Meteor over Moscow

I always presumed the comparison was supposed to illustrate the difference atomic bombs made in the size of a practical bomb. As WW2 progressed, bombs of 5 and 10 tons became available as did aircraft capable of carrying them. The step up made an equivalent "10,000 ton" bomb which could still be carried by a plane.
 
I don't know which ones you watched. At 20 or above kilometers height, it takes quite some time for the shock wave/explosion/whatever reach the ground. You can actually time it in some videos.

Yes ... but that doesn't contradict what I said.

-- Roger
 
It's hard to believe 12 seconds of friction with air can cause 10,000 tons of rock/metal or whatnot to glow brighter than the sun then explode.
 
It's hard to believe 12 seconds of friction with air can cause 10,000 tons of rock/metal or whatnot to glow brighter than the sun then explode.

Probably the same way that a couple of seconds interaction with shockfront from an nuclear explosion will destroy a city.
 
Yes ... but that doesn't contradict what I said.

If not, then I too must have misunderstood you.

You said:
... in all of the videos I watched, the "boom" is "heard" just as the meteor passes by.

It was my understanding that people reported the 'boom' arriving 30 or 40 seconds after the meteor passed by.

I think that's what you'd expect to happen if the meteor's path passed about 10km from the witness.
 
...

It was my understanding that people reported the 'boom' arriving 30 or 40 seconds after the meteor passed by.

I think that's what you'd expect to happen if the meteor's path passed about 10km from the witness.
I don't know how many seconds, but the videos where the windows shatter show people video recording the meteor and there is at least some delay with the vapor trail lingering in the sky, the leading edge clearly ended, before the boom startles everyone, including me when I watched the first clip and didn't know it was coming.
 
Last edited:
The video of the intersection and streetcars shows the flash at about 46 seconds in.

It can be seen at this site, along with another one I have never seen before, and is used in analyzing the shadows.

There is no sound unfortunately, but the video lasts a total of 5 minutes, providing about 4 minutes and 15 seconds of video after the flash of the meteor exploding, but there is no reaction that I can see indicating anyone's response to the sonic boom during this period. Traffic and pedestrians just keep moving normally.

That amount of time would indicate a distance from the blast/boom of at least 50 miles at 5 seconds/mile. This distance could be mainly lateral of course. It seems to me that the boom occurs after the video ends. I have not found any video that shows the flash AND the boom. The boom appears to occur well after the contrails have begun to dissipate in all the other videos.
 
It's hard to believe 12 seconds of friction with air can cause 10,000 tons of rock/metal or whatnot to glow brighter than the sun then explode.
I thought it was ram pressure not friction.
 
r-j said:
It's hard to believe 12 seconds of friction with air can cause 10,000 tons of rock/metal or whatnot to glow brighter than the sun then explode.
I thought it was ram pressure not friction.

The pressure gradient is why the body explodes, if there was equal pressure on all sides it would compress.

It's friction that causes the heat and vapor trail.
 
The military certainly was aware, and still is. If it was about helping ordinary folks understand, they would use Dynamite to compare. Dynamite is more powerful, and something people may have actually watched blow a stump out of the ground.
Well that depends on the grade of dynamite, and the additives. Classic dynamite isn't that common any more.

Most chemical explosives aren't that much more powerful than TNT; even CL-20 and ONC are only around twice as powerful.
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gQ6Pa5Pv_io

Meteor passing by (4:36), arrival of boom (7:00, not only audible but VISIBLE). 2 min 24 secs.

Now that is very useful. I had been looking for МЕТЕОР (meteor) and not МЕТЕОРИТ (meteorite).:) Thanks alot.

It looked like it was far from an overhead pass, so the distance was at least 25 miles from this observation point, vertical + horizontal. Lots of smaller booms afterwards. Good video, one of the comments in Russian is from a journalist offering to buy it.

The "boom" must have occurred in the video mentioned in my previous post, but oddly not apparent, even though it looks like the meteor was pretty close to judge by the shadows and the intensity.

There seems to be no real consensus on the sound's source, either a sonic boom or the noise of an explosion accompanied by the intense flash. I tend to think the flash/explosion produced the main damaging boom, even though it was in the highly rarefied atmosphere.

I found it curious that this guy's dash cam runs even while he is out of the car, motor off. Not a bad idea. I can see these things becoming very popular in the States.

 
It was my understanding that people reported the 'boom' arriving 30 or 40 seconds after the meteor passed by.

I think that's what you'd expect to happen if the meteor's path passed about 10km from the witness.

That's what I meant. I shouldn't have used the word "just." It implies too short a period of time.

You see the meteor pass in most of the videos then, later, you hear the "boom." That's more consistent with a "sonic boom" than an explosion. The sonic boom travelled along the same path as the meteor so the boom would be heard at about the same time and place - relative to the meteor - by all the observers on the ground. And that's what appears to be the case in the videos I watched.

The shock wave from an explosion could travel faster-than-sound and, more importantly, would radiate in all directions from the source. So, if the videos were capturing the shock wave from the explosion as the big "boom," the timing wouldn't have been as consistent across the videos.

But, I watched maybe seven or ten of the videos, so it's a small sample. It could be that they were all from locations along the path of the meteor, but not near the point of the explosion. For most people along the path, the sonic boom may have been the biggest "boom" while for those closer to the explosion, it might have produced a bigger bang.

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
The pressure gradient is why the body explodes, if there was equal pressure on all sides it would compress.

It's friction that causes the heat and vapor trail.

No, the heat is due to the air in front of the meteor being compressed.
 
The pressure gradient is why the body explodes, if there was equal pressure on all sides it would compress.

It's friction that causes the heat and vapor trail.

Friction isn't the source of the heat. It's the air being compressed in front of the meteor.

Edit: Honestly ... I didn't see phunk's post right ^^^ there before I posted this. :-)

-- Roger
 
Last edited:
The shock wave from an explosion could travel faster-than-sound and, more importantly, would radiate in all directions from the source. So, if the videos were capturing the shock wave from the explosion as the big "boom," the timing wouldn't have been as consistent across the videos.
A shock wave is just audio, an (abrupt) change in air pressure. It will travel at the speed of sound.
 
No, the gas ahead of the meteor gets compressed and changes phase from gas to plasma. The sudden change of phase is part of what created an evolving pressure wave, which is what caused the damage.

Friction isn't the source of the heat. It's the air being compressed in front of the meteor.

Edit: Honestly ... I didn't see phunk's post right ^^^ there before I posted this. :-)
It is not only the source of the heat, it is the source of the bolide (fireball).

Oddly enough, a very thin layer of comparatively calm gas forms close to the leading edge, and a relatively small amount of material is ablated that contributes to the color and the "smoke". Eventually, the meteor is slowed enough to where that no longer forms, and the heat and shock burn and shatter the meteor.

In those videos that run through the whole event, you can hear the transition from the first shock, to the continuous wave (lasting about a minute), and then there is another five minutes of very low frequency pressure waves generated by the broken up meteor.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom