragments that make up meteor showers.

You are reading posts with an unnecessary shoulder chip. There are no pissing contests going on in this thread that I can see. There's no reason to start one by reading imaginary insults into posts directed your way.


BTW, your link is inaccessible in this post as well, but I found it going back to your older post.
 
Last edited:
His update is a little unclear, the meteor obviously "broke up", just not in an explosive way. The large bang was due to the shock wave and not the exploding meteor.
I think both are true, the way a meteor explodes is from pressure, not combustion. Much of the sounds from the Russian event was due to the sonic boom from the wake of the meteor.

But the loud bang was also affected as the meteor violently broke apart and that altered the pressure wave.

Those video records gave me a different appreciation for how thunder is occurring.

From Phil's Slate article:
"explode". I don't want to mislead people; there may not have been any explosion at all. To be clear, the "explosion" heard in so many videos below is almost certianly from the shock wave of the meteoroid, and not from it exploding or hitting the ground.]
Which I see Polaris quoted on page 2.
 
Last edited:
I think both are true, the way a meteor explodes is from pressure, not combustion. Much of the sounds from the Russian event was due to the sonic boom from the wake of the meteor.

But the loud bang was also affected as the meteor violently broke apart and that altered the pressure wave.

To elaborate on this, when the meteor violently breaks apart, the atmospheric drag on it is suddenly going to increase, a lot. So the rate of energy transfer from the meteor to the atmosphere is going to jump at that point too, and I would expect that the sonic boom created from that part of the trajectory should be particularly strong. But not everyone on the ground is going to hear the boom from that part of the trajectory.
 
Olivines are paramagneitc minerals, if submitted to a magnetic field strong enough, they may "build" a magnetic field which will disappear after the original field is removed.

Native iron is a ferromagnetic mineral; it will react to the presence of a magnetic field (a magnet will "stick") and it may retain an induced magnetic field after the original field imposed to the mineral is removed.

Magnetite and troilite are ferrimagnetic minerals, they have a permanent magnetic field. Yes, magnets will "stick" to them and these minerals may orient themselves according to Earth's magnetic field if they have a chance.

All minerals above are common in meteorites, so, magnetic meteors are not exactly unexpected. Sure, not in the levels shown at B-movies.
I don't believe that is correct, unless by "common" you mean with a mineralogical exam rather than finding a magnetized meteorite which attracts metal.

WA University in St Louis: Meteorites or meteorwrongs
Although for convenience we sometimes state here that the minerals quartz, calcite, magnetite, hematite, and micas do not occur in meteorites, these statements are not entirely true. Each of these minerals are among the many minerals listed by Rubin (1997a,b) that have been observed in some meteorites. However, all these minerals are minor to rare in any type of meteorite and don't occur at all in the most common types of meteorites.

There is no type of meteorite in which quartz would be evident without the aid of a petrographic microscope and a petrographic thin section...

...Magnetite and hematite are oxides of iron. Magnetite occurs as a trace to minor mineral in several kinds of meteorites. Rubin (1997a) states that it is the "principal oxide phase in the CK chondrites," a rare type of meteorite (0.3%). Geiger and Bischoff (1995) found that the modal abundance of magnetite ranged from 1% to 8% in the 19 CK chondrites that they studied. Thus, a large CK chondrite with 8% magnetite might deflect a compass needle.

Hematite does not occur in meteoroids, but occurs in some meteorites as a terrestrial weathering product.
CK Chondrite is a specific kind of chondrite. There are only about 20 different CK members known if we exclude all the pairings that have been found so far in the hot deserts of Africa and on the blue-ice fields of Antarctica. That doesn't mean there's no magnetite in any other chondrite types because there is also some in CI (C1) chondrites.
Rubin (1997a) also states that "Phyllosilicates [e.g., micas] occur in the matrix and the interiors of chondrules... Associated with the phyllosilicates are Ca-carbonates and magnetite." Again, however, these mineral occur in very small quantities.



This was interesting (if you are a meteorite nerd like me): Magnetite in CI Carbonaceous Meteorites: Origin by Aqueous Activity on a Planetesimal Surface.
The composition and morphology of magnetite in CI carbonaceous meteorites appear incompatible with a nebular origin. Mineralization on the meteorite parent body is a more plausible mode of formation. The iodine-xenon age of this material therefore dates an episode of secondary mineralization on a planetesimal rather than the epoch of condensation in the primitive solar nebula.
 
Last edited:
To elaborate on this, when the meteor violently breaks apart, the atmospheric drag on it is suddenly going to increase, a lot. So the rate of energy transfer from the meteor to the atmosphere is going to jump at that point too, and I would expect that the sonic boom created from that part of the trajectory should be particularly strong. But not everyone on the ground is going to hear the boom from that part of the trajectory.
Thanks, I was trying to think that through and this helps.
 
Re the shocked remagnetization process discussed in papers on impact craters like this one Macdoc linked to, it's a bit of a red herring here. The discussions are about impact craters, not meteorites. I don't know the proportion of meteorites found around impact craters vs the rest that reach Earth without an impact event but I think most meteorites are not from impact craters. And for those that are, they still aren't magnetized to the point one would attract metal.

Beyond that, this level of geological science is beyond my knowledge base. I know about shocked quartz and shatter cones and the alignment of igneous metals to the poles at the time the lava solidified.

Petrography and shock-related remagnetization of pyrrhotite in drill cores from the Bosumtwi Impact Crater Drilling Project, Ghana
Rock magnetic and magnetic mineralogy data are presented from the International Continental Scientific Drilling Program (ICDP) drill cores LB-07A and LB-08A of the Bosumtwi impact structure in order to understand the magnetic behavior of impact and target lithologies and their impact-related remagnetization mechanism....

...Sixty-three percent of the investigated rock specimens show Q values above 1 indicating that remanence clearly dominates over induced magnetization, which is a typical feature of impact structures. Ferrimagnetic pyrrhotite is the main magnetite phase, which occurs besides minor magnetite and a magnetic phase ...

...Grain sizes of pyrrhotite show a large variation but the numerous stress-induced nanostructures observable by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) are assumed to behave as single-domain grains. We suggest that the drilled rocks lost their pre-shock remanence memory during the shock event and acquired a new, stable remanence during shock-induced grain size reduction.
I had to look up remanence memory to be sure it was what I thought it was. (It was.)
Remanence or remanent magnetization is the magnetization left behind in a ferromagnetic material (such as iron) after an external magnetic field is removed. It is also the measure of that magnetization.[1]
I learned what degaussing meant. ;)

I do believe this is all about microscopic mineralogy and not about magnetized meteorites attracting metals, note the 'nanostructures' I bolded.

When you start looking at the microscopic mineralogy, you are talking about properties you won't necessarily see in a gross exam of the meteorite. Interesting, but a red herring here I think.
 
It did; but it's my understanding that the consensus still remains that the large "boom" was the sonic shock caused by the object's speed, not the sound of the explosion.


I think that's correct because in all of the videos I watched, the "boom" is "heard" just as the meteor passes by. If the videos were capturing the sound of the shock wave from an explosion, the boom would happen at some random point in time as the meteor flies by.

I guess that's why so many people were hurt. They saw the meteor approaching and went to the window or outside for a better view. Then, as the meteor passed, the shock wave produced the sonic boom shattering windows around them.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
I don't believe that is correct, unless by "common" you mean with a mineralogical exam rather than finding a magnetized meteorite which attracts metal.

[/url]
That would be common when it comes down to meteorite mineralogy, but note also that "mineralogical exam" is a rather broad term. It can mean anything from looking at a hand sample with Mk.I eyeball to isotope assay. Experts (amateurs and pros) can tell what sort of meteorite they are handling using the Mk.I eyeball; a more precise characterization usually will require thin sections (transmitted and reflected light) and eventually microprobe and/or electron microscopes.

I've worked with magnetites (BIFs very very rich in magnetite); they would not attract metal, but their magnetism would screw up any compass measurement and in extreme cases change the polarity of compass needles (requires continuous use). And I'm talking about a hill composed mostly by magnetite. So, again, a magnetic meteorite, well, OK, but a weak field, not soemthing like in B-movies. I doubt it woult attract iron nails. It probably could change a compass' needle if the compass is close to it.
 
That would be common when it comes down to meteorite mineralogy, but note also that "mineralogical exam" is a rather broad term. It can mean anything from looking at a hand sample with Mk.I eyeball to isotope assay. Experts (amateurs and pros) can tell what sort of meteorite they are handling using the Mk.I eyeball; a more precise characterization usually will require thin sections (transmitted and reflected light) and eventually microprobe and/or electron microscopes.

I've worked with magnetites (BIFs very very rich in magnetite); they would not attract metal, but their magnetism would screw up any compass measurement and in extreme cases change the polarity of compass needles (requires continuous use). And I'm talking about a hill composed mostly by magnetite. So, again, a magnetic meteorite, well, OK, but a weak field, not soemthing like in B-movies. I doubt it woult attract iron nails. It probably could change a compass' needle if the compass is close to it.
But a compass needle is magnetized, isn't it? Yes, a meteorite is going to overwhelm the planetary magnetic field and the needle turn toward a nearby meteorite.
 
Last edited:
I think that's correct because in all of the videos I watched, the "boom" is "heard" just as the meteor passes by.
I don't know which ones you watched. At 20 or above kilometers height, it takes quite some time for the shock wave/explosion/whatever reach the ground. You can actually time it in some videos.
 
Interesting article on the possible effect of meteorite impacts and why simple energy comparisons to nuclear weapons aren't that directly useful.

I realized, after reading that article, that nuclear bombs are still described by comparing them to TNT, something almost nobody these days is familiar with.
 
The military certainly was aware, and still is. If it was about helping ordinary folks understand, they would use Dynamite to compare. Dynamite is more powerful, and something people may have actually watched blow a stump out of the ground.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom