Meteor over Moscow

The meteor blew up over the Russian city, with the force of 400 kilotons.

And yet the worst damage was windows being smashed and doors blown in.

What was the altitude of the meteor when it blew?

Not with the force of 400 kilotons; with the energy thereof!

When you fire a nuclear bomb of that magnitude, all the energy gets released within a tiny fraction of a second, causing a massive shockwave and intense radiation from million degrees of heat. Any point impacted by either will absorb its full share of that energy within two instances for both events. That's a massive amount of power (energy absorbed per time unit), which is an important reason for the bomb's destructiveness.

The meteor converted its kinetic energy of said 400 kilotons TNT equivalent to heat (from friction) and shockwave over the course of a number of seconds - at least equal to the time it was drawing visible signs in the sky. The shockwave, as a consequence, did not emanate with enormous amplitute from almost a single point but its origin was smeared out over many kilometers.

This comparatively slow release is, IMO, the main reason this event was much less powerful than a bomb.

Distance of course also plays an important role. Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chelyabinsk_meteor_event

WP said:
The Russian Geographical Society said the passing of the meteor over Chelyabinsk caused three blasts of different power. The first explosion was the most powerful, and was preceded by a bright flash, which lasted about five seconds. Altitude estimates ranged from 70–30 km, with an explosive equivalent of roughly 500 kilotonnes of TNT (2,100 TJ),[n 1][41] and the hypocenter of the explosion was to the south of Chelyabinsk, in Yemanzhelinsk and Yuzhnouralsk. The shock wave reached Chelyabinsk two minutes and 57 seconds later.[42] ...

Analysis of CCTV and dash cam footage posted on-line indicates that the meteor approached from east by south, and exploded about 40 km south of central Chelyabinsk above Korkino at a height of 27 km, with fragments continuing in the direction of Lake Chebarkul.
 
Not with the force of 400 kilotons; with the energy thereof!

When you fire a nuclear bomb of that magnitude, all the energy gets released within a tiny fraction of a second, causing a massive shockwave and intense radiation from million degrees of heat. Any point impacted by either will absorb its full share of that energy within two instances for both events. That's a massive amount of power (energy absorbed per time unit), which is an important reason for the bomb's destructiveness.

The meteor converted its kinetic energy of said 400 kilotons TNT equivalent to heat (from friction) and shockwave over the course of a number of seconds - at least equal to the time it was drawing visible signs in the sky. The shockwave, as a consequence, did not emanate with enormous amplitute from almost a single point but its origin was smeared out over many kilometers.

This comparatively slow release is, IMO, the main reason this event was much less powerful than a bomb.

Distance of course also plays an important role. Wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chelyabinsk_meteor_event

Wow, 70 km up??? That's nuts.
 
Wow, 70 km up??? That's nuts.

Did you see that video on the previous page where there is a delay of 2:24 minutes between the shine of the meteor and the bang? 146 seconds, at a speed of sound of 315 m/s (very cold air!), that would mean the source of the sound was 46 km away. Since the thing didn't pass directly overhead, that's not the height bove ground. Difficult to gauge the angle at which the line of sight was to horizontal. If 30°, that would compute to an elevation of 23 km.
 
Did you see that video on the previous page where there is a delay of 2:24 minutes between the shine of the meteor and the bang? 146 seconds, at a speed of sound of 315 m/s (very cold air!), that would mean the source of the sound was 46 km away. Since the thing didn't pass directly overhead, that's not the height bove ground. Difficult to gauge the angle at which the line of sight was to horizontal. If 30°, that would compute to an elevation of 23 km.

Yes, I noticed the "bang" was considerably after the big flash.
 
A shock wave is just audio, an (abrupt) change in air pressure. It will travel at the speed of sound.

Nope. A shock wave from an explosion is not "audio" and it can travel faster than sound.

"A shock wave travels through most media at a higher speed than an ordinary wave." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shock_wave

"Detonation involves a supersonic exothermic front accelerating through a medium that eventually drives a shock front propagating directly in front of it." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detonation

-- Roger





-- Roger
 
There is a lot of talk about all the video of the event (car cameras, security cameras), but there isn't any actual footage of what happened. No detail of what happened. And even if a high resolution camera was zoomed in on it, the light would have prevented seeing anything during the important part.

We don't actually know what happened.
 
Whatever. It's obvious it wasn't friction that caused the heat.


Repeating a bad argument doesn't make it better.

Again, what is "obvious" to you might not be obvious to an astrophysicist.

If something were obvious to everyone, there would be no disagreement, so no need to attempt a faulty "it's obvious" argument.
 
There is a lot of talk about all the video of the event (car cameras, security cameras), but there isn't any actual footage of what happened.

:confused:

Yes there is. Lots of it. There's even satellite video of it.
 
Repeating a bad argument doesn't make it better.
I agree, and I wish people would stop doing it.

Again, what is "obvious" to you might not be obvious to an astrophysicist.
That it wasn't air friction would be obvious to anyone with a basic knowledge of physics.

If something were obvious to everyone, there would be no disagreement, so no need to attempt a faulty "it's obvious" argument.
Among scientists who study meteors and the re-entry of space craft, there is agreement. Air friction is not the reason for heating.

I grew up following NASA and the space program. That's how I knew air friction isn't the problem when coming back down from space.
 
I agree, and I wish people would stop doing it.

That it wasn't air friction would be obvious to anyone with a basic knowledge of physics.

Among scientists who study meteors and the re-entry of space craft, there is agreement. Air friction is not the reason for heating.

I grew up following NASA and the space program. That's how I knew air friction isn't the problem when coming back down from space.

OK--it's from pressurizing the air due to the high speed collision of the mass entering the atmosphere. When you compress gas, its temperature increases.

You could have just said that you're making this point instead of simply repeating the "it's obvious" nonsense and implying some kind of CT.

No argument can be made, as I've said, by the observation that something is obvious. If it were in fact obvious, then no one would disagree.
 
If air caused friction (which results in heat), then all the surfaces of the space shuttle would heat up. But obviously that doesn't happen. Just the surfaces exposed to the hot plasma in front of the shuttle. It's why it was designed as it was, and the special tiles were only placed on areas exposed to the heat.
 
If air caused friction (which results in heat), then all the surfaces of the space shuttle would heat up. But obviously that doesn't happen. Just the surfaces exposed to the hot plasma in front of the shuttle. It's why it was designed as it was, and the special tiles were only placed on areas exposed to the heat.
My car's tires are not covered with special tiles and yet I am told that they are exposed to frictional forces (which supposedly produce heat). Is it "obvious" that they do not heat up and that therefore I have been told wrongly?
 
I don't think anyone is arguing against friction causing heat, just that it's not a significant factor in heating up meteors.
 
My car's tires are not covered with special tiles and yet I am told that they are exposed to frictional forces (which supposedly produce heat). Is it "obvious" that they do not heat up and that therefore I have been told wrongly?
Rubber, meet road.

You are talking about the behavior of two solids rubbing against each other as if they were a solid and a gas.
 
Nope. A shock wave from an explosion is not "audio" and it can travel faster than sound.

"A shock wave travels through most media at a higher speed than an ordinary wave." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shock_wave
This is poorly written and unclear. In a given medium, the speed of sound is a constant. There are wave types that can travel slower, but none can travel faster. This is why things break and deform.

What is not clear is that the description of the the meteor pressure wave and breakup as an "explosion" is an analogy, since most people can visualize the pressure wave generated by a detonation. It would be more accurate to say that the pressure wave shattered the meteor. As can be seen by the vapor trail, there is a record of the initial shock, a period of time during which a steady pressure wave is developed, and finally a time after the meteor is shattered. The audio records the same sequence: a sharp crack, a strong and complex rumble, and finally a dispersed infra-low frequency rumble.
 
Rubber, meet road.

You are talking about the behavior of two solids rubbing against each other as if they were a solid and a gas.

My message was meant as a reply to r-j's non sequitur comment that "If air caused friction (which results in heat), then all the surfaces of the space shuttle would heat up" and as a result it was also an analogous and somewhat sarcastic non sequitur.

We are talking about two different but related things (or you could also classify it as one thing which can be divided into two types of things*) which can be referred to by the word "friction". This refers to all of the forces which oppose the vector of motion of an traveling object (either one traveling in a gaseous or liquid medium or one traveling while in contact with a stationary object and as a result of traveling through the medium or of being in contact with the stationary object**). In the case of air friction (also known as drag) one contribution to these forces comes from the compression of the fluid ahead of the traveling object.

These forces all have the potential of creating heat (at least when work is being done). That does not mean that where they are in effect heat shielding will always be required since it's not an all or nothing proposition (sometimes things heat up a lot and requite it and most of the time things don't heat up so much and we don't even notice the heating effect).

* Six of one, half a dozen of the other --since how you talk about it does not change the underlying realities and concepts.
** Yes, I'm ignoring static friction (which would be even less relevant to an object traveling through a medium).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom