Meteor over Moscow

While this certainly won't solve the meteor conundrum, it should settle the shockwave speed issue.

explosive detonation

low explosive, subsonic combustion, deflagration speeds measured in hundreds of m/s
gunpowder (KNO3 or NaNO3 + C + S)
high explosive, supersonic combustion, detonation speeds measured in thousands of m/s
TNT (trinitrotoluene) 6,900 m/s
NG (nitroglycerine) 7,700 m/s — active ingredient in dynamite
TATB (triaminotrinitrobenzene) 7,350 m/s — used to trigger nuclear weapons, extremely insensitive to accidental detonation
RDX (research department explosive, cyclotrimethylenetrinitramine) 8,750 m/s — active ingredient in plastic explosives (e.g.; C-4)
HMX (high melt explosive, octogen, octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocane) 9,100 m/s — military explosive

http://physics.info/shock/

You do realize that these are deflagration (object source) speeds and not propagation speeds, don't you?

The ratio of the speed of a moving object (v) to the speed of sound (c) in a fluid is known as the Mach number in honor of Ernst Mach (1838-1916), the Moravian physicist, psychologist, and philosopher who studied sound and ballistics.

M = v/c
The Mach number is a dimensionless measure of speed common in aerodynamics. Mach 0.5 is half the speed of sound, Mach 2 is twice the speed of sound, and so on. Speeds less than the speed of sound have a Mach number between zero and one and are described as subsonic. Those greater than the speed of sound have Mach numbers greater than one are a described as supersonic. Speeds approximately equal to the speed of sound have Mach numbers approximately equal to one and are described as transonic.

The shock wave from a supersonic object is a cone composed of overlapping spherical wavefronts. As any one of these wavefronts forms, it propagates radially outward at speed c and acquires a radius ct.

Way to prove my point for me.
 
Last edited:

Thanks. Good find.

I can't help wondering why this guy, Spahr, "isn't so sure" about the cause of the [crater] hole in the ice.

I would look for the pieces of ice that had been removed/expelled; how far from the hole were they; what evidence of cutting by axe can they find, etc.

Russian military divers are busy searching the shallow lake. But Spahr, who discussed the impact with other scientists at a meeting of the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space in Vienna last month, isn’t so sure. “From what we’ve seen on pictures, the ‘crater’ just doesn’t look right,” he says. “It looks more like a hole someone has cut in the lake with an axe.”
 
“From what we’ve seen on pictures, the ‘crater’ just doesn’t look right,” he says. “It looks more like a hole someone has cut in the lake with an axe.”

"HAHAHA... Your advanced Earthling weaponry is no match for our puny axes!!!"
 
Thanks. Good find.

I can't help wondering why this guy, Spahr, "isn't so sure" about the cause of the [crater] hole in the ice.

I would look for the pieces of ice that had been removed/expelled; how far from the hole were they; what evidence of cutting by axe can they find, etc.
What an axe-hole.
:boxedin:
 
You do realize that these are deflagration (object source) speeds and not propagation speeds, don't you?
"Detonation involves a supersonic exothermic front accelerating through a medium that eventually drives a shock front propagating directly in front of it."

"The main cause of damage from explosive devices is due to a supersonic blast front (a powerful shock wave) in the surrounding area."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detonation

"When a shockwave is created by high explosives such as TNT (which has a detonation velocity of 6,900 m/s), it will always travel at high, supersonic velocity from its point of origin."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shock_wave#Detonation_wave
​
I've just quoted Wikipedia, but you can search the 'net for "detonation shock wave supersonic" or a similar collection of keywords to find many more references that support the fact that shock waves from detontations move faster than the speed of sound.

The shock wave from a supersonic object is a cone composed of overlapping spherical wavefronts. As any one of these wavefronts forms, it propagates radially outward at speed c and acquires a radius ct."

That's the description of what's generally called a "sonic boom." No one is disagreeing that the shockwave in that case moves at the speed of sound.

-- Roger
 
[
That's the description of what's generally called a "sonic boom." No one is disagreeing that the shockwave in that case moves at the speed of sound.

-- Roger
Then what is your quibble?

A shockwave propagates at the speed of sound in a particular medium, no more, and no less.

All of the authorities on the matter conclude with it.
 
Then what is your quibble?

A shockwave propagates at the speed of sound in a particular medium, no more, and no less.

That's true for the shock wave that creates a sonic boom. Shock waves, from a detonation for example, travel faster than sound.

But, you knew that. Unfortunately, I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt, so I often end up feeding the trolls.

-- Roger
 
... It will probably end up being the most recorded spontaneous event in history.

By far the most beautiful of all the photographs of it, is the one that you see below.

Pity no one saw it coming. They say it was because the rising sun blocked their view of it.

In my Time Zone it was still Valentine's Day ...

8488585838_b8b43acbe8_o.gif

8487535225_35532d75e0_o.gif

11795497394_e4ccd45073_z.jpg


"Fear" is a thousand people bloodied by "thunder without lightning," and an object that will look like a "burning feather," in the sky.

 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom